ŷ

Lisa's Reviews > As if I am not there: A novel about the Balkans

As if I am not there by Slavenka Drakulić
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
32532774
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: 1001-books-to-read-before-you-die

This was the first Drakulic I read, and at the time, I felt incapable of writing a review, although I consider it both very well written as a novel and immensely important as a historical reflection on the routine of rape during wars.

There was a double reason why I could not put into words what I thought. First of all, I struggled with the closeness of the atrocious events: both in a geographical and historical sense. This book took me to a war in Europe during my own lifetime, my teenage years, and it contained the whole spectrum of innocent civilians suffering that I can hardly bear to witness from a distance when reading about World War Two, for example. The graphic description of rape, and the information that there had been a routine of holding women hostage to use them as sexual slaves, not that far away from where I spent my safe adolescence, made a strong impact on me, stronger than I had expected. Now, when the book is not haunting me as vividly anymore, I find myself in the position to reflect on it more calmly and to appreciate the important message about the incredible vulnerability of women in unstable societies.

The other reason why I had trouble with reviewing was that I felt I could not place the author properly. The topic was so extreme, the suffering described so harsh - I could not imagine what her writing would look like if she chose a different subject.

Then a while ago, I read A Guided Tour Through the Museum of Communism, and was completely surprised by the wit and almost silly sense of humour displayed in the excellent short story collection. I would never have expected to pick up a book by Drakulic and actually have a good, lighthearted laugh, not after my first encounter with her. In a way, that humorous approach to Communist rule made the pain of "As if I Am Not There" even more tangible.

Both books however are similar in the way they describe how people suffer from an oppressive system that they can't escape, either during a war or within a totalitarian political system. They also show a variety of different characters reacting to the system, using their individual survival skills.

So I thought that might be the "recipe" to Drakulic' writing. But then I started to read Marble Skin, and I was again taken by surprise - being catapulted into a brilliant opening, describing a sculptress' creation of a female marble body as an introduction to a dark inner journey to get to terms with her mother and her sexuality. It feels like it is - again - an entirely new author I am trying out. What a versatile storyteller!

I will continue to think about "As If I Am Not There" for a while, but the contrast to the other novels gave it even more depth, pain and acute relevance than it had when I first stumbled upon it.

And I am curious to try the rest of Slavenka Drakulic' oeuvre as well, now definitely expecting to be surprised (if I may say so, well knowing that it is an oxymoron, kind of...).
61 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read As if I am not there.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
September 1, 2016 – Shelved
September 1, 2016 – Shelved as: 1001-books-to-read-before-you-die

Comments Showing 1-18 of 18 (18 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Cheryl (new) - added it

Cheryl I appreciate the audacity of any book that elucidates the harsh realities women face during war. While I do realize that every individual struggles during war, man, woman or child, the horrific idea that in addition to the lack and horrors, a person has to worry about something as simple as the freedom to her own body, now that's a psychological feat of which many international organizations, thankfully, have started to build awareness. Thank you for introducing this book through your gripping review, Lisa. I'll be adding it at once.


message 2: by Lizzy (new) - added it

Lizzy What an amazing review for such a difficult theme, Lisa! What makes it even better is when you tell us about how you felt reading it. I am going to check it out, although I don't know if I dare. L.


Lisa Cheryl wrote: "I appreciate the audacity of any book that elucidates the harsh realities women face during war. While I do realize that every individual struggles during war, man, woman or child, the horrific ide..."

Thank you, Cheryl! I agree with you: there is a lot of audacity in this book, and it left me speechless for a while. I will be excited to follow your thoughts on it when you get to read it!


Lisa Lizzy wrote: "What an amazing review for such a difficult theme, Lisa! What makes it even better is when you tell us about how you felt reading it. I am going to check it out, although I don't know if I dare. L."

Thank you, Lizzie! I am indeed hesitating to outright recommend something that I found so hard to stomach. I think it is incredibly important to spread knowledge of these things, though.


Lisa Jean-Paul wrote: "Thank you for sharing your thoughts with us about this book Lisa. Your personal feelings made it all the more palpable and brought the depth of the suffering so vividly to the surface."

Thank you Jean-Paul! I think we talked about it the other day: reading brings personal joy, but also personal suffering. It simply makes you participate in many different experiences. And this one is hard, for sure. But she is also a fascinating, multifaceted author, and well worth reading!


message 6: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala Lisa wrote: "...But she is also a fascinating, multifaceted author, and well worth reading! ."

I just took a look at her author page, Lisa, and was astonished at the variety of subjects she has written about. The fun last line of your review is very likely to come true!


message 7: by Dolors (new) - added it

Dolors Lisa, this review is doubly compelling, not only because of the horrific subject of the book, but also because of the browsing into Drakulić's works so we can get a glimpse of how each of them has pulled a different heartstring in you. She sounds like a very complete and committed writer.
As much as I dread reading any graphic description of abuse or violence, I am adding this one because sometimes it's necessary to face (and feel) horror in order to bring awareness to the simplified history we were taught at school.


Lisa Fionnuala wrote: "Lisa wrote: "...But she is also a fascinating, multifaceted author, and well worth reading! ."

I just took a look at her author page, Lisa, and was astonished at the variety of subjects she has wr..."

We'll see, or maybe I'll report being surprised because I finally discover a recurring pattern,... :-)


Lisa Dolors wrote: "Lisa, this review is doubly compelling, not only because of the horrific subject of the book, but also because of the browsing into Drakulić's works so we can get a glimpse of how each of them has ..."

Very true Dolors, traditional history teaching in school is simplified and carefully chosen to fit educational purposes. It is hard to break that pattern, but reading literature (poetry and drama as well), is one way to transmit a more personal experience of the past. This novel, however, is definitely not for children, as it is hard to stomach even with a good share of historical knowledge and life experience.
I am looking forward to reading your thoughts on it!


message 10: by Eleanor (new)

Eleanor A powerful and distressing book - thank you for sharing your thoughts on it and on Slavenka Drakulic with us.


message 11: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Eleanor wrote: "A powerful and distressing book - thank you for sharing your thoughts on it and on Slavenka Drakulic with us."

Thank you, Eleanor!


message 12: by John Anthony (new) - added it

John Anthony Thanks Lisa for your powerfully moving review.


message 13: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa John wrote: "Thanks Lisa for your powerfully moving review."

Thank you, John!


message 14: by [deleted user] (new)

Awesome review!


message 15: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa A. wrote: "Awesome review!"

Thank you, A.!


message 16: by Starjustin (new) - added it

Starjustin Amazing review! I'm adding this and will be sure to check out some of this author's other writings. Thanks Lisa.📘🐦


message 17: by Lisa (new) - rated it 5 stars

Lisa Starjustin wrote: "Amazing review! I'm adding this and will be sure to check out some of this author's other writings. Thanks Lisa.📘🐦"

Thank you, Starjustin!


message 18: by Ana (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ana Ovejero EXcellent review! I just finished reading the book and, although it contains terrible scenes, I think the author handles them appropriately. I really like how she talks about Women's reality during wars, when their bodies become objects for the pleasure of men who only want to humilliate them. Here, in Argentina, during the last dictatorship, pregnant women were kept captive in concentration camps until they gave birth. Then, they were killed and their babies were given to families of members of the army. The organization "Abuelas (gradmothers) de Plaza de Mayo" has been fighting all these years to recover those babies. Apparently, 500 babies were born in those centers.


back to top