Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Lisa's Reviews > Die linkshändige Frau

Die linkshändige Frau by Peter Handke
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
32532774
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: 1001-books-to-read-before-you-die, nice-try-but-no-cigars, nobels, peter-handke

I am a left-handed woman.

I was born in the winter/spring when the author wrote this book. But not in Paris, where he wrote it.

Do I need more connection to it? Does Handke need any connection to his story, or his characters? Isn't everything meaningless, lonely, randomly thrown together, or held together by unimportant circumstances?

Are we happy alone or in company? Are we happy? Why would we want to leave each other? Or stay together?

A woman (left-handed, presumably, although she uses a typewriter that makes her feel pain in her wrist joints) spontaneously leaves her husband and tries to live life on her own, drifting from one day to the next, feeling good sometimes, and horrifyingly lonely at other times. My latent thought is: exactly as she would if she stayed in her relationship.

Boredom, pain, aggression, occasional happiness and freedom. Time passes. Slowly.

What would change the situation?

"If he loved me when I am not dependent on him anymore."

I wonder if that is true. Women's eternal dilemma.

I am a left-handed woman typing on a computer. My left-handedness doesn't show that often anymore. Handke captures a question in the air, and he leaves it there - blowing bubbles of words to give it temporary company.

Plop! Another one burst. The question lingers...

PS: A Nobel Prize wasted! The world is full of writers that are AT LEAST as talented as the out-of-date Mr Handke, and they don't fit the disappointingly boring framework of being a white male European with a tendency to choose their politics to fit their inflated ego!
87 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Die linkshändige Frau.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

October 10, 2016 – Shelved as: to-read
October 10, 2016 – Shelved
April 17, 2017 – Started Reading
April 17, 2017 – Shelved as: 1001-books-to-read-before-you-die
April 17, 2017 – Shelved as: nice-try-but-no-cigars
April 17, 2017 – Finished Reading
October 11, 2019 – Shelved as: nobels
October 11, 2019 – Shelved as: peter-handke

Comments Showing 1-17 of 17 (17 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Eleanor (new)

Eleanor Oh so gradually we learn to accept and even be comfortable with difference. My father (born in 1902) was left-handed, but back then children were forced to use their right hands, to the extent of the left hand being tied down so it could not be used. And the result was that he wrote very neatly with his right hand, but did most other things with his left. This enforced use of the right hand I believe to be the cause of his developing a bad stammer as a child. He never overcame it, though it became less of a difficulty as he grew older. I hope your experience growing up left-handed was a much happier one.

Thank you for another enjoyable review. I think Jean-Paul's description fits it perfectly.


Lisa Jean-Paul wrote: "I loved the ethereal note you composed, Lisa, which added an illusive effervescence to my Monday morning..."

Then some of Handke's magic sticks in the air, Jean-Paul!


message 3: by Ali (new)

Ali It's always a great pleasure to read your writings, Lisa.


Lisa Eleanor wrote: "Oh so gradually we learn to accept and even be comfortable with difference. My father (born in 1902) was left-handed, but back then children were forced to use their right hands, to the extent of t..."

I didn't have any issues being left-handed, but I have heard stories of older relatives who were treated in an abominable way - simply for not being exactly the same as the majority in their natural approach to writing. Bizarre to think of humanity's need for cruelty against difference. Horrible. Being left-handed in this story also indicates doing things differently, straying from the traditional path. To me, the distinction doesn't make more sense than judging people by the size of their feet or their height.


message 5: by Ilse (new)

Ilse Women's eternal dilemma - if he loved me unconditionally and irrespective of whatever change would appear, then....; apparently that wouldn't change a thing. Thought-provoking review, Lisa.


Lisa Ali wrote: "It's always a great pleasure to read your writings, Lisa."

Thank you so much, Ali!


message 7: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala If we judged books by the originality of the thoughts they inspire, this book would surely be a good one.


Lisa Ilse wrote: "Women's eternal dilemma - if he loved me unconditionally and irrespective of whatever change would appear, then....; apparently that wouldn't change a thing. Thought-provoking review, Lisa."

Well, Handke isn't one to give definitive answers for sure. But I appreciate that open structure to be honest. Seems like a fair take on a complex reality...


Lisa Fionnuala wrote: "If we judged books by the originality of the thoughts they inspire, this book would surely be a good one."

It is, Fionnuala. I haven't stopped thinking about it yet...


message 10: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Thought provoking read and review, Lisa.

When I was in grade 1 and 2 (early 80's) I would switch hands when coloring etc. A teacher wanted me to pick a hand (preferably the right) and my mother basically told her to back off. I continued to use both hands but eventually settled on my left for writing and the right for everything else.
The only negative thing about writing left-handed is the permanent ink stain often left from dragging your hand through what you just wrote ;-)

I love your reviews, Lisa :)


message 11: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Deanna wrote: "Thought provoking read and review, Lisa.

When I was in grade 1 and 2 (early 80's) I would switch hands when coloring etc. A teacher wanted me to pick a hand (preferably the right) and my mother b..."


Oh yes, I know about the ink stains! As I still use a fountain pen, I am very careful these days. Funny how obsessed humanity has been, historically speaking, with left-handedness.
And thank you, Deanna!


message 12: by [deleted user] (new)

Are we happy alone or in company? Are we happy? Why would we want to leave each other? Or stay together?

I just finished watching Bergman's excellent Autumn Sonata, Lisa, and the questions you posed in this review made me think about the movie's central themes. I have heard about Handke before, and hopefully I will explore his works as your review really had me interested in this author!


message 13: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Waqas wrote: "Are we happy alone or in company? Are we happy? Why would we want to leave each other? Or stay together?

I just finished watching Bergman's excellent Autumn Sonata, Lisa, and the questions you pos..."


Bergman is fascinating, and I am happy to hear he still inspires people outside my small country. Handke has some similarities in the questions he raises, and a unique style. This was my third Handke, and certainly not the last. I like him more with every novel I try.


Chris Chapman I really must read this. After all it has been on my shelf since 1986. Too late to get me through that second year 20th C. German lit seminar, but somehow I think I'll get more out of it now!


message 15: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Chris wrote: "I really must read this. After all it has been on my shelf since 1986. Too late to get me through that second year 20th C. German lit seminar, but somehow I think I'll get more out of it now!"

I love it that you also have decade-long book guilt, Chris. I know EXACTLY what you mean. Handke is worth a dusting off!


Chris Chapman ah, book guilt, such a bitter-sweet emotion! And thanks for your intriguing review Lisa. As you see you are a better motivator than my Uni teachers were.


message 17: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Chris wrote: "ah, book guilt, such a bitter-sweet emotion! And thanks for your intriguing review Lisa. As you see you are a better motivator than my Uni teachers were."

Very touched, Chris! I am looking forward to your Handke readings.


back to top