Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

leynes's Reviews > Great Expectations

Great Expectations by Charles Dickens
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
45198798
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: penguin-deluxe

I adore this book, and I'm honestly amazed at the literary genius that went into it. I attempted reading Great Expectations as a teenager and I utterly failed. I didn't make it past chapter 3. The language was too challenging for me, and overall I felt like I didn't know where the story was going.

I recently picked this back up because I wanted to buddy read it with some friends, and that was such a good decision. I geniuenly feel like I've read this book at the perfect time in my life.

Great Expectations is a bildungsroman by Charles Dickens which was published between 1860 and 1861, and it deals with timely themes such as wealth and poverty, love and rejection and the differences between a rural environment and the London metropolis. In this novel we follow the psychological and moral developement of the young orphaned boy Pip to his maturity. It exhibits his hopes and youthful dreams and their metamorphosis through the hardships of adulthood.

I have to admit that my reading experience of this novel wasn't necessarily worthy of five stars. There were times when the novel dragged, and didn't manage to hold my interest, but overall, and especially looking back on it, I have to give credit where credit is due: The novel in itself is such a well-rounded story, in which every narrative thread was picked up again and resolved, thus weaving a complexity into this narrative which was honestly impressive.

Dickens created a lot of unlikeable characters for this tale: The cold-hearted bitch that is Estella. The crazy, egocentric spinster that is Miss Havisham. The disloyal ambitious boy that is Pip. However, all of these characters have a certain depth to them that makes them multi-layered and most importantly, real. Estella learns the hard way that her mannerism was cruel. Miss Havisham sees the flaws of her behaviour as well. And even Pip aspires to improve eventually, and pays his dues.

Great Expecations glistens with its side characters. I will never forget Wemmick and the comic relief he provided to the story. I will forever cherish his entertaining and loveable relationship to Mr Jaggers. Also, Orlick is a character that I'll think about for a long time. (Am I the only one who thought of Caliban from The Tempest whenever he popped up?)

Great Expecations is such an atmospheric tale and seems to draw heavily on the gothic novel, especially with Miss Havisham, the bride frozen in time and the ruins of Satis House filled with weeds and spiders. And even the aristocratic Drummle and his bursts of extreme cruelty, and Pip himself who spends his youth chasing for beauty fit the picture. Then again, it displays comedic, almost satirical moments, highlighting the novel's most eccentric characters. One only has to remember Pip's christmas dinner, Wopsle's performance of Hamlet or Wemmick's marriage, and the comedic traits of this story can't be denied.

I could literally praise this novel all day. It provides a rich basis for an analysis through the postcolonial lens (the book reinforces the standards that support the authority of the British empire and thus the exploitation of the Middle East through trade and travel), but also a basis for psychoanalytical criticism (the construction of identity in relation to the social order) and feminist criticism (the silence of women in the novel, and the glorification of domestic violence).

Moreover, in the centre of the novel stands the idea that wealth is only acceptable to the ruling class if it comes from the labour of others. Miss Havisham's wealth is considered 'pure', because it comes from rent collected on properties she inherited from her father and not from the sweat of her brow. Whereas, Magwitch's wealth is socially unacceptable, even repugnant to Pip, because he earned it through his own hard work, and because he was a convict.

The setting of the metropolis functions almost as a prison for Pip. In London, neither wealth nor gentility brings him happiness. His experience is dominated by chronic unease, weariness and feelings of insecurity. In the crowded metropolis, Pip grows disenchanted, disillusioned and lonely. Just like Estella (at the end of the novel), he learned the hard way how he took for granted what was most precious to him � his native Kent and the support provided by his dearest friends Joe and Biddy.

And I have to say that I've never read a better last chapter to any story. Ever. I saw no shadow from another parting from her. My mind is blown. Only few authors can pull of ambigious endings, but they all pale in comparison to Dickens. When Pip returns to the ruins of Satis House and meets Estella there, the whole scene had such a melancholic vibe to it, that I could literally feel it in my body. We witnessed two characters intentionally and unintentionally wreck the lives of the other, both have grown from the hardships that life has thrown in their way. They are 'bent and broken � but perhaps into a better shape.' Will they leave together or go seperate ways? It's up to the reader to decide, and I was never more satisfied after finishing a novel.
120 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Great Expectations.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 10, 2016 – Shelved
May 19, 2017 – Started Reading
May 21, 2017 –
page 189
36.91% "I did not expect (hehe) to love this as much as I do. It is brilliantly written, and I can't wait to learn more about Pip's upbringing."
June 12, 2017 –
page 373
72.85% "I knew it ... ;) Now onto the last volume!"
June 13, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

leynes @kit: YES! It was absolutely fantastic. I'm pretty sure it will make it to my TOP 10 books of 2017. I'm honestly so impressed with this narrative!


Joshie Magnificent and thoughtful review! I admit myself amongst all Dickens novels I've read so far, I took awhile with this one. But it grows on you the more compelling it gets that even afterwards, it never leaves the mind. It's a rewarding novel.


leynes Joshie wrote: "Magnificent and thoughtful review! I admit myself amongst all Dickens novels I've read so far, I took awhile with this one. But it grows on you the more compelling it gets that even afterwards, it ..."

Thank you! And I couldn't agree more, "rewarding" is the perfect way to put my reading experience of Great Expectations.


message 4: by Lucie (new)

Lucie Alice Hey, I love your review. What's your interpretation of the last chapter? Also, what did you think of the original? I really liked the version that was published, but I feel that, just because it wasn't the one Dickens originally wrote, this more optimistic one(at least in my perspective) doesn't feel like real canon. On the other hand, this cold original makes me feel... dead inside. One last thing, do you have any videos where you go more in depth into this book? Have a good day!


Nina ( picturetalk321 ) I like a lot what you say how the reading experience wasn't always enjoyable. I too think about what my stars mean and had a very similar dilemma after finishing Turgenyev's Sketches from a Hunter's Album. I ended up giving it 5 stars much for the reasons you did here but it took me 3 years to wade through it. Interesting that both Dickens and Turgenyev are 19th C authors - perhaps we are just no longer attuned to that mode of writing?


leynes Nina ( picturetalk321 ) wrote: "I like a lot what you say how the reading experience wasn't always enjoyable. I too think about what my stars mean and had a very similar dilemma after finishing Turgenyev's Sketches from a Hunter'..."

Interesting. I think reading more Victorian authors would help in finding it easier to get accustomed to their writing style. Great Expectations was one of my first Dickens novels, when I read A Tale of Two Cities last year it was already much easier to comprehend and get through. So yes, I would say that the more we expose ourselves to these authors and their writing styles, the easier and more natural it becomes!


²¹²âÅŸ±ð²Ô³Ü°ù Love this, Leynes! I was thinking to read some works by Dickens, and after a quick research I found your outstanding review. I couldn't be more motivated! I'll start this masterpiece this week.


Dana Thank you for the great review. what you say about the ending of the book is interesting especially because it was not its original ending; In the original, Estella remarried after her first husband died, and Pip remained single. Dickens rewrote the original after he received some complains about it ending so sadly for pip. But some critics argue that the original ending was a better suited ending to the theme of the book and less of a cliché. Personally, I think he found the perfect compromise with this ambiguous ending. The reader can interpret it as he wishes. He only gave us Pip’s conviction at a moment in time, frozen forever. On the one hand, we saw his convictions were so wrong in the past. On the other hand, it felt as if a real change occurred in the characters so we can easily believe in the happy ending.


leynes AyÅŸenur wrote: "Love this, Leynes! I was thinking to read some works by Dickens, and after a quick research I found your outstanding review. I couldn't be more motivated! I'll start this masterpiece this week."

Hope you ended up enjoying it! :)


leynes Dana wrote: "Thank you for the great review. what you say about the ending of the book is interesting especially because it was not its original ending; In the original, Estella remarried after her first husban..."

"He only gave us Pip’s conviction at a moment in time, frozen forever." YES YES YES! I like the ending he settled on. It's perfect in its ambiguity.


back to top