ŷ

flo's Reviews > Asya

Asya by Ivan Turgenev
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
21575078
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: russian, stories-and-novellas-for-this-life

description


The Peach Blossom Spring is a Chinese tale written by Tao Yuanming (c. 365�427). It tells the story of a fisherman who, by chance, discovers a beautiful place where its community and the natural surroundings were in perfect harmony. Dynasties, people, politics, fashion - everything outside their haven of peace and plenty was unbeknownst to them. The fisherman was received and treated with great cordiality and after several days of idyllic landscapes and hospitality, the man left not without marking the route with signs. He tried to return but never found it again. This story is the inspiration for Wei’s poem.
There is no such thing as a utopia, but even something remotely beneficial is hard to find. One of the many ironies of life is that, when we find it, we are usually oblivious to its existence until we lose it.
We are prone to clichés.

That’s the rule. To imagine it, to see it, to finally grasp it. And to let it go, unaware of the transient nature of things and people. To contemplate the distance between the bodies, the unspoken words, the constant glances. There, where the soothing Rhine, whitened by the moonlight, became the path to confusion, intense happiness and immeasurable loss. Turgenev told his story using a most delectable language, the kind that is often inspired by a bittersweet reminiscence.

The sound of a soft, carefree laugh which could melt glaciers. The eyes to which everything is saying goodbye. A withered geranium flower given as a gift amidst laughs. The only permanent thing he owns is the memory of its faint fragrance, which finally outlived him: N. N., who spent unforgettable days in the small German town of Z–� on the left bank of the Rhine, when he was about 25. The unwary writer who thought he could buy time, control circumstances, trick fortune. The one who would later travel the world to find that fragrance again, just to see his enthusiasm wane at the thought of defeat. The one whose love had burst alight with irresistible force only a few moments later, when there was nothing to be done.

Loss is everywhere and regret, a faithful companion.
A similar issue is addressed in one of the books I’ve read recently which left a deep impression on me. Using the kind of gorgeous language whose lucidity stirs the heart, Yoshida Kenkō discusses the nature of delay: the art of vacillation, the tendency to procrastinate. I’m one of its victims trying to recover, so this monk’s words kept reverberating through my head: ...always intending to make more effort later. And if such are your days, how much less aware must you be of the passing moment’s indolence. Why should it be so difficult to carry something out right now when you think of it, to seize the instant? To seize the instant. To seize the instant that will never repeat itself. The simplicity of the statement is overwhelming. Taking into account the natural awareness of human finitude, why should it be so difficult to�?

Loss is everywhere and time never calls a truce. It’s inevitable. Alone, in a little room, you find a tiny piece of paper with a few words written in pencil: ...if you’d said one word to me, just one word, I’d have stayed. You didn’t say it.
Turgenev knew it well. So do we. Countless examples with solutions and complete desolation.
The keys you lost because of your general absent-mindedness. The job opportunity that slipped out of your hands due to perpetual doubts. The potentially entertaining conversation with a stranger that never started thanks to your shyness, even your mistrust. The quarrel you couldn’t avoid because of your senseless and oppressive silence, or a shameless lie that never knew guilt; a mixture of both and the following distance that preserves ‘dignity�. The possibility of a little happiness you didn’t pursuit because of fear. Or the arrogant thought that the unique was going to appear in your life a thousand times.

description



Jan 16-Feb 05, 18
* Also on .
** Actual rating: 4.5 stars.
79 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Asya.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 14, 2016 – Shelved
January 12, 2018 – Started Reading
January 12, 2018 –
page 0
0.0% "I was always particularly happy and at ease in a crowd.

Huh?"
January 14, 2018 –
0.0% "I realised why this strange girl had so attracted me, not only by the half-wild charm that poured through every inch of her slender body, but also she attracted me because I liked her spirit."
January 15, 2018 –
0.0% "I couldn't understand how the meeting could have had such a swift and stupid ending, how it could have ended when I hadn't said a hundredth part of what I'd wanted to say or should have said, when I still hadn't any idea how it could all be resolved..."
January 16, 2018 –
100.0% "I was young in those days � and the future, the brief, ephemeral future, seemed to me limitless. Surely the same thing could happen again, I thought, and perhaps be even better, even more beautiful? I have known many other women, but the feeling aroused in me by Asya � that burning, tender, profound feeling � has never been repeated."
January 16, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-27 of 27 (27 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Vessey (new) - added it

Vessey Wow! If I had to quote all the memorable passages from your review, I would have to copy-paste the whole thing. :) Truly splendid and powerful. But still, if I had to choose one particular part, it would be this one:

The sound of a soft, carefree laugh which could melt glaciers. The eyes to which everything is saying goodbye. A withered geranium flower given as a gift amidst laughs. The only permanent thing he owns is the memory of its faint fragrance, which finally outlived him

And you make some good points. Unfortunately, too good.

There is no such thing as a utopia, but even something remotely beneficial is hard to find. One of the many ironies of life is that, when we find it, we are usually oblivious to its existence until we lose it.

It happened to me. I didn’t appreciate it while I had it and now that it’s gone, I know how valuable it was. A consolation is the opportunity to pass on the wisdom, to stop others from making the same mistake. Will I succeed? Doubtfully. But one must keep trying. :) You are so right in prompting us to cease the moment. Carpe diem. :) You reminded me of this very memorable passage from Paul Bowles� “The Sheltering Sky�:

“Death is always on the way, but the fact that you don’t know when it will arrive seems to take away from the finiteness of life. It’s that terrible precision that we hate so much. But because we don’t know, we get to think of life as an inexhaustible well. Yet everything happens only a certain number of times, and a very small number, really. How many more times will you remember a certain afternoon of your childhood, some afternoon that’s so deeply a part of your being that you can’t even conceive of your life without it? Perhaps four or five times more. Perhaps not even that. How many more times will you watch the full moon rise? Perhaps twenty. And yet it all seems limitless.�

Another good side of the loss you speak of is that you grow in the way only pain can make you grow and if by some miracle you regain the lost, you can appreciate it in an entirely new and deeper level.

Thank you so much for this gutting - in the good sense of the word :) - review, Florencia! :) I will surely list it. :)


message 2: by flo (last edited Feb 12, 2018 05:03AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

flo Vessey wrote: "Wow! If I had to quote all the memorable passages from your review, I would have to copy-paste the whole thing. :) Truly splendid and powerful. But still, if I had to choose one particular part, it..."

I've been on this site many years now, and there have been people on my list I knew couldn't care less about the stuff I read and wrote about; pretty easy to identify. Normal people naturally entitled to do so, but I had the feeling they shouldn't be on a list of 'friends', that's all - I still interact with them occasionally if I read something interesting. In that sense, I think my list should have no more than 10 friends. And I'd be grateful if you could still be on it, since a thoughtful comment like yours is always truly appreciated and one doesn't need more. I'm glad you liked this non-review, it's kinda funny that I couldn't relate to Turgenev's First Love but I really enjoyed this one. I connect with loss surprinsingly well.
Thanks for quoting that passage - But because we don’t know, we get to think of life as an inexhaustible well, a lovely expression to illustrate the feeling. I remember you mentioned The Sheltering Sky on another review, I should really check it out!
And, you grow in the way only pain can make you grow - very true. I happened to read a quote by Proust the other day that said something like "happiness is beneficial for the body but it's grief that develops the powers of the mind". I couldn't agree more. Though sometimes we're not meant to regain the lost, sometimes it's better if we don't. Other times, the circumstances should be ideal ;D and that doesn't happen often.
Many thanks for your kind words, Vessey. I see you added this book, I hope you enjoy it as much as I did. :)


message 3: by Carol (new) - added it

Carol Your review is magic in words. I shall have to change check out this short story that inspires it.


message 4: by J.S. (new)

J.S. Burke Great review!


message 5: by - Jared - (last edited Feb 13, 2018 09:02AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

- Jared - ₪ Book Nerd ₪ "The sound of a soft, carefree laugh which could melt glaciers. The eyes to which everything is saying goodbye."..."Loss is everywhere and regret, a faithful companion."..."Loss is everywhere and time never calls a truce."..."...if you’d said one word to me, just one word, I’d have stayed. You didn’t say it."

I just read this book myself. Lovely review! I think you captured the book in just those lines alone! Such a thoughtful review. I sure felt the sense of loss in this book. Turgenev writes it so well.

Curious, are you reading through Russian works this year as I am?


message 6: by Ilse (new) - added it

Ilse Why do today what you could do tomorrow, my sassy daughter asks me teasingly when procrastinating a call another time and observing me indulging in this happy moment of reading your thought-provoking write-up, Florencia. The stunning quote you picked to close your thoughts reminded me that the same goes not only for happiness, as I learnt from a Flemish philosopher:
Pluck the day, not just when it is a rose or a daisy - then it is no great feat - pluck it too if it is a thistle (Patricia De Martelaere).


message 7: by Alejandro (new)

Alejandro Astonishing review, Florencia! :)


message 8: by flo (new) - rated it 4 stars

flo Carol wrote: "Your review is magic in words. I shall have to change check out this short story that inspires it."

That's wonderful, Carol. I hope you also enjoy this lovely short story. Thanks for reading.


message 9: by flo (new) - rated it 4 stars

flo J.S. wrote: "Great review!"

Thank you!


message 10: by flo (new) - rated it 4 stars

flo (_.- Jared -._) wrote: ""The sound of a soft, carefree laugh which could melt glaciers. The eyes to which everything is saying goodbye."..."Loss is everywhere and regret, a faithful companion."..."Loss is everywhere and t..."

I'm glad you think so, thanks so much for your kind words, Jared. Yes, the sense of loss is almost tangible.
Actually, I'm sort of a Russophile when it comes to literature, so I'm usually reading Russian authors. Dostoyevsky is one of my favorite writers. :) I hope you enjoy their works!


message 11: by Gaurav (new)

Gaurav Great review, Florencia! How is accurately you've pointed out ironies of life- procrastination, regret. The point that we always value something when we start losing it is bang on and it happens probably because it's human nature that we enjoy the pretense of possessing something more than actually possession of it and after we get hold of it, it just becomes any other things we, human beings, have- the best example could be how we've dealt with nature. Quite a thought provoking review, thanks for it :)


message 12: by flo (new) - rated it 4 stars

flo Ilse wrote: "Why do today what you could do tomorrow, my sassy daughter asks me teasingly when procrastinating a call another time and observing me indulging in this happy moment of reading your thought-provoki..."

Your daughter's words are usually mine :P but between one relapse and the other, I'm trying to change that, while doing or saying what I feel without unnecessary delays for I don't know if I'll be able to tomorrow.
I noticed those words by De Martelaere on your page a while ago, thank you for the lovely reminder. And thanks so much for your kind comment, Ilse. :)


message 13: by flo (new) - rated it 4 stars

flo Alejandro wrote: "Astonishing review, Florencia! :)"

Thanks a bunch, Alejandro. :D


message 14: by flo (new) - rated it 4 stars

flo Marita wrote: "Lovely review, Florencia."

Many thanks, Marita.


message 15: by flo (new) - rated it 4 stars

flo Gaurav wrote: "Great review, Florencia! How is accurately you've pointed out ironies of life- procrastination, regret. The point that we always value something when we start losing it is bang on and it happens pr..."

So happy to read your insightful comments again, Gaurav. :) You always understand what I try to say and share your thoughts with great eloquence.
I hope you're well, enjoying some great books - looking forward to more of your delightful reviews when you have more time to write; no pressure but your words are dearly missed. Thanks for reading and commenting!


message 16: by Tara (new)

Tara Gorgeous review, Florencia! The only Turgenev I've read so far is Fathers and Sons, which I thoroughly enjoyed. I noticed that you have it marked as to-read, and I look forward to hearing your take on it. Anyway, after reading all the intriguing thoughts this work stirred up in you, I'm going to have to make it a priority to get better acquainted with him :) The always compelling themes of loss and regret sound like they made quite an impact.

Thanks for providing such an incisive, haunting review!


message 17: by flo (new) - rated it 4 stars

flo Tara wrote: "Gorgeous review, Florencia! The only Turgenev I've read so far is Fathers and Sons, which I thoroughly enjoyed. I noticed that you have it marked as to-read, and I look forward to hearing your take..."

It's wonderful to hear that you enjoyed Fathers and Sons! I started with some of Turgenev's short stories - I think I did the same thing with Dostoyevsky, one of my favorites, not reading their masterpieces first but shorter works - and that novel should be my next read. Don't know when but it's definitely on my list.
I'm glad you liked this 'review' and thanks so much for stopping by and leaving such kind words. :) I look forward to hearing your thoughts.


message 18: by Dolors (new)

Dolors I don't know how on earth did I miss this ode to loss and fleeting happiness, Florencia. Your voice sings harmoniously when you ponder about existencial issues, and this poetic review is no exception. I had never heard of this story, and the delicate motifs you alternate with your thoughts won me over completely. There is no such thing as "cliché" when your pen is at work, and everything in this write-up races to a perfectly executed poem. A delight to read, Flo.


message 19: by flo (new) - rated it 4 stars

flo Dolors wrote: "I don't know how on earth did I miss this ode to loss and fleeting happiness, Florencia. Your voice sings harmoniously when you ponder about existencial issues, and this poetic review is no excepti..."


It's great to see that you found this 'review' and made my day with your kind and uplifting words. When I decided to read Asya, I wasn't expecting such a gem. I read it was one of Turgenev's best short stories but since I wasn't able to connect with First Love, I didn't have high hopes. It ended up being a delightful surprise that perfectly blended with my journey with Chinese poetry. :P
Thanks so much for reading and for your thoughtful comment.


message 20: by flo (new) - rated it 4 stars

flo Scarlett wrote: "Deeply moving, exquisite piece of a profound reflection, Florencia. I found myself completely immeresed in your gentle words building a delicate temple of quiet introspection. Grasping what we have..."

"a delicate temple of quiet introspection" - this reader can't ask for a more beautiful compliment. Whereas she deserves it or not, who knows, but I can assure you she's happy. And referring to herself in the third person. That's weird and she'll stop.
Seizing the moment must be one of the most important and most ignored concepts in life. It's always wonderful when we find a piece of writing that reminds us - at least for a while - of that fundamental notion. As you say, sometimes chances just need to be taken: good or bad results but no perpetual uncertainty: what if's are torturous.
Many thanks for leaving this gorgeous comment, especially now that you're so busy. :) I really appreciate it.


message 21: by Anu (new)

Anu I have had a busy week, and hadn't really had time to catch up till now. You have such an amazing way with words, Flo; even with books I haven't read, I feel like I'm actually living its experience through your reviews.


message 22: by flo (new) - rated it 4 stars

flo Anuradha wrote: "I have had a busy week, and hadn't really had time to catch up till now. You have such an amazing way with words, Flo; even with books I haven't read, I feel like I'm actually living its experience..."

That's very kind, Anu, thanks so much for your words. :) I'm glad you have time now to catch up. I'm starting my studies soon so I'll be rather busy again. I'm enjoying my last days of literary freedom.


message 23: by Anu (new)

Anu I unfortunately know what that feels like. I hope you'll have time to pop in every now and then! Oh, good luck with your studies, Flo! :))


message 24: by flo (last edited Mar 04, 2018 01:45PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

flo Anuradha wrote: "I unfortunately know what that feels like. I hope you'll have time to pop in every now and then! Oh, good luck with your studies, Flo! :))"

Thanks! I start tomorrow *sigh* A quiet first week, I assume, so I'll read another new book and then spend the year trying to finish what I started ages ago, Proust and Mishima's novels, and other two mammoth projects. Good luck to you too, if you have some more studying to do. :)


message 25: by Seemita (new)

Seemita Oh dear Flor! What a sweeping, serene stream of reflections flow in this review of yours! It was just two days ago that a friend of mine was urging me to read 'First Love' by Turgenev and here I am, finding myself pleasantly besieged by your call. I love the allusion you make to the Yuanming's tale; very apt on the subject of the novel being reviewed in its acute longing and consistent evasion in facing the same. I shall make my way to 'First Love' first and then take the natural course :)


message 26: by flo (last edited Mar 10, 2018 08:03AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

flo Seemita wrote: "Oh dear Flor! What a sweeping, serene stream of reflections flow in this review of yours! It was just two days ago that a friend of mine was urging me to read 'First Love' by Turgenev and here I am..."

Heh. I think I haven't met the right people to avoid the sour seeds of cynicism. I'd also encourage to read First Love, and I'll be waiting for what I know will be a delightful review. That one and Asya are considered his finest short stories. I hope you enjoy them both. :)
I'm glad you liked this. My journey with Chinese poetry has been (and still is) an incredibly enriching journey.
Many thanks for your kind words!


message 27: by Anu (new)

Anu Florencia wrote: "Thanks! I start tomorrow *sigh* A quiet first week, I assume, so I'll read another new book and then spend the year trying to finish what I started ages ago, Proust and Mishima's novels, and other two mammoth projects. Good luck to you too, if you have some more studying to do. :)"

Ah, I start for good in September, so I'm a little better of till then. :P However, I've also been focussing on my smaller reads, smaller projects, because I can't seem to find the time to read the really lovely, large books that stare at me from my shelf. :( Thanks Flo! And happy reading to you! :D


back to top