Sign in with Facebook
James DeSantis's Reviews > JLA: Earth 2
JLA: Earth 2
by
by
I think I would have liked this more with better art...maybe?
So besides the ugly art and the dumb as fuck idea to put this in a graphic novel costing 15 bucks but only half of it being a actual story the rest being just pages of random sketches, it wasn't all that bad. It was interesting, kind of fun, but little pointless.
On a world that is based off evil is right the Justice league come to fix things. As they do, they finally realize this world isn't like their own. NO matter how much you try to do "right" the right in this universe isn't what works. It's a interesting take on things and I enjoyed that part.
I also enjoyed the interaction of the characters, all well done.
I dunno though, just didn't grab me. It's good, just not great.
So besides the ugly art and the dumb as fuck idea to put this in a graphic novel costing 15 bucks but only half of it being a actual story the rest being just pages of random sketches, it wasn't all that bad. It was interesting, kind of fun, but little pointless.
On a world that is based off evil is right the Justice league come to fix things. As they do, they finally realize this world isn't like their own. NO matter how much you try to do "right" the right in this universe isn't what works. It's a interesting take on things and I enjoyed that part.
I also enjoyed the interaction of the characters, all well done.
I dunno though, just didn't grab me. It's good, just not great.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
JLA.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
November 19, 2016
–
Started Reading
November 19, 2016
– Shelved
November 19, 2016
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-7 of 7 (7 new)
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Jesse
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Nov 19, 2016 08:34AM
You might be the only person to ever call Frank Quitely's art ugly. Lol.
reply
|
flag
Did you just... "like" a Morrison comic? Whoa.Maybe I'll pick this up soon. Sounds interesting.
Paz wrote: "Did you just... "like" a Morrison comic? Whoa.Maybe I'll pick this up soon. Sounds interesting."
Yeah, scary. Though I also did like Batman and Robin Volume 1 and 3 that he did. That's about it though haha.
Jesse wrote: "You might be the only person to ever call Frank Quitely's art ugly. Lol."
Yeah. I like to be a first of a lot of things. I hate All Star Superman, people go all wide eye. I think Kingdom Come was meh (and dislike Alex's art after awhile) and people had a heart attack. I seem to make people go crazy with some of my views haha
You're not alone, James; I really don't like Frank Quitely's artwork either.
Paul wrote: "You're not alone, James; I really don't like Frank Quitely's artwork either."Woot! High Five!
Josh wrote: "No shame in not digging the art. Quietly is very hit or miss. His X-Men art was funky. I'm with you on Alex Ross too. His art works great as individual frames, but once action is thrown into the mi..."
Yeah, well funny thing is I liked his art on Batman and Robin and LOVED it in Jupiter's Legacy but I believe that was because it was it's own "feel" it's own "look"
In all seriousness I get people who don't care for some of his work. I like it alot but to each his own.
I'll just pile on here: I despised the art in this comic. Every man and woman has the same face and the women look borderline retarded, with huge jaws and tiny features in the middle of the face.Everything else was very good, but that guy cannot do different faces to save his own life.
