Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Graeme Rodaughan's Reviews > Carmilla

Carmilla by J. Sheridan Le Fanu
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
56397934
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: horror, vampires, gets-under-your-skin

Horror Reader Shocker! Spooky Vampire Leaves Wannabe Author Prostrated!: "What the FRACK!!! I can't get her out of my head!" - Vampire Guild Weekly

After reading this book, I am left frustrated and oddly underwhelmed, and yet there is an undeniable and dare I say it 'uncanny,' power to this story which is a mystery to me.

The smartest character in the story is the antagonist (who is not that smart), who proceeds to charm and bamboozle an array of protagonists who are all very nice, and not the least bit given to suspicion of others.

There are multiple events where the fact that Carmilla is a vampire is hinted at with growing strength, up to and including the discovery of a perfect portrait painted in the dim past. Le Fanu doesn't quite get to the point of hanging a sign, written in fresh blood around Carmilla's neck proclaiming, "I am a vampire, and I am here to kill you." But he gets close.

With the characters stumbling about in their ignorance as the Vampire runs rings around them - I was left imagining shooting fish in a barrel. I found myself thinking what if a terrible blizzard arrived that shut up the Schloss for 3 days (and especially 3 nights). Leaving Carmilla alone with only the hero - Laura (our narrator), her father, the governess, and the other staff without any hope of escape. As the death toll mounted, the presence of a vampire would quickly become obvious. Laura would then be confronted with a need to make a decision of consequence and take irrevocable action. Something she really doesn't get much of a chance to do.

Passive characters, especially if the narrator are frustrating.

On the plus side, the author has made an excellent stab at establishing the vampire genre. He has also provided a clever subplot of lesbian love. Neither would have been easy to do in his day and age.

Also the description of the actual vampire attacks is genuinely spooky and admirable writing.

While this book failed to excite me with it's general lack of pace and suspense, It has deep qualities that many would appreciate. Especially those with a taste for "Creeping Horror."

On a decidedly UNCANNY personal note. ... I had a dream, an incredibly VIVID dream, while reading this novel where I was visited by a magnetic, alluring, dark-haired female vampire and I willing offered my arm to her. Something that I have never done before in a dream. What was also noteworthy was the experience of an abiding personal intimacy that accompanied the act of freely giving blood to sustain another.

The sultry summer evening had barely given way to the night. I had left the bedroom doors open to the balcony to allow a light breeze to circulate. I lay back on the bed, tossing and turning, unable to sleep. The house belonged to me, I was its sole occupant, but the loneliness of this house weighed heavily - it was not a home.

Moonlight cut through the room, then it vanished for an instant. A momentary shadow flitting through the doorway, entering my bedroom and filling it with a pervasive sense of possession - the room was no longer mine.

My heart thudded in my chest. I sat up suddenly, pressing backward against the headboard. There was someone in the room, the feeling of Her presence was overwhelming, but I couldn't see anyone - there was no one there.

The shadows thickened at the end of my bed. I stared, frozen where I sat, as the shadows coalesced into the ethereal shape of a young woman. She wore a light diaphanous gown. Her hair was lustrous black, her skin pale like marble, her eyes were large and dark, her lips red, full and slightly curved in a coy smile.

Her form solidified. A faint perfume filled the air. She seemed deeply familiar, and yet, I had never seen her before - at least I had no memory of ever meeting her and I'm sure I would not have forgotten.

She moved to her right, floating, lithe, serene. She was majestic and mesmerizing - power beyond words was bound up in her gaze. Her eyes glittered like black diamonds, brilliant and hard. I couldn't tear my eyes away from them even if I tried.

She sat down beside me, gently picking up my left arm with her cool hands. She turned it over, palm up. I didn't resist - I didn't want to. I lifted my arm up and she lent forward.

A bell rang in the distance, a muffled warning - ignored and discarded in the face of her needs. Needs I was a willing servant to.

Moonlight gleamed on her ivory fangs. She leaned further in, first kissing, then licking - finally biting. A single drop of blood fell off my wrist, dark against the white bed sheet. She murmured in delight, my heart beat hard in my chest, but I stayed still - unwilling to disturb her feast.

Everything was for her...

(inspired by my dream while reading this book...)


I am left wondering just how deep this story can creep into you when you read it?

Strongly Recommended. 5 'Spooky Vampire Kisses Beneath the Moonlight,' Stars.
117 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Carmilla.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 29, 2016 – Started Reading
December 29, 2016 – Shelved
December 29, 2016 – Shelved as: horror
December 29, 2016 – Shelved as: vampires
December 29, 2016 –
page 1
0.93% "Reading this with Castle Dracula, BoM at /topic/show/...

Really looking forward to my first taste of this vampire classic."
January 5, 2017 –
31.0% "Well - Carmilla has her feet under the table, and now I'm waiting to see when she sinks her fangs in."
January 6, 2017 –
43.0% "Takes off with the narrator's 1st real nightmare - or was it an attack."
January 8, 2017 – Finished Reading
March 27, 2020 – Shelved as: gets-under-your-skin

Comments Showing 1-30 of 30 (30 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Sr3yas (new)

Sr3yas Nice Review ! So is it worth my time ?


Lena You too! What is it about this book?!?!


Graeme Rodaughan Sreyas wrote: "Nice Review ! So is it worth my time ?"

Do you have an interest in historical fiction, vampires, and creeping horror done at a leisurely pace?

If so - then yes.


Graeme Rodaughan Lena wrote: "You too! What is it about this book?!?!"

Yes, I know - bizarre.


Perry Lake Graeme, while I hold the story in higher esteem than you, I am intrigued and amused about the dream that followed your reading of "Carmilla". Recall that (view spoiler)
So has the Countess set her eyes on you? *Perry giggles gleefully and rubs his hands together*


Graeme Rodaughan LOL Perry!

(Well you never know...)


message 7: by Miriam (new)

Miriam Smith (A Mother’s Musings) Brilliant review Graeme! 😊


Graeme Rodaughan Thanks Miriam.


message 9: by LGandT (new)

LGandT I loved this one, except I wish there had been more backstory for Carmilla herself.


Graeme Rodaughan LGandT wrote: "I loved this one, except I wish there had been more backstory for Carmilla herself."


Hi LGandT, check out /review/show... there is a fair amout of material around Carmilla and her relationship to Dracula.


message 11: by Greg (new)

Greg Sounds like the dream was better than the book! :P


Graeme Rodaughan Greg wrote: "Sounds like the dream was better than the book! :P"

That's a bit naughty... :-).


message 13: by Greg (new)

Greg Graeme Rodaughan wrote: "Greg wrote: "Sounds like the dream was better than the book! :P"

That's a bit naughty... :-)."


Well that depends on the dream... :P


Luvtoread (Trying to catch up) Great review Graeme! Wondering about this dream though, maybe Perry has something there! Lol. Are you certain that this was just
a vivid dream? Did you check your wrist and your sheets for a drop of BLOOD?!!


Graeme Rodaughan No blood on the sheets ... fortunately.


message 16: by C.T. (new)

C.T. Phipps That was no dream! :)


Graeme Rodaughan Fortunately C.T. - it was. I'd hate to have that in real life. True terror of some sort - I'm sure.


Ginger Great review Graeme! I listened to this one on audio and loved it. I wasn’t expecting to enjoy it as much as I did and we both experienced the mystery of Carmilla. 🤣😂


Graeme Rodaughan Hi Ginger, definently a spooky story. Glad you enjoyed it.


message 20: by Marie (new) - added it

Marie Cool review! The dream sounds like a nightmare but authors have weird vivid dreams anyway so that is a given. lol

Loved your five star quote and the headliner was cool too. :)


Graeme Rodaughan Thanks, Marie.


Graeme Rodaughan Hi N, imagine a piece of paper with a large plus sign '+' on it. At the top is 'Loved it,' at the bottom, is 'Hated it,' on the right side, is 'Huge Impact,' on the left side, is 'No Impact.'

How I really feel about this book is a star on the far right about half way up the vertical axis.

I.e. I quite liked the story (say ... 3 conventional stars), as I found it a bit slow (languid pace) with some features (passive narrator) that I'm not keen on - but, my goodness, THE IMPACT WAS OFF THE SCALE!!!! This story gave me spooky vivid dreams...

Hence 5 stars.

I hope that helps.


message 23: by Graeme (last edited May 17, 2022 01:48PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Graeme Rodaughan She's the most interesting character in the book, and kinda gets under your skin.

Noting that I love a well-drawn villain, and there's definently a charisma present in her character.


Graeme Rodaughan N wrote: "Was there anything else you disliked about the story?"

Summed up above with "While this book failed to excite me with it's general lack of pace and suspense, It has deep qualities that many would appreciate. Especially those with a taste for "Creeping Horror.""


Graeme Rodaughan N wrote: "Also do you recommend it?"

As per above, 'Especially those with a taste for "Creeping Horror."'


Graeme Rodaughan N wrote: "Do you think the characters are well written? Besides the passive narrator of course. And how about the story, was it well written to you as well? Sorry about the questions, I am just still a bit confused by your review as you never really mention much of that...."

Hi N. I see that you remain confused by my review.

I don't see how I can help you with further explanation.

May you have a good day, or evening, or night, depending on your locale, and best wishes for your future reading.

Cheers Graeme


message 27: by C.T. (last edited May 21, 2022 06:46PM) (new)

C.T. Phipps Fantastic review, though I do think there's a very good reason that no one thinks Carmilla is a vampire. At the time of the book's writing, vampires weren't even that famous of a monster let alone something you didn't believe to be real.


Graeme Rodaughan C.T. wrote: "Fantastic review, though I do think there's a very good reason that no one thinks Carmilla is a vampire. At the time of the book's writing, vampires weren't even that famous of a monster let alone ..."

Hmmm. The simple ignorance excuse. You have a point. The poor people of the schloss needed a Van Helsing figure to point the finger and whisper in dramatic tones, "Vampire!"


message 29: by C.T. (new)

C.T. Phipps Graeme wrote: "C.T. wrote: "Fantastic review, though I do think there's a very good reason that no one thinks Carmilla is a vampire. At the time of the book's writing, vampires weren't even that famous of a monst..."

Yeah, it'd be like someone points and goes, "Rakshasa!"

"What?"


Graeme Rodaughan Lol


back to top