Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Larry H's Reviews > The Perfect Stranger

The Perfect Stranger by Megan Miranda
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5872506
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: netgalley

I'm between 3.5 and 4 stars here.

Sometimes I think we put unfair pressure on authors. Let's say an author writes a book that blows you away. You eagerly anticipate their next book, sometimes you get impatient if it takes them too long to write another one, and then when you get the chance to read it, you expect this one to blow you away, too, right? (I know I'm not alone here.) But if it doesn't come close to the last book, at least in your mind, whose fault is that, yours or theirs?

I pondered this as I got ready to read Megan Miranda's The Perfect Stranger . Her last book, All the Missing Girls , was fantastic, both for the mystery itself and the unique way Miranda let the story unfold. The book even made my list of . So needless to say, I tried very hard to ratchet back my expectations of her new book, because I didn't want to be disappointed just because I loved her last book so much.

Did she deliver? While The Perfect Stranger isn't perfect, it's a good, suspenseful read. And I think I might have liked it even more if I didn't read Miranda's last book and expect to be dazzled. If you go in knowing that, you'll hopefully enjoy it.

"I can only explain it this way: that I knew her deeply, if not thoroughly; that a four-month relationship can supersede all the boyfriends, all the friendships, that came after and lasted longer, that our friendship was born from the one time I'd stepped off track, done something unexpected that did not follow the predicted steps of my life. And for that reason, it shone brighter, and so did she."

Leah Stevens was a journalist in Boston who got a little too emotionally invested in an exposé she wrote. When she refused to reveal her source, and things related to her story unraveled, a restraining order was taken out against her and the newspaper she worked for was threatened with a lawsuit. Without a job and feeling utterly betrayed, she needed to get out of town—fast. She ran into an old friend, Emmy Grey, with whom she lived just after college.

On the run from a bad relationship, Emmy is desperate to leave Boston as well, so she involves Leah in her plan. The two head to a small town in Western Pennsylvania, where Leah gets a teaching job, and they can both keep off the grid. Leah and Emmy live on parallel schedules, and the two rarely if ever see each other for more than a few minutes, especially when Emmy starts dating someone new. But Leah keeps getting the sense that Emmy is still on her guard, that she's waiting for something to happen.

One night, a woman with a strong resemblance to Leah is assaulted and left for dead. A teacher who has shown a little too much interest in Leah is the suspect, which puts Leah a little more in the spotlight than she'd like, since her previous life has been kept a secret. But when Emmy disappears a few days later, Leah has no choice but to put herself out there and try to find out what happened to her friend.

Leah cooperates with the handsome young police officer who is assigned to the assault case, and tries to get him to help find Emmy. As the police investigate, she realizes that despite feeling tremendously close to Emmy, she never really knew her, which leads the police to suspect that Leah may be making the whole story up, that Emmy may not really exist, especially once they learn of Leah's past. But she knows the truth, and she is determined to find out just who Emmy was, and what happened to her, even if it means returning to the scene of her past transgressions, and possibly putting her own life and her own future at risk.

How well do we really know someone? How far would you go for a friend who has done a lot for you? Does one questionable action in our past doom us forever? The Perfect Stranger strives to answer all of those questions. It definitely keeps you guessing, because you aren't sure how reliable of a narrator Leah really is. The book's setting helps add to the tension, adding an almost moody feel to the whole thing.

As I mentioned earlier, there are things I didn't like about the book. There were a lot of things happening at once, and some of the storylines seemed unfinished, even unnecessary to the core of the plot. But Miranda really is an excellent writer, and knows how to slowly let details unfold so you stay hooked. So of course, what this means is, I'll eagerly await her next book, and remind myself to dial back my expectations again. (I never learn...)

NetGalley and Simon & Schuster provided me an advance copy of the book in exchange for an unbiased review. Thanks for making this available!

See all of my reviews at .
191 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Perfect Stranger.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 17, 2017 – Started Reading
January 17, 2017 – Shelved
January 17, 2017 – Shelved as: netgalley
January 19, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-25 of 25 (25 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Lindsay L Excellent review Larry!!


Larry H Lindsay wrote: "Excellent review Larry!!"

Thanks, Lindsay!!


Chelsea Humphrey I've put this one off for that very reason. I loved All the Missing Girls and I'm terrified this one won't live up to my expectations. Wonderful review Larry!


Bam cooks the books Great review! I have yet to read anything by this author and may have to rectify that.


message 5: by Victoria (new)

Victoria Why do I get the feeling I liked your review a lot more than I'll like the book? I agree with you about expectations, but some authors do manage to deliver time and again and I'm left to wonder if the magic of All the Missing Girls was in the reverse telling. Hmmm.


message 6: by Christine (new)

Christine Gosh Larry, this sounds really good. Since I didn't read her first, perhaps I am in good position to read this one. Thanks for the excellent review!


Larry H Chelsea wrote: "I've put this one off for that very reason. I loved All the Missing Girls and I'm terrified this one won't live up to my expectations. Wonderful review Larry!"

Thanks, Chelsea! I don't think it was as good as that book, but if you read it without thinking about that, if you pretend this is the first Miranda book you've read, it's a good one.


Larry H Bam wrote: "Great review! I have yet to read anything by this author and may have to rectify that."

Thanks, Bam! I highly recommend "All the Missing Girls," but this is good, too.


Larry H Victoria wrote: "Why do I get the feeling I liked your review a lot more than I'll like the book? I agree with you about expectations, but some authors do manage to deliver time and again and I'm left to wonder if ..."

Agreed, Victoria. Some authors do deliver every time. I still think she's a good storyteller, although nothing can beat the way she told "All the Missing Girls."


Larry H Christine wrote: "Gosh Larry, this sounds really good. Since I didn't read her first, perhaps I am in good position to read this one. Thanks for the excellent review!"

Thanks, Christine! Yeah, it was a good one, and without the expectations of her first book, you may enjoy this even more than I did! I'll look forward to your thoughts!


message 11: by Carol (new)

Carol Oh Larry, I love the questions you ask and the summation. I try really hard not to be too hard on authors and to rate each book on its own merits. Of course if I loved one, I want the next to deliver and maybe it does but it's not for me. Series are particularly hard in this regard as it must be difficult for an author to keep up the momentum. Sometimes I do think they should end a series while it continue to be fresh and exciting.

The question of how well you really know someone is one heck of a theme to explore. I live for this kind of a book. I haven't read All the Missing Girls and perhaps should try that one first.


message 12: by Jordan (new) - added it

Jordan I totally get what you mean about setting high expectations for authors - when one of their books is amazing we expect the same from all. I am the same way and if I love an authors book I go out immediately and get another book they've written and often find it disappointing, whereas, if I'd read it with no preconceived notions or expectations I probably would have enjoyed it more. I love that your reviews are fair and kind but still very accurate and helpful, you've found an excellent balance which I myself aim for as well. I always try to remember it's the book I'm rating/reviewing, not the person who wrote it, and I try not to post anything I wouldn't feel comfortable saying directly to the writer.


Larry H Carol wrote: "Oh Larry, I love the questions you ask and the summation. I try really hard not to be too hard on authors and to rate each book on its own merits. Of course if I loved one, I want the next to deliv..."

Thanks so much, Carol! I try, too, but we're only human after all. Again, I enjoyed this book and think I might have even a bit more if I wasn't thinking of her last book. But I still think it's a worthwhile read because of the questions it raises.

I hope you enjoy it if you read it!


Larry H Jordan wrote: "I totally get what you mean about setting high expectations for authors - when one of their books is amazing we expect the same from all. I am the same way and if I love an authors book I go out im..."

Jordan, you are so right! There are very few books I out-and-out hate, and the truth is, if I feel that way, I rarely finish them so I don't even bother reviewing those I DNF unless I get far into it. (And then, if I get too far, what's the point of stopping?)

I've read too many books--and reviews--to think everyone's opinions will echo mine. There are some books I loved that others didn't, and vice-versa. So even when a book doesn't click for me like I hoped, I try to find the things that might appeal to others. (It's not always easy, LOL!)


message 15: by Liz (new) - rated it 5 stars

Liz I loved All the Missing Girls as well. Will try to keep an open mind when I read this one.


Larry H Liz wrote: "I loved All the Missing Girls as well. Will try to keep an open mind when I read this one."

Yeah, I think if you can put out of your mind it's another of her books you'll enjoy it even more, but it's still a good read.


Lesley Moseley Just started reading this one as many of my GR friends have rated it 3-4 stars. Thanks.


Larry H Lesley wrote: "Just started reading this one as many of my GR friends have rated it 3-4 stars. Thanks."

Hope you enjoy it, Lesley!


Robbi Leah  Freeman I was lost and feel asleep during this book numerous times! But the last hour of reading she packed in her writing talent.


Candace Blackwell Very true!! It's hard not to put expectations on authors follow up books ! Especially when the first book blows you away ! However , the majority of my favorite authors continue to write suspenseful story's that keep me reading to the wee early morning ...


message 21: by James (new) - added it

James F. Thanks Larry I added it to my books I want to read I also enjoyed All the Missing Girls


PattyMacDotComma Good review, Larry, and I like your comments about raised expectations. It’s a bit depressing when you feel disappointed, and maybe you couldn’t really be disappointed if you didn’t have some preconceived idea of what to expect. I find it hard to pinpoint why one story might appeal to me more than another, but sometimes I think it’s as simple as the mood I’m in.


Larry H James wrote: "Thanks Larry I added it to my books I want to read I also enjoyed All the Missing Girls"

Hope you enjoy this one, too, James! It's not quite as good but it's still a good read!


Larry H PattyMacDotComma wrote: "Good review, Larry, and I like your comments about raised expectations. It’s a bit depressing when you feel disappointed, and maybe you couldn’t really be disappointed if you didn’t have some preco..."

I couldn't agree more, Patty! There are some books that EVERYONE has loved and I've really disliked them. I wonder if it was my mood, or if I just really didn't like the book.


Terry Derossitt This was the first book I have read from this author and maybe because of that...I was blown away by this one. I DO believe it is difficult to find the same passion for the next book if the first was one of your favorites. I can't wait to read "All the missing girls" since I loved this one so much!


back to top