Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Kalliope's Reviews > El barón rampante

El barón rampante by Italo Calvino
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3593962
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: 20-century, translation, italy



PARALLEL WORLDS

Most peculiar this Fable. Or at least its beginnings.

It baffled me that after the initial proposition, the notion of a young nobleman exiling himself to live in the trees of his family’s estate--a proposition that has a great deal of charm and immediately captivates the reader--, a fair amount of the early part of the novel is devoted at making the unlikely believable, and the unbelievable likely.

For the ordered and systematic transposition of the life on the ground onto its parallel life in the trees made me wonder whether the initial idea was becoming less and less lofty.

Unquestionably, the novel never stopped being a great pleasure to read. Calvino’s prose (in translation, but I like to remind myself that Spanish and Italian are sister languages) is sheer delight. Clear and balanced sentences rich in imaginative detail. But the undoing of the doing � the bringing down to the ground what had been raised above it, or rather, the raising of the ground until the higher branches seemed just another ground, perplexed me.

That is until suddenly the magic of the allegory crystalized in my mind: Cosimo, the young nobleman, as the writer, as the creator of his own world, keeping a separate existence but never forgetting the world from which he originates and which he never stops observing. Life in parallel worlds.

With this interpretation, the setting of the story during the Enlightenment received a new glow for me too. I had been noting the various references: Paul Et Virginie; La nouvelle Héloïse. Tome I; Montesquieu; Clarissa, or, the History of a Young Lady; Henry Fielding. All mentioned with enthusiasm. Cosimo lived in the century of Utopias.

But this novel reminds us that absolutism followed the epoch of ideas, and that Cosimo’s parallel world, like most utopias, can dissolve.

What was Calvino trying to tell us about his world?
55 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read El barón rampante.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

December 8, 2012 – Shelved (Other Paperback Edition)
July 15, 2013 – Shelved as: considering (Other Paperback Edition)
January 26, 2017 – Started Reading
January 26, 2017 – Shelved
January 28, 2017 –
page 65
23.64%
January 30, 2017 –
page 108
39.27% "Esa necesaria presencia que para el perro es el hombre y para el hombre es el perro, nunca los traicionaba, ni a uno ni al otro; y aunque distinto de todos los hombres y perros del mundo, podían decirse, como hombre y perro, felices."
February 1, 2017 –
page 119
43.27% "A Cosimo, el comprender el carácter de Carreta le benefició en algo: entendió muchas cosas sobre la soledad, que después le sirvieron en su vida. Yo diría que siempre llevó a cuestas la imagen singular del Caballero Abogado, como advertencia de en qué puede convertir el hombre que separa su suerte de la de los demás, y consiguió no parecérsele nunca."
February 4, 2017 –
page 170
61.82% "En resumen, le había entrado esa manía de quien cuenta historias y nunca sabe si son más hermosas las que ocurrieron de verdad, y que al evocarlas traen consigo todo un mar de horas pasadas, de sentimientos menudos, tedios felicidades, incertidumbres, vanaglorias, náuseas de uno mismo, o bien las que se inventan, en las que se corta por lo sano y todo parece fácil."
February 5, 2017 –
page 184
66.91% "Paul et Virginie, La nouvelle Heloïse... more 18thC writing."
February 5, 2017 –
page 197
71.64% "Comenzó por esa época a escribir un "Proyecto de Constitución de un Estado Ideal fundado en los árboles", donde describiría la imaginaria República de Arbórea,habitada por hombres justos.Lo inició como un tratado sobre la leyes y los gobiernos, pero al escribir se vio arrastrado por sus inclinación de inventor de historias complicadas y salió un florilegio de aventuras, duelos e historias eróticas."
February 17, 2017 – Shelved as: 20-century
February 17, 2017 – Shelved as: translation
February 17, 2017 – Shelved as: italy
February 17, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-20 of 20 (20 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Great analysis of a beautiful book, Kalliope. Makes me want to reread it immediately.


Kalliope Thank you, Lisa.. as you may well know this forms part of a group of 3. I plan to get to the other two at some point.


Kalliope Jean-Paul wrote: "Riviting review, Kalliope, of a book, which I look forward to reading soon."

Thank you, J-P... I will be very curious to know your opinion when you get to read this.


Violet wells First Italian book I ever read in Italian. My memory is of reaching for the dictionary every three minutes. Nice review, Kal.


Kalliope Violet wrote: "First Italian book I ever read in Italian. My memory is of reaching for the dictionary every three minutes. Nice review, Kal."

Thank you, Violet. I have his Il visconte dimezzato in Italian...


message 6: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala You really create the sense of the ground shifting, Kalliope! And I was interested in all the references you picked up. I look forward to reading this soon - but in the meantime, I had a thought about a possible inspiration for the Baron. I remember reading that Calvino had modeled his Silas Flannery character from If on a Winter's Night a Traveler on the author Flann O'Brien - and 'If on a Winter's Night' is after all a compilation of interrupted narratives like O'Brien's At Swim-Two-Birds. Well, there's a character in 'At Swim' called Sweeny - he's a medieval king who lives in the trees. Your review set me thinking of him - though he grew feathers while living in the trees...


Kalliope Fionnuala wrote: "You really create the sense of the ground shifting, Kalliope! And I was interested in all the references you picked up. I look forward to reading this soon - but in the meantime, I had a thought ab..."

Thank you, Fionnuala, for your interesting comment. I remember your reading Flann O'Brien and your reviews.... I have not tackled this author yet... Fascinating his Sweeny....


message 8: by Lizzy (new) - added it

Lizzy Great review, Kalliope! I've had this in my wish list for ever, now it seems you inspired me to finally read it. L.


Kalliope Lizzy wrote: "Great review, Kalliope! I've had this in my wish list for ever, now it seems you inspired me to finally read it. L."

Thank you, Lizzy. You will not regret it. I look forward to your take.


message 10: by Steve (new) - added it

Steve "making the unlikely believable, and the unbelievable likely. " Great antimetabole and great review. Looks like another one to add to the wishlist. Thanks, Kalliope.


Kalliope Steve wrote: ""making the unlikely believable, and the unbelievable likely. " Great antimetabole and great review. Looks like another one to add to the wishlist. Thanks, Kalliope."

Thank you, Steve.. I did not know that the name for such an expression is an antimetabole. Nice term... This book, like most of those I have read by Calvino, are great reads.


message 12: by Steve (new) - added it

Steve Kalliope wrote: "Steve wrote: ""making the unlikely believable, and the unbelievable likely. " Great antimetabole and great review. Looks like another one to add to the wishlist. Thanks, Kalliope."

Thank you, Stev..."


Rhetorical figures of speech always catch my attention. As for Calvino, I have Invisible Cities already on my shelf, so maybe I'll start there.


Kalliope Steve wrote: "Kalliope wrote: "Steve wrote: ""making the unlikely believable, and the unbelievable likely. " Great antimetabole and great review. Looks like another one to add to the wishlist. Thanks, Kalliope."..."

Invisible Cities is a perfect book to start with.


David Hanging out in trees is fun. I loved this book. Loved your comments. And yes, trying to get away from the mad, mad world.


Kalliope David wrote: "Hanging out in trees is fun. I loved this book. Loved your comments. And yes, trying to get away from the mad, mad world."

I imagine.. life in the trees would certainly have many advantages.... I was perplexed though, the a great part of the beginning of the novel was to show that life on earth could be replicated with a life on branches... May be the replica would should not be the objective.


David Kalliope wrote: "David wrote: "Hanging out in trees is fun. I loved this book. Loved your comments. And yes, trying to get away from the mad, mad world."

I imagine.. life in the trees would certainly have many adv..."

Yes I remember that too. Perhaps I spoke too rashly.


message 17: by Seemita (new) - added it

Seemita Ah, the typical ingenuity of Calvino! Perhaps he was trying to tell the world to pare up to his'? ;) Lovely review, Kall.


message 18: by Cecily (new) - added it

Cecily I've not read this Calvino, but I love the sound of this one, especially the fact it isn't straightforward (is it ever with Calvino?).


Kalliope Cecily wrote: "I've not read this Calvino, but I love the sound of this one, especially the fact it isn't straightforward (is it ever with Calvino?)."

This one forms part of a sort of trilogy -loosely understood. I still have to read the other two.


Kalliope Henry wrote: "Lovely review. Not my favorite Calvino, but I thoroughly enjoyed this one nonetheless. There is romanticism in the notion, and you are spot on on the parallel worlds, which push and pull but never ..."

Thank you, Henry.. yes, the parallel story is another parallel story in the shape of a nice cherry.... wonderful image.


back to top