ŷ

Julie G's Reviews > Pastoralia

Pastoralia by George Saunders
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5211606
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: in-short, this-fantasy-life

Almost two decades before George Saunders published the everybody's-talking-about-it book, Lincoln in the Bardo, he published Pastoralia.

Pastoralia is a collection of six short stories, and they are some of the weirdest, bleakest, and most well-written ones I've ever encountered.

As I worked through (struggled through) each one of them, I kept asking myself, Are these dystopian? I tend to think of "dystopian" as futuristic, or containing more futuristic elements, of government-imposed rations, restrictions, etc, and these stories are not like that. However, when I looked up the actual definition of the adjective "dystopian," this is what I found: "relating to or denoting an imagined place or state in which everything is unpleasant or bad, typically a totalitarian or environmentally degraded one."

Okay. So, yes, they're dystopian. And more.

The first one, "Pastoralia," the lead story of the collection, is the longest and the weirdest. I think his editor made a mistake placing this in the first position. I found the story beyond quirky and unrelatable, and I would have been done with the entire collection after this weird tale, had I not told my sister I would read this book.

The second, third and fourth stories were so dark and depressing, I wished I'd had a cup of Kool-Aid and a cyanide capsule to go along with the book. Reading about the people in these stories is like having a nightmare in which a former reality-tv host is the president of the most powerful country in the world, and waking up to discover it's true.

In the fifth and sixth stories, I finally got to sit back a little and think, "Damn, Mr. Saunders, when you're not depressing the hell out of me, you can be funny and a little bit romantic, too. It made me hopeful to read Lincoln in the Bardo.

But, of course, the last sentence of the collection left me sucker-punched in the gut. Who is this guy?

I'm hesitant to recommend this, unless you're a reader who likes to smack your shoulders up against the edge, or if good writing supersedes all else for you.

Four stars for excellent writing, originality and memorable, though disturbing perspectives on humanity. . . that I hope, despite our current despair, are not true.
45 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Pastoralia.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 20, 2017 – Started Reading
February 20, 2017 – Shelved
February 24, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-14 of 14 (14 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Robin (new)

Robin I love this review. And I think I might enjoy reading this book because damn it, I *love* to smack my shoulders up against the edge. It's my favourite thing to do, ever!

Oh, and I also love good writing. Including yours Julie, you are so fun to read.


Julie G Why, thank you!! I feel the same way about your writing. And, yes, I do think you'd like this read, if only for the succinct and precise prose and the genius of his madness!!


Christine Boyer Ha! I just saw your review. Excellent! I wasn't sure where you were going to go with this. I think your conclusions were dead on. It's definitely not for every reader, but the writing IS incredible - which I feel like you conveyed. I had that "sucker punch" moment several times throughout the book, too.


Ilana (illi69) Just saw this recommended in “Read this Next�. Great review. Taking a chance and adding it. I’ve enjoyed his short stories before and looking forward to “Lincoln� too.


Sara the Librarian Julie, Julie, Julie....it was FLAVORADE not Koolaid....siiiiiggghhhh

;)


Julie G Sara,
Isn't Kool-Aid the fancy version? I'd want to take my cyanide capsule with the fanciest trashy drink possible.


message 7: by Susanne (new)

Susanne Oh my you do beat all girl. I have in fact thought of taking a cyanide pill since reality tv did in fact become reality. .. yet as Scarlett O’Hara said “Tomorrow is Another Day..�

Your review made me laugh..and then gulp.. and sigh and then laugh all over again. Sounds like a brilliant novel. If only it could hold up to your review of it!


Julie G Oh, Susanne. You're so sweet.
I think you'd be a good reader for this one. It's edgy and unpredictable. I actually thinks it deserves more attention than it has received.


Sara the Librarian Julie wrote: "Sara,
Isn't Kool-Aid the fancy version? I'd want to take my cyanide capsule with the fanciest trashy drink possible."


Fancier than Flavoraid but not exactly on the same level as Tang.


Julie G Sara,
I remember, as a kid, thinking that Tang was pretty high brow. I was also pretty amazed by the full-sized Snickers bar. You knew you'd made it big, if you were buying the big candy bars.


message 11: by Ken (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ken Lindholm Thank you for the terrific review. I’ve enjoyed Sanders before, but Pastoralia caught my attention when it was included in the NYT top 100 books so far in the 21st century. Now it’s a Kindle $1.99 special. But, it could have languished in my “to read� queue for who knows how long. With your review, I’ll be looking for the opportunity to pick up this short story collection!


Julie G Good morning, Ken! Thank you for your kind words. I think that George Saunders is an excellent writer and I don't think that you'll be disappointed in this collection. Just prepare yourself for a little weirdness!


message 13: by Ken (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ken Lindholm Yes, I’ll have to wait for the right moment! BTW - I don’t know if you’ve read Saunders’s A Swim in a Pond in the Rain. For me it was a pretty unique book based on his writing courses, studying Russian short stories.


message 14: by Ken (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ken Lindholm I recently finished the book and reread your review. I’m very much in line with your thoughts. I somewhat struggled through the early stories, but was rewarded by the conclusion.


back to top