ŷ

Jeffrey Keeten's Reviews > Istanbul: City of Majesty at the Crossroads of the World

Istanbul by Thomas F. Madden
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3427339
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: turkey

”Though all other cities have their periods of government and are subject to the decays of time, Constantinople alone seems to claim a kind of immortality and will continue to be a city as long as humanity shall live either to inhabit it or rebuild it.�

Pierre Gilles, The Antiquities of Constantinople (1548)



Old section of Istanbul.

Whether you call the city Byzantium, Constantinople, Stamboul, or Istanbul, each name evokes the same sense of mystery, decadence, and intrigue. ”Writers such as Ian Fleming and John le Carre fixed in the Western imagination a picture of Istanbul as an exotic and decadent home of treachery and subterfuge, And indeed it was.� I recently finished Joseph Kanon’s Istanbul Passage, and I would add it as another book that adds to the mystique of this famed city. Since I’ve never been to Istanbul, all of my impressions of this city have been formed by literature. I am an enthusiastic armchair traveller who frequently escapes from the desolate plains of Kansas to the most striking foreign climates by pulling a book from the shelf and letting my mind carry my body away.

Copious amounts of the world’s alcohol raki, vodka, Scotch, retsina, absinthe, bourbon, or sake are purely optional. As they say, when in Rome! Istanbul! Edinburgh! Athens! London! New York! Tokyo!

A band of Greeks were the first settlers in the place they called Byzantion in 657 BC. What the Greeks didn’t fully fathom was that they had landed in what was going to become one of the most strategic locations in the world. ”No city, not even Rome, was so strategically, so powerfully situated. Byzantion had become a city at the crossroads of the world.�


Constantine the Great

Constantine the Great arrives in 327 AD and decides to transfer the capital of the Roman Empire to this city. He refers to it as Nova Roma or New Rome, and by 330 AD, he gives up all pretenses and names the city after himself...Constantinople. After Rome falls, The City becomes the center and last bastion of power of the Roman Empire. Constantine was a Christian, but it was one of his successor, Theodosius, who in 381 put the final nail in the pagan coffin. ”The once mighty pagan cults had become an antiquarian shell, a tradition rather than a practice. Theodosius simply defunded them, while at the same time strongly supported the new religion of the Roman people, Christianity. Never again would paganism be more than a curiosity.�

Defunded is such a modern sounding word, as if it were something that was decided by a committee of Republican lawmakers in the United States. They frequently discover that they cannot abolish something, but they can starve a program by take away all of its means of support.

Constantine the Great builds massive walls to protect the city, and frequent rulers down through the ages contribute to their upkeep and add more walls. These walls are needed as Constantinople becomes more rich and power. It is the jewel that every conqueror from the Sasanids, Avars, Bulgarians, Varangians (later they served as an elite guard for future sultans), Macedonians, and Crusaders to the Ottoman Turks tries to possess. The Turks salivate for centuries over the precious pearl that rests just beyond their grasp. Constantinople is the crossroads of the world, and to control it, one could feel they also control the world. In 1453, after a seven week siege, Constantinople falls to Mehmed II, a twenty-two year old Ottoman Sultan, who comes to power after his competitors die under suspicious circumstances. He is perfect for Constantinople. The city has seen many rulers come and go. Ruthless kin or ambitious factions blinded, poisoned, stabbed, or tossed from the ramparts those who were in their way for ultimate power.


Mehmed II also has an interesting connection to Vlad the Impaler that I would tell you about, but it has no connection to this book.

Mehmed declares that all the buildings belong to him, especially the Ayasofya. Everything else in the city belongs to his soldiers. Justinian I had commissioned the building of Hagia Sophia, and it was finished in 537. It is considered to be one of the most important structures in the world. It was originally a Greek Orthodox Church, and Mehmed could have ordered it destroyed and could have attempted to build an even grander structure in its place. Thank goodness he decided to add some minarets, splash some new plaster on the walls, and reopen it as a mosque.


Ayasofya...Hagia Sophia

Now Justinian has an interesting story. He comes from very humble origins, and after becoming emperor by simply surviving longer than his more prestiges relatives, he scandalizes the empire by marrying his mistress, Theodora. ”In 525 the two were married. Two years later, in a magnificent ceremony in Hagia Sophia, the patriarch of Constantinople placed the imperial crowns on the heads of a peasant and a prostitute.�

Oh, my goodness.

Regardless of his lack of pedigree or the sullied reputation of his wife, he leaves the world a beautiful landmark that dominates the skyline of one of the most important cities in the world.


The Peasant and the Prostitute.

I’ve only touched on a handful of the wonderful stories that are contained within this book. At 358 pages it is a brief summary of a city rich with culture heritage and colorful stories. There is a lot of fascinating history to cover in so few pages, but it does serve as a good overview of knowledge, which I plan to build on as I explore more of the history of this amazing, beautiful, and intriguing city.

”Istanbul located at the junction of two great worlds, the ornament of the Turkish nation, the treasure of Turkish history, the dearest object of the Turkish nation, has a place in the heart of every Turk.� Mustafa Kemal (Ataturk) And in the heart of people from all over the world.

If you wish to see more of my most recent book and movie reviews, visit
I also have a Facebook blogger page at:
151 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Istanbul.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 21, 2017 – Started Reading
February 21, 2017 – Shelved
March 4, 2017 – Finished Reading
March 5, 2017 – Shelved as: turkey

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by John (new)

John Behle Sounds interesting. Funny, I just read a film review about the stray cats of Istanbul called "Kedi"


Jeffrey Keeten John wrote: "Sounds interesting. Funny, I just read a film review about the stray cats of Istanbul called "Kedi""

I've heard of the film John, but haven't seen the movie.


message 3: by John (new)

John Behle Jeffrey---It's Spring Break time. Vera and i are leaving March 8 for Galapagos, other South America spots


message 4: by Michael (new)

Michael Perkins Across the Golden Horn and up the hill, near the reconstructed Tower of Galata, you can visit the Orient Express Hotel. It's where the folks who road the train would stay. There's still a room with Agatha Christie's name on it. With us was a Chinese woman, a professional photographer, who had been present at Tiananmen Square. All the people involved had been exiled from China. The government did not want any martyrs. Accompanying her was her ten year old daughter. In a mischievous mood, I told her daughter that Christie's mummified remains were in the bed in the room with her name out it. There was a moment of astonished horror until my wife made me admit I was making it up.


message 5: by Treece (new)

Treece This is a really good review with amazing pics! Splendid!


Jeffrey Keeten John wrote: "Jeffrey---It's Spring Break time. Vera and i are leaving March 8 for Galapagos, other South America spots"

Enjoy yourself John! I'm looking forward to your travel report when you get back.


Jeffrey Keeten Jean-Paul wrote: "Fabulous review, Jeffrey. I highly recommend: Istanbul: Memories and the City, should you not have read it yet."

I've got it marked to read Jean-Paul. Thanks for reminding me to prioritize it. I'm so glad you enjoyed the review. These overviews are so difficult to review, what to say? and how much?


Jeffrey Keeten Michael wrote: "Across the Golden Horn and up the hill, near the reconstructed Tower of Galata, you can visit the Orient Express Hotel. It's where the folks who road the train would stay. There's still a room with..."

Now that is something I want to be able to say someday. I'm taking the Orient Express to Istanbul! Great story Michael! Love that kind of stuff.


Jeffrey Keeten Treece wrote: "This is a really good review with amazing pics! Splendid!"

Thanks Treece! I was very happy with the pics I found as well. I'm so glad you liked them!


message 10: by Michael (new)

Michael Perkins Just remember "it's Istanbul not Constantinople" in more ways than I realized until we got there.


Jeffrey Keeten Michael wrote: "Just remember "it's Istanbul not Constantinople" in more ways than I realized until we got there."

Ahh yes, of course.


message 12: by Vessey (last edited Jul 14, 2018 03:01AM) (new) - added it

Vessey Oh you brought to me such good memories. :) Not that I have ever been to Istanbul, but I remember how interesting it was when we were studying about this at school. I would even read an additional literature by my own initiative. My teacher even praised me for it. :) So what you talk of here isn't unfamiliar to me, though, admittedly, I didn't remember everything. Thank you for expanding my knowledge with your wonderful review. :) I'm listing it :)




message 13: by Sweetwilliam (new) - added it

Sweetwilliam Mehmed II also has an interesting connection to Vlad the Impaler that I would tell you about, but it has no connection to this book.

Ok, I'm intrigued...what is the connection?


Jeffrey Keeten Sweetwilliam wrote: "Mehmed II also has an interesting connection to Vlad the Impaler that I would tell you about, but it has no connection to this book.

Ok, I'm intrigued...what is the connection?"


Vlad before he was the Impaler was held captive, to keep Vlad's father in line, by Mehmed II's father Murad II. So Mehmed and Vlad knew each other. There is a book by Lucille Turner called The Sultan, the Vampyr and the Soothsayer that really explores this connection. Fascinating book!


Jeffrey Keeten Vessey wrote: "Oh you brought to me such good memories. :) Not that I have ever been to Istanbul, but I remember how interesting it was when we were studying about this at school. I would even read an additional ..."

You do know that Istanbul is just a hop, skip, and a jump from you. :-) You'll see it one day. Thanks Vessey!


message 16: by Vessey (new) - added it

Vessey Jeffrey wrote: "Vessey wrote: "Oh you brought to me such good memories. :) Not that I have ever been to Istanbul, but I remember how interesting it was when we were studying about this at school. I would even read..."

You do know that Istanbul is just a hop, skip, and a jump from you :-)

Indeed! Now I feel very important. :)

You'll see it one day.

Thank you :)


message 17: by Karin (new) - added it

Karin I read Istanbul by Bettany Hughes recently and was just there 2 weeks ago. Incredible to see how all this old history is integrated in a modern and lively city. An absolute delight. Do try to get there if you can.


Jeffrey Keeten Karin wrote: "I read Istanbul by Bettany Hughes recently and was just there 2 weeks ago. Incredible to see how all this old history is integrated in a modern and lively city. An absolute delight. Do try to get t..."

I've got Bettany's book in the stack next to my bed which means the book is on the verge of hitting my currently reading list. :-) We have actually planned two trips to Istanbul and had them cancelled due to political upheaval in the country. We will get there!


message 19: by Karin (new) - added it

Karin Jeffrey, I can assure you the odds of any political impact affecting you as a traveler now is slim to none!


message 20: by Pizza Face 973 (new)

Pizza Face 973 Face Great review. 😉


message 21: by Rowena (new) - added it

Rowena Hoseason Ooooh, this looks wonderful. Byzantium (sorry, Constantinople - sorry Istanbul) is one of our fave places. Have visited several times, and we're going back again in 2020 (strife and circumstance permitting).
Will read this beforehand, and hopefully go with my head full of new info...


Jeffrey Keeten Karin wrote: "Jeffrey, I can assure you the odds of any political impact affecting you as a traveler now is slim to none!"

I agree! If only the peace will hold!


Jeffrey Keeten Pizza wrote: "Great review. 😉"

Thanks Pizza!


Jeffrey Keeten Rowena wrote: "Ooooh, this looks wonderful. Byzantium (sorry, Constantinople - sorry Istanbul) is one of our fave places. Have visited several times, and we're going back again in 2020 (strife and circumstance pe..."

You might grab Istanbul: A Tale of Three Cities book as well Rowena. I haven't read it yet, but I will bet her book will prove useful. I probably won't get there until 2020 either, but heck who knows which direction the wind will push the sails.


message 25: by Zina (new) - rated it 5 stars

Zina Cappiello Can't wait to read! Thanks for the review!


Jeffrey Keeten Zina wrote: "Can't wait to read! Thanks for the review!"

You are welcome! I hope you enjoy it!


back to top