Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Sasha's Reviews > Are You There God? It’s Me, Margaret

Are You There God? It’s Me, Margaret by Judy Blume
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3144945
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: 2017

The first thing Margaret asks God is "Don't let New Jersey be too horrible," so you know she's in for a rough time with God. The second thing she asks for is boobs.

What makes Blume so wonderful - well, there are lots of things, but one of them is that she respects her audience, which is specifically 12-year-old girls and no one else. She's tackling big subjects here - puberty and God, so that's half of the entire list of Big Subjects - and she respects their difficulty. Margaret is the product of a mixed marriage - her mom is Christian and her dad is Jewish - and the big debate here is which God, if any, she will choose. Her parents have left the decision to her, which she feels is bullshit. "If I should ever have children," she declares, "I will tell them what religion they are so they can start learning about it at an early age. Twelve is very late to learn." And what I love is that by the end of the book, (view spoiler) this is hard, isn't it? she says.

She does this throughout the book. Margaret's new best friend Nancy is a mean girl. Blume doesn't exactly tell you this, and there's (arguably) no character arc. She's just there, kindof a bitch. Blume drops hints that the sixth-grade teacher is harboring inappropriate feelings for early-developing Laura Danker, but she leaves it to the reader to decide how seriously to take them. Most dramatically, Margaret's maternal Christian grandparents arrive for a reconciliation, after disowning their daughter when she married a Jew. You expect some resolution; (view spoiler) This is hard, right?

But look, no one even remembers any of this shit. What you and/or your girlfriend remember about this book is that it's the first one that talked about boobs and periods, and this is why Judy Blume is one of the great heroes of literature: she takes growing up seriously, which is important because growing up is serious business. Blume doesn't talk down and she doesn't moralize. She wrote this way back in 1970, in the olden days when peoples' dads subscribed to Playboy magazine, and she's still one of the most because she dared to approach topics like periods. (And sex and masturbation and other marvelous things.) It's a seminal work for generations. My wife got all giddy with nostalgia when I told her I was reading it.

Which, like, I mentioned that Blume is writing solely for 12-year-old girls, and you might wonder what it's like for a 42-year-old man to read this. Probably not though, because literally who cares, but I'll tell you anyway: it's awkward. On the one hand, we enlightened men should be well past being freaked out by periods, right? And on the other hand, there's a heavy social taboo against adult men being in any way interested in training bras, and some of the reasons for it are good. Let's just say that I often label my Kindle so people on the subway can tell what I'm reading, and this time around I chose not to. And let's also reiterate that no one cares what I think about Judy Blume.

What matters is that, 50 years on, her voice is still clear, universal, non-judgmental, invaluable. "I wanted to be honest," she says. "And I felt that no adult had been honest with me. We didn't have the information we should have had." Here is the honesty and the information. God will not increase your bust and neither will as Judy Blume is in the most likable author interview ever. And New Jersey is horrible.

If you are a parent:
There's nothing objectionable in this book. I'm alert to dated gender roles and old-timey bigotry, a la the unfortunate "darkey" poem in Little House in the Big Woods, and there's nothing like that here. You're all good.

If you are a kid and your mom won't let you read this:
Your mom sucks. Read it under the covers with a flashlight, or whatever kids use for light these days. Welcome to literature.
94 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Are You There God? It’s Me, Margaret.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 17, 2017 – Started Reading
April 17, 2017 – Shelved
April 18, 2017 – Finished Reading
April 19, 2017 – Shelved as: 2017

Comments Showing 1-46 of 46 (46 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Vrixton (new)

Vrixton Phillips lol mom told me about this one, said it "isn't for kids, though they market it that way."
also it's where the "WE MUST! WE MUST! WE MUST INCREASE OUR BUST!" chant came from, no? lol hilarious.


message 2: by Vrixton (new)

Vrixton Phillips granted, mom was raised by one of those people that would've challenged its availability at schools and libraries. Very conservative, my parents and grandparents...


message 3: by Sasha (last edited Apr 19, 2017 06:03AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sasha Vrixton wrote: "lol mom told me about this one, said it "isn't for kids, though they market it that way."
also it's where the "WE MUST! WE MUST! WE MUST INCREASE OUR BUST!" chant came from, no? lol hilarious."


Ha, yeah, what's funny is that there've now been like two full generations of moms who can't handle this book.

I did maybe more research on "we must increase our bust" than was strictly necessary, and by Blume's own account she did not invent it, although she's unquestionably responsible for its cultural relevance: "We all did that. That was just something we knew. I have no idea where it came from. It was preteen lore." Here's


message 4: by Julie (new)

Julie I read this as a teen and it is interesting that I remember the bras and periods, but nothing about the god talk. Religion was irrelevant to me.


message 5: by Sasha (last edited Apr 19, 2017 06:16AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sasha Julie wrote: "I read this as a teen and it is interesting that I remember the bras and periods, but nothing about the god talk. Religion was irrelevant to me."

I bet that's true for a lot of kids.


message 6: by Jennifer (new)

Jennifer What a great review. Thank you for reading this. Judy Blume is a hero for all kids.


Sasha Jennifer wrote: "Judy Blume is a hero for all kids."

Thank you! And yes!


message 8: by Silvana (new)

Silvana Great review, Alex. I haven't read this book but wonder what I'll feel after reading it. And how do you exactly label your kindle? You put stickers on the screen?


Sasha On the back. I have a label maker and I'm not afraid to use it.


message 10: by Sera (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sera Alex, like your wife, I became giddy to see you reading this book, and your review, made me feel nostalgic as well.


message 11: by El (new)

El This book taught me that once-upon-a-time, sanitary napkins involved a belt. That was an interesting discussion my mom and I had. I hadn't even started my period when I first read this, so I was like "Wait, I have to wear a what now??"


Sasha Oh shit yeah, I looked up sanitary belts once in response to some book or other, they're crazy.


Sasha ...oh right: the book was Rabbit, Run, and it led me to a wonderful article called which - full circle! - was inspired by Are You There God?


message 14: by El (new)

El I want to write an article called "The Menstrual Education of Alex".


message 15: by carol. (new)

carol. Best subway idea ever. Do you change the covers when you are in different boroughs?

I also got a little nostalgic when you said you were reading this. Even though I never actually read Judy Blume (she wasn't fantasy/sci-fi).


Sasha What were your big landmarks in fantasy/sci-fi, Carol? Madeline L'Engle? She was big for me.


message 17: by carol. (new)

carol. Nailed it! ;)

Middling age: along with C.S. Lewis, Phantom Tollbooth, My Father's Dragon series, the 'color' fairy tale books
Slightly older: The Hero and the Crown/The Blue Sword, anything in Darkover series by Marian Zimmer Bradley, Piers Anthony, Anne McCaffery, Mercedes Lackey, Terry Brooks


message 18: by Mary (new)

Mary This book was considered scandalous in the small Wisconsin city where I grew up, early 1970’s. My best friend Patty and I were afraid to check it out of the library so we sat side by side at a table in the library and read it together cover to cover one Saturday afternoon.


Sasha Ha! Thank you for that image, Mary, that's perfect.


message 20: by Natalia (new)

Natalia Heaney Excellent review. I've heard they've updated the book since I read it sometime around 1990, and I'm devastated! I want the retro version!

Vrixton wrote: "lol mom told me about this one, said it "isn't for kids, though they market it that way."
also it's where the "WE MUST! WE MUST! WE MUST INCREASE OUR BUST!" chant came from, no? lol hilarious."


Oh, she absolutely did NOT invent that! I know women who were born about the same time as the Margaret character, and they all did it as kids.


Sasha Thanks Natalia!


message 22: by Nadine in NY (last edited Jan 06, 2019 05:20AM) (new) - added it

Nadine in NY Jones hahahahaha somehow I never saw your review of this book!!! New Jersey is NOT horrible!!! New Jerseyans just spread the rumor that it's horrible to keep people out because it's too crowded already. It's like a Secret Society.

I feel certain I read this book because I read every Judy Blume book my library had at the time (and "at the time" was "BEFORE Forever & Wifey were published" - I distinctly remember the Big Controversy for each of those. And I skipped Deenie because that was too close to my name and that was weird.) but I don't remember any of this religion talk!! I feel like I should read this again.


Sasha Look, there are two hills that I plan to die on and they are 1) making fun of New Jersey and 2) making fun of Canada and you can pry those jokes from my cold dead fingers and reality is irrelevant.


Sasha I do want to get around to reading both Forever and Wifey.


message 25: by carol. (new)

carol. Blame Canada!


message 26: by Justine (new)

Justine Awesome review:)


Sandi This is such a great review. Thank you for writing it.


Sasha Hey, thanks Sandi! That's such a great comment; thank you for writing it!


message 29: by El (new)

El Sara Butler wrote: "your weird"

You're


Sasha well done, both of you


message 31: by NORAH (new)

NORAH Great reveiw alex! I haven't read the book but you basicly sum it up for me!


message 32: by NORAH (new)

NORAH Great review alex! I promise i did not write "your weird" my sister did! I apologise. But i have never read the book but you amazingly sum it up for me! Thanks! :) :) :)


message 33: by NORAH (new)

NORAH SORRY!!!!!!!!!!


message 34: by NORAH (new)

NORAH Alex how do you write reviews? When I learn I probably wont be as good as you!


message 35: by NORAH (new)

NORAH btw my name used to be sara butler


message 36: by NORAH (new)

NORAH I mean my goodreads name


message 37: by Sasha (last edited Feb 25, 2019 08:59AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sasha Hi Norah! Thank you for the kind words!

My biggest trick for writing is I just start - even if I don't know what to write, I just start typing. Even if it's awful. Eventually I'll type my way into something interesting (I hope). Then I pretty much erase all the nonsense and just keep the interesting part. You'll be great!


Laurie Connolly Stream of consciousness response to all this wonderfulness here . . . When I was growing up in Congo/Zaire in the '70s (dad was a bush pilot, mom taught math and operated the station's shortwave radio), our house was always filled with traveling missionaries, students, and Peace Corps volunteers hanging out between flights, getting a hot meal, and catching up on whatever was going on in that region of the country while passing through. My on-the-sly elementary school reading consisted primarily of whatever they left behind: Enid Blyton novels, The Borrowers series, The Phantom Tollbooth, George MacDonald, C.S. Lewis, Zen & The Art of Motorcycle Maintenance, The Once and Future King, Love Stories of the Bible by Billy Sunday, Heinlein's Stranger in a Strange Land, Valley of the Dolls, Hermann Hesse's Narcissus and Goldman, The Ugly American, anthropologist Colin Turnbull, Future Shock, and a whole lotta Barbara Cartland, Louis L'Amour, and missionary biographies in which the protagonists invariably and happily experienced suffering and violent deaths for Jesus. I'm pretty sure/absolutely certain my parents had no idea what I was consuming. :-D

The summer before 7th grade, we moved to a different part of the country. My new friend Sanna and I spent a week of days giggling in her bedroom as we read Are You There, God aloud to each other. Her mom had given it to her, I think, as an alternative to "the sex talk," and we wrote eagerly in our diaries and practiced "We Must! We Must!" with prayerful anticipation. (Mind you, God answered Sanna's prayers in that regard long before and far more bountifully than He answered mine.) I was hooked; Judy Blume saw straight into into my SOUL. Reading her made me feel like, wow, that girl in "Killing Me Softly with His Song": She wrote as if she knew me in all my dark despair . . . .

Kidding. Sort of.

The next place we moved to, we shared a duplex with a widowed professor who taught at the medical school on our station. (Random detail: Following the 1978 Jonestown mass suicide in Guyana, she told us Jim Jones had been her pastor "back before he went off the deep end"). Both Mom and Annabelle loved sci-fi. Someone sent Annabelle boxes of books from the states on a regular basis, and for the next three years I devoured Marion Zimmer Bradley, Ray Bradbury, Anne McCaffery, Ursula Le Guin, Lloyd Alexander, and Roger Zelazny. Ah. Major love for those authors there and then.


Sasha You found all my favorite reviews! And you had some crazy early books, huh? :) Valley of the Dolls, lol


Laurie Connolly Your reviews rock, Alex. They make me think and make my heart so dang happy in this season of crazy. I look forward to finding more of them . . . and feeling just a tad bit stalkerish at the moment.

As for early reading, yeah. Not highly age-appropriate fare in retrospect. :-D


message 41: by [deleted user] (last edited Apr 27, 2023 03:47PM) (new)

Hey, Alex. Don't tell other people how to raise their own children. And also. Don't tell children to disobey their parents. That is just creepy. And then to tell children to hide it from their parents. Good grief! So many red flags here.


message 42: by Sasha (last edited Apr 27, 2023 09:18AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sasha ESPECIALLY DONNA'S KIDS! Sorry about your mom, she seems like the worst! DM me and I'll find you a copy of this book. Remember: ALWAYS DISOBEY DONNA!


message 43: by [deleted user] (new)

And then to tell children not only to disobey their parents, but to hide it from their parents. That is seriously, seriously red flag. By any metric, you should not be trusted around children.


Sasha HIDE DRUGS AND SEX STUFF FROM DONNA, KIDS


message 45: by Arlian (new) - added it

Arlian Alex wrote: "HIDE DRUGS AND SEX STUFF FROM DONNA, KIDS"

Of all the things you've written, your reply to "Donna" is the best.

To "Donna" and similar parents: If, in 2023, *this* book is sending you into conniption fits, you probably shouldn't be having children. If letting your 11 year old child learn about periods is too scary for you, you're not mature enough to be having children. If letting your kids think about how they are going to make their own personal choices in the face of difficult philosophical decisions is too hard for you, you're a control freak and shouldn't be having children. If letting children hear other children talk about their fears of being "the new kid" is too emotionally fraught for you, you're emotionally dysfunctional and shouldn't be having children.

To the kids of parents like this: for the sake of society, please ignore your parents. Bodies gon' body, sometimes you have to make a decision that is in line with your desires and other people won't be happy about those decisions, and sometimes life changes without your input and despite your best laid plans. There's really nothing special or tabboo about any of that.

Thank you, Alex, for your words of wisdom.


Sasha Poor Donna - I think I singlehandedly ruined Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ for her. She deleted her account pretty soon after that exchange. I hope her kids are doing okay!

And thank you, Arlian.


back to top