Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Trish's Reviews > From Hell

From Hell by Alan             Moore
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3461034
's review

really liked it

This is the second graphic novel by Alan Moore that I've read. He is a very prolific writer, but sometimes he's a bit too over the top for my taste. It was OK in V for Vendetta though I must admit to liking the movie a bit better because it was more grounded. With From Hell, once again, I've seen the movie before having read the graphic novel and although the movie features Johnny Depp and a lot of opium, I liked that one better as well.

Why? Rather simple: the movie was a mystery with the watcher having to investigate along with the inspector. Here, we get the solution to it all right off the bat and it seems like wasted potential.

This graphic novel tells the story of the murders committed by one of THE most well-known serial killers of all time: Jack the Ripper.
There are many theories out there (I actually have a Mammoth Book about it because I find it so intriguing) and some of those theories are a bit more "out there". One particular conspiracy theory revolves around one of Queen Victoria's heirs having fathered a child and married a commoner, which was inconceivable back in the day (funnily enough, it still is rather unusual with the remaining royals nowadays which made Princess Diana become such a star *rolls eyes*). Anyway, since Albert is the heir to the English throne, this is unacceptable and Queen Victoria orders her physician to handle the subject. And let me tell you, he wasn't gentle about it. (view spoiler) But the plan has a flaw because there are other people who know about the child and these women, prostitutes, try to blackmail the prince's friend because they are getting harrassed by a street gang and need money to survive. Thus, the doctor is dispatched once again and goes about the grizzly work we know of.

I won't say anything about the ending, but the police (or some levels at least) knew about the plot and were paid to play along, and the killer becomes more and more psychologically unstable. That in itself is all well and good and even realistic (except for the fact that the Queen probably would have had a different way of dealing with something like this), but all the Masonic bits, the visions of the future etc were too trippy for me.
Because yes, the good doctor is not only a lord and friend to the Queen, he's also a Freemason and trying to block the influence of the Illuminati by murdering women in a grizzly way. It's all a bit bonkers.

The art is ... not to my taste. The black-and-white is OK and I get that the rudimentary and blunt style is a tool to convey a message of its own; it shows the grittiness of life if you weren't in certain social circles, illustrates the depravity of certain people and the downward spiral the Ripper takes psychologically. The panels are very graphic where sexuality is concerned (female and male body parts are shown explicitly). Both author and artist don't hold back and most in the story is somehow tied to sex. I don't mind this at all since we are following the lives of prostitutes and I don't like taboos anyway, thus I don't faint when seeing a penis depicted anywhere. No, my "problem" with the art is that I just don't find it "pretty" (attractive might be a better word to say what I mean).

Nevertheless, this is an ambitious and good piece of work and it deserves all the recognition it's gotten over the years.
68 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read From Hell.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 18, 2017 – Started Reading
April 18, 2017 – Shelved
April 18, 2017 –
page 65
11.28% "I knew this was basically the telling of one of the conspiracy theories surrounding Jack the Ripper but to basically give it all up from the beginning instead of making a mystery out of it? Hm ... seems like thrown away potential."
April 20, 2017 –
page 235
40.8% "The art work is not really to my liking but I guess it fits the theme. We've now come to the first two victims and just like with the explicit depictions of sex, the violence is shown just as bluntly. I think that is a good thing actually (authentic and I never understood taboos anyway) but I can imagine many people being too squeamish about it. *lol*"
April 20, 2017 –
page 429
74.48% "What a mess everyone's made of this! To think that only a handful of murders turned into THIS. *lol*
But the story itself has a lot of threads, intelligently woven as expected from Moore."
April 20, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-23 of 23 (23 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Bradley Great review, but I have to say I really enjoyed all the Masonic bits and the nutso mystical stuff, but that's just a matter of taste.

I, too, thought the art could have been a lot better, though. :) Just easier to read, easier to draw the eye, even if it IS bloody and sexual, those bits could have been better, too.

I actually HATED the script used in the blurbs, too, but maybe that's just me.


Trish Bits like the letter (when the handwriting got really deranged) were hard to read but since I found the rest of the art ugly already, it kinda fit and wasn't "extra" bad. *lol*


Sud666 I'm with Brad...I don't like the art and also the script style makes it hard to read at times


Sud666 ....and now that I've read your excellent review we are all in the same boat about the art.


Bradley Right? Sigh. Story needs a bit of an upgrade in art. :)


Tyler I agree on the script and art as well. The chapter where they were riding around London naming landmarks took me forever to get through. So much to read.


Sud666 Exactly..while art should be secondary to the prose, in a GN they must be more complementary and in this case the art/writing style font actually bogs you down trying to figure out WTF it says.


Trish Sud666 wrote: "....and now that I've read your excellent review we are all in the same boat about the art."

*lol* Yeah.


Sud666 wrote: "Exactly..while art should be secondary to the prose, in a GN they must be more complementary and in this case the art/writing style font actually bogs you down trying to figure out WTF it says."

I agree. While I did like the gritty art of Northlanders more than you did, for example, I just couldn't like this AT ALL. The writing font was OK most of the time. I only had realy problems with the letter and some narrower speech bubbles.


Sud666 Trish wrote: "Sud666 wrote: "....and now that I've read your excellent review we are all in the same boat about the art."

*lol* Yeah.


Sud666 wrote: "Exactly..while art should be secondary to the prose, in a G..."

Northlander's art was bad and thats a shame since good art would have enhanced a great story..but the art is not a hindrance to the story..this one unfortunately is


Trish I loved the Northlanders art. :P


Sud666 Trish wrote: "I loved the Northlanders art. :P"

some of it is ok


Trish Sud666 wrote: "Trish wrote: "I loved the Northlanders art. :P"

some of it is ok"


Well, I still need to read volumes 5 to 7 so maybe that's what you'e talking about (I know it's not).


message 13: by Sarah (new) - added it

Sarah P I still haven't finished this one yet, I've been «reading» it for months. The art didn't really bother me, mostly because I barely looked at it: I'm weird like that but I pay way more attention to the text than to the drawings. I apologise to all the artists. The lettering though is awful, it's hard to read, to the point where I get fed up pretty quickly. I though it was me but most reviews mention it as well. The historical bits are the only interesting part to me. I've never seen the movie, but maybe I should just check that one out instead?


Trish The movie isn't mind-blowing but it's pretty good (but different from the graphic novel at some point).


Sud666 Trish wrote: "Sud666 wrote: "Trish wrote: "I loved the Northlanders art. :P"

some of it is ok"

Well, I still need to read volumes 5 to 7 so maybe that's what you'e talking about (I know it's not)."


ok as in passable...I found certain issues to be execrable in art quality


Sud666 SarahP wrote: "I still haven't finished this one yet, I've been «reading» it for months. The art didn't really bother me, mostly because I barely looked at it: I'm weird like that but I pay way more attention to ..."

wait..what movie you two talking about?


Sud666 Never mind I am an idiot..I thought there was a Northlanders movie *lol* Yeah From Hell is ok...I like J Depp though, as an actor...


Trish Sud666 wrote: "Never mind I am an idiot..I thought there was a Northlanders movie *lol* Yeah From Hell is ok...I like J Depp though, as an actor..."

*lol* It's OK, it's your age so you'll get a pass. :P
I really started disliking Johnny Depp some years ago. Maybe it was his true character combined with seeing him everywhere. I don't know.


message 19: by Evan (new) - rated it 5 stars

Evan Listro It's reviews like this that make me realize the world is uneven. You are one of the many members of the 20th century that the novel so aptly predicts. From Hell is a masterpiece. If you can get over your impatience, you'd understand that. Liked the movies better, don't fucken kill me.... that's a great joke.


Trish You know, one of the great things in life is that people's tastes vary. Just because you love something, doesn't mean the whole world has to. Besides, 4 stars doesn't mean I didn't like it. So how about you go and try to find your manners, I'm sure your mother taught you some - then come back and adequately comment on why you disagree.


Sud666 Hmmm he might have a point about you being predicted in the book. I know I shake in fear at the thought of you running around unsupervised :(*


Trish Sud666 wrote: "Hmmm he might have a point about you being predicted in the book. I know I shake in fear at the thought of you running around unsupervised :(*"

Just the way I like it. It's good to see that all my hard work paying off. *evil grin*


Sud666 To be honest I'm not quite sure what that dude was blathering about. O try not to think too much about the opinions of the Hoi piloi since it would cause me to be an alcoholic


back to top