Vanessa's Reviews > Der Totenleser
Der Totenleser
by
by

I found this book in a bargain bin and thought it sounded interesting. A crime novel set in historical China? Sign me up!
Now I'm just glad I found it in a bargain bin, because otherwise I'd probably be a lot more disappointed.
Cause you see, the back of the book promised me a thrilling story about murder in the emperor's palace. That's what I wanted to read about!
Instead what I got was the tale of How Ci Has The Worst Day Of His Life Everyday. Literally everything in this dude's life that could go wrong, went wrong. Every damn time.
People died on him, people betrayed him, people stole from him, people wanted to hunt him down, people wanted to execute him etc. etc.
I assume all of this was to show us that Ci wouldn't be one of those protagonists people would just love and protect cause he was the main character and that while he (apparently) was a genius from the beginning, he still needed training to aquire a skill set that would get him into the royal palace. I do appreciate the thought, but he was the unluckiest guy I've ever read about and it was just exhausting.
Yet I stuck with this book, because I wanted to get to that damn murder case he was supposed to solve.
Finally, around page 380 of roughly 600, the plot aka the gruesome murder arrived. Now, know that it took me several weeks to get to that point. Know also that I finished the rest of the book in less than a day. I won't say that the murder case was the best I've ever read, but it was honestly engaging and for once I wasn't able to guess who was responsible right away. There were some twists and turns and some honestly interesting characters around. If the whole book had been written like that, I would have given it at least one star more.
Now, there was also some weird love story in the mix that I didn't really like, because male crime solving characters tend to become stupid when they see a beautiful woman they want to boing (as was the case here, too), but at least it sort of had a purpose. Maybe. How it ended certainly helped, even if I still have questions.
Another reason why I couldn't give this a higher rating was because the characters were either bland or flat out hateable, with only maybe two exceptions. Sadly our main character fell into the "bland" category, despite all the attempts to make him interesting and special without making him too perfect to relate to.
Despite all the unlucky things that happened to him and the bad decisions he unwittingly made (again and again), I did not feel anything for him till maybe right before the end. He was supposed to have been a genius from the start, but in the beginning most other people were simply crude and dumb, so he looked good in comparison only. Then he was supposed to have a genetic disorder that didn't allow him to feel any pain, but I wouldn't even have known it, if the text hadn't reminded me every time it was plot relevant, because Ci didn't act like it at all. No bruises or cuts he didn't remember getting or wondering what pain actually feels like when he's surrounded by violence and death all the time. Would have made him more interesting.
In the end, the most interesting character to me was his later mentor aka the only person who seemed to have brains, a heart and some common sense in this story. I liked his sort of fatherly relationship with Ci a lot and while I feared it was coming, I did not like that (view spoiler) (Non-murderer spoiler! It's mostly harmless, but just making sure.)
He's definitely the one character I will remember best.
All in all, this is a pretty looking book on my shelf that could have been so much more than it was. If there was a sequel that was simply about another murder case, I would read it, though.
Now I'm just glad I found it in a bargain bin, because otherwise I'd probably be a lot more disappointed.
Cause you see, the back of the book promised me a thrilling story about murder in the emperor's palace. That's what I wanted to read about!
Instead what I got was the tale of How Ci Has The Worst Day Of His Life Everyday. Literally everything in this dude's life that could go wrong, went wrong. Every damn time.
People died on him, people betrayed him, people stole from him, people wanted to hunt him down, people wanted to execute him etc. etc.
I assume all of this was to show us that Ci wouldn't be one of those protagonists people would just love and protect cause he was the main character and that while he (apparently) was a genius from the beginning, he still needed training to aquire a skill set that would get him into the royal palace. I do appreciate the thought, but he was the unluckiest guy I've ever read about and it was just exhausting.
Yet I stuck with this book, because I wanted to get to that damn murder case he was supposed to solve.
Finally, around page 380 of roughly 600, the plot aka the gruesome murder arrived. Now, know that it took me several weeks to get to that point. Know also that I finished the rest of the book in less than a day. I won't say that the murder case was the best I've ever read, but it was honestly engaging and for once I wasn't able to guess who was responsible right away. There were some twists and turns and some honestly interesting characters around. If the whole book had been written like that, I would have given it at least one star more.
Now, there was also some weird love story in the mix that I didn't really like, because male crime solving characters tend to become stupid when they see a beautiful woman they want to boing (as was the case here, too), but at least it sort of had a purpose. Maybe. How it ended certainly helped, even if I still have questions.
Another reason why I couldn't give this a higher rating was because the characters were either bland or flat out hateable, with only maybe two exceptions. Sadly our main character fell into the "bland" category, despite all the attempts to make him interesting and special without making him too perfect to relate to.
Despite all the unlucky things that happened to him and the bad decisions he unwittingly made (again and again), I did not feel anything for him till maybe right before the end. He was supposed to have been a genius from the start, but in the beginning most other people were simply crude and dumb, so he looked good in comparison only. Then he was supposed to have a genetic disorder that didn't allow him to feel any pain, but I wouldn't even have known it, if the text hadn't reminded me every time it was plot relevant, because Ci didn't act like it at all. No bruises or cuts he didn't remember getting or wondering what pain actually feels like when he's surrounded by violence and death all the time. Would have made him more interesting.
In the end, the most interesting character to me was his later mentor aka the only person who seemed to have brains, a heart and some common sense in this story. I liked his sort of fatherly relationship with Ci a lot and while I feared it was coming, I did not like that (view spoiler) (Non-murderer spoiler! It's mostly harmless, but just making sure.)
He's definitely the one character I will remember best.
All in all, this is a pretty looking book on my shelf that could have been so much more than it was. If there was a sequel that was simply about another murder case, I would read it, though.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Der Totenleser.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
May 1, 2017
– Shelved
May 1, 2017
– Shelved as:
to-read
August 4, 2017
–
Started Reading
August 4, 2017
– Shelved as:
crime-novels-and-thrillers
August 4, 2017
–
3.28%
"A severed head? Whatever should I do? I know! Just keep on working!"
page
21
August 4, 2017
–
18.13%
"Okay it's getting ridiculous. No one is THAT unlucky.
Dear authors, you don't need something dramatic in every chapter jfc."
page
116
Dear authors, you don't need something dramatic in every chapter jfc."
August 5, 2017
–
23.44%
"I signed up for a crime novel and not for the main character stumbling from one bad situation to the next just to come out fine. Rinse and repeat."
page
150
August 8, 2017
–
31.87%
"He screws up (once again) and something actually good comes out of it? A miracle!"
page
204
August 25, 2017
–
42.97%
"Back to this and I see that the protagonist is still the unluckiest guy ever.
Who knew that too much tragedy would be boring?"
page
275
Who knew that too much tragedy would be boring?"
August 30, 2017
–
50.16%
"So he can't feel pain, but everything a prostitute does to him? How convinient!"
page
321
August 30, 2017
–
67.03%
"Gruesome murders? Fine. I can deal with that. But animal cruelty? NO. Just don't. I don't need descriptions. D: *goes to hug my cats*"
page
429
August 30, 2017
–
70.78%
"Dude, she's not all that good at getting to tell you her secrets... you just have always been a bit dumb."
page
453
August 30, 2017
–
74.22%
"Dude. Don't you dare. He is one of like three people who were ever nice to you."
page
475
August 30, 2017
–
75.63%
"Dear authors: Those "the protagonist somehow doesn't know a thing that literally everyone and their hamster knows" moments are not clever ways to reveal something to the audience. They're simply dumb."
page
484
August 30, 2017
–
70.63%
"You missed it cause you were too focused on banging the wife of a man who has been nothing but kind of you."
page
452
August 30, 2017
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-5 of 5 (5 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Tessa
(new)
Sep 01, 2017 12:23PM

reply
|
flag

Ich freue mich auch! XD
Ich habe es tatsächlich auch als Mängelexemplar gebraucht, weswegen ich jetzt nicht allzu enttäuscht bin. Aber es ist schon schade, weil es so interessant klang (und man findet ja jetzt nicht soooo viele nicht-Liebesromane die im historischen China spielen).
Leider fing der Plot rund um das Morden im Palast erst gut 200 Seiten vor Schluss an (davor ists echt nur ein Unglück nach dem anderen), denn wenn das Buch die ganze Zeit so geschrieben gewesen wäre, hätte ich auch drei Sterne rausgerückt. Ich glaube ohne wären mir doch sogar die zwei Sterne schwer gefallen. :/
Na mal sehen wie ich mich nach dem wirklichen Review fühlen werde!

Das stimmt, deswegen dachte ich auch das es vllt doch ganz gut sein könnte- aber nach deinem Review bin ich wirklich froh das ich es liegen gelassen habe. Das Cover fällt aber halt auch wirklich auf, besonders bei den Mängelexemplaren :D
Man fragt sich bei solchen Büchern schon immer was sich die Verleger dabei gedacht haben- wenn der Plot erst 200 Seiten vor Ende beginnt ist doch irgendwas schiefgelaufen. Erst Recht bei über 600 Seiten.. Respekt das du durchgehalten hast, ich glaube ich hätte das schon vorher aufgegeben.
Ich hoffe dein nächstes Buch ist besser! ;)

Das stimmt, deswegen dachte ich auch das es vllt doch ganz gut sein könnte- a..."
Und du wirst hier wahrscheinlich auch keine Notification kriegen. Es geht nämlich nicht nur dir so. Bei mir ist das schon seit ner Woche, dass ich nur eine kriege wenn jemand bei meinen eigenen Sachen (Bücher- oder Status Updates und Reviews) kommentiert. Wenn ich aber bei jemand anderen kommentiere, kriege ich nichts. Ich will nicht wissen wie viele Leute mich mittlerweile für unhöflich halten. :/
Aber ich weiß noch von mindestens zwei anderen bei denen es genau das Gleiche is. Das Problem ist halt dass es einfach nicht auffällt, bis man es mal durch Zufall sieht, weil ein Post wieder mal über die Timeline geistert (weswegen ich hier auch "Add to my Update Feed" anklicken werde, in der Hoffnung dass du das dann besser siehst).
Yeah, es ist einfach nur schade drum, weil der Fall an sich nicht schlecht war. Ich war am Ende fast davor sogar 3 Sterne zu geben, bis ich mir selber auf die Finger gehauen und mich an mein Leiden beim Lesen erinnert habe.
Ich weiß nicht mal mehr warum ich nicht vorher aufgegeben habe... vielleicht weil ich das Gefühl hatte dass ich in letzter Zeit zu viele Bücher nicht zu Ende gelesen hatte. Und natürlich weil ich wissen wollte was für ein Verbrechen wohl im Palast statt finden würde... u_u
Danke! Leider war das Buch was ich danach gelesen habe einfach grottenschlecht (noch ein Review dass ich noch schreiben muss. Sie türmen sich langsam. x__x), aber dafür kurzweilig.
Dafür ist mein jetziges Buch ganz gut. :D

Das stimmt, deswegen dachte ich auch das es vllt doch ganz gut..."
Ja wie gesagt, habe hiernach meine Email Benachrichtigungen eingeschaltet weil mir das dann auch irgendwie zu blöd ist. Hoffe das sie das bald in den Griff kriegen- bis dahin funktioniert das mit den Emails hoffentlich..
Einerseits freue ich mich immer wenn dann gegen Ende alles so gut war das man mehr Sterne geben will und andererseits ärgert es mich immer weil das nur zeigt das der Rest des Buches hätte besser sein können. Erst Recht in so einem Fall wenn das Buch so lang ist und man wirklich so lange gelitten hat bis es ein bisschen bergauf ging -.-
Das Gefühl kenne ich. Ich habe mich vor einer Zeit durch Arcadia gekämpft (ich meine auch so um die 700 Seiten), obwohl das Buch absolut nichts für mich war und ich es wirklich grottenschlecht fand am Ende, aber ich wollte einfach nicht aufgeben. Seit dem bin ich allerdings besser geworden darin Bücher einfach beiseite zu legen wenn es keinen Sinn hat. Überlege mir dann ob ich sie wann anders noch mal lesen will und wenn nicht gebe ich sie weg. Habe zu viele Bücher zu Hause rumzuliegen um mich mit schlechten aufzuhalten ;)
Haha, jaa, die liebe Neugier.. Na immerhin war der Part ja dann nicht so enttäuschend!
Oh nein! Aber gut das du wenigstens schneller durchgekommen bist!
Schreibst du zu jeden Buch das du liest eine Rezension?
Das ist ja super, dann ganz viel Spaß dabei!! :)