ŷ

Madeline's Reviews > Fingersmith

Fingersmith by Sarah Waters
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
111921
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: historic-fiction
Read 2 times. Last read August 2016.

“I have some knowledge of the time that may be misspent, clinging to fictions and supposing them truths.�

Sue Trinder is an orphan living a Dickensian-like life in 19th century London - her mother was hanged as a murderer when Sue was a baby, leaving Sue to be raised by Mrs. Sucksby in a "baby farm" in the slums of London. Sue grows up surrounded by thieves and pickpockets ("fingersmiths"), learning to counterfeit coins and commit petty crimes, and then one day she's offered a chance at a much bigger job. A con man known as Gentleman has a plan to trick an heiress out of her fortune by seducing and marrying her (and then dumping the girl in an insane asylum once he has the money), and he needs Sue to pose as the girl's maid and spy on her. But as in all good crime stories, the job isn't as simple as it sounds, and everyone has their own agenda. And it turns out that Sue's target, the innocent heiress Maud Lilly, has secrets of her own that Sue will discover...(Homer Simpson voice) with sexy results.

Here's an indication of how good Fingersmith is, and how well it hooks you - I read this book six months ago, but I can still remember every great plot twist and betrayal that happens. It sticks with you, is what I'm saying.

The book is divided into sections based on character perspective. First we're in Sue's head, learning the details of the job and going to the Lilly mansion to pull off the con. Just as soon as we feel comfortable, and are confident that we know what's going on, Waters yanks the rug out from under us. The con, we learn, is not what we thought it was, and then, in the next section, we get to read the same scenes again - but from Maud's perspective this time. And Waters isn't done! After that, we get another section, just to drive home the point that every time we thought we had the whole story, we were wrong.

Con men (and women), romance, revenge, skullduggery, betrayals on top of betrayals! What's not to love?

AND NOW A NOTE ON THE MOVIE: The Handmaiden, Park Chan-Wook's adaption of Fingersmith, is fascinating for a lot of reasons. First, changing the setting to 1930's Korea works really, really well, and the movie sets just the right beautiful but vaguely suspicious tone that the novel requires. The changing perspectives are handled well too, and as a bonus, the romance elements are lovely and charming and sexy. (fun fact: I saw this movie in theaters, and let me tell you, it is quite an experience to sit in a room full of people all maintaining mature, thoughtful silence while we watch two women [redacted because of spoilers and children present]) Also, if you saw the movie but didn't read the book, man you are missing out, because The Handmaiden cuts off Waters' story about two thirds of the way in, because they just didn't have enough time to explore all the plot twists from the original. So if you liked the movie, please go read the book, because there are some major, major bombshells that you still need to know about.
63 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Fingersmith.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
Started Reading
August, 2016 – Finished Reading
June 14, 2017 – Shelved
June 14, 2017 – Shelved as: historic-fiction

Comments Showing 1-29 of 29 (29 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Keith (new)

Keith let me tell you, it is quite an experience to sit in a room full of people all maintaining mature, thoughtful silence while we watch two women [redacted because of spoilers and children present])

Ha, I remember going to see (artistic retro lesbian BDSM romantic comedy, yes really) at a tiny screen in an arthouse cinema, and everyone there seemed to be in couples except me.


Madeline That's funny, because I spent a lot of that scene (and a lot of other scenes in the movie) thinking I am so happy I'm not on a first date right now.


Cynthia Paschen Madeline wrote: "That's funny, because I spent a lot of that scene (and a lot of other scenes in the movie) thinking I am so happy I'm not on a first date right now."

Ha!


message 4: by Keith (new)

Keith tiana wrote: "I am a great reader. I am eight years old"

If you're 8, I hope you haven't been reading Fingersmith...


Madeline Even money says she hasn't even read the review, so I think we're good.


message 6: by Anya (new) - added it

Anya I watched The Handmaiden only yesterday and oh god, it was so glorious.


message 7: by shreyanaidu (new)

shreyanaidu #deeweaves


message 8: by shreyanaidu (new)

shreyanaidu #deeweaves


message 9: by Keith (new)

Keith What's with all the weird spam comments that keep popping up in this review?


Madeline The spam accounts get notified when I post a new review, and they all come popping up like mushrooms. Nothing to do but block, delete, repeat.


message 11: by Umar Khan (new) - added it

Umar Khan hi i like your choice we have the same taste


message 12: by Umar Khan (new) - added it

Umar Khan you are a really special person and your description says you are interested in a lot of thing


message 13: by Keith (new)

Keith Spam spam spam spam!
Spam spam spam spam!
Lovely spam! Wonderful spam!


message 15: by Keith (new)

Keith GEORGE SPENCER wrote: "
"


Nice bit of minimalism! Now do the phonetics of one hand clapping!

(Who are these people? Are they bots? They're not even advertising anything...)


Madeline There are three types of commenters that I group under the "spam" umbrella - first are the straightforward spam bots, which are easy to spot because their usernames and comments are always just a string of gibberish. Then there are sock puppet accounts, which usually give themselves away because they have no profile picture, no books or reviews, no friends, and are following only a handful of people (these are the ones I hate the most, actually, because sometimes I'll be the only reviewer they're following, which makes me worry that people think I'm the one creating the accounts to increase my follower count). Then we've got people like George, who are real people (usually children whose parents got a Kindle with a ŷ account attached), who don't write reviews and whose only goal is to gain as many friends as possible before they get tired of the site in three months. I don't know how they find me specifically, but I'm guessing they just go through the list of top reviewers and leave comments on the most recent reviews. They figure that, the more followers a reviewer has, the more people will see their comment on that review, and this will give them more exposure on the site. Even if they send me a friend request, they're not actually interested in interacting with me or using this site for book reviews; they just want to piggyback on popular reviewers' comment threads and try to grab followers.

Funnily enough, this month actually marks my tenth year on ŷ. I've seen it all, children.


message 17: by Keith (new)

Keith I didn't know Kindles could come with a ŷ account; that explains a few things, like people who seem to think ŷ is a bookseller site.


message 18: by Florence Y. Pan (new)

Florence Y. Pan nice rhymez xD.


message 19: by Florence Y. Pan (new)

Florence Y. Pan too much spam!!! ŷ should JUST FUCKInG DO SOMETHING ABOUT THIS!!
*rant over*
anywayyyyyyyyyy great review!


Madeline Four stars is hardly a negative review.


message 21: by Keith (new)

Keith Madeline wrote: "Four stars is hardly a negative review."

Yes, according to ŷ' guidelines, 3 stars is "liked it", 4 stars is "really liked it" and 5 stars is "loved it". People interpret that differently (and some people ignore the guidelines and treat 3 stars as a negative review). I personally reserve 5 stars for "the best of the best" and/or books which really inspired or impressed me - I'm guessing you have similar criteria.


message 22: by Amy (new) - rated it 5 stars

Amy Fantastic review! I haven't wanted to drop all the books I'm currently reading, forget about my TBR list, and run to the bookstore for a new one in a long time. This story sounds perfect.


message 23: by lele baby (new)

lele baby can u make me a movie star


message 24: by Madeline (last edited Jun 28, 2017 07:48PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Madeline description


message 25: by Keith (new)

Keith lele baby wrote: "can u make me a movie star"

You can find the ONE WEIRD TRICK that will make you a Hollywood A-lister overnight, at this very special super secret link!




Cynthia Paschen I am not clicking.


message 27: by shivam mathur (new)

shivam mathur i suppose you write really nice books


message 28: by shivam mathur (new)

shivam mathur thanks madline for the book


message 29: by Keith (new)

Keith shivam mathur wrote: "i suppose you write really nice books"

This is a review of the book. The author of the book probably isn't going to see it.


back to top