ŷ

Andrew Smith's Reviews > Nemesis

Nemesis by Philip Roth
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
5885760
's review

it was amazing

A further reading of a book that has stayed with me. I'd go as far as to say it's one of the five most memorable books I've read. A sympathetic and sometimes unsettling account set at a time of suspicion and suffering. The reflection on human nature - both good and bad - has the ring of complete truth about it. It's easy to believe that the conversations and events depicted here actually happened. It's both a sad tale and an uplifting one. It's a book that creates in the reader the need for reflection to ponder on the messages the story carries.

A good book? No, in my opinion, it's a great book. One I'll return to again, for sure.

--------------------------------------------

Roth's books are usually dark, unsettling, argumentative, challenging, sexually explicit, political� well, you get the picture. So, it's not quite what you'd necessarily reach for when you're spending your summer holiday lazing on a beach. But if you've had your fill of crime capers and mysteries and fancy something a little more serious, then a ration of Roth might just do the trick.

This novel is set in Newark in the sweltering summer of 1944 at the time of a polio epidemic. It follows a young man who is not fighting in the war due to his poor eyesight and has instead become a school playground director. His goal is to nurture and protect the young people in his charge and to show them the joys and benefits of sporting activity. What transpires is told beautifully by the author, as we witness the story unfolding through the eyes of one of the youngsters who is to become a victim of the outbreak. It's a concise and spare tale, but it is none the worst for that.

It's a gripping story of compassion and dedication set against the backdrop of truly heartbreaking events. It's a departure, I feel, for Roth - gone is the anger and invective that permeates much of his work, replaced by subtlety and a deftness of touch I've not seen from him before. A wonderful read one not to be missed.
88 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Nemesis.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 2, 2011 – Shelved
Started Reading
September 14, 2011 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Andrew Smith Thanks Eylse - I saw your review and know you loved this book too! I really like some of Roth's work, but not all the books I've read (and I've certainly not read his full output) have floated my boat. This one, though, is the one I'll always think of when I think of him. Superb!


Carol Added it to my read-next shelf after your convincing review! :-)


Andrew Smith Excellent! I hope you enjoy it, Carol :-)


message 4: by Natalie (new)

Natalie Richards Added this based on your review :-)


Andrew Smith I hope you enjoy it, Natalie. I'll look out for your thoughts, in due course :)


message 6: by Christine (new)

Christine Andy, this one sounds special.


Andrew Smith It is to me, Christine. I always liked Roth but found his style somewhat over the top. Here he holds back a bit and the writing is all the better for it. The story is haunting and has stayed with me.


message 8: by Guy (new)

Guy OK Andrew now I need to know what the other four are... It has been a long time since I've read Roth. I don't do much re-reading. So many books on my want to read list and so little time. I just saw an interesting quote by Dick Cavett: "We'd all have been better off to have read half as many books. Twice." Has gotten me thinking.


Andrew Smith That's a good quote, Guy. I need to ponder on that a bit myself...
Nemesis is what I'd call 'soft' Roth. This is a story well told, not pages of ranting or the descriptions of the inner mind of someone I'd rather not get to know.
Any top five is going to be a moving feast, but here's my other top 4 as of this morning:
The Wind-up Bird Chronicles - Haruki Murakami. Surreal tale with many smaller stories woven in. Quite magical, in my view.
A Man in Full - Tom Wolfe. I loved Bonfire of the Vanities, but this has stayed with me longer.
Small Town - Lawrence Block. I think he's a brilliant writer of crime fiction and could have picked any number of his books, but this is the one I think I liked best if all.
Rain Gods - James Lee Burke. My favourite writer. Period. Again, I could have picked pretty much anything but I particularly loved this one.
Happy New Year and happy reading :)


message 10: by Guy (new)

Guy I do like lists. And you are right. They do tend to change over time. Or as the mood shifts. My top five books list has not been amended for quite a while now. Maybe nothing recent has knocked my socks off. Top four in no particular order (it's like saying which child is your favorite) : Catch 22. 100 Years of Solitude. On the Road. In Cold Blood. #5 is not so clear. I had several candidates but I'm going for today with The Book Thief. Which I did just read this past year. James Lee Burke is definitely in my top five authors list. Difficult to choose one title though. I guess whichever one I read last. Lawrence Block I put at the top of the grand master list for the crime genre along with Donald Westlake. Hard to pick one over the other. And Haruki Murukami I have only read Kafka on the Shore (loved it) but am planning to remedy that this year. Happy New Year to you as well.


Andrew Smith Catch 22 - I've seen the film (which I liked) but haven't read the book
100 Years..., In Cold Blood - I have in the back of my mind that I must read both. Perhaps I'll accelerate that process!
On the Road - I tried this on audiobook and didn't get on with it. Which is strange, as it's just the type of story that should float my boat.
Ditto the above re The Book Thief.
Couldn't agree more in respect of your comments concerning JLB & LB. I've read a couple of Westlake's (Parker) but am still a novice in terms of catching up with his work.
Kafka on the Shore is great. In fact, it's the closest of Murakami's books to Wind-up Bird..., so I think you'll love that one too.
Great to hear your thoughts. Best wishes.


message 12: by [deleted user] (new)

I agree with you entirely! I read this book a few years back for a class on sickness in literature and it is still one of my favorite books. It's stuck with me and I intend to keep coming back to it! Have you read Everyman? It's been on my radar but I can't decide if I want to read it.


message 13: by Andrew (last edited Mar 28, 2018 09:47AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Andrew Smith Stephany - I loved this book and I too will come back to it again. And yes, I read Everyman quite a while ago - I haven't reviewed it but I did award it five stars. It's a short intimate account of one man as he deals with old age and what comes next. I didn't find it too dark or hard to read. It's a another brilliantly written piece by Roth.


Lisa (NY) Andrew, a very compelling review. I'm definitely moving this up in my stacks (I own a copy, unread).


Andrew Smith Lisa - I like Roth’s ranting... sometimes. But here he demonstrated a different side to his writing - a compassionate & much softer side. It’s a great, if sad, story & it’s beautifully told. A masterpiece, I believe.


message 16: by Jaidee (new) - added it

Jaidee Wow have not heard of this novel. Onto the tbr list it goes :)


Andrew Smith Jaidee - it’s one of my favourites. Superbly written by a master of the English language. Hope you enjoy it! 😁


Andrew Such a wonderful review! I just ordered this now and I'm looking forward to reading it.


Andrew Smith Andrew - thank you so much! It’s a wonderful book, my favourite Roth, and I hope you enjoy it as much as I did 👍


Phrodrick slowed his growing backlog Have you decided who or what is the Nemesis?
I read this recently and that was my take away question.


Jo-Ann Breitstein Andrew, this is a wonderful review. A few years ago I saw Roth at an event in Newark. It was fascinating and inspiring. I have not read Nemesis but will now. Thank you again for your review and recommendation.


Andrew Smith Phrodrick wrote: "Have you decided who or what is the Nemesis?
I read this recently and that was my take away question."


Phrodrick, what a great question. It’s something that’s completely passed me by, I hadn’t really given it a thought until now. I’ve searched around for clues but the only real suggestion I’ve come across is that it’s the grim reaper himself. This sort of works, doesn’t it. What do you think?


Andrew Smith Jo-Ann - you’re too kind, but thank you! I’ve really enjoyed the ‘ranting� Roth but I think this is one that would possibly have wider appeal.

And wow, I’m so envious that you actually saw the man - I’m sure I’d have found this totally inspiring too.

There are still a few of his books I haven’t gotten around to reading, so perhaps I’ll grab another soon and immerse myself in his mastery of words once again.


Phrodrick slowed his growing backlog Andrew wrote: "Phrodrick wrote: "Have you decided who or what is the Nemesis?
I read this recently and that was my take away question."

Phrodrick, what a great question. It’s something that’s completely passed m..."


No excuse fir waiting this long to reply.

I like your answer that the overriding enemy is Death. But , I still have a feeling that , this being Roth: The Nemesis is God.


message 25: by Ron (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ron Brown I read his book in 2018. A group of 11 Jewish worshipers had been slain in a Pittsburgh synagogue. The only way I could react was to read a book with Jewish characters, so I picked up Nemesis. A wonder story. In reflection it had great relevance, for two years later when COVID. Anti-semitism is something alien to me. Definitely a great book.


message 26: by Andrew (last edited Feb 02, 2025 07:02AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Andrew Smith Ron - yes, I could see how an event like that could lead you to read this book.

I always found Roth to be a powerful writer. Sometimes hard to read (with sentences half a page long) but always thought-provoking. This one, particularly, affected me.


back to top