ŷ

Ian Laird's Reviews > The Road

The Road by Cormac McCarthy
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
28547777
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: usa, dystopia, father-son, fiction, usa-author

Revised and quotes added 25 August 2023

This is an unremittingly bleak dystopian saga ending with the smallest gesture of hope. A gesture which offers the prospect of a dark journey continuing a little longer before petering out completely.

It’s hard to imagine a more depressing scenario. Life on earth has all but ended through an unexplained catastrophe, leaving only a few scattered humans; no birds or animals, not even, ironically, cockroaches. When we join them, a father (‘the man�) and his son (‘the boy�) are on the road:
Then they set out along the blacktop in the gunmetal light, shuffling through the ash, each the other’s world entire. (p4)
They are moving south to the warmth, and the coast, a warmth which is unlikely given the omnipresent ash filling the atmosphere, covering the ground, the bitter cold and the driving polluted rain. The coast turns out to be equally disappointing as the ocean is grey slosh. The absence of colour is disturbing. The lack of life is one thing, dim light another, but the charred remains and the ubiquitous grey ash over everything weighs heavily.

The gloom is heightened by its permanence. The catastrophe is not recent; it’s possible the boy has lived his entire young life in these bleak conditions: he is around eight to ten years old. His mother gave up early on, perhaps wisely, and we know this only retrospectively. The boy understands life and colour only through his father’s stories. He startles his father by asking a question:
The boy stood up and got his broom and put it over his shoulder. He looked at his father. What are our long term goals? he said.
What?
Our long term goals.
Where did you hear that?
I don’t know.
No, where did you?
You said it.
When?
A long time ago.
What was the answer?
I don’t know.
Well, I don’t either. Come on. It’s getting dark. (p170-171)
I like this exchange because it shows the boys optimism, such as it is, and his father’s determination just to keep on going.

The man keeps them alive, being practical, careful and wary: distrustful by default. With their packs and cart loaded with cans of food and supplies, the man and the boy have survived only through their systematic searching of long abandoned homes, already well-looted, looking for anything edible or useful that might have been overlooked, but usually finding only the spoiled reminders of the families who lived there.

On one occasion they find the underground hoard salted away by a prepper, long ago, hitherto untouched. They enjoy the luxury of eating till they are full, putting on new clothes, cutting their hair, washing their bodies and replenishing their supplies. But they don’t stay long. There is ever present danger, from other survivors, armed and mean. The man’s skills and good sense keep them going, and alive, but these would not be enough on their own. The difference is the boy, his son, who provides the biggest motivation for going on, for staying alive, for keeping on the move - to the south, to the coast.

The boy represents the inchoate future, such as it is. The boy retains his humanity, wanting to help people they come across, even when to do so would be unwise or pointless. In a real sense the boy keeps the man (‘Papa�) alive, at least longer than he otherwise might have.

(view spoiler)

***

I first thought I would begin this review referring to my own son, but it is better to add a postscript. My boy is now 16, as of early 2023, in his penultimate year of secondary school. The Road is one of his set English texts. Hence me reading it. He also needs to come to terms with Nineteen Eighty-Four and Brave New World. This strikes me as too much, after years of the pandemic, adverse climate change and increased global tensions. Could they not have set The History of Tom Jones, a Foundling, or On the Road or Puberty Blues? Call it the Lord of the Flies approach to literary education.

Even so, I’m grateful for the opportunity to read The Road and to enjoy father–son bonding, while there is still time. It all goes so quickly. I am writing this as I watch him play in a round robin football competition for his school. Even though it is very hot the boys are having a great time. Which is good. They are the future after all.
23 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Road.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 9, 2017 – Shelved
Started Reading
March 2, 2023 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Emmkay (new)

Emmkay Gosh, that’s quite the trio of set texts for your son and his classmates! I think I’d agree with you it’s too gloomy even absent the pandemic. I know I was resentful of the darkness of much of the assigned reading when I was that age too.


message 2: by Ian (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ian Laird Emmkay wrote: "Gosh, that’s quite the trio of set texts for your son and his classmates! I think I’d agree with you it’s too gloomy even absent the pandemic. I know I was resentful of the darkness of much of the ..."
Yes, I think it needs to be balanced: serious works certainly, but with some optimism and light.


Cecily I'm sure you and your son will get a lot from reading this alongside each other - it's a profound and beautifully bleak book - but I agree about the narrow and depressing genre of your son's set texts. I'm glad he has other interests as well!


message 4: by Jodi (new) - added it

Jodi Tremendously good review, Ian!! But holy cow, that really DOES sound heart-crushingly despairing! I must remember to keep it far, far away!! I'm surprised schools would add this book to the curriculum for teenaged students! My goodness, they're depressed enough as it is, after the COVID years. Why on earth would they ask these poor kids to read something like this?? It's actually quite scary to think of the potential for disastrous outcomes. Hold your son close, my friend.👨‍�


Carol A powerful and compelling review, Ian. It has been a while ago since I've read this novel, so I appreciate its recollection.


message 6: by Ian (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ian Laird Carol wrote: "A powerful and compelling review, Ian. It has been a while ago since I've read this novel, so I appreciate its recollection."

Thank you Carol.


message 7: by Bob (new)

Bob Brinkmeyer Very fine review--and yes, there is some hope at the end--which is not always (to say the least) characteristic of McCarrthy's work.


Cecily How goes it with your son and his literature course? The three books you mention are all excellent, but I agree that all three together, shortly after the pandemic, is a bit much. Is he studying any others as well?


message 9: by Ian (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ian Laird Bob wrote: "Very fine review--and yes, there is some hope at the end--which is not always (to say the least) characteristic of McCarrthy's work."
Thank you very much Bob.


message 10: by Ian (new) - rated it 4 stars

Ian Laird Cecily wrote: "How goes it with your son and his literature course? The three books you mention are all excellent, but I agree that all three together, shortly after the pandemic, is a bit much. Is he studying an..."
Hi Cecily, I think it is fair to say that in a household with parents who read, it is not unlikely that a son might eschew paper for screens, and be primarily interested in sport and health. Junior has, like so many of his friends, emerged from lockdown and isolation very well. So we don't get much about literature, but a lot about food technology and fitness. Cheers, Ian


back to top