ŷ

Sean Barrs 's Reviews > Norwegian Wood

Norwegian Wood by Haruki Murakami
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
27788046
's review

liked it
bookshelves: 3-star-reads, contemporary-lit, magical-realism

Murakami divides his novel into two. There is the past and death. Then there is future and life. What road do you take?

Seems like an easy question to answer. But what happens when you are in love with the past? And what happens when you so desperately want to save that past from such a death? Life becomes complicated and the prospect of the future feels like a brutal betrayal of one who is desperately clinging to you. You are her anchor; her only connection with reality. And you love her. How can you ever walk away? Life is fickle, though true love isn’t. Sometimes we have to do the hard thing and let go even if it kills us.

"The dead will always be dead, but we have to go on living."

Such words are easier said than put into practice. Sometimes the dead carry so much of ourselves that living without them is not quite living anymore. Toru lost his best friend when he was seventeen. He killed himself. We never find out why, but I have my own ideas about what and who caused it. He carries on, feeling empty. He falls in love with his dead friend’s girlfriend Naoko but she has her own problems. They maintain a friendship for a year, and then she institutionalises herself because she simply cannot cope with life in the wake of her old boyfriend’s death. He was her soulmate and now she is rudderless in a sea of uncertainty.

Anyone who has read a Murakami will know the importance of music in his storytelling. These lyrics say more than I ever could about the novel. Read them, hear them and feel them.

Cue the music:

Norwegian Wood (This Bird Has Flown) by the Beatles.

I once had a girl
Or should I say
She once had me

She showed me her room
Isn't it good
Norwegian wood

She asked me to stay
And she told me to sit anywhere
So I looked around
And I noticed there wasn't a chair

I sat on a rug
Biding my time
Drinking her wine

We talked until two
And then she said
"It's time for bed"

She told me she worked in the morning
And started to laugh
I told her I didn't
And crawled off to sleep in the bath

And when I awoke
I was alone
This bird had flown

So I lit a fire
Isn't it good
Norwegian wood


I want to interpret them and put them in the context of the novel and explain what they mean, but to do so would be to ruin it all for you. If you have read the book read through the lyrics and ponder the actions Naoko takes towards the end of the story, what she does and why she does it seemed a little selfish to me at first. But the lyrics tell the truth. Perspective is everything and we never had the perspective in the novel that would have spoken the truth.

Norwegian Wood is a novel that feels like it should never have ended. It is the sort of book that carries you away into the lives of the characters and should carry on as long as they continue to live. With suicide such a strong theme through the novel, no less than three major characters commit it, I was surprised the ending was not more of a universal ending so to speak. The power of the writing resides in his ability to tangle you up within the story. Murakami’s characters here feel so terribly, tragically, real. They are some of the most human I’ve ever encountered on a page.

It all felt so desperately unresolved towards the end of the story. But isn’t that life? How often do we truly resolve our daemons and feel satisfied with how things went? Rarely. Norwegian Wood is a dangerous novel because it has a certain sense of universal appeal; it has the ability to speak to may a reader as they compare their own situation to that depicted here. Sure, it’s likely less dramatic but the need to move on being weighed against a past that hangs over us, whatever that past may be, is a dilemma most of us will face.

But the real question is did I enjoy it and would I recommend it?

I would recommend it, but I certainly didn’t love it. There’s little to love here, but there is also little to hate. What Murakami delivers is a sprawling peak into the lives of a bunch of severely damaged youths coping with the realities of what emptiness means. Take from it what you will. A warning though, it may hurt.

| | |
422 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Norwegian Wood.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 12, 2017 – Started Reading
July 12, 2017 – Shelved
July 26, 2017 – Shelved as: 3-star-reads
July 26, 2017 – Shelved as: contemporary-lit
July 26, 2017 – Finished Reading
January 15, 2018 – Shelved as: magical-realism

Comments Showing 1-33 of 33 (33 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Hailie one of my all-time favorites, hope you keep enjoying it


message 2: by Sofia (new)

Sofia a really great quote Sean a good credo to keep close


Maria I'm smack in the middle of a Murakami kick reading this one right now, too. Can't wait to see your review.


message 4: by Rosemary (new)

Rosemary Atwell My first Murakami - still addicted!


Hans Christian It's the most un-Murakami among his novels, yet also one of his best.


message 6: by Margaret (new) - added it

Margaret I love the quotation you chose:

"If you only read the books that everyone else is reading, you can only think what everyone else is thinking."

But, of course it need not be true. Much more goes into how we think and know than what we read. But who cares about that; the quotation serves as a grand invitation.

Look forward to the review to come.


Sean Barrs Rosemary wrote: "My first Murakami - still addicted!"

4th for me now!


Sean Barrs Margaret wrote: "I love the quotation you chose:

"If you only read the books that everyone else is reading, you can only think what everyone else is thinking."

But, of course it need not be true. Much more goes i..."


Very true, though the right book can certainly open up doorways in life that may never have appeared otherwise.


message 9: by Margaret (new) - added it

Margaret Bookdragon Sean wrote: "Margaret wrote: "I love the quotation you chose:

"If you only read the books that everyone else is reading, you can only think what everyone else is thinking."

But, of course it need not be true...."


Sean, now your statement about the "right book" is 100% on target. I totally agree with you there.


message 10: by Hafsa | حفصہ (new)

Hafsa | حفصہ This quote just made me want to buy this book! *book hoarder alert* lol


Sean Barrs Hafsa Z.U wrote: "This quote just made me want to buy this book! *book hoarder alert* lol"

You should see my house.


message 12: by Hafsa | حفصہ (new)

Hafsa | حفصہ Bookdragon Sean wrote: "Hafsa Z.U wrote: "This quote just made me want to buy this book! *book hoarder alert* lol"

You should see my house."


haha would love to fellow hoarder!


Sean Barrs Hafsa Z.U wrote: "Bookdragon Sean wrote: "Hafsa Z.U wrote: "This quote just made me want to buy this book! *book hoarder alert* lol"

You should see my house."

haha would love to fellow hoarder!"


A bit blurry, but you get the gist!

description


message 14: by Hafsa | حفصہ (new)

Hafsa | حفصہ Bookdragon Sean wrote: "Hafsa Z.U wrote: "Bookdragon Sean wrote: "Hafsa Z.U wrote: "This quote just made me want to buy this book! *book hoarder alert* lol"

You should see my house."

haha would love to fellow hoarder!"
..."


Oh my god! Can't believe you actually posted this haha I do get the gist though, definitely a bigger hoarder lol


message 15: by [deleted user] (new)

I've never heard about the music part of his book. Usually when I ask about him people say "he good, read him"...yeah that makes me want to read a book even less. Good review. Now where is a good place to start with him?


Sean Barrs Morgan wrote: "I've never heard about the music part of his book. Usually when I ask about him people say "he good, read him"...yeah that makes me want to read a book even less. Good review. Now where is a good p..."

Thanks Morgan. This is my third Murakami. Of the three I've read, I would suggest After Dark is a good place to start. It was the strongest I've seen so far, and it was quite short too (less than 200 pages) so you won't get trapped into a novel by an author your unsure about.


Jason Great review, Sean. This is certainly a melancholy read and one that I appreciated more than I ended up 'liking'. Analyzing the book in the context of the song does add a special layer.


Sean Barrs Jason wrote: "Great review, Sean. This is certainly a melancholy read and one that I appreciated more than I ended up 'liking'. Analyzing the book in the context of the song does add a special layer."

Thanks, it's a tricky one to talk about because it is sucessful just not overly enjoyable.


ali rahim aka silentninja23 BRAVO BRAVO amazing!!


ali rahim aka silentninja23 but this back and forth thing is annoying


message 21: by Tassa (new)

Tassa DeSalada Nice review!


Black Tea Lady ☕️&#x1f4da; Thank you, Sean!! <3 Most people can’t relate the Beatle song and title to the story and you totally nail it! Wonderful review! This novel is one of my favorite novels from Murakami because I can relate to Toru and his lost love Naoko, it’s always hard to let go of the past and move forward, especially when love and unexpected death are involved. That’s growing up and it’s hard and it hurts. Murakami’s way to mix music and nostalgia is perfect, since most of our memories are related to music and people� finally, the novel is wrap around all Rubber Soul album not only Norwegian Wood.


Sean Barrs Tassa wrote: "Nice review!"

thanks :)


Sean Barrs BookLady wrote: "Thank you, Sean!! <3 Most people can’t relate the Beatle song and title to the story and you totally nail it! Wonderful review! This novel is one of my favorite novels from Murakami because I can r..."

Then I need to listen to the rest of the album. I love what Murakami does with music in his writing. I related to him too and that’s why found the book difficult to read in parts, but I totally understand why people love this book. Kafka on the Shore will be the next one for me, though not until next year most likely.


Haroon Your review makes me want to read 'Norwegian Wood' again....as I crawl on to sleep in the bed 🎶


message 26: by Sean Barrs (last edited Aug 04, 2017 11:30AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Sean Barrs Haroon wrote: "Your review makes me want to read 'Norwegian Wood' again....as I crawl on to sleep in the bed 🎶"

go for it. it's so easy to beocome lost in a Murakami novel! :)


Haroon Bookdragon Sean wrote: "Haroon wrote: "Your review makes me want to read 'Norwegian Wood' again....as I crawl on to sleep in the bed 🎶"

go for it. it's so easy to beocome lost in a Murakami novel! :)"


Never an excuse needed for Murakami....have his "Men without women" at bedside along with Norwegian Wood.


Sneha Khanna Love that last paragraph Sean. Perfect.


Snehal Sonawane Exactly my thoughts
The thoughts I was trying to find after finishing the novel


message 30: by Sowndharya (new) - added it

Sowndharya This is so well put. Thank you. I felt the same way - little to love and little to hate.


Julio Balderas Take from it what you will. I read some women's opinions about this book and a lot of them hate it. It's a perspective thing I think...as a musician should interpret an old classical piece we need to know some author context, who was Murakami when wrote this book and so. It's interesting to me to see how this book can generate a great diversity of opinions, you can like it or dislike it, but you have read it anyway.


message 32: by Paul (new)

Paul Magnussen Since you mention the lyrics: I found it strange that every piece of music mentioned here was Western, even the folk music. Of course, I realise the prevalence of Western pop, but is this normal in Japan, even for that decade? No Japanese music at all?


Robyn Mc Beautiful review!


back to top