ŷ

megs_bookrack's Reviews > One of Us Is Lying

One of Us Is Lying by Karen M. McManus
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
48328025
's review

really liked it

Five kids, one room, one mysterious death and endless possibilities. ((dun dun dunnnn))

One of Us Is Lying is the classic set-up for one of my favorite Mystery subgenres: the locked-room.



I love Locked-Room Mysteries on a level that borders on the unhealthy. We're talking next level obsessed. I will pick up any that come my way!



They're so nostalgic for me, bringing back memories of family games of Clue, watching Murder, She Wrote with my Mom and binge-reading Agatha Christie books while on summer vacation.

Add in the fact that this cast is similar to the stereotypical cast of characters found in The Breakfast Club, one of the best movies EVER created, and you have an equation for a near perfect book for Megs!



I listened to the audiobook and was pleased that it had different narrators for each of the main characters.

They did a fantastic job bringing the story to life and consequently, I flew through it.



Even though I predicted the whodunit less than halfway through, I still ended up genuinely enjoying the story.

Getting to the conclusion was pure fun and I never felt bored, or that the story was dragging.



Each chapter is told from the perspective of one of the suspects, one of the four kids left alive after detention, and each chapter ended in a revelation of incriminating facts related to that character. I felt that format really pushed the narrative along at a nice, steady pace.

This was my first Karen M. McManus book and I look forward to picking up more books from her in the future!

504 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read One of Us Is Lying.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 1, 2017 – Shelved
August 1, 2017 – Shelved as: to-read
September 7, 2018 – Started Reading
September 8, 2018 –
12.0%
September 8, 2018 –
33.0% "Coming of the heels of an Agatha Christie book, this is such a great modern YA whodunit! Living for the end of each chapter when something possibly incriminating is revealed about each character!"
September 9, 2018 –
72.0% "Low-key obsessed with this book & author"
September 10, 2018 –
85.0%
September 11, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-29 of 29 (29 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Kelsey I know whodunit!!! LOL ;)


megs_bookrack Kelsey wrote: "I know whodunit!!! LOL ;)" I was glad she wrote it that way - it was fun!


Sylvie {Semi-Hiatus} Yes, so glad you loved this book. It’s one of my favorites in YA mystery/thriller genre.


megs_bookrack Sylvie wrote: "Yes, so glad you loved this book. It’s one of my favorites in YA mystery/thriller genre." I was really impressed!


Tucker Almengor I was very disappointed that mental illness was used as a plot twist


message 6: by [deleted user] (new)

Great review. I tried to like this more but, ugh...I struggled.


megs_bookrack Tucker wrote: "I was very disappointed that mental illness was used as a plot twist" I have heard that from a few people and I can definitely understand that point of view for sure!


megs_bookrack Dita wrote: "Great review. I tried to like this more but, ugh...I struggled." I have heard that from quite a few people. I am wondering if the fact that the audiobook was narrated so well if I enjoyed it more than I would have if I read a physical copy?


Tucker Almengor megs_bookrack wrote: "Dita wrote: "Great review. I tried to like this more but, ugh...I struggled." I have heard that from quite a few people. I am wondering if the fact that the audiobook was narrated so well if I enjo..."

I know this isn't my conversation but yes! The audiobook was a game changer for me


megs_bookrack Tucker wrote: "megs_bookrack wrote: "Dita wrote: "Great review. I tried to like this more but, ugh...I struggled." I have heard that from quite a few people. I am wondering if the fact that the audiobook was narr..." Ummm, you are always welcome in my conversations!! Join join join ;) xo


message 11: by [deleted user] (new)

Which conversations?

Girl, you know I like to talk about what I think! : )


megs_bookrack Dita wrote: "Which conversations?

Girl, you know I like to talk about what I think! : )"
Hahaha, I was talking to Tucker ;) See above - I love our book chats, Dita! xo


message 13: by [deleted user] (new)

Hahaha....so typical of me to be all barging in looking for the party! LOL!!


megs_bookrack Dita wrote: "Hahaha....so typical of me to be all barging in looking for the party! LOL!!"
Hahahaha - I love you!



message 15: by [deleted user] (new)

megs_bookrack wrote: "Dita wrote: "Hahaha....so typical of me to be all barging in looking for the party! LOL!!"
Hahahaha - I love you!
"


Right back at you!!!


Kat valentine ( Katsbookcornerreads) Awesome review megs!💖😉


megs_bookrack Kat wrote: "Awesome review megs!💖😉" Thank you so much, Kat! xo


Jessi ❤️ H. Vojsk [if villain, why hot?] Wonderful review 👏🏻☺️ Can’t wait to read this book!


megs_bookrack Jessi ♥️ H. Vojsk wrote: "Wonderful review 👏🏻☺️ Can’t wait to read this book!"
Awww, thank you so much, Jessi! I hope you enjoy it as much as I did! xo


message 20: by Jayden (new) - added it

Jayden I think I might read this book.


megs_bookrack Jayden wrote: "I think I might read this book."It's fun, but I think I enjoyed the second one more, so don't stop here!


message 22: by sophie (new)

sophie does this book end with a cliffhanger? can i read it without the second one? does everything get resolved in this one?


megs_bookrack jen wrote: "does this book end with a cliffhanger? can i read it without the second one? does everything get resolved in this one?" ummmm, yes, I believe everything does get resolved. I think at the time, it might have been slated as a standalone. The second book is years later and follows different characters; although, I actually think I enjoyed the second one more, so if you have fun with this one, you should really consider picking that one up!


message 24: by leila (new) - rated it 1 star

leila i haven't read it but does it contain smut or any type of sex or whatever? (please someone answer)


megs_bookrack Leila wrote: "i haven't read it but does it contain smut or any type of sex or whatever? (please someone answer)"To my remembrance, it does not. All of her books are pretty romance/sex-free.


 THRILLED to read This is a tv show now. I think its on Apple tv


megs_bookrack bookscheapestvacation wrote: "This is a tv show now. I think its on Apple tv" I heard that. I actually heard it was pretty good, but I don't have Apple tv. Maybe someday!! It's a cool premise for a show!


Winonas_Books girl you summed up the book perfectly! Have a good day!


megs_bookrack Winona Hess wrote: "girl you summed up the book perfectly! Have a good day!"Thank you so much, Winona!! xx


back to top