Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Jola's Reviews > Old School

Old School by Tobias Wolff
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
4785895
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: books-about-books, united-states, school, teachers, childhood

What a book! Despite the tranquil title, it's been an engrossing emotional roller coaster, which made me feel dizzy.

The setting of 'Old School' (2003) by Tobias Wolff is an elite boarding school in the United States in 1960�61. The unnamed narrator is one of the students, 'book-drunk boys', obsessed with literature and creative writing: 'one could not live in a world without stories'. The school regularly organizes a competition and the prize is a private audience with a notorious author. The desire to win makes the protagonist choose a road with no return, like in a poem by Robert Frost:
'I took the one less traveled by,
And that has made all the difference.'



The Hill School in Pottstown, Pennsylvania which probably inspired Tobias Wolff.

Sandy, one of my favourite Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ friends, wrote in her comment that despite some convincing suggestions, 'Old School' somehow hadn't made it to her TBR shelf yet. She added that maybe my recommendation would do the trick.

Truth be told, it's definitely Tobias Wolff who does the trick here. What if he was asked to write down the instructions for it? I doubt if he's willing to share the tricks of the trade in the first place, but let's assume he could come up with something like that:

The Name of the Trick: Old School

Trickiness Level: four stars out of five

Supplies: talent, wisdom, sensitivity to various writing styles, penmanship, ability to stir strong emotions with a few words, irony. Neither a rabbit in a hat nor a lovely assistant needed, although sharing the experience would be enriching for sure. By the way, I think 'Old School', with its ability to provoke fascinating discussions, would make a perfect group read.

Magic effect: an enchanted, shaky reader who can't put the novel down. Not able to stop thinking about it either.

Preparation and secret steps: firstly, you start with quite a prosaic topic and gradually turn it into something harrowing and special. The plot summary won't give you a thrill I guess but the impact of the novel may surprise you. Let's see what it imperceptibly does to you. I was quite astounded when I realized how profoundly invested in the book I got.

Get ready for trick and treat, two in one.


Harry Anderson, 'Boarding School'.

Tips and hints to help you perform the trick like Tobias Wolff:

* Give your book a great title.
The first and obvious association is the sophisticated institution portrayed in the novel but 'old school' may refer also to long-established moral values and conventional literary traditions which are sort of mocked here.

* Make a firework display of your writing skills.
Wolff amazed me with his ability to pastiche - not only the style of three visiting writers but also the narrator's and other students'. Each style is very distinctive and individual.

* Follow Anton Chekhov's advice: 'The role of the artist is to ask questions, not answer them.'
Like Henry James, Tobias Wolff doesn't offer easy solutions to the dilemmas his characters face. He invites us to ponder and solve the puzzles on our own.

* Resist the temptation to use words soaked in high-key emotions.
The author's writing style is concise, calm and matter-of-fact, even when he reports on dramatic events.


Mark Draisey Photography, Eton College.

* Create unforgettable characters.
I admired Wolff's impressive portrayals with three exceptions. The writers - Robert Frost, Ayn Rand and Ernest Hemingway - seemed to be painted with wide brushstrokes, more like caricatures, not real people. I'm aware that the portraits were supposed to be satirical but in my opinion the author exaggerated a bit.

* Don't be a one-trick pony.
Tobias Wolff provides abundance of food for thought. The writer at work, the process of creation, the role of literature, coming of age, school, being a teacher, making choices, search for truth, the masks we wear, looking for identity, honesty - these are just a few examples of areas covered by this novel which is only 195 pages long. The observation I've made while reading 'Old School', which surprised me most, was a paradox: Wolff made me realize how destructive the process of creation is.

* Entertain your audience.
Personally, I wouldn't call this book hilarious as a few reviewers did, but from time to time Wolff's sense of humour gleams through. Just a little sample: 'Writers are just like everyone else, only worse.'

* Be a magician (not necessarily of Lublin), not just an illusionist.
Albeit the story is overloaded with literary themes, there is nothing artificial about it. 'Old School' has a vintage feel and quality of works by classics. The old masters' touch. What a pity that few people have heard about 'Old School'. I was fortunate enough to read Orsodimondo's splendid review, which urged me to indulge in this outstanding novel.

* Don't reveal how the trick worked.
'Don’t talk about your writing. If you talk about your writing you will touch something you shouldn’t touch and it will fall apart and you will have nothing.'

* Don't miss a trick and let 'Old School' mesmerize you.


Norman Rockwell, 'Boy Reading an Adventure Story'.
72 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Old School.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 10, 2017 – Shelved
August 10, 2017 – Shelved as: to-read
August 11, 2017 – Started Reading
August 11, 2017 –
page 0
0.0% "'The headmaster had studied with Robert Frost at Amherst and once published a collection of poetry, Sonnets Against the Storm, which it now pained him to be reminded of. Though listed in the library’s card catalogue, the book had vanished and the headmaster was rumored to have destroyed it.'"
August 11, 2017 –
page 27
13.78% "English teachers: 'Adept as they were at dissection, they would never leave a poem or a novel strewn about in pieces like some butchered frog reeking of formaldehyde. They’d stitch it back together with history and psychology, philosophy, religion, and even, on occasion, science.'"
August 12, 2017 –
page 76
38.78% "'And why would Caesar fear Ovid, except for knowing that neither his divinity nor all his legions could protect him from a good line of poetry.'"
August 13, 2017 –
page 111
56.63% "'Make no mistake, he said: a true piece of writing is a dangerous thing. It can change your life.'"
August 13, 2017 –
page 127
64.8% "'Rhyme says that everything works out in the end. All harmony and order. When I see a rhyme in a poem, I know I’m being lied to. Go ahead, laugh! It’s true � rhyme’s a completely bankrupt device. It’s just wishful thinking. Nostalgia.'"
August 14, 2017 –
page 170
86.73% "'The appetite for decisive endings, even the belief that they’re possible, makes me uneasy in life as in writing.'"
August 14, 2017 – Shelved as: books-about-books
August 14, 2017 – Shelved as: united-states
August 14, 2017 – Finished Reading
August 24, 2017 – Shelved as: school
August 24, 2017 – Shelved as: teachers
August 24, 2017 – Shelved as: childhood

Comments Showing 1-31 of 31 (31 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Jola Sandy wrote: "Eagerly awaiting your review, Jola. This was recommended very highly a few years back by a friend of mine, but somehow it didn't make it to my TBR shelf. Maybe your recommendation will do the trick?"

I will try to do my best, Sandy. :) It doesn't often happen to read a book which is so thought-provoking and emotionally engaging at the same time.


message 2: by Christine (new) - added it

Christine I really enjoyed your review, Jola!


Jola Christine wrote: "I really enjoyed your review, Jola!"

Thanks a lot, Christine. This book was such a marvellous surprise. Glad I managed to express at least some of thoughts and emotions it provoked.


message 4: by Irena (new)

Irena Pasvinter Wow, another splendidly written review which in itself makes for a great read. I have not heard about The Old School before, although I think I might have heard about Tobias Wolff. Adding another book to my long to read list -- can't help it after such a review.


Jola Irena wrote: "Wow, another splendidly written review which in itself makes for a great read. I have not heard about The Old School before, although I think I might have heard about Tobias Wolff. Adding another b..."

I appreciate your kind words, Irena. Thank you so much! Actually, being a writer and knowing from experience how breathtaking and painful at the same time it is, you may enjoy 'Old School' even more than I did. I look forward to your impressions if you decide to read it. And I know exactly what you mean by a long list, mine has been quite out of control recently. :)


message 6: by Irena (new)

Irena Pasvinter Yes, somehow never mind how many books are in my "read" list, the "to read" list is always almost two times longer.;)


message 7: by Jola (last edited Aug 25, 2017 03:53AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jola Irena wrote: "Yes, somehow never mind how many books are in my "read" list, the "to read" list is always almost two times longer.;)"

Same here, Irena. :) I'm seriously considering daily or weekly limits, otherwise I'll end up with a billion of titles in a few months. :)


message 8: by Irena (new)

Irena Pasvinter Besides, after reading your reviews, I think you are a writer, and a very good one.


Jola Irena wrote: "Besides, after reading your reviews, I think you are a writer, and a very good one."

You've just made my day again, Irena. Thanks a lot!
If I ever consider creative writing, I will definitely take the aspirin test you mentioned on your blog. :)
I'm keeping my fingers crossed for all your plans, dear Irena.


message 10: by Irena (new)

Irena Pasvinter Thank you, Jola!


message 11: by Darlene (new)

Darlene Beautiful, Jola!:) And what an endorsement for this book!! I remember reading 'This Boy's Life' many years ago and you're right.. Wolff doesn't use words 'soaked in high-key emotions' (like I tend to do!:) ; but his writing IS thought-provoking! Thanks for bringing this to my attention! :)


message 12: by Jola (last edited Aug 25, 2017 07:11AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jola So sweet of you, Darlene. Thanks a million! Actually, I thought about you when I read that the boarding school portrayed in the novel is probably based on the author's memories from Pottstown, Pennsylvania. I was wondering if it's far from you. :)
In 'Old School" emotionless words definitely dominate, it's not only Wolff's tendency but also a sort of caricature of the style appreciated by the students - there was nothing worse than expressing feelings straightforward. That's one of the things I hated about this institution, with all due respect for impressive scholar achievements. I much prefer your sincere and natural style to the artificially dispassionate one, fashionable among these boys.


message 13: by Darlene (new)

Darlene Your reviews are always so creative and fascinating to read, Jola! Pottstown is in the eastern part of Pennsylvania, Jola... a little northwest of Philadelphia. I had a friend in college who was from Pottstown! I live in the western part of Pennsylvania.. a bit north of Pittsburgh.

When I read your wonderful review of this book, I was reminded that those 'emotionless words' are definitely Wolff's style. I really think I liked his writing so much BECAUSE he is quite different from me and how I tend to write (not that I am imagining myself a writer in Wolff's 'league' because clearly I am NOT! ). :) I am definitely NOT a 'stiff upper lip' kind of person and in fact, I look at this with a kind of weird fascination! It also reminds me that fate smiled on me in making me female!! I can be as emotional as I want to be... in fact, it is often expected! :)


message 14: by Jola (last edited Aug 25, 2017 09:48PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jola Darlene wrote: "Your reviews are always so creative and fascinating to read, Jola! Pottstown is in the eastern part of Pennsylvania, Jola... a little northwest of Philadelphia. I had a friend in college who was fr..."

Thanks a lot Darlene, so generous of you.
Well, it's far indeed. Pottstown is not present in the book anyway, the school is the setting here. And a railway station for a while.
What a relief men are allowed to be emotional also nowadays, it must have been horrible to pretend to be a tough guy even if the person was scattered inside.
I hope to read some more books by Wolff for sure, I think he's quite underrated.


message 15: by Jola (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jola Sandy wrote: "Very enticing review, Jola. Now I am just too curious to pass this one by any longer! I just ordered a copy through inter-library loan."

Oh, that's fantastic to know that Tobias Wolff has done the magic trick successfully! :) So glad you are going to read this novel, Sandy. I wish you would be as impressed as I still am.


message 16: by Jola (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jola Marita wrote: "Such an excellent analysis, Jola! Perhaps you should write a novel..."

Thanks from the bottom of my heart, Marita. Both for your lovely comment and your trust in my skills.
Actually, we could consider writing together a roman à clef novel, depicting literary celebrities we will meet next year during various galas and after-parties! :D


message 17: by Ilse (new) - added it

Ilse Thank you for this magnificent and entertaining review, Jola - I will suggest it to my 'real life' readinig group using your wonderful analysis to draw the other members into it, please wish me luck :))!


message 18: by Jola (last edited Aug 26, 2017 10:35PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jola Ilse wrote: "Thank you for this magnificent and entertaining review, Jola - I will suggest it to my 'real life' readinig group using your wonderful analysis to draw the other members into it, please wish me luc..."

Huge thanks to you, Ilse for being so generous! I'm extremely honoured that you are going to use my review.
In my view 'Old School' may really turn out to be a perfect group read: quite short and compact, emotionally engaging, provoking many questions which might be answered differently. Besides, it deals with the experiences we've all had at some point and can relate to easily, for example being a student or coming of age or discovering that adults are humans, not superheroes.
I do hope the group will accept your suggestion, Ilse. It would make me really happy. I'll do some cheerleading gladly if necessary. :D Of course I promise to keep my fingers crossed for sure!


message 19: by Marcia (new)

Marcia Wow! What a great review.


Audrey Harrison Can’t get the last line out of my head. Thoughts?


Margaret Mcneill Thanks for this great review


message 22: by Jola (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jola Marcia wrote: "Wow! What a great review."

So glad you liked it, Marcia.


message 23: by Jola (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jola Audrey wrote: "Can’t get the last line out of my head. Thoughts?"

I will answer with a quote from this novel: 'The appetite for decisive endings, even the belief that they’re possible, makes me uneasy in life as in writing.'
:)


message 24: by Jola (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jola Margaret wrote: "Thanks for this great review"

You are very welcome, Margaret.


Violeta It’s been years since I read this book but your imaginative review makes me want to read it once more if only to find out for myself all the fine points you brought to light. Great job Jola!


message 26: by Elena (new)

Elena Sala Mmmm this book sounds just right for me. I wonder if a school full of "book drunk boys" has ever existed in real life... Loved your review, Jola, very tantalizing!


message 27: by Jola (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jola So glad you enjoyed it, dear Elena! Thanks a lot. I'm afraid "computer game drunk boys" or "mobile phone drunk boys" would be more apt nowadays.


message 28: by Jola (last edited Jul 28, 2020 10:10PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jola Dear Violeta, so happy my review rekindled your interest in this amazing book. Sadly, it's almost completely forgotten, as it seems. I appreciate your lovely comment and hope you will have a great time with Old School again if you decide to reread it.


message 29: by Elena (new)

Elena Sala Jola wrote: "So glad you enjoyed it, dear Elena! Thanks a lot. I'm afraid "computer game drunk boys" or "mobile phone drunk boys" would be more apt nowadays."

Oh yes, absolutely!!


Timothy R The last line would harken to the parable of the prodigal son.


Abraham What a review! Amazing. Old school is magic. Regards.


back to top