ŷ

La Petite Américaine's Reviews > What Made Maddy Run: The Secret Struggles and Tragic Death of an All-American Teen

What Made Maddy Run by Kate Fagan
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
59329
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: auto-bios-etc, biography
Read 2 times. Last read August 16, 2017.

The next time you find yourself shocked/stupified/wishing you could bitchslap some obnoxious Millennial, do yourself a favor and pick up a copy of Kate Fagan's What Made Maddy Run
The Secret Struggles and Tragic Death of an All-American Teen
. It won't make you want to bitchslap them any less, but at least you'll understand what the hell is wrong with them.

Seriously.

What Made Maddy Run profiles just one 19 year-old woman, but the story of her life, from its promising beginning to its tragic end, encapsulates the flaws and struggles of an entire generation.

Fagan's book, which poses important questions about the pressures facing the youngest Millennials and discusses the state of mental health on college campuses, should be required reading for all incoming freshmen, their parents, and their professors--recognizing mental health issues in this famously non-communicative generation is their job.

As for the rest of us?

The book gives us a little insight into what makes these kids tick. You won't come away with a newfound respect (lol) for Millennials--kudos to Fagan, by the way, for making zero attempt to defend the Shittiest Generation--but at least you'll understand 20-somethings a little better.

But I digress.

Fagan's book explores the events leading up to the suicide of 19 year-old Ivy League track star Madison Holleran. What was it that drove a beautiful, brilliant, accomplished student and star athlete--and 6 others at her university that same year--to take her own life?

The girl had everything, and a bright future was all but guaranteed.

So.

What the hell happened?

Fagan does a lot of deep diving into possible factors leading to Maddy's suicide, from mental illness to the enormous amount of pressure that student athletes endure, but her main theory is one that rings so true that it's particularly alarming.

Simply put, Fagan argues that Madison's generation of "digital natives" (those who never lived in a world without the Internet) are social media savvy as fuck, but offline, they lack basic social and emotional skills--i.e. empathy, introspection, self-expression, compassion, etc.--essential to human communication and interaction. In Madison's case, real communication was exactly what she needed, was incapable of asking for, and wasn't getting.

To paraphrase the hell out of Fagan, think about Millennials like Madison this way:

--Growing up with a screen in their faces has left these kids with almost zero capacity for critical thinking; instead, they function mindless and automated...just like the computers that raised them. The result is "a generation of world-class hoop jumpers...young people who know what they’re supposed to say, but not necessarily why they’re saying it." This is a group of young people who "have been taught what to think, but not how to think."

--The majority of their socialization takes place online: text messages, Facebook, Instagram, etc., which keeps communication at an emoji-filled level of superficiality. Citing scholar William Deresiewicz, Fagan notes the problematic nature of that superficiality: "We have 968 “friends� that we never actually talk to; instead we just bounce one-line messages off them a hundred times a day. This is not friendship, this is distraction."

--They're masters at perfecting their online personas but, as Fagan notes, the controlled image these kids present on social media "reduces [the] ability to reach one another when in distress." Keeping up appearances online is one thing, but these kids are often focused on maintaining that same facade offline. Gee. Never getting the space to be real and your social media self begins to interfere with your true self, all while masking potential problems beneath the surface... What could go wrong?

--Because those "life marketing" social media skills come at the expense of real human interaction, these kids are at a disadvantage when real-life happens--especially when there are problems that require articulating emotions that run deeper than an "I'm-so-happy-life-is-so-perfect" Instagram post.

Take all of those factors, along with that group of young people so completely incapable of coping, and consider what would happen in the case of a major life upset.

In Fagan's book, that life upset was Madison Holleran's freshman year of college. (Seriously, does anything suck more than the first year of college?? UGH). If you can remember a world without the Internet, then you probably coped like the rest of us did: you cried to your roommate, got pancakes at 3AM, and finally got wasted friends until some of the stress abated.

But this new generation is different. To understand Madison Holleran's freshman year, take out the human connection and the normalcy in expressing negative emotions that we had. Add in perfectionism, the grueling schedule of a student athlete, and mental illness. And remember the pressure to maintain a perfect social presence, both on and offline, even if it's masking serious inner turmoil.

The result?

A girl who had it all was suddenly facing the dark depths of depression alone, with no understanding of what she was experiencing, no ability to articulate what she was feeling, and a near-zero support system because her Instagram persona kept friends unaware of the depths of her depression.

I suppose I couldn't put this down because I felt a brief pause in my daily rage at Millennials...I mean, it's not their fault that they were raised in front of screens their whole lives. (Actually, that's probably the reason they're like the human equivalent of a popup error message when asked to think outside the box to solve a fuckin problem--but whatever).

It makes them no less irritating, but...

...at least in this case, the story of one digital native who had the potential to be great and lost it all touches you in some way. Fagan's depiction of Maddy's final moments was devoid of sensationalism, maybe even brought tears to my eyes >ahem<, and showed the reality of what these young people are truly robbed of when we teach them how to navigate the Internet but not life itself.

So, extremely well-written, excellent piece of sports journalism, and while not exactly an uplifting read, an important one for understanding the next generation.

Nicely done.
130 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read What Made Maddy Run.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
August 16, 2017 – Started Reading
August 16, 2017 – Shelved
August 16, 2017 – Shelved as: auto-bios-etc
August 16, 2017 – Shelved as: biography
August 16, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-31 of 31 (31 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Faizan (new)

Faizan wow.. definitely going to read it... I was thinking to read something on millennial.. and this is it


La Petite Américaine Faizan wrote: "wow.. definitely going to read it... I was thinking to read something on millennial.. and this is it"

Definitely worth it.


message 3: by Ali (new) - added it

Ali K I enjoy so much reading your reviews. They are so to-the-point and witty. Especially love reading your 'hater' 1-star reviews, they became kind of my guilty pleasure.
Will be picking up this book as well.


La Petite Américaine Alina wrote: "I enjoy so much reading your reviews. They are so to-the-point and witty. Especially love reading your 'hater' 1-star reviews, they became kind of my guilty pleasure.
Will be picking up this book a..."


Aw thanks! I'll try to read something I hate for you. :)


message 5: by Latifaha (new)

Latifaha . why so much hatred towards Millenials though?


message 6: by La Petite Américaine (last edited Jul 27, 2018 12:30AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

La Petite Américaine Latifaha wrote: "why so much hatred towards Millenials though?"

I was born in 1980, which means I've got one foot in the Millennial generation and the other in Gen X, so I'm not not some grandma going off about these kids today...

It's just that the 5-10 year head start I've got on Millennials is significant: the 20-somethings I've worked with have a massive sense of entitlement, talk down to people who've done the job for 30 years (you know, experts who don't confuse job skills knowing how to login to Twitter), they've got a poor work ethic, are overconfident in their abilities, and despite their lack of work experience, are convinced of (and vocal about) their own intelligence. Oh, and their militant rage about the unfairness of life bugs me too.

That said, I've known a couple of amazing Millennials--exception that proves the rule...,


message 7: by Marianne (new) - added it

Marianne Your review has peaked my interest. This topic (mental health, especially of millennials) is particularly important to me. With two adult children 21 and 19, this book will surely resonate. Definitely will read.


La Petite Américaine Marianne wrote: "Your review has peaked my interest. This topic (mental health, especially of millennials) is particularly important to me. With two adult children 21 and 19, this book will surely resonate. Definit..."

Ohhh, definitely check it out for sure then if you've got Millennial kids. Don't forget to let me know what you think when you're done with it. :)


message 9: by Bruce (new)

Bruce Welton Always love your reviews. I remember seeing an ESPN piece on this and feeling stunned and sad about her. Now I know where I can dig into the rest of the story. Thanks.


La Petite Américaine Bruce wrote: "Always love your reviews. I remember seeing an ESPN piece on this and feeling stunned and sad about her. Now I know where I can dig into the rest of the story. Thanks."

Thanks! I really need to go back and clean up this review, so I'm not done with it yet, but review aside, the book is great. Really sad story but at the same time offers incredible insight into a generation whose world view is entirely different from our own.


message 11: by Bruce (new)

Bruce Welton It's interesting- the prisms and slants through which different people of different places and ages see the world. At times, heart-warming, at other times, shocking. But that is part of the wonder of human being, I reckon.


La Petite Américaine Bruce wrote: "It's interesting- the prisms and slants through which different people of different places and ages see the world. At times, heart-warming, at other times, shocking. But that is part of the wonder ..."
Absolutely.


message 13: by Donna (new)

Donna Dicuffa Interesting review and I agree that social media is killing our kids and their ability to socialize/cope but your range toward them is a bit excessive. There are also many well-adjusted ones, and a bit of compassion and understanding never hurt.


La Petite Américaine Donna wrote: "Interesting review and I agree that social media is killing our kids and their ability to socialize/cope but your range toward them is a bit excessive. There are also many well-adjusted ones, and a..."

Probably. :)


message 15: by Toni (new) - rated it 4 stars

Toni Fuscellaro Your review is excellent. After reading this book, I agree with you. I think every parent should read this book.


La Petite Américaine Toni wrote: "Your review is excellent. After reading this book, I agree with you. I think every parent should read this book."

Thank you.

Feel exactly the same way about every parent needing to read this book.

This younger generation is just so radically different from their predesscors in how they think, interact, and communicate, and What Made Massey Run? shows us exactly what can go wrong if we don’t understand these kids.

I’m so glad that Fagan wrote this book—by doing so. she’s preserved the legacy of a someone who was clearly a remarkable young woman, and ensured that her story serves a purpose, and is more than just a tragic loss.


message 17: by Toni (new) - rated it 4 stars

Toni Fuscellaro “shows us exactly what can go wrong if we don’t understand these kids.�

I also thought the part about parents being with their young adults through every minute of every day putting extra pressure on them. My son is currently taking exams and I thought twice about texting him right after to see how they went. He puts enough pressure on himself, he doesn’t need me texting him.
Again, parents need to read this book. Agree about preserving the legacy about a remarkable young woman who continues to touch and change lives.


message 18: by La Petite Américaine (last edited Dec 19, 2018 03:13AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

La Petite Américaine Toni wrote: "“shows us exactly what can go wrong if we don’t understand these kids.�

I also thought the part about parents being with their young adults through every minute of every day putting extra pressur..."


Yes, I really feel that Fagan did an excellent job telling this story as objectively as possible, but also humanizing this young woman, her family, her struggles, etc. � she took what looked like just a senseless tragedy, gave it meaning, and held the mirror up to a larger cultural problem in this country right now with this younger generation. If one person is helped by this book, then her death wasn’t for nothing - her story ultimately gives life to others.

Re: not texting your son: that’s some remarkable restraint. I know the feeling...every day is an exercise in balancing giving my son space to become his own person but still making sure he knows that no matter what, he can come to me about anything, and that he should always express his feelings. (Hopefully this tactic works).

I’m just so tired of this whole notion of kids being defined by what they achieve. All that matters is that they grow up to be happy, healthy adults and kind human beings. This constant pressure to chase perfection is the race to nowhere, and it’s ridiculous and toxic.

My theory is that (here comes a sweeping generalization) Boomers didn’t provide a whole lot of guidance or parenting (I’m sorry but what other generation needed a TV commercial saying “It’s 10PM, do you know where your children are�?). Their Gen X kids went to the opposite extreme, being over-involved, hand-holding their kids through everything that they needed to learn and develop on their own, and pressured them to “be the best� at everything to achieve a good life, because their own parents sent the message that material shit = success and happiness. And because Gen Xers wanted their kids to achieve so badly, they handed them unfettered access to technology thinking it would help them—but instead shit like Instagram happened and created an entirely new set of pressures for these kids. (I’m 100% generalizing, and not saying this is what happened to Maddy). The result is what feels like an entire generation of “perfect on paper� kids who lack basic human coping mechanisms and zero creative problem solving or critical thinking skills. I’m only ten years older than this generation, and they’re largely difficult to work with, shallow, entitled...and while that’s annoying, the worst part is seeing these young people who appear to be profoundly unhappy.

I’m sure my son’s generation will be messed up for an entirely different set of reasons we never saw coming :), but I’m grateful that the elemtary schools now are teaching things like empathy, expressing your feelings, asking for help, and limiting screen time—these are critical skills that were never learned, taught, or developed in Milennials and Gen Z, and thre worst cases aren’t the Bernie Bros, the entitled kids who are pissed that they have to work for money, or the rude kids at Starbucks who don’t get why their fantastic attitude hasn’t landed them their dream job—the worst cases are the ones who endure what Maddy went through.

Anyway, that was longer than I intended...this book left me with some pretty strong feelings, so...


message 19: by Noah (new) - added it

Noah Crocker ....ouch.


message 20: by Noah (new) - added it

Noah Crocker I do understand your reasoning. Many Millennials are complete idiots, who have no idea how to socialise outside of a screen. However, there are some of us who's parents had the decency to raise us outside of a screen, teaching us to express things in our own way, instead of spouting out what we've heard. I don't think that it's very fair to stereotype all Millennials just because some of us are robotic dipwads.


La Petite Américaine Noah wrote: "I do understand your reasoning. Many Millennials are complete idiots, who have no idea how to socialise outside of a screen. However, there are some of us who's parents had the decency to raise us ..."

No, it’s totally unfair. It was supposed to be funny (I.e. using the term “bitchslap� was meant to indicate I wasn’t serious).


message 22: by Noah (new) - added it

Noah Crocker Oh, ok. Sorry about that :/


La Petite Américaine Noah wrote: "Oh, ok. Sorry about that :/"

No worries :)


message 24: by Toni (new) - rated it 4 stars

Toni Fuscellaro “I’m just so tired of this whole notion of kids being defined by what they achieve. All that matters is that they grow up to be happy, healthy adults and kind human beings. This constant pressure to chase perfection is the race to nowhere, and it’s ridiculous and toxic.�


As you can see I’m still thinking about this book and your review.


La Petite Américaine Toni wrote: "“I’m just so tired of this whole notion of kids being defined by what they achieve. All that matters is that they grow up to be happy, healthy adults and kind human beings. This constant pressure t..."

Ty. This book is a hard one to shake after you’ve read it...


message 26: by Coco (new) - rated it 4 stars

Coco Torre Thank you for going in depth on this book. I feel like I’m swimming upstream with my 14 year old. It’s so hard to get these notions into her brain when she’s surrounded by friends that who can’t put their phones down. It’s a struggle trying to get her to tear away from it. :-(


La Petite Américaine Coco wrote: "Thank you for going in depth on this book. I feel like I’m swimming upstream with my 14 year old. It’s so hard to get these notions into her brain when she’s surrounded by friends that who can’t pu..."

Sorry to hear about your 14 year-old. I hear that’s a rough age for parents.

If this is in anyway helpful: I have a 9 year-old son, and I ended up taking away his iPhone a few months ago. No warnings, no drama, I just put it in a cabinet while he was at school. When he came home asking if he could have his phone, I said that he’d get it back after I’d come up with some new rules about him using it. I finally decided that the phone = earned privilege: he’s allowed 45 mins on his phone after karate (so, twice a week) and...well, that’s it. He carries a basic Nokia in his backpack so he can make calls and so I can see his gps in emergencies.

It was the right choice, and I’m keeping it in place until this kid moves out for college. Seriously. I wasn’t liking *at all* what I was seeing with that smartphone thing, and I think any parent who wants to limit or cut out screens should do it. They’re destructive for kids and teens.

It might be helpful if some high schools and middle schools in this county required students to read this book as well...

Sigh.


message 28: by Stephanie Grajek (new)

Stephanie Grajek I consider myself an "elder millennial" (born in 89), but I agree with you about social media. The past couple of years the anxiety I have seen in my athletes has greatly increased and I think a lot of it has to do with social media. I try to explain that you can do a lot with pictures and that no ones life is perfect. I am looking forward to finishing the book, hopefully I will learn a few ways to help my athletes.


(Tracy's) Book Balderdash Never in my life has a 5 star review for a book turned me off from it so hard. The “Shittiest Generation?� I think it’s more likely that millennials don’t want to talk to you because you think they’re shitty broken people whose way of life is broken trash, and not that they are “famously non-communicative� people. I’ll end my expression of my negative emotions there, because that’s all my shitty timid non-communicative uncritical perfectionist people-pleasing millennial brain can handle.


Kendall Brown Yikes - I agree with a lot of your review, despite your raging hatred toward millennials.


message 31: by Pam (new) - rated it 5 stars

Pam This review is amazing! I just stumbled up Maddy's story very recently because I was looking up Kate Fagan's other books and was intrigued by this one.
I cracked up at your comment "It's 10 pm, do you know where your children are"? because I remember it so well when I was growing up. I'm a young Boomer, born in 1962. I have a little boomer and x in me. My parents were on the cusp of greatest gen/silent gen. Talk about hands off parenting! They never quite knew where we were nor what we were doing. So, I had my kids very late in life, and they are Gen Z. To say that it has been difficult to parent is an understatement. I'm more hands-off, which really sucks in the digital age and a time when everyone gets a trophy just because their parents paid the registration fee.
Maddy's story is truly heartbreaking, but it was the absolute perfectionism that actually made me mad. It may be innate, but what 7 year old plays competitive soccer and has the schedule of a professional athlete? A recipe for disaster, on top of all the other clues in Maddy's life that pointed to what ultimately took place. Especially telling was that she and her friends never wanted to grow up. Maddy didn't even want to learn how to drive, keeping her dependent on others. Lots of red flags.
Anyway, thanks for your review and comments. They give readers of all generations pause, or at least they should.


back to top