ŷ

dianne b.'s Reviews > Eileen

Eileen by Ottessa Moshfegh
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
246171
's review

it was amazing

Because Eileen is completely alone, in every imaginable way, she can comfortably know everything absolutely. If i were younger i’d be tempted to consider a sideline religion based on her Absolutes; well, some of them. Maybe. When you’re unchallenged, you are, de facto, correct in all things and i thoroughly enjoyed this point of view from our auto-antifa heroine-ista, a perverse, artfully self-deprecating Tanner stage 2 twenty-six year old - all revved up and ready for ruination.

Creating her days - “out of whole cloth� (which qualifies as the miracle part of the religion thing), such as the surely inevitable romance with one of the guards in the boys prison where Eileen works:

“I spent many hours watching his biceps flick and pump as he turned each page of his comic book. When I imagine him now, I think of the way he’d swerve a toothpick around in his mouth. It was beautiful. It was poetry. I asked him once, nervous and ridiculous, whether he felt cold wearing just short sleeves in winter. He shrugged. Still waters ran deep, I thought, nearly swooning. It was pointless to fantasize, but I couldn’t help imagine one day he’d throw stones at my attic window, motorcycle steaming out in front of the house, the melting the whole town to hell. I was not immune to that sort of thing.�

And her ability to pull the all-star out of the grotesque:
She kept a frozen (dead) mouse in the glove box of her car, finding that it bolstered her with a hearty “glad i’m not you!� sentiment. Creative, yes? Prior to the appearance of the frozen vermin, she had used photos of new inmates - responding with the same feeling. Now that's just making the best of things!

I also found myself agreeing with many of her insights on the silly disguises we use:

p. 138 “Getting dolled up was completely silly, of course. You can always tell something when a woman is overdressed - either she’s an outsider, or she’s insane.�

p. 29 “People smelled better back then. I am certain this is true�.Nowadays I often have to leave a room or walk away when a person near to me smells bad. I don’t mean the smell of dirt and sweat, but a kind of artificial, caustic smell usually from people who disguise themselves in creams and perfumes. They are predators. They are like the dogs who roll around in one another’s feces. It’s very disturbing.�


Some might find the twists, surprises, momentous moments in this book ridiculous or completely unrealistic. Nah, not really...i don’t. Anyone who has the privilege of spending a few decades in an emergency or drop in clinic, can trace the increasingly perverse and sad, the deeper depths of loneliness and desperation, as folks, freshly unemployed, perhaps just evicted, see no future, no safety net, no outstretched hand - only nastiness and xenophobia as the oligarchs divide and conquer. Crack, meth, alcohol, heroin - all or any of it - if it can make it all go away for awhile...

The boys locked up in Eileen’s prison - each part of their own Greek tragedy. Each landing there because they saw no way out of impossibly awful situations. Abused horribly, nightly by your father, after being prepared by your mother (by enema). At what point is it reasonable self-defense to kill the father? Day one? Or after 12 years? None of them initiated the evil that landed them in this place - guaranteed to send them downhill forever. No - they all were just Big Losers in the Womb Lottery.

Eileen's send off -which i can’t say anything about without saying too much - was Perfect.

I loved this book. It was heartbreaking and brilliant and hilarious, and, yes, i did pour myself a vodka tonic or two while reading it - Wanna make something of it? Wanna meet me outside? After church, of course.
15 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Eileen.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

September 15, 2017 – Started Reading
September 15, 2017 – Shelved
September 17, 2017 –
page 89
34.23% "what a perverse, artfully self-deprecating Tanner stage 2 twenty-six year old - all revved up and ready for ruination."
September 21, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-7 of 7 (7 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Violeta I enjoyed every single sentence of your review, Dianne! Especially this: "When you’re unchallenged, you are, de facto, correct in all things...: How true, and sadly, how common nowadays, in this armor-clad, internet world; can you imagine Eileen's days had she had a Facebook profile?


message 2: by Ulysse (last edited Jul 01, 2023 04:45AM) (new)

Ulysse That quote about the perfume, I can relate. Why do some people put so much of that stuff on themselves, what are they trying to cover up? I'll take a little BO over artificial nose law violation #1 anytime. My wife's reaction is even more extreme: you wouldn't believe the number of times we've had to walk out of movie theatres because of bad perfumes.

I love your phrase "Big Losers in the Womb lottery." I might have to steal that one day.


dianne b. Violeta wrote: "how common nowadays, in this armor-clad, internet world; can you imagine Eileen's days had she had a Facebook profile?."

Thank you and glad you enjoyed it, Violeta. Your review is the perfect encapsulation of the book's main dish, so I'll be the pre-meal jester, okay?

Well, had Eileen a Facebook profile, or better yet become an Instagram influencer I'd probably subscribe - her humor is so infectious.

The insular, self-congratulatory world of the internet reminds me of a William Golding quote that comes to mind when I read about the ridiculous political machinations of the country I was born in (and happily no longer live in):
"I am astonished at the ease with which uninformed persons come to a settled, a passionate opinion when they have no grounds for judgment."


dianne b.
Ulysse wrote: "That quote about the perfume, I can relate. Why do some people put so much of that stuff on themselves, what are they trying to cover up? I'll take a little BO over artificial nose law violation #1..."

Yeah - I'm fairly certain we didn't spend hundreds of thousands of years evolving our first cranial nerve and the sensitive receptors in our nose; sending those messages to the olfactory tract - which sits just under our frontal lobes, that seat of creativity - and then the neuronal relationship of those olfactory nerves to our tender memory to have it all assaulted by anything more powerful than a blooming flower. I'm with your wife.

How could she appreciate your (no doubt galvanic) pheromones when the whole system is being slaughtered by some synthetic, overwhelming, profit-driven, nose-obliterating, brick-wall-smash-at-high-speed of a Perfume?

At least you can leave the theater. Artificial scents should be banned from public transportation. My partner becomes quite tense when a perfumed person is walking the aisle. The approach! With the threat of taking the empty seat next to him.

See? I'm a faithful follower of Eileen's Religion. BO just means you are a laborer. Or you went for a run. Or more probably, these days (at least in the USA) that you're homeless. Whatever, it's natural. Too little of that now. Maybe because it's free?

Oh, and sure! Steal away!


message 5: by J.C. (new)

J.C. Just brilliant, Dianne! I feel that the style of your review must echo the book itself, and so portray it perfectly. When you write about your years of working and living in the world of hurt and injury it is extremely moving.
I feel that Eileen could be multiplied over and over, and her attitude feels exactly like someone throwing stones at a window and waking the whole town with the motorbike - which the prison guard doesn't do.
Well captured - if that isn't too cruel a pun.
I'm off to find Violeta's review. I agree with her absolutely about you first sentence (sorry to descend into the realm of pun)!


message 6: by dianne b. (last edited Jul 01, 2023 07:47PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

dianne b. J.C. wrote: "I feel that Eileen could be multiplied over and over, and her attitude feels exactly like someone throwing stones at a window and waking the whole town with the motorbike - which the prison guard doesn't do. "

Thank you, dear JC, yes, our prison guard wasn't going to save Eileen, or anyone. She may have dreamt of him "melting the whole town to hell" but, of course, she would have to start the fire and provide the kindling for her life, as all women must - despite the myths and sleight of hand that still attempt to divert our energy, our focus.

Puns are high art. My beloved father regaled me with them and I loved it.

My decades "working and living in the world of hurt and injury" were a privilege. At least I felt like I was doing something that mattered. They did leave me somewhat prickly, snarky for the rest of the world. But at this age? No matter.


Violeta dianne b. wrote: ".Well, had Eileen a Facebook profile, or better yet become an Instagram influencer I'd probably subscribe - her humor is so infectious."

You are a brave woman, Dianne! :))


back to top