ŷ

s.penkevich's Reviews > Beloved

Beloved by Toni Morrison
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
6431467
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: important

Something that is loved is never lost.

Every so often a book comes along that shakes you until you feel you might break open and, worn out in the aftermath of emotional devastation, you recognize how important and impactful storytelling can be. Storytelling carries memories on into the future though, as is the case of Nobel Prize winning novelist Toni Morrison’s Beloved, memories can often be very painful to revisit and can still haunt and harm in the present and future. Such are the horrors of slavery and Beloved addresses the collective memory of violences that are physically, emotionally and spiritually destructive. �Rememory� is the term Morrison’s character Sethe gives to memories that not only affect the individual but those around them as well, and through the rememory of Beloved Morrison addresses not only the child that was killed but also the countless deaths to slavery and racial violence and states that all of them are beloved. Beloved is an essential classic, revising and revitalizing the slave narrative through a collective of voices that explore the psychological as well as physical suffering and shows how it is perpetuated for years to come. While those who met Beloved seem to fall silent on the matter later because �It was not a story to pass on,� Morrison shows why it is necessary to tell these stories (especially as Sethe is ) and through Beloved she expertly explores memory, community and the lasting consequences of the horrors of slavery.

Who would have thought that a little old baby could harbor so much rage,� those who live in the house 124 say of the ghost who haunts the home. Yet if this ghost—that of Sethe’s unnamed child known only as Beloved for the solitary word Sethe paid in flesh to have carved—is also the memory of all those lost to slavery, one begins to understand the limitless express of sadness and rage that could be had. �Beloved represents African American history or collective memory as much as she does Sethe’s or Paul D’s individual memory,� wrote Pamela E. Barnett, and other critics have compared her to the collective pain of those lost in the Middle Passage (Beloved at one point recalls memories of being aboard a slave ship) and is much a figure of Sethe’s daughter remembered but also the countless lost to slavery.

This can be a very difficult book, especially emotionally, with horrific depictions of sexual and physical violence and recounting some of the darkest moments in US history, yet through Morrison’s exquisite prose it becomes a horror one cannot—or should not—look away from. An aspect of Morrison’s oeuvre that ensures it lasting importance is how she draws a direct line between past and any present to force us to confront the lasting effects of slavery and that we cannot just dismiss it as a sin of the past but as a lasting trauma with its talons still drawing blood in the present day. Which is why we tell stories, to draw attention to the past and contextualize the present, which Morrison does here showing how slavery affects those who have been freed.

Me and you, we got more yesterday than anybody. We need some kind of tomorrow.

Sethe and Paul D have a lot of trauma behind them, having both been captive at Sweet House, a place that �wasn’t sweet and it sure wasn’t home.� They do not want to revisit these stories, but the sudden arrival of the mysterious Beloved force the memories to resurface. Sethe cannot help but see even beautiful natural scenery without juxtaposing it with images flashing in her mind of bodies hanging from the branches and Paul D hopes to keep the past hidden away �in that tobacco tin buried in his chest where a red heart used to be.� Beloved ruptures this and calls to mind the lost child haunting the house, depicted in many ways like an infant with her head seemingly unable to be supported by her neck, having croup, and demanding all of Sethe’s attention and support, but we see how while these memories can be painful they can also be healing. For Sethe we see the connection with her and Beloved being assessed as a second chance to raise her child, but a moment of more or less sexual assault on Paul D also returns his memories to him. In Pamela E. Barnett’s essay , she describes Beloved as a figure of a succubus from African folklore and that by awakening his memories—which also reconnect him to his body and emotions—is a recurrence of his sexual assault and �has emasculated him just as the guards in Alfred, Georgia did.� Except through this he heals instead of breaks.

In this here place, we flesh; flesh that weeps, laughs; flesh that dances on bare feet in grass. Love it. Love it hard. Yonder they do not love your flesh. They despise it.

The sexual encounter also points at another major theme in the book about the focus on flesh. We have, of course, the violence against the flesh of work on the plantations and the extreme abuse that lacerated their skin. But we also see the healing of touch, such as Baby Suggs working Sethe back to health with her hands.There is also the imagery of the bruises around Sethe’s neck, which Denver accuses Beloved of leaving but Beloved says �I didn’t choke [her neck]. The circle of iron choked it� in reference to the iron collar worn by the slaves leaving a lasting mark on the body. There is the lesson that Black people must remember to love their flesh despite and in spite of the hatred for it from the white people. To love oneself and love the Black community is the path to freedom:
And O my people, out yonder, hear me, they do not love your neck unnoosed and straight. So love your neck; put a hand on it, grace it, stroke it and hold it up. and all your inside parts that they'd just as soon slop for hogs, you got to love them. The dark, dark liver--love it, love it and the beat and beating heart, love that too. More than eyes or feet. More than lungs that have yet to draw free air. More than your life-holding womb and your life-giving private parts, hear me now, love your heart. For this is the prize.

One of the best depictions between the link of the individual body and the collective body is that of the call and response songs sung as slaves. They �saing it out and beat it up, garbling the words so they would not be understood; trickling the words so their syllables yielded up other meanings.� There is the aspect that they were a community through song as much as they were being physically chained together in shared, forced labor. Body and spirits united, and why it was so important to remember �a man could risk his own life, but not his brother’s.� I also feel Morrison helps create a feeling of community and the collective through the multiple perspectives sharing the narrative.

A critical form of community with others in Beloved is that of motherhood. Under slavery, bonds between mothers and their children we thwarted because a mother would likely watch their children sold to another farm. For this reason Paul D sees Sethe’s relationship with Denver and thinks �to love anything that much was dangerous, especially if it was her children she had settled on to love.� The connection with a mother is also why Denver feels so betrayed by the closeness of Sethe and Beloved, who she feels is usurping her place (while most character growth is turned inward in the novel, Denver’s is more active, going from isolated and somber to entering the larger community through work and taking a more active role in everyone’s lives). Motherhood is such a strong emotional core to the novel, particularly when we learn why the unnamed child was killed and how we as readers cannot even fathom having to choose to find the death of your own child a sort of mercy when �being alive was the hard part.� I enjoyed Morrison’s craft of juxtaposing the climax of both the past and present narratives around Sethe seeing a white man as a threat to her freedom and the freedom of her children, with the scene in the present being a moment where she is saved by her community, reestablishing its importance to the story.

Freeing yourself was one thing, claiming ownership of that freed self was another.

Toni Morrison once said �slavery broke the world in half� and her body of work examines this as well as the long litany of aftershocks haunting the present. In Beloved we watch how even those freed from slavery after escaping are still suffering in its shadow. Memory is a point of pain, but also an avenue to healing and we tell these stories so those who are not here to tell of their pain are still remembered and loved. Beloved is a towering achievement of a novel, both in terms of craft and importance and it is one that rocks the reader to the core. An essential read if there ever was one.

5/5
488 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Beloved.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
September 24, 2011 – Shelved
August 10, 2023 – Shelved as: important

Comments Showing 1-41 of 41 (41 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Catherine (new) - added it

Catherine (alternativelytitledbooks) - in a book slump :( Stunning review, S! I need to make it a personal mission to get to Morrison ASAP!


s.penkevich Catherine wrote: "Stunning review, S! I need to make it a personal mission to get to Morrison ASAP!"

Thank you! ooo yay, hope you get to her she is SO good. I actually read this the first time in college during a semester where I read 3 of her books simultaneously for 2 different classes so I've decided to reread them all again because I couldn't remember which parts were in which books anymore haha, but I feel like she not only held up but I've appreciated her even more.


message 3: by Amina (new)

Amina This paragraph and this statement of yours, 'some of the darkest moments in US history, yet through Morrison’s exquisite prose it becomes a horror one cannot—or should not—look away from' was just so brutally honest and illustrated so vividly the context of the novel. I always admire how you highlight the important themes depicted in the novel and the one where the present can never escape the past is a sad one, for sure. Incredible review, S.! 💙


Daniel Fletcher This is one of those books that is so devastating that I almost can’t bear to think about it, which I suppose is the point! It’s absolutely a masterpiece, and I think should be a must-read for everyone. Great review!!


Andrea Cox Great review. I think this is one of the only books I’ve read that literally left me breathless. Toni Morrison is such a master storyteller! She is also a beautiful audiobook narrator of her own works and I need to listen to more of her books!


s.penkevich Amina wrote: "This paragraph and this statement of yours, 'some of the darkest moments in US history, yet through Morrison’s exquisite prose it becomes a horror one cannot—or should not—look away from' was just ..."

Thank you so much! Yea I’m beginning to see how that is sort of a larger theme for Morrison which makes me appreciate her even more than I had before when I sort of viewed each novel separately and focused more on the aspects of the past than how it reaches out towards the present. Definitely an amazing author!


message 7: by Julio (new)

Julio Pino Si, S. The oppressed have a much stronger sense of memory than the oppressors, perhaps precisely because it must be kept hidden or sublimated. Afro-Americans would be an outstanding example, from both North and South America, and also the Irish and the Jews. Strange as it may sound, unofficial history is more enduring.


s.penkevich Daniel wrote: "This is one of those books that is so devastating that I almost can’t bear to think about it, which I suppose is the point! It’s absolutely a masterpiece, and I think should be a must-read for ever..."

YEA! There were moments where I sort of had to just take a little break, it’s brutal but so good. This was a reread for me and I think I enjoyed it even more than when we read it for a class (conveniently I had all my class notes in the margins haha it was like reading it with my 20 year old self). Glad you love this one as well! And thank you!


s.penkevich Andrea wrote: "Great review. I think this is one of the only books I’ve read that literally left me breathless. Toni Morrison is such a master storyteller! She is also a beautiful audiobook narrator of her own wo..."

Thank you so much! Oh for sure, breathless is a good way to put it. It’s so relentless yet still so important and rather beautiful. Oooo good advice I should definitely do my next Morrison on audio she has such a lovely reading voice


s.penkevich Julio wrote: "Si, S. The oppressed have a much stronger sense of memory than the oppressors, perhaps precisely because it must be kept hidden or sublimated. Afro-Americans would be an outstanding example, from b..."

Brilliant way of putting it. I suppose because there is a greater necessity to retain it and the subversive aspect gives it a fresh life every time? And also so much of why literature exists and is important. I’ll think about that more on this flight now


message 11: by Julio (new)

Julio Pino Variations on this theme: You're more likely to get a picture of the American working class by reading PEOPLE or THE NATIONAL ENQUIRER than any leftist rag. Or, as the presidential historian Michael Beschloss once said, "The American proletariat is Jackie Robinson and Elvis, not Lenin and Trotsky".


switterbug (Betsey) Beautiful review, s. Heartbreaking, like the book, and also life-affirming.


s.penkevich Julio wrote: "Variations on this theme: You're more likely to get a picture of the American working class by reading PEOPLE or THE NATIONAL ENQUIRER than any leftist rag. Or, as the presidential historian Michae..."

Ah yes whenever I read something from journals like Jacobin I think of that line in Steinbeck’s In Dubious Battle that is something to the effect that theory is good and all but the moment you use a word that the laborers don’t know you’ve lost their trust forever


s.penkevich switterbug (Betsey) wrote: "Beautiful review, s. Heartbreaking, like the book, and also life-affirming."

Thank you so much! Ooo yes heartbreaking yet life affirming is the perfect description of Morrison. I think I need to just deep dive through all her books now


message 15: by Piuh (new) - added it

Piuh What a remarkable review, S! I words echo my sentiments too. 'Beloved' is one of those novels that live outside the text than within it. How wonderfully it celebrates life, even as it laments it. One of my favorite reads ever.


s.penkevich Piuh wrote: "What a remarkable review, S! I words echo my sentiments too. 'Beloved' is one of those novels that live outside the text than within it. How wonderfully it celebrates life, even as it laments it. O..."

Thank you so much! What a novel. Ooo that is a lovely way to put it, but yea capturing all the sorrow and beauty together. I enjoy that a Morrison can deal with really uncomfortable and distressing scenes without making it…a dark novel if that makes sense? Like It’s still dark but the overall effect is still really life affirming at the end? perhaps because she is memorializing more so than even moralizing? Either way, I love her writing. Glad you enjoyed this one as well!


message 17: by Ava (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ava Cairns Love this review, and love reading all these comments 💜


s.penkevich Ava wrote: "Love this review, and love reading all these comments 💜"

Thank you so much! Yea it’s really cool to see how many people were so strongly affected by this book. What a gem.


DivaDiane SM This book devastated me when I read it 30 years ago. I think it’s time to reread it.


message 20: by Julio (new)

Julio Pino s.penkevich wrote: "Julio wrote: "Variations on this theme: You're more likely to get a picture of the American working class by reading PEOPLE or THE NATIONAL ENQUIRER than any leftist rag. Or, as the presidential hi..."
Si, S. And Steinbeck was writing in the Thirties, when leftist vocabulary was much more common. Today's left press and pamphlets are literally unreadable and, worse still, no fun. RIP John Reed.


Summer Phenomenon review, S! I’m reading Beloved for the first time in the upcoming week and your review has me even more excited to start it


s.penkevich Julio wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Julio wrote: "Variations on this theme: You're more likely to get a picture of the American working class by reading PEOPLE or THE NATIONAL ENQUIRER than any leftist rag. Or, as..."

Oh the gap between theory and praxis. I feel today too we have a lot of (understandable) emphasis on looking at what is omitted in theory too which can make texts very bulky by attempting to hit every angle.


s.penkevich Summer wrote: "Phenomenon review, S! I’m reading Beloved for the first time in the upcoming week and your review has me even more excited to start it"

Thank you so much :) oh excellent I am excited for you! And eager to hear what you think. This one shattered me but in the best way


message 24: by dee (hiatus) (new) - added it

dee (hiatus) i need this in my hands right now!!


message 25: by Terrie (new) - added it

Terrie  Robinson Your review is both thoughtful and thought-provoking, Spenk! I’ve only read Morrison’s debut novel “The Bluest Eye� and it was an emotional experience. Taking this one on feels very daunting to me. Are my shoulders big enough to carry this with me afterwards? Who knows, I’m adding regardless, thanks to all your wonderful thoughts! Many thanks!


s.penkevich dee. wrote: "i need this in my hands right now!!"

Yesssssss It’s so good, like honestly one of the best books I’ve ever read. I hope you enjoy!


s.penkevich Terrie wrote: "Your review is both thoughtful and thought-provoking, Spenk! I’ve only read Morrison’s debut novel “The Bluest Eye� and it was an emotional experience. Taking this one on feels very daunting to me...."

Thank you so much. Oooo that is her big one that I’ve yet to read and have similar feelings, like whew am I prepared to get destroyed like this again. Perhaps we will have to swap haha. Well I hope you enjoy if you do get to this one! I’d recommend it!


message 28: by Suhailah (new) - added it

Suhailah Amazing review! I need to get around to the book sooner, sounds like the book is extremely powerful.


message 29: by Julio (last edited Aug 14, 2023 08:01AM) (new)

Julio Pino s.penkevich wrote: "Julio wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Julio wrote: "Variations on this theme: You're more likely to get a picture of the American working class by reading PEOPLE or THE NATIONAL ENQUIRER than any lefti..."
D'accord, S. Derrida is largely at fault. I once reviewed, for publication, an article on the aftermath of the Civil War in which the author had, a la' Derrida, crossed out sentences she herself had written. "It's there and not there at the same time" True and untrue. If there's anything worse than trying to defend and apply a religion it must be applying a pseudo-science.


s.penkevich Suhailah wrote: "Amazing review! I need to get around to the book sooner, sounds like the book is extremely powerful."

Thank you so much! Ooo yes would recommend, this blew me away honestly. Hope you enjoy if you get to it!


s.penkevich Julio wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Julio wrote: "s.penkevich wrote: "Julio wrote: "Variations on this theme: You're more likely to get a picture of the American working class by reading PEOPLE or THE NATIONAL ENQ..."

Ha Im glad you mentioned Derrida because his style was exactly what I was thinking of. I mean, it’s pretty necessary to the type of thought he’s doing to recheck premises and talk specifically but whew does that get dense.


Margaret M - (having a challenging time and on GR as much as I can) Such a wonderful review. I must try this one, how could I not now after reading your review


s.penkevich Margaret M - Back properly in Feb - wrote: "Such a wonderful review. I must try this one, how could I not now after reading your review"

I hope you enjoy! Its quite the incredible book. And thank you so much!


message 34: by Stacey B (new)

Stacey B Love this review.


message 35: by Wendy (new) - added it

Wendy Hart Your reviews has convinced me to read this.


message 36: by Annie (new) - added it

Annie Jeng i neeeed to read this. i've read jazz and bluest eye and morrison is the best! i also love her audible. her voice adds so much depth to the book


s.penkevich Stacey B wrote: "Love this review."

Thank you so much!


s.penkevich Wendy wrote: "Your reviews has convinced me to read this."

Oh excellent I hope you enjoy!


s.penkevich Annie wrote: "i neeeed to read this. i've read jazz and bluest eye and morrison is the best! i also love her audible. her voice adds so much depth to the book"

It’s so good I think you would really get a lot out of it! And oooo good to know, especially because I REALLY want to read Jazz. A few weeks ago I saw Hanif Abdurraqib give a talk and he read this passage that he said was inspired by his favorite part of Jazz but I cannot find a copy of the book anywhere haha so maybe I’ll just get the audio. Thank you!


message 40: by Sandy AE (new) - added it

Sandy AE I had this book sitting on my shelf for an entire year and I’m finally reading it now. I’ll come back to read your review after I’m done to avoid spoilers


message 41: by s.penkevich (last edited Dec 17, 2024 08:38AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

s.penkevich Sandy AE wrote: "I had this book sitting on my shelf for an entire year and I’m finally reading it now. I’ll come back to read your review after I’m done to avoid spoilers"

Oh excellent, I hope you enjoy! I'll look forward to discussing the book with you when you finish. Its so brutal but good.


back to top