ŷ

Lea's Reviews > Gulliverova putovanja

Gulliverova putovanja by Jonathan Swift
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
38055348
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: classic, fantasy, fiction, owned, book-club-d

“Undoubtedly, philosophers are in the right when they tell us that nothing is great or little otherwise than by comparison.�

Swift’s masterpiece, brilliant satire Gulliver's Travels was published in 1726. Swift lived in the 18th century, times of great societal changes when the legacy of Enlightenment culminated in French Revolution and caused a great political and cultural change. Also, European exploration of the world advanced, resulting in growing colonization of the Americas and other parts of the world. That intensified mass migrations as well as expanded the slave trade on a global scale.

The novel is dived into four parts, each describing one of Gulliver's adventures. It has an epistolary form as the narrator is Gulliver himself, Swift is laying out the events as they happened, striving to be emotionally detached and as objective as he can, without deeper reflections. Swift never breaks character, and we see the world exclusively through Gulliver’s eyes, making the narration unreliable to an extent. The language is quite similar to Robinson Crusoe's, in long, detailed descriptions, somewhat dry and preachy tone with racist and imperialist overtones, but Swift uses the form to ridicule the adventure genre of novels and break out some inappropriate jokes, with unexpected descriptions of excretory bodily functions or genitals. Swift also writes a fantastic story, that could be in parts even considered as speculative fiction. With imaginative events the narrator claims have happened, he precisely mocks those who include untrue events in their travelogues and claim them to be true. Through his satirical overtones, Swift gives a critique of colonialism and slavery, European governments, rulers and scientists, doctors and attorneys, the complete human nature.

The first Gulliver adventure is the most famous one, in the land of Lilliputians, people 15.24 centimeters tall. Here Swift highlights the human tendency to consider themselves the most important creatures despite their small size, being unaware of their insignificance in the universe. The government of Liliput is unable to make and adhere to important decisions and their ruler abuses power. Lilliputians have a heavily bureaucratic society, with absurd rules and social conventions and brutal punishments if one does not adhere to them. Their obsession with rules comes from an inflated ego, where they have to have a rigid system that will hide their insignificance. They also want to use Gulliver as a weapon in their petty wars, which shows that someone's grandiosity is a reason for calculation and exploitation by others, and Gulliver is endangered by their number and eventually accused of high treason. Their system of court and punishment is not a reflection of justice - the more innocent a man is, the heavier and more brutal is the punishment, and the absurdity of the legal system is highlighted. They have a conflict with other nation in regards to what is the best way to break an egg - on a smaller or larger end. Here Swift comments on the conflict between Catholics and Protestants - and Gulliver is not surprised by the absurdity of the conflict over breaking an egg, which shows how people are well adapted to insignificant differences causing large divisions and violence among menkind.

On the next adventure, Gulliver visits the land of Brobdingnag, a land of giants. The giants of Brobdingnag are in contrast to the Lilliputians, showing that the concept of a person's size, significance, and power differs as the world around him changes. Gulliver's dominance and grandiosity, but also vulnerability is a relative concept, dependant on the size of those around him. Gulliver here has constant anxiety and feeling of inferiority as he goes from being colossal to smallness and endangered insignificance in Brobdingnag. Residents of Brobdinagnag have a tendency towards extremes, they are prone to both greed and tenderness. Here Gulliver is being exploited again by a farmer, which shows that exploitation is a matter of opportunity, not size, social status, or wealth. The king and queen of Brobdingnag are not malevolent, and they care for Gulliver, but at the same time regard him as a funny puppet. For them, it is unimaginable that Gulliver is a complete person, a man with a homeland with history, laws, philosophy. The king is interested in Gulliver's stories but only as entertainment, mirroring the European sentiment of the time, towards foreigners and other cultures, considering them fun and interesting, but not to be taken seriously. The king also has a very narrow, limited perspective of the world - he has absolute authoritarian power, the country is isolated, they do not travel, they learn only a few subjects in education, only ones with practical significance and they are not interested in philosophy and abstract ideas. They are very bodily, sensual and sexual, prone to pleasures and celebrations, with no interest in the progress of mind or culture. Their king does not understand war or democracy, representing the peaceful but limited and isolated monarchy. After the rescue from the land of giants, Gulliver can't get used to the size of normal people and he consideres himself bigger than them.

Gulliver’s third adventure is in the land of Laputa, floating island Swifts uses for satire of scholars and scientists, philosophers, Pythagoreans, and Enlightenment. In the contrast to Brobdinagnag, in the land of Laputa mathematics and music are of the highest importance, and the importance of theory and science is taken to an extreme. Lauptans know complex geometry but are at the same unable to build proportionate houses or make a decent suit. Their theoretical knowledge is deeply impractical, they do absurd experiments that are useless or even destructive, they complicate to an obscure level that becomes counterproductive. The wise man of Laputa embodies the futility of the search for knowledge as a means to an end, without taking into account the practical and concrete world. This is a reflection of Swift’s thought that the philosophers of the Enlightenment were theoretical in their thinking to the point of obscurity. It is a critique of schools and educational institutions, societies of top intellectuals. Gulliver also goes to the land of sorcerers where he encounters the spirits of the past - Alexander the Great, Caesar, Homer, Aristotle, Descartes. Gulliver here realizes how knowledge of history is used manipulatively for someone's interest as the history he knew was full of misinterpretation and learns that all knowledge of history is subjective.

The last adventure takes Gulliver in the land of noble talking horses, Houyhnhnms. Houyhnhnms use the benefits of a rational mind combined with moral virtues, creating a country where the common good is of the greatest value. Houyhnhnms tell only truth and live without lies, injustice, corruption, class, diseases, in an atmosphere of seemingly minimal suffering and inequality. They maintain domination with physical strength and reason. Here, friendship and goodwill replace romantic love and family. The marriages are arranged for the production of specifically two children of different sexes and they exchange of children if they are of the same sex, granting absolute gender equality, but with loss of emotional connections. Houyhnhnms have no emotional experiences of love (the death of a member of society is insignificant) which gives meaning to life, they do not celebrate and do not rejoice, creating a peaceful, but somewhat cold utopia with loss of individual identity and diversity.
In this utopian society, the ideal of Enlightenment, where reason rules everything, horses rule over the Yahoos- the savage, hairy, primitive, animal-like men. Houyhnhnms reject the primal human nature reflected in Yahoos, exposing their tendency toward superiority if one looks and behaves differently, rejecting everything that is not in line with their ideal of culture and reason. Benevolence and friendship are reserved only for their kind, embodying the basic idea of colonialism. Gulliver idealizes Houyhnhnmas, and being blind to their hypocrisy and narcissism, he wants to integrate into their society. In a quest in merging with the collective, he tries to give up the human identity that makes him different, being ashamed of his similarity to Yahoos.
But Gulliver is deceived because he identifies with the horses. Houyhnhnms are a reflection of himself � his superiority he felt towards every culture he came to, but also his superiority he feels towards the European society.

Gulliver is ultimely the antihero that used the exploration of the world and different societies for making the faults of human nature visible to him, but not being aware he himself is also part of society, akin to human nature he keeps critiquing, full of flaws. Gulliver is both “gullible� and full of prejudges and false concepts. He is grandiose, egocentric, pliable, without a firm attitude, restless, adventurous, insensitive, unsympathetic, always running from everything less than ideal, even if that means running away from his pregnant wife and children. Gulliver seeks the fantom of a perfect society and rejects the dark and primal side of human nature as unworthy of love. He criticizes and mocks others but never ridicules himself and his shortcomings. It is not a great wonder that Gulliver becomes the figure of repulsion and rejection in any society - he ultimately cannot integrate even in the society of narcissistic horses he regards as ideal. Unlike Don Quixote, his illusions and prejudices remain to the end, as well as disgust of others.

Through the novel in each adventure and the culture Gulliver encounters, we see a progression of the political systems from the unjust, brutal authoritarian bureaucracy of Liliput, to benevolent but ignorant monarchy of Brobdinagnag, to leaders that value science and philosophy of Laputa, and, in the end, to land of Houyhnhnms, the society that values reason, morality and equality - the utopian society that revolutions promised in the 18th century. But even the ideal society enlightened by reason and morality dominates tribes and races that are different, the ones they decide are not decent, or cultural enough to be equal. The morally superior horses push violently against the primal part of human nature symbolically represented by Yahoos, revealing the criticism of enlighted, morally superior European societies that continue to flourish in colonialism and the exponentially growing slave trade, brutal oppression of different cultures they call “savages� in the period that is known as "century of lights" or the "century of reason". Colonization is the ultimate expression of pride and narcissism. Even worse than open tyranny, is the oppression that comes from moral superiority.

Recommended for the readers going through the literary canon, lovers of satire, misanthropes and social critics but also for narcissists who think all humans are corrupt, except themselves.
193 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Gulliverova putovanja.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

October 16, 2017 – Shelved as: must-read
October 16, 2017 – Shelved
January 10, 2022 – Started Reading
January 22, 2022 – Finished Reading
January 23, 2022 – Shelved as: classic
January 23, 2022 – Shelved as: fantasy
January 23, 2022 – Shelved as: fiction
January 23, 2022 – Shelved as: owned
January 23, 2022 – Shelved as: book-club-d

Comments Showing 1-37 of 37 (37 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Petergiaquinta Great review! I need to go back and reread this, now thirty-some years later. I am afraid my views on humanity have become more closely aligned with Swift’s over the years…as a younger person, I held some hope for the human race and my countrymen. I know Swift would argue that we’ve always been that way, but the rise of QAnon, the widespread embrace of Trumpian neofascism, and the denial of science have all led me to sadly admit the US is little more than a nation of poop-flinging filthy Yahoos.


message 2: by Sebastian (new)

Sebastian TDS is real LOL. Keep getting triggered by good values. Get the fuck out of the country if you dont like it


Petergiaquinta Someone taught a Yahoo to type?


Kalliope A review to keep.


message 5: by Jonathan (new)

Jonathan O'Neill I didn't know this was quite so old!
Excellent analysis, Lea!


Persephone's Pomegranate Awesome review Lea.


message 7: by Violeta (new)

Violeta Lea, thank you for this erudite, masterful analysis of a book read in childhood! Its multiple layers were vaguely grasped then but I do remember an uneasy sense while getting through it.
And your closing paragraph is to die for!!😊


message 8: by Lea (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lea Petergiaquinta wrote: "Great review! I need to go back and reread this, now thirty-some years later. I am afraid my views on humanity have become more closely aligned with Swift’s over the years…as a younger person, I he..."

Thank you, P. I think you would enjoy the re-read immensely. Swift brilliantly mocks concepts that are very much present in today's society. A lot of satire could be applied to nationalism, racism, scientism, absurd bureaucracy, tyranny in general but also the moral superiority present in many groups on both left and right sides of the political spectrum. Not to mention Swift foresaw communism with the land of Houyhnhnms. Also, he succeeds to be incredibly funny even to readers of the 21st century. And I still have hope for humanity. Currently, I'm reading Hegel's Philosophy of history and it gives me hope that there is a greater plan at work even in the dark times :)


message 9: by Lea (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lea Kalliope wrote: "A review to keep."

Thank you so much, Kalliope, these words mean a lot coming from you!


Petergiaquinta I like your optimism, Lea!


message 11: by Lea (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lea Jonathan wrote: "I didn't know this was quite so old!
Excellent analysis, Lea!"


The novel is quite old, but gems of literary canon always stand the test of time. There is a legit reason why this book is still well-known. Swift lays out the essential truth about human nature that transcends time. Thank you so much, Jonathan! :)


message 12: by Baba (new)

Baba Such an enlightening review, thank you :)


message 13: by Antigone (new)

Antigone This certainly seems like a timely read! A terrific review, Lea, and one that informs me of a classic I thought more a fable than a societal examination. I've learned quite a bit here. Thanks. ;-)


message 14: by Lea (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lea Persephone's Pomegranate wrote: "Awesome review Lea."

Thank you, I'm glad you liked it :)


message 15: by Lea (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lea Violeta wrote: "Lea, thank you for this erudite, masterful analysis of a book read in childhood! Its multiple layers were vaguely grasped then but I do remember an uneasy sense while getting through it.
And your ..."


I've also read Gulliver's Travels as a child, Violeta! And I have watched animated movie, the images from the cartoon are still very vivid in my mind. Thank you for the kind words, the essence has been said in the last paragraph ;D


message 16: by Lea (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lea Petergiaquinta wrote: "I like your optimism, Lea!"

I have to hold on to the last glimmer of hope :D


C.  (Comment, never msg). Okay, I am pretty sure this title means "Gulliver's Travels". I do'nt want what else Jonathan Swift wrote and the first name is clear enough to a fellow linguist. :)


message 18: by Lea (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lea Baba wrote: "Such an enlightening review, thank you :)"

Thank you, Baba! Swift had a lot of messages he subtly tried to convey through the story, and I wrote down ones that struck me as most important. As with all great works, one could go into even more detail.


Leonard Gaya Excellent and very thorough review there, Lea! You point out incredibly well how Swift was responding to the philosophical and socio-political issues of his time (some of them still topical today). In that way, this book could also be compared to Voltaire’s Candide, I think. And btw, Swift’s A Modest Proposal is another piece of appalling yet hilarious irony, too, just in case!


message 20: by Homo (new)

Homo Sentimentalis Ovo sam čitao još u osnovnoj, definitivno bi valjalo obnoviti. Pronašao sam se u bar tri kategorije ljudi kojima preporučuješ knjigu. :D


message 21: by Lea (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lea Antigone wrote: "This certainly seems like a timely read! A terrific review, Lea, and one that informs me of a classic I thought more a fable than a societal examination. I've learned quite a bit here. Thanks. ;-)"

When I first learned about this story, in childhood, I also had an impression of fable! So I got into this book with the same feeling, not expecting much more than to be reminded of a story I liked as a child. But it takes an adult mind and knowledge of politics and history to fully appreciate the numerous layers Swift added to a compelling tale. And thank you, dear Antigone, you are most generous with compliments ;D


message 22: by Lea (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lea C. (friends, please call me by name) wrote: "Okay, I am pretty sure this title means "Gulliver's Travels". I do'nt want what else Jonathan Swift wrote and the first name is clear enough to a fellow linguist. :)"

You are right, Carolyn! This is the Croatian edition from my personal physical library, I always add the exact edition I own even though I know the title can be confusing to my English-speaking friends here on GR. But I want to have some orientation and keep a record of numerous books I own. Because not one time it happened to me I bought a book I already own :D


message 23: by C. (Comment, never msg). (last edited Jan 27, 2022 10:29AM) (new)

C.  (Comment, never msg). Yes, I always choose my edition with the right cover. The rare time I read something in French, Spanish or hardest of all, German (a baby book); I only see the English one. If you find books in Croatian, use them!

I have had this book since I was a child and will read it soon.


message 24: by Lea (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lea Leonard wrote: "Excellent and very thorough review there, Lea! You point out incredibly well how Swift was responding to the philosophical and socio-political issues of his time (some of them still topical today)...."

Gulliver's Travels could be compared to Candide, Voltaire crafted a satire of philosophical views, and Swift of societies. They have somewhat the same tone. And feel they were both influenced by ѴDZè, the master of satire and irony. But I think Swift's novel is more memorable and complex, at least I liked it better. I have to check out if you've written a review about Candide. I read the book last year and postponed writing a review for the future, but I would love to analyze more profoundly someday. I'm keeping A Modest Proposal in mind. And I'm most thankful for your comment, Leonard, it means a lot to hear such nice words from you!


Leonard Gaya Ah yes, I wrote a review of Candide some time ago, for what it’s worth. I believe it’s in French, sorry! And, you’re right about ѴDZè. I never thought of it that way. La Fontaine comes to mind as well�


message 26: by Lea (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lea Homo wrote: "Ovo sam čitao još u osnovnoj, definitivno bi valjalo obnoviti. Pronašao sam se u bar tri kategorije ljudi kojima preporučuješ knjigu. :D"

I ja sam čitala u osnovnoj i sjećala sam se radnje ali zapravo nisam uhvatila ni djelić toga što prepoznajem danas. Arhaičnog je stila ali vrlo slojevita pustolovina, mislim da bi ti se svidjela puno više sad kad imaš više uvida i čitateljske mudrosti. Iskustvo čini svoje, a isto tako da sve više tonemo u spomenute kategorije s godinama, tako da suosjećam :D


message 27: by Lea (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lea C. (friends, please call me by name) wrote: "Yes, I always choose my edition with the right cover. The rare time I read something in French, Spanish or hardest of all, German (a baby book); I only see the English one. If you find books in Cro..."

Yes, when I first started GR I was editing the first edition that came up, what a beginners mistake :D I did not know you read in so many languages, Carolyn! And I'm very intrigued what will you think of this book.


message 28: by Jola (new)

Jola Dear Lea, your excellent review made me ponder on how universal this book is: some readers will enjoy just an adventure novel, some will find much food for thought as you did.


message 29: by Lea (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lea Leonard wrote: "Ah yes, I wrote a review of Candide some time ago, for what it’s worth. I believe it’s in French, sorry! And, you’re right about ѴDZè. I never thought of it that way. La Fontaine comes to mind a..."

Never mind, I checked the review for A Modest Proposal! And La Fontaine is also a brilliant comparison! I guess Frenchmen just have it in themselves, and could be crowned as the role models of the genre :D


Leonard Gaya Nah! :D


message 31: by Serge (new)

Serge Love this review Lea! This made me extremely curious to read the book, and I love how the author uses fantastical elements to highlight the flaws of human nature, while also showing that the main character is part of that schema as well. Excellent review! :)


message 32: by Cheri (new)

Cheri Excellent review, Lea! I read this long ago, I think around the time I was maybe 7 years old, maybe 6. One day I might re-read it, but I still remember being fascinated by the story, and talking with my older brother about it since he read it before I did - he taught me how to read when he learned to read, and also with my grandfather, whose love of reading was largely classics and poetry, and he was a big influence on my reading.


message 33: by Lea (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lea Jola wrote: "Dear Lea, your excellent review made me ponder on how universal this book is: some readers will enjoy just an adventure novel, some will find much food for thought as you did."

Dear Jola, it is a professional deformation for me to (over)analyze everything :D But I loved Gulliver's Travels even as a child when I only read it as an adventure!


message 34: by Lea (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lea Serge (on a semi-hiatus) wrote: "Love this review Lea! This made me extremely curious to read the book, and I love how the author uses fantastical elements to highlight the flaws of human nature, while also showing that the main c..."


Great observervation, Serge. Swift did use the fantastical elements very carefully, dissecting the societal flaws with surgical precision. Truly noteworthy achievement that stands the test of time. And thank you!


message 35: by Lea (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lea Cheri wrote: "Excellent review, Lea! I read this long ago, I think around the time I was maybe 7 years old, maybe 6. One day I might re-read it, but I still remember being fascinated by the story, and talking wi..."

Dear Cheri, thank you for sharing your personal story about reading and childhood memories. My family, mostly my brother and parents had an immense influence on my reading, and my brother adored this story. It is so nice to come across stories we first heard in childhood as adults, there is always something special, nostalgic, and emotional about that.


message 36: by Drew (new) - rated it 4 stars

Drew Israel Amazing review! It really offered me a new perspective on the novel. Do you think Swift could have accomplished the same theme and message without the fantastical elements?


message 37: by Anh (new) - rated it 4 stars

Anh Gordon What a fantastic review. Thank you so much. Made me rethink some of my thoughts about this book.


back to top