Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Dolors's Reviews > Gilead

Gilead by Marilynne Robinson
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
18383778
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: read-in-2017, dost

Old reverend John Ames writes a long farewell letter to his seven-year old son after he is informed of a cardiovascular problem that will eventually take his life.
What starts as a chronicle of his childhood memories and the life stories of his father and grandfather, also pastors, and the ongoing tensions between them about the use of religion to serve their ideals, progressively becomes an introspective, fragmented confession where the old man reveals his soul to the reader, but mostly, to himself.
A person from his past, his namesake, and somehow alter-ego, reappears in this transcendental moment of the minister’s life; right when he is about to lose what he loves most: his much younger wife Lila and his son. The miracles that were sent to him in his golden years are now threatened by a man who seems evil by nature. Ames will have to pass the final test he has preached about in his countless sermons and assimilate the real meaning of love, grace and forgiveness.

With luminous, patient voice, John Ames reveals the nooks and crannies of past griefs, fears and weaknesses, exposed through the filter of his unfaltering faith. Prolonged loneliness, jealousy, covetousness, envy and other corroding emotions nag at the essential goodness of a man confronted with his last days in this world. As his nemesis approaches, Ames will gradually rise up to the son he aspired to be and the father he could have been.

This slowly paced novel, almost philosophical in nature and devoid of plot, told in the first person narrator using the stream of consciousness technique, might be the ultimate parable of the Prodigal Son, revisited by a humble but highly literate reverend in a forsaken village in the bare plains of Iowa, the town of Gilead. Places that cast no allure are likely to be the scenarios for miracles, if the observer notices a certain slant of light, or the moonbeams washing clean the dusty paths in silver streams, or the soft, velvety caress of a voice speaking kindly to us.
Ames� unremarkable life story is also the testimony of the history of a country that witnessed three wars in three generations and the violent genesis between them, between families, between fathers and sons, and the wounds that never healed properly because permanent estrangement settled in for good. At the end, Ames is faced with a very simple question, which, according to the reader’s understanding of a blessing, he might answer fully, or he might elude.

Marilynne Robinson’s prose reads like a prayer. It exudes profound religiosity, but it’s not necessary to be a participant in the Christian doctrines to feel comfortable in its magnanimous embrace. She includes the reader, appeals to every cell of his humanity and leaves several doors open for him to walk out, un-judged and free, but above all, totally and wholly recognized, and therefore, always forgiven.
103 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Gilead.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

October 22, 2017 – Started Reading
October 22, 2017 – Shelved
October 23, 2017 –
page 44
17.81% ""When people come to speak to me, whatever they say, I am struck by a kind of incandescence in them, the "I" whose predicate can be "love" or "fear" or "want", and whose object can be "someone" or "nothing" and it won't really matter, because the loveliness is just in that presence, shaped around "I" like a flame on a wick, emanating itself in grief and guilt and joy and whatever else.""
October 25, 2017 –
page 98
39.68% ""These people who can see right through you never quite do you justice, because they never give you credit for the effort you're making to be better than you actually are, which is difficult and well meant and deserving of some little notice.""
October 27, 2017 –
page 191
77.33% ""Ashy biscuit, summer rain, her hair falling wet around her face. If I were to multiply the splendors of the world by two - the splendors as I felt them- I would arrive at an idea of heaven very unlike anything you see in the old paintings.""
October 27, 2017 – Finished Reading
October 28, 2017 –
page 247
100.0% ""I don't know exactly what covetise is, but in my experience it is not so much desiring someone else's virtue or happiness as rejecting it, taking offense at the beauty of it.""

Comments Showing 1-50 of 50 (50 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Lisa Great and kind review, Dolors! I am happy to hear you liked it. For me, it was one of the most frustrating reading experiences I ever had. Ames reminded me too much of the self-indulgent, arrogant, ignorant and intolerant religious unholy men of my childhood, and his whiny voice keeps creeping back into my mind after years. Boy, did I hate him.


Violet wells Lovely review, Dolors.


message 3: by Ilse (new)

Ilse Wow, I am impressed by another great start of a trilogy, Dolors! Since having read Helle's review on Gilead, I have been on the fence on reading this or not, Dolors - finding both elements which appeal to me (the father's legacy to the son) as making me wary (the religious component). Your velvety review, beautifully alluding to the philosophical nature of this novel, together with high opinions of other friends who's taste I trust, tells me I have at least to make an attempt...


message 4: by Samra (new)

Samra Yusuf I am never been comfortable with religious personas as narrator,to be truthful,I avoid getting into these kinda concoctions of a book,where war is overpowering factor in shaping the lives of characters who populate the novel,but the fact is,youve a gift for enchanting phrases,a flow so gentle and yet caressing every pour of one's being,I am truly tempted,Dolors!


message 5: by Jo (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jo Dolors, although I read this many years ago, I remember loving it and your review reminded me why. I have the second in the series, Home, on my list to read for next year and can’t wait!


°­²¹°ù±ð²Ô· A quite enchanting review, Dolors, beautifully structured, perfectly executed. Some time, maybe, I will move towards this book. It's fixed in my mind as being a bit like Stoner, another one I haven't read. I don't know, at the moment I tend towards the exuberantly playful, which is obviously neither Gilead nor Stoner.


message 7: by flo (new)

flo Philosophical novels devoid of plot are the real gems of this planet. Along with your reviews, whose delicate and contemplative prose makes any piece of writing sound like an engaging masterpiece. This powerful story told with such lyrical words sounds rather tempting.
Looking forward to reading more of your exquisite reviews in 2018. :) Thanks so much for your GR friendship; your kind comments always put a smile on my face. I wish you all the best!


Markus What a deep sighted review Dolors. I read this book some time ago and you have just brought it back into my mind in a beautiful condensed version.

Thank you again for all your encouragements throughout 2017
and as we are in for a running start int 2018, I look forward to it!
Happy New Year


message 9: by Cecily (new) - added it

Cecily Beautiful, slightly cryptic review. Robinson's been on my radar for a while, and you make this one sound very enticing.


message 10: by Seemita (new)

Seemita I get to have the taste of a Dolors' review after a hiatus and the texture on my soul is nothing different - her words come deep and close, and leave a lasting, optimistic impression behind. Some deliberate and some implied meanings of life are peppered throughout your review and give me an idea of a torn man at their centre. That every time, you can see through the terrains and cultures, rituals and dichotomies ingrained therein, gives me a sense of awe. I saw the 'recommended for' and understood why it struck a chord with you, dearest. Thank you for this gem.


message 11: by Ed (new) - added it

Ed Beautiful review Dolors. This one has been on my radar for some time, but I've not committed to it due to mixed reviews.


Dolors Lisa wrote: "Great and kind review, Dolors! I am happy to hear you liked it. For me, it was one of the most frustrating reading experiences I ever had. Ames reminded me too much of the self-indulgent, arrogant,..."

Well Lisa, I was much more frustrated by the "sequel" to this one, the less famous Home.
(view spoiler) But I thought Robinson's writing was flawless, and style and deliverance got my rating here more than character portrayal and non-plot.


Dolors Violet wrote: "Lovely review, Dolors."

Thanks a lot, Violet. And Happy New Year!


Dolors Ilse wrote: "Wow, I am impressed by another great start of a trilogy, Dolors! Since having read Helle's review on Gilead, I have been on the fence on reading this or not, Dolors - finding both elements which ap..."

I felt exactly the same way, Ilse. Undecided. I will summarise my reading experience in two sentences: elegant writing style, intellectual layout of religious doctrine and some lyrical wisdom that truly got to me. And yet, and yet. A character difficult to relate to because his frame of mind -always from within the religious paradigm- is vastly different from mine. But still, a book worth reading. I don't think it would leave you indifferent...


Dolors Samra wrote: "I am never been comfortable with religious personas as narrator,to be truthful,I avoid getting into these kinda concoctions of a book,where war is overpowering factor in shaping the lives of charac..."

Same here, Samra!!! I felt curious about Robinson's trilogy, as she is considered one of the best contemporary American writers, but you shouldn't force yourself to get into her philosophical treatise on faith, death and guilt. It's not a light book to read, and therefore, one should be on the right frame of mind to tackle it.
There are too many other books out there waiting for you...so don't force it! ;P
Thanks for your kindness, as always, my friend! :))


Dolors Jo wrote: "Dolors, although I read this many years ago, I remember loving it and your review reminded me why. I have the second in the series, Home, on my list to read for next year and can’t wait!"

I read "Home" a couple of weeks ago and even though I liked the characters much better, I felt somewhat disappointed by the end. It seems I respond to Robinson's masterful prose but I can't quite connect fully to it... Still, she is worth reading!
Glad you enjoyed revisiting her most famous book through my meandering thoughts, Jo. Thanks for taking the time to read and for your kindness.


Dolors ·°­²¹°ù±ð²Ô· wrote: "A quite enchanting review, Dolors, beautifully structured, perfectly executed. Some time, maybe, I will move towards this book. It's fixed in my mind as being a bit like Stoner, another one I haven..."

Right on, Karen. Stay clear of Robinson or Williams if you are in a playful, creative frame of mind...
This book is reflective, definitely character-driven and it will probably challenge the patience of the non-religious reader, but I found Robinson's prose was a delight to read. You will know when the time is right to pick this up, Karen. Meanwhile, enjoy the more humorous reads!


Dolors Florencia wrote: "Philosophical novels devoid of plot are the real gems of this planet. Along with your reviews, whose delicate and contemplative prose makes any piece of writing sound like an engaging masterpiece. ..."

Oh Flo...you'd find much philosophical unrest in this book, although drenched in theological doctrine, which might not make the book so appealing. Needless to say, a toast to you and to the next year, which I hope will bring you much more free time to devote to reading and writing for pleasure so you can delight all your ravenous admirers here! ;P
It's a pleasure to count you among my friends, Flo... May this friendship defy time and years! :)


Dolors Markus wrote: "What a deep sighted review Dolors. I read this book some time ago and you have just brought it back into my mind in a beautiful condensed version.

Thank you again for all your encouragements throu..."


Thanks so much, Markus. Your pithy comment on this book summarised my own thoughts rather well! :)
I wish the same to you, a happy New Year and many more literary trips to come. Thanks for your friendship and kindness.


Dolors Cecily wrote: "Beautiful, slightly cryptic review. Robinson's been on my radar for a while, and you make this one sound very enticing."

Thanks, Cecily. I have the feeling you would find much to ponder about in this book. When the time is right.


Dolors Seemita wrote: "I get to have the taste of a Dolors' review after a hiatus and the texture on my soul is nothing different - her words come deep and close, and leave a lasting, optimistic impression behind. Some d..."

You are the real gem around here, dear Simi!
Every time I read a comment of yours or a review of yours I get anxious to read more by you... so a toast to next year, new projects and many more shared literary journeys. It's always a real delight to bask in your words, Simi. No matter the time or the place, they always sit well with me.
Happy New Year, my dearest friend, be well and make your dreams come true.


message 22: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Wonderful review, Dolors!!


Dolors Thanks so much for taking the time to visit me on the last day of the year, dear Deanna! May 2018 bring you joy and fulfilment.


message 24: by Lynne (last edited Jan 01, 2018 05:17AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Lynne King A beautiful review Dolors as only you can do.

I made a mistake here, but perhaps it was just as well with this author as I read Lila first and I just loved it! If I had read "Gilead" first which I must confess I was not too impressed with, well "Lila" would never have seen the light of day.

And Dolors I wish you all happiness, good health, prosperity, fulfillment of one's expectations and all that good stuff for 2018!


Laysee Dolors, such a treat to read an exquisitely beautiful review of my all time beloved Robinson book. Love especially your tribute to Robinson’s writing in the last paragraph.


message 26: by Carol (new)

Carol Another beautifully written and flawless overview, Dolors. I look forward to following your reviews in 2018!


Lynne King I agree one hundred percent Carol!


message 28: by Seemita (new)

Seemita Lynne wrote: "I agree one hundred percent Carol!"

Taking the liberty, D, and wishing Lynne a happy 2018 since she is here, on your page :) Have a great year, Lynne!


Lynne King Oh Seemita, I need to contact you also! I wish you and Dolors all the best for 2018 - a time of love and forgiving!


message 30: by Seemita (new)

Seemita Lynne wrote: "Oh Seemita, I need to contact you also! I wish you and Dolors all the best for 2018 - a time of love and forgiving!"

Thank you so much :)


Lynne King Th


Lynne King Thank you as ever Seemita. You're a good friend.


message 33: by Deea (new) - rated it 4 stars

Deea As beautiful as ever :). This review evokes the power of memory and your ability to describe this in eloquent terms is very impressive. This seems slow-paced, without much of a plot, but who needs a plot when introspection and wise conclusions of a lifetime are present in the lines of a book?


message 34: by Agnieszka (new) - added it

Agnieszka Beautiful as always, Dolors. I loved reading your thoughts emanating wisdom and understanding. I was curious of your response to the novel for I know that if Lila is widely praised and loved here then Gilead aroused rather mixed opinions. Have a copy and hopefully will make own opinion on that one too.


Dolors Lynne wrote: "A beautiful review Dolors as only you can do.

I made a mistake here, but perhaps it was just as well with this author as I read Lila first and I just loved it! If I had read "Gilea..."


What a treat to "see" you after such a long hiatus, Lynne!
I will read "Lila" soon, hoping I will finally be able to connect with a character in Robinson's universe.
I wish you a fantastic 2018 and many thrilling reads to come, thanks for your lovely words.


Dolors Laysee wrote: "Dolors, such a treat to read an exquisitely beautiful review of my all time beloved Robinson book. Love especially your tribute to Robinson’s writing in the last paragraph."

So glad you liked it, Laysee. This wasn't a light novel, but I greatly basked in Robinson's smooth prose. She is a great writer and worth reading. I wish you a 2018 full of joy and great reads!:)


Dolors Carol wrote: "Another beautifully written and flawless overview, Dolors. I look forward to following your reviews in 2018!"

Oh, same here Carol! Thanks a bunch for your steadfast kindness and lovely words here and everywhere else. May 2018 bring you joy and many more exciting reads, and may you keep on sharing them with us here!:)


Dolors Deea wrote: "As beautiful as ever :). This review evokes the power of memory and your ability to describe this in eloquent terms is very impressive. This seems slow-paced, without much of a plot, but who needs ..."

You are totally spot-on, Deea. This is a contemplative, slow-paced novel about life, guilt and grace, seen through the eyes of an old minister, which might prove unattractive to some readers, but Robinson's flawless prose makes up for the religious perspective of the main character.
What a treat it always is to count on you among my GR friends, Deea. May 2018 continue to bring us together in this world of books and friendship! :))


message 39: by Dolors (last edited Jan 02, 2018 03:52AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dolors Agnieszka wrote: "Beautiful as always, Dolors. I loved reading your thoughts emanating wisdom and understanding. I was curious of your response to the novel for I know that if Lila is widely praised and loved here t..."

I totally understand your angle, Agna. My reaction to this book was also mixed somewhat. I had trouble identifying with Rev Ames, the main character, but then, I couldn't deny Robinson's mastery with words. There are incredibly beautiful passages in this novel, full of wisdom and grace, even though I found myself disagreeing with Ames' thoughts and reasons to act the way he did.
But then, this is a great novel, in my opinion, and I tend to rate a book on the writing rather than the plot.
I will be looking forward to your thoughts on this one as I enter the third novel in the trilogy... Thanks for your comment, Agna!


message 40: by Cheryl (new) - added it

Cheryl So I have this lined up on audio and I was scared to read your review in depth, but I'm really glad you enjoyed this pensive and philosophical read, Dolors. Lovely thoughts, as usual.


message 41: by Dolors (last edited Jan 08, 2018 06:16AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Dolors Cheryl wrote: "So I have this lined up on audio and I was scared to read your review in depth, but I'm really glad you enjoyed this pensive and philosophical read, Dolors. Lovely thoughts, as usual."

I will look forward to your opinion, Cheryl. This is quite a controversial read and I will be interested to read your intake on it. Thanks for stopping by to see mine!


message 42: by Anu (new) - added it

Anu Your reviews are music to my ears, Dolors! They urge me to not read any mediocre books, and move on to books like these, that you so beautifully praise. It always feels great when one of the first things I see after I come back, is a gorgeous review by you!


Dolors Anuradha wrote: "Your reviews are music to my ears, Dolors! They urge me to not read any mediocre books, and move on to books like these, that you so beautifully praise. It always feels great when one of the first ..."

Thanks so so much Anu! I say that whatever you read, read it with gusto, no matter what! This book was not easy to get through, I found the overall experience satisfying, but it left me wary and melancholic. But then, these are the kind of novels that stick with us, right? Those that hurt and puts us on edge, testing our limits. May you find your reading balance this year, and pay us visits more often, because you are greatly missed around here! :)


message 44: by Caterina (new) - added it

Caterina Exquisite, enchanting review Dolors -- this book truly sounds luminous, as you have described it. I think I must read it. Thank you.


Dolors Caterina wrote: "Exquisite, enchanting review Dolors -- this book truly sounds luminous, as you have described it. I think I must read it. Thank you."

I hope you like it if you do, Caterina. This is the first installment in the Gilead Trilogy and I am about to start the last one. I will be interested in your thoughts if you finally decide to take the plunge. Thanks for your kind words.


Linda I really liked your review, Dolors


Dolors Thanks for reading and for your kind comment Linda!


Elena Sala Lovely review, Dolors. It is absolutely true that it is a profoundly religious novel which embraces everyone, no matter what you believe in.


Dolors Thanks a lot Elena! Glad you liked the book and that you agree with my general opinion of this novel. Curiously enough, this might be the title I like least in the trilogy.


Elena Sala Dolors wrote: "Thanks a lot Elena! Glad you liked the book and that you agree with my general opinion of this novel. Curiously enough, this might be the title I like least in the trilogy."

Really??? Then, I am still missing the best part? Did you know that a fourth part was published this year? The title of the book is Jack.


back to top