ŷ

Miranda Reads's Reviews > Scarlet

Scarlet by Marissa Meyer
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
71848701
's review

really liked it

There should be more to this book.

I'm a sucker for a good fairytale rewrite - so I (mostly) enjoyed this retelling of Red Riding Hood.

BUT, the couple in this one (Scarlet and Wolf) and the book in general seemed to be missing something.
“What’s your name, anyway?�

That awkward shrug again. “They call me Wolf at the fights.�

� Wolf? How � predatory."
It's like they are on the cusp of being truly great but fell a smidge short. Their rapport just seemed...off... Forced might be a better word.
“Wolf, are you asking me to be ... your alpha female?"
Perhaps it was Scarlet's complete lack of common sense. (oh, the Wolf has something to do with my grandmother? Suspicious background? Unparalleled fighting skills? Great, I'll follow him into the wilderness.)

Or maybe it was the frustrating subplot. (CINDER - why won't you just send Kai an email or something? You're half robot, I'm sure you can figure out how to send a digital message.)

Or it could have been the even more frustrating subplot. (KAI - You have LITERALLY trained for this your entire life. How are you so consistently bad at being Emperor?)

Or maybe it was Wolf's - nah, he was just too great. He was the shining beacon of light in this one.

Overall, this was an entertaining, light read. I liked most of it - especially the subtle hints of the characters yet to come and I really look forward to the next one!

Edit: As pointed out by Angela's Booked, I completely neglected to mention the absolute best part of the book: Thorne.

I mean, how could you not love him?

There's this:
A relieved grin filled up Thorne’s face. “We’re having another moment, aren’t we?�

“If by a moment, you mean me not wanting to strangle you for the first time since we met, then I guess we are.�
And this:
"But I'm a wanted fugitive, like Cinder." Thorne continued. "They do realise I'm missing, don't they?"

"Maybe they're grateful," Cinder muttered.
AND THIS:
"I don't like to think of it as 'stolen.' They have no proof that I didn't plan on giving it back"
I am eternally sorry for neglecting the banter in my original review.

Audiobook Comments
Exceptionally well-read by Rebecca Soler. Loved the voices!

If you are curious about Rebecca Soler, check Tucker the Reader's !

| | | | | Snapchat @miranda_reads
384 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Scarlet.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Started Reading
October 29, 2017 – Finished Reading
November 7, 2017 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-35 of 35 (35 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Angela's Booked All these points are valid but you forgot to talk about how fun Thorne is! He’s my favorite and totally made this book with his relentless banter and personality lol


message 2: by Miranda (last edited Apr 24, 2018 11:31AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Miranda Reads Angela's Booked wrote: "All these points are valid but you forgot to talk about how fun Thorne is! He’s my favorite and totally made this book with his relentless banter and personality lol"

LOL - yes. Thorn is such a peach!! I can't believe I didn't mention him. I've updated the review in response.


Angela's Booked Yessss! I love the new addition and his quotes; I would read this book again just for him 😜


Audrey I must be the only person who found Thorn immature and annoying!


Miranda Reads Angela's Booked wrote: "Yessss! I love the new addition and his quotes; I would read this book again just for him 😜"

Just wait for book 2!!


Miranda Reads Audrey wrote: "I must be the only person who found Thorn immature and annoying!"

Hmmm. ..i disliked Scarlett far more than Thorne. She just seemed so over the top...


message 7: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Excellent review!! :)


Miranda Reads Thank you!


Miranda Reads Thanks 😊😊


message 10: by Tom (new)

Tom Lewis Really great review!


Miranda Reads Thank you :)


message 12: by Kay (new)

Kay Amazing review, Miranda!


Miranda Reads Jennifer (Jen) wrote: "Amazing review, Miranda!"

Thank you very much!!


message 14: by KAS (new)

KAS Glad this was an overall good read for you, Miranda ;) Super review!! xox


Miranda Reads Thank you KAS - you're the best :)


KReads24 I'm looking forward to seeing what you think of the rest of the series. And I totally agree with you about Thorne being the best part of this book :)


Robin Thorne is the best part of the whole series haha


Whitney Thorne is great :) I think if you plan on reading the rest of the series, Scarlett and Wolf get better. She wasn’t my fave when I initially read this book, either, but I grew to really like her.


Shitaki_Mushrooms this book seems great


lucia meets books I loove thorne so much! :D You're so right with Kai too, he's the most frustrating character in this series.


Fergus, Weaver of Autistic Webs Loved this. You are a born writer!


Miranda Reads KReads24 wrote: "I'm looking forward to seeing what you think of the rest of the series. And I totally agree with you about Thorne being the best part of this book :)"

I think Thorne is going to be the best part of the series :)


Miranda Reads Robin wrote: "Thorne is the best part of the whole series haha"

YAAAAAAAS!


Miranda Reads Whitney wrote: "Thorne is great :) I think if you plan on reading the rest of the series, Scarlett and Wolf get better. She wasn’t my fave when I initially read this book, either, but I grew to really like her."

She just seems so...extra :P I think I will tolerate her better when she isn't the main character :) I do adore Wolf - I wish his character was explored more!


Miranda Reads Luupi wrote: "I loove thorne so much! :D You're so right with Kai too, he's the most frustrating character in this series."

UGH! I know, right? It's like...if Kai was a random kid was elected emperor - I would totally understand Kai's actions but since he's had the training and experience, I just feel like he should be doing a better job at it.


Miranda Reads Fergus wrote: "Loved this. You are a born writer!"

Awwww thank you :D


message 27: by Eva (new)

Eva Hey, is Scarlet a virgin? I just dislike the the really overdone virginal heroine with experienced hero.


Audrey Eva wrote: “Hey, is Scarlet a virgin? I just dislike the the really overdone virginal heroine with experienced hero.�

It doesn’t really say. I got the impression both are not too experienced.


message 29: by Eva (new)

Eva Oh is the book YA / PG 13 then?


message 30: by Eva (new)

Eva What about rest of the series?


Audrey Very YA. Lots of teen angst. The whole series is PG/PG-13.


Miranda Reads Audrey wrote: "Very YA. Lots of teen angst. The whole series is PG/PG-13."

Which is pretty much why I'm bowing out. Just didn't click for me


Natasa I'm so glad that somebody agrees with me that Kai is bad at being the emperor!


Miranda Reads Natasa wrote: "I'm so glad that somebody agrees with me that Kai is bad at being the emperor!"

High five to that


message 35: by Zoe (new) - rated it 2 stars

Zoe Kai is bad at being the emperor for sure but I still love him, lol


back to top