ŷ

Melissa's Reviews > The Hush

The Hush by John Hart
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
9684061
's review

liked it
bookshelves: 2017, netgalley, boring, not-for-me, suspense-mystery-thriller

If, like me, you were completely enamored with Johnny and Jack from The Last Child, here’s your chance to find out where time and space has landed the childhood friends. Be warned though, this might not be what you had in mind when you thought about a follow-up.

From the suspense driven whodunnit of The Last Child, to a mystery swathed in magical realism, it’s safe to say, John Hart took a bit of a risk with The Hush. If you’re not a reader that suspends disbelief easily—hello, that’s me!—this might not work for you. Missing was the frantic page turning frenzy his writing usually incites; replaced instead by this mantra, “keep an open mind . . . keep an open mind . . . keep an open mind.� That’s never a good sign, am I right?

Hush Arbor or The Hush�6,000 acres of dense woods, swamp, rocky terrain, creatures and spookiness—is known for having a bit of a shady history. Once belonging to Johnny's ancestors, but ultimately signed over to a group of freed slaves, the land reverted back to Johnny on a technicality after the death of one of the pivotal characters from The Last Child.

Something about Hush Arbor captured Johnny’s heart immediately and he chose to become a hermit of sorts, living in a desolate cabin and watching over his property from a ancient tree. People that step foot on the land experience a host of things—weightiness, the sense of being watched, hours unaccounted for, disorientation and for some, it costs them the ultimate price. Unearthing what transpired between Johnny’s ancestors and the slaves is ultimately the mystery that drives the story. Who or what are the strange beings that now inhabit the land and torture the visitors? Again, not a storyline that got my blood pumping. In fact, the last 25% of the story was sort of torturous. Ludicrous. Pointless. Blah. You pick the adjective.

While this is technically a follow-up, in no way is The Last Child required reading beforehand. In fact, although most of the characters are present and accounted for, so much time has passed between the two stories—there’s a 10 year gap in the timeline—they’re almost unrecognizable, along with the writing itself. It’s like starting all over with a new cast and maybe even a new author.

*A big thank you to St. Martin's Press and NetGalley for a copy in exchange for an honest review.
241 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Hush.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

November 12, 2017 – Started Reading
November 12, 2017 – Shelved
November 12, 2017 – Shelved as: 2017
November 12, 2017 – Shelved as: netgalley
November 16, 2017 –
34.0%
November 17, 2017 –
61.0% "My mantra has been, “Keep an open mind . . . keep an open mind . . . keep an open mind . . .� Not so sure it’s working though. #magicrealism #notforme"
November 18, 2017 – Shelved as: boring
November 18, 2017 – Shelved as: not-for-me
November 18, 2017 – Shelved as: suspense-mystery-thriller
November 18, 2017 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 98 (98 new)


message 1: by Maureen (new)

Maureen Shame it wasn't what you were expecting Melissa, great review though 😊


Canadian Jen Thanks for the warning, Melissa. I don't suspend belief easily either but going in knowing this, I hope he can pull it off for me still. Nice review.


message 3: by Julie (new)

Julie Very nice, honest review, Melissa! I'm sorry it was disappointing.


Karen Sorry it wasn’t good for you!


Melissa Ana wrote: "Hope you're enjoying it Melissa ;)"

Thanks, Ana! Turns out, it was completely different from the first book—in genre and feel. 😭


message 6: by JanB (new)

JanB I sometimes have trouble with magical realism and definitely have trouble suspending disbelief, so thank you for your honest review!


message 7: by Cheri (new)

Cheri Terrific, honest review, Melissa.


message 8: by Svetlana (new)

Svetlana oh man 😭 that's so upsetting! I know how much you were looking forward to reading this one. I'm so sorry it didn't turn out as you had expected Melissa. Thanks for sharing your honest thoughts on the book. I'm not good with magical realism but I hope I like this one still


Melissa Maureen wrote: "Shame it wasn't what you were expecting Melissa, great review though 😊"

Thanks, Maureen. Completely different than expected unfortunately. 😞


message 10: by Mackey (new)

Mackey Oh no....terrific review. Sometimes authors really should leave well enough alone.


message 11: by Candace (new)

Candace Terrific review, Melissa! Sorry it was a disappointment. May your next book be better.


message 12: by Chan (new)

Chan That's an odd way to introduce a sequel. Good honest review!


Melissa Jen wrote: "Thanks for the warning, Melissa. I don't suspend belief easily either but going in knowing this, I hope he can pull it off for me still. Nice review."

Thanks, Jen. I hope you have a much better experience than I did! Looking forward to your thoughts. 😬🤞


message 14: by Holly (new)

Holly  B (slower pace!) Hmm....I dunno but I'll keep an open mind! Great review Melissa!


message 15: by Kristy (new)

Kristy Great review, Melissa! I haven't read either of these books, though the first one sounds interesting. I completely understand what you mean about suspending disbelief, though.


message 16: by Kaceey (new)

Kaceey Great review Melissa! Sorry it wasn’t what you expected! Hope your next read is a 5*🤗


Sunflowerbooklover You and I are on the same wavelength with this one. Wasn’t his best work at all :(.


message 18: by [deleted user] (new)

terrific review! from the choices, i'll pick blah.


message 19: by Selene (new)

Selene Great honest review, Melissa. Definitely avoiding this one. 😟


message 20: by Dana (new)

Dana So sorry it was a disappointment and torturous! I have both of these on my list. Luckily, I love magical realism...so this might just work for me....but your review gives me pause.


message 21: by Nazanin (new)

Nazanin Wonderful review, Melissa! Sorry it wasn't what you expected! 💟


Melissa Julie wrote: "Very nice, honest review, Melissa! I'm sorry it was disappointing."

Thank, Julie! Definitely not what I was hoping for after my love for the The Last Child.


message 23: by Barbara (new) - added it

Barbara Your review helped me avoid disappointment. Thanks!


message 24: by Supratim (new)

Supratim Great review, Melissa!


David - proud Gleeman in Branwen's adventuring party "From the suspense driven whodunnit of The Last Child, to a mystery swathed in magical realism" - I love that wording, a mystery swathed in magical realism! You are an amazing writer, Melissa! :D


Melissa Karen❄️ wrote: "Sorry it wasn’t good for you!"

Thanks, Karen! Wish I could be more open minded were magical realism is concerned. There was a part of me that thought the trajectory of the story was a little murky though, too. Oh well. I'm glad you had a much better experience. 😊


message 27: by Victoria (last edited Nov 19, 2017 09:11AM) (new)

Victoria Oh, Lawdie...this feels like a publisher said, hey, John, The Last Child was wildly popular and you know what else plays well? Magical realism. And a murky disappointment was born. Not enthused, but it's still Hart so I'll give him the benefit.


Linda Great review, Melissa. Uh, oh! Have this one coming up soon. Sounds like John Hart (one of my all-time favorites) might have gone off the turnpike on this one. Biting my knuckle in anguish at the moment. ;)


Karen Melissa wrote: "Karen❄️ wrote: "Sorry it wasn’t good for you!"

Thanks, Karen! Wish I could be more open minded were magical realism is concerned. There was a part of me that thought the trajectory of the story wa..."

If you don’t like the magical realism,you just don’t. Some of my favorite books ever have magical realism, Himself, this year.. so good! Also Garden Spells, Of Bees and Mist, The Story Sisters... to name a few😊


message 30: by Carol (new)

Carol Masterful review, Melissa. I'm not a fan of magical realism so I appreciate the heads up. I do enjoy this author.


message 31: by cluedupreader (last edited Nov 19, 2017 09:27AM) (new)

cluedupreader Thanks for setting the record straight: magic realism.👎🏻 Terrific review!


Melissa JanB wrote: "I sometimes have trouble with magical realism and definitely have trouble suspending disbelief, so thank you for your honest review!"

No problem, Jan. Honestly, I’m not sure I would have requested this one had I known about the magical realism. Don’t let that deter you from his other work though. 😊


message 33: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Looks like there are a lot of mixed reviews for this one. I'm sorry it didn't work out for you :( I hope your next/current reads are great ones!!


message 34: by Sandra (new)

Sandra Fab review Melissa! :) Too bad it was disappointing.


Melissa Cheri wrote: "Terrific, honest review, Melissa."

Thanks, Cheri! 😀


Melissa Svetlana wrote: "oh man 😭 that's so upsetting! I know how much you were looking forward to reading this one. I'm so sorry it didn't turn out as you had expected Melissa. Thanks for sharing your honest thoughts on t..."

Right?! Well, I hope you have much better luck with this one. Had I known the level of "magic" in the storyline, I probably would have skipped it. 😀


Melissa Chan wrote: "That's an odd way to introduce a sequel. Good honest review!"

Yes, very odd! Completely different from the first book, in almost every way.

Candace wrote: "Terrific review, Melissa! Sorry it was a disappointment. May your next book be better."
Thanks, Candace!! Thankfully I found something great to get me over the sting of this disappointment. 😀

Mackey wrote: "Oh no....terrific review. Sometimes authors really should leave well enough alone."
I agree! I guess he wanted to try something different? It just didn't work for me.


Melissa Kristy wrote: "Great review, Melissa! I haven't read either of these books, though the first one sounds interesting. I completely understand what you mean about suspending disbelief, though."
I highly recommend checking out his work, Kristy. This was my third of his and it obviously didn't work out all that well for me, but The Last Child and Redemption Road are phenomenal! 😁

Kaceey wrote: "Great review Melissa! Sorry it wasn’t what you expected! Hope your next read is a 5*🤗"
Thanks, Kaceey! I'm reading a Kristin Hannah and if anyone can deliver a 5 star, it's her! 😉

Holly wrote: "Hmm....I dunno but I'll keep an open mind! Great review Melissa!"
Yes! Keep an open mind. Seems some of the sisters are enjoying this one much more than me, so you might also. 😀


message 39: by Melissa (last edited Nov 20, 2017 04:44AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Melissa Kendall wrote: "You and I are on the same wavelength with this one. Wasn’t his best work at all :(."

What a bummer. It was still fun sharing thoughts with you along the way though. Looking forward to our next group read. 😀


Melissa Nazanin wrote: "Wonderful review, Melissa! Sorry it wasn't what you expected! 💟"
Thanks, Nazanin!! 💜

Dana wrote: "So sorry it was a disappointment and torturous! I have both of these on my list. Luckily, I love magical realism...so this might just work for me....but your review gives me pause."
Oh well, you should be good then. I tried and tried, I just struggle big time with suspending disbelief. I think it also had to do with how different the two books really are, not just in genre, but feel. I would love to hear your thoughts. 😀

Selene wrote: "Great honest review, Melissa. Definitely avoiding this one. 😟"
Thanks, Selene! Not at all what I expected after the first one.

paulie wrote: "terrific review! from the choices, i'll pick blah."
Hahahaha . . . perfect! 👌😂


Melissa Supratim wrote: "Great review, Melissa!"
Thank you, Supratim! 😀

Barbara wrote: "Your review helped me avoid disappointment. Thanks!"
Glad to help! I read this with a group an others seemed to like it more, so you never know. 😉


Melissa David - proud Gleeman in Branwen's adventuring party wrote: ""From the suspense driven whodunnit of The Last Child, to a mystery swathed in magical realism" - I love that wording, a mystery swathed in magical realism! You are an amazing writer, Melissa! :D"

Thanks, David! What a nice comment. Made my day. ☺️😀


Melissa Victoria wrote: "Oh, Lawdie...this feels like a publisher said, hey, John, The Last Child was wildly popular and you know what else plays well? Magical realism. And a murky disappointment was born. Not enthused, bu..."

Hahahahaha . . . exactly. JH totally veered off course with this one and sadly it just didn't work for me. I hope he gets back on track.


Melissa Linda wrote: "Great review, Melissa. Uh, oh! Have this one coming up soon. Sounds like John Hart (one of my all-time favorites) might have gone off the turnpike on this one. Biting my knuckle in anguish at the m..."

Eek . . . fingers crossed you have much better luck with this one, Linda. Had I known about the magical elements, I probably would have passed. Honestly, that's just never been my thing. But you know how it goes, twitching finger and seeing it was JH . . . sold. Looking forward to reading your review. 😀


message 45: by Melissa (last edited Nov 20, 2017 04:54AM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

Melissa Karen❄️ wrote: "Melissa wrote: "Karen❄️ wrote: "Sorry it wasn’t good for you!"

Thanks, Karen! Wish I could be more open minded were magical realism is concerned. There was a part of me that thought the trajectory..."


So true! Or maybe I just haven't read the right one, yet. I'm curious, so I'll check out the ones you mentioned. Thanks! 💜


Melissa Carol wrote: "Masterful review, Melissa. I'm not a fan of magical realism so I appreciate the heads up. I do enjoy this author."

Thanks, Carol! I hope you have better luck with this one than I did, if you decide to give it a chance. 💜


Melissa jendlo wrote: "Thanks for setting the record straight: magic realism.👎🏻 Terrific review!"

Hahahaha! No problem. I wish I would have known before I requested this book. The synopsis is quite vague though.


Melissa Deanna wrote: "Looks like there are a lot of mixed reviews for this one. I'm sorry it didn't work out for you :( I hope your next/current reads are great ones!!"

Thanks, Deanna. Silly me, I didn't realize this had magical realism elements and that's not really my thing. The synopsis is quite vague in that aspect. I absolutely loved the first two books of his I read, Redemption Road and The Last Child, so naturally, I expected this would be the same. Felt like an entirely different cast and writer instead.


Melissa Sandra wrote: "Fab review Melissa! :) Too bad it was disappointing."

Thank you, Sandra! 💜


Paula K Nice review, Melissa! Sorry to hear this wasn’t as good as The Last Child. That’s disappointing.


« previous 1
back to top