Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Katie's Reviews > The Ministry of Fear

The Ministry of Fear by Graham Greene
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
56035852
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: set-in-the-uk

First thing to say is that I thought the quality of the writing deserved a more sophisticated plot. The plot seemed overegged to me and kept changing key as if Greene couldn’t quite decide if he was writing a psychological thriller or a comic farce. The novel opens with a preposterous premise � a cell of Nazi spies hide a vital roll of film inside a cake which is the prize at a fete. That they choose this wholly irrational method of passing on vital information makes you feel you’re entering into a whacky comedy. This feeling is given further weight when someone is murdered at an equally preposterous séance. An entire chapter was then dedicated to a dream. I don’t like dreams in novels. It seems like cheating. And this dream was a clumsy and unrealistic way of imparting important background detail. However all this is taking place during the London Blitz and it was the descriptive writing and detail of his evocation of this moment in history that was my favourite part of this novel. “In Gower Street they were sweeping up glass, and a building smoked into the new day like a candle which some late reveler had forgotten to snuff.�

The plot, though never entirely believable, becomes more gripping at the half way point. Most of all though it was the quality of Greene’s writing that impressed me and left me wanting to read more of his work.
69 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Ministry of Fear.
Sign In »

Quotes Katie Liked

Graham Greene
“Her face looked ugly in the attempt to avoid tears; it was an ugliness which bound him to her more than any beauty could have done. It isn't being happy together, he thought as though it were a fresh discovery, that makes one love--it's being unhappy together.”
Graham Greene, The Ministry of Fear

Graham Greene
“But it is impossible to go through life without trust; that is to be imprisoned in the worst cell of all, oneself.”
Graham Greene, The Ministry of Fear

Graham Greene
“One can't love humanity. One can only love people.”
Graham Greene, The Ministry of Fear

Graham Greene
“In Gower Street they were sweeping up glass, and a building smoked into the new day like a candle which some late reveler had forgotten to snuff.”
Graham Greene, The Ministry of Fear


Reading Progress

December 24, 2017 – Started Reading
December 24, 2017 – Shelved
December 24, 2017 – Shelved as: set-in-the-uk
January 1, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Robin (new)

Robin Thoughtful, critical review, Katie. I definitely want to read more Greene this year - as you say, the quality of his writing beckons us to come back.


Katie Robin wrote: "Thoughtful, critical review, Katie. I definitely want to read more Greene this year - as you say, the quality of his writing beckons us to come back."

It was my first Greene, Robin and since I don't think this is ever mentioned as his best I'm keen to read more - probably The End of the Affair first.


message 3: by Cheri (new)

Cheri Katie, I haven't read any Greene - yet. I loved reading your thoughts on this one, although it sounds as this isn't his best. I'm glad you at least enjoyed it!


message 4: by Susanne (new)

Susanne Nice review Katie!


Katie Cheri wrote: "Katie, I haven't read any Greene - yet. I loved reading your thoughts on this one, although it sounds as this isn't his best. I'm glad you at least enjoyed it!"

Thanks Cheri. I read in another review that he considered this "entertainment" rather than a serious novel so I'm keen to read one of his "serious" novels now!


Katie Susanne wrote: "Nice review Katie!"

Thanks Susanne.


message 7: by Margitte (new)

Margitte A great critical review, Katie. Contains all the right elements to be fair. Love it.


message 8: by Margitte (new)

Margitte A great critical review, Katie.


message 9: by Deanna (new)

Deanna Excellent review, Katie!


Katie Margitte wrote: "A great critical review, Katie. Contains all the right elements to be fair. Love it."

Thanks Margitte.


Katie Deanna wrote: "Excellent review, Katie!"

Thanks Deanna.


message 12: by Svetlana (new)

Svetlana Brilliantly reviewed Katie. This actually sounds quite interesting. And I'm curious, why do dreams in novels seem like cheating?


Katie Svetlana wrote: "Brilliantly reviewed Katie. This actually sounds quite interesting. And I'm curious, why do dreams in novels seem like cheating?"

Thanks Svetlana. Good question! Dreams can seem like cheating because in real life they're fragmentary, like a couple of bars from a familiar song. In novels they sometimes contain the narrative of the entire song, as was the case here. That's the best answer I can give!


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) His writing is better than his plots, I agree. That's fine for me.


message 15: by Teresa (new)

Teresa I haven't read this Greene yet, but as far as well-written farce goes, I'm reminded of another of his 'entertainments': Our Man in Havana. Nice review, as usual, Katie!


Katie Adina wrote: "His writing is better than his plots, I agree. That's fine for me."

This is the only one of his I've read, Adina. It'd be a shame if this was the case in all his books!


Katie Teresa wrote: "I haven't read this Greene yet, but as far as well-written farce goes, I'm reminded of another of his 'entertainments': Our Man in Havana. Nice review, as usual, Katie!"

Thanks Teresa. Interesting that he resorted to farce in another novel. I wasn't convinced he has much of a flair for it!


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) Katie wrote: "Adina wrote: "His writing is better than his plots, I agree. That's fine for me."

This is the only one of his I've read, Adina. It'd be a shame if this was the case in all his books!"
What I wanted to say is that his writing shines and the plots are more subtle.


Katie Adina wrote: "Katie wrote: "Adina wrote: "His writing is better than his plots, I agree. That's fine for me."

This is the only one of his I've read, Adina. It'd be a shame if this was the case in all his books!..."


That's good to know, Adina. I'll definitely be reading more of his books.


Katie Elyse wrote: "I liked what you had to say.... I have that same resistance to dreams in novels ....
yet a story within a story doesn’t bother me. Your thought about that?
This sounds like a nutty book.... lol
I ..."


He wrote it while the war was happening, Elyse, and probably didn't yet have a clear idea of how sinister and clinically ruthless the Nazis were. At that time the British poked fun at Hitler much as we now poke fun at Trump or Kim Jong Un and that spirit seems to pervade his depiction of the enemy. However, the slapstick element is soon replaced by all the tricks of a good conventional thriller and all the best writing has gravitas. So not really a comedy.


message 21: by [deleted user] (new)

that first sentence is outstanding, i luuv it! wonderful review, katie!


Katie paulie wrote: "that first sentence is outstanding, i luuv it! wonderful review, katie!"

Thanks Paulie. I'd rate it 4.127 stars.


message 23: by [deleted user] (new)

Katie wrote: "paulie wrote: "that first sentence is outstanding, i luuv it! wonderful review, katie!"

Thanks Paulie. I'd rate it 4.127 stars."


i'm truly besotted.


Katie paulie wrote: "Katie wrote: "paulie wrote: "that first sentence is outstanding, i luuv it! wonderful review, katie!"

Thanks Paulie. I'd rate it 4.127 stars."

i'm truly besotted."


Fully reciprocated, Paulie.


message 25: by Dov (new)

Dov Zeller Great review, Katie! And also, thank you for introducing me to the word overegged! I am now going to try to find a way to use it as often as possible (without overegging?) I tend to really like reading about dreams in general, and in novels when done convincingly or well. (There are dreams in a few novels I've read as of late, including "The Last Chicken in America" in which I think they work pretty well.) But, I hear you. It can be a bit of a literary crutch. Not that crutches are necessarily a bad thing. In any case, sorry for rambling on. I enjoyed your review and thoughts on plot structure vs. writing quality and the novel's ambivalent register/genre identity...


message 26: by Ian (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ian Fryer I thought it was the cake which was overegged, rather than the plot! Seriously, though, I wasn't bothered that the plot was reasonably straightforward, and even a little silly. It all added to the sense that normality was suspended for the duration of the war, as people, familiar places and even ones self could vanish in the blink of an eye during the Blitz. Greene seems to have been as preoccupied with guilt, fear and Londoners' sense of dislocation in this period as he was with producing a straight spy-thriller.


back to top