Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Cheryl's Reviews > Snow

Snow by Orhan Pamuk
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
11255849
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: nobels, fiction

And the quiet of this empty city was as if the world had come to an end, and it was snowing.


If this were the beginning of a poem, he would have called the thing he felt inside him the silence of snow.

He walked the city in the cold, alone with his poems. Around him, snowflakes formed a blanket of white silence. He traversed Kars, a remote city in Turkey, where he found the poor forgotten, where democracy he saw was nonexistent and the Western world shunned. He, a prodigal son, never fully welcomed, a loner misunderstood, a man with the sort of angst only seen clearly through poetry. There, like the snow, he walked the city quietly, thoughtfully, observantly, deliberately, and Kars became his muse.

But- just as the poem itself defies easy explanation - it is difficult to say how much he decided at that moment and how much of his life was determined by the hidden symmetries this book is seeking to unveil.


Can one ever know the underpinnings of a man's heart when he is in love with a woman at the same time he is in love with the art of poetry? What explains best the shards of a person's soul when he is faced with a home no longer familiar, a city no longer his, a woman who was never his, a mindset unique from that of his peers? Loneliness and despondency are certainly themes in this book, as Ka is faced with those darkening thoughts, even as he experiences moments of euphoria. Politics and religion are bigger themes threaded in each chapter and the socio-political-economic climate unfolds with consistency. This is not the easiest book to maneuver, not the simplest unfolding of plots, but it certainly is intriguing to visit the mind of a political exile, to visit the daily lives of characters trapped behind vocal cages within their own homeland.
32 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Snow.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 1, 2018 – Started Reading
January 1, 2018 – Shelved
January 2, 2018 –
page 53
11.45% ""If this were the beginning of a poem, he would have called the thing he felt inside him the silence of snow.""
February 12, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-17 of 17 (17 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Agnieszka (new) - added it

Agnieszka Great review, Cheryl. Your review confirms everything I heard abot that Pamuk earlier. Not the easiest thing but definitely worth our time. I liked the way you presented the novel and its general mood and for sure going to read it at some point.


message 2: by Seemita (new) - added it

Seemita Beautiful review, Cheryl! Teeming with substance, silent in its flow. I am yet to read Pamuk and the ambivalent sentiments around his name in my friends circle make me a tad apprehensive. But knowing you and I often wear the same lens of perspective, I shall dip my hands in this Pamuk Snow now.


Cheryl Agnieszka wrote: "Great review, Cheryl. Your review confirms everything I heard abot that Pamuk earlier. Not the easiest thing but definitely worth our time. I liked the way you presented the novel and its general m..."

Yes, a great author to try, Agnieszka. The mood of the novel, particularly in the first half, was stimulating and worked as the force that moved the story. I'm glad you've chosen to try it and I can't wait to see what you'll think later.


Cheryl Seemita wrote: "Beautiful review, Cheryl! Teeming with substance, silent in its flow. I am yet to read Pamuk and the ambivalent sentiments around his name in my friends circle make me a tad apprehensive. But knowi..."

Ah, your succinct take on these thoughts is a cup of tea on this cold evening. Thank you, Simi. I teetered between a 3 and 4. The first half was intriguing and the middle almost lost me, but there was something spellbinding about the narrative structure and point of view, as well as those deeply embedded subjects that begged a deliberate reading. I also enjoyed the culmination. Read this when you have the time and be wary of anyone who reads this while reading quite a few other books - won't do it justice!


Cheryl Hi Marita - thank you! There’s an insightful probe at the core of this novel that I found alluring even though the many scenes and new characters that led to the probe were at times distracting and slow-moving.


message 6: by flo (new)

flo Thank you for reminding me of this author through your exquisite review, Cheryl. I must get acquainted with his work someday. The themes you mentioned are certainly interesting.
Btw, so glad to read your splendid prose again. :)


Cheryl Florencia, how awesome to come across your endearing words in the comment stream - thank you! Pamuk was on my 2018 must-try list and I’m glad I did. I can’t wait to read your thoughts later.


Dolors I remember very little of his book, only the feeling of frustration while I was reading it. Your incisive critique tempts me to give Pamuk another try, Cheryl.


Ilse Very fine, beauteous and thoughtful write-up on this novel, Cheryl of which I, like Dolors, sadly remember not much ('Kars, Kars' still resonating, and a vague eerie atmosphere of desolation and mystery) - and a good reminder I should attempt to read another one by Pamuk...


Cheryl Dolors - He’s a different caliber of writer, for sure, idiosyncratic in some instances. Maybe another one of his will resonate?


Cheryl Ilse - desolation, indeed. I didn’t try to follow the path of mystery and I’m glad I didn’t, because when the narrator finally enters the scene, that is when the mystery properly unfolds. It was an odd take on narrative voices, a beautifully weird angle at the third-person and semi- omniscient narrator who appears in the flesh. The reflection had its dazzling moments at times, riddled by poetry. I’m sure I’ll see you read another Pamuk at some point and I’m glad you stopped to reminisce. Both you and Dolors should have great insight after your future reads and I’ll be lurking to read them, of course!


message 12: by Margaret (new) - added it

Margaret Glad to see your beautiful words again. Pamuk has been on my still-to-be-read list for quite a long while, although not this title. I might move this one up bit a higher on the list. After all, your final sentence is that intriguing. How could I not want to "visit the daily lives of characters trapped behind vocal cages within their own homeland?"


Cheryl Margaret wrote: "Glad to see your beautiful words again. Pamuk has been on my still-to-be-read list for quite a long while, although not this title. I might move this one up bit a higher on the list. After all, you..."

What a joy to come across your lovely words, Margaret. I know that you'll have a special time with Pamuk - a unique and informative read.


message 14: by Fionnuala (new)

Fionnuala Not an easy book to make your way through, agreed, Cheryl, but you seem to have taken much from it all the same. Looking back, I probably took some useful ideas from it too, though it alienated me at the time.


MihaElla I love(d) your review, Cheryl. IF I could have been able to write something then I am convinced your words would have mastered me too. Thank you very much, I greatly appreciate having now rekindled the flavour of Pamuk's novel(s).
'Snow' was my first read (I actually purchased the book during a very snowy December day, and it was the only one that resonated with me from that book shop) and despite the many years gone by in-between I still remember it pretty clearly. I found KA and his love - of a human, of art, of poetry, of his homeplace, of his people - the most outstanding and like a break-through feeling even for the present days, such kind of authenticity is mostly gone...


Cheryl Fionnuala wrote: "Not an easy book to make your way through, agreed, Cheryl, but you seem to have taken much from it all the same. Looking back, I probably took some useful ideas from it too, though it alienated me ..."

I'm sorry I only came across this comment recently, Fionnuala. You're right, not an easy book, but I read it at the right time. It's a quiet book with subtle force, if that's even a thing. Your thoughts are always appreciated :)


Cheryl MihaElla wrote: "I love(d) your review, Cheryl. IF I could have been able to write something then I am convinced your words would have mastered me too. Thank you very much, I greatly appreciate having now rekindled..."

Thanks kindly, MihaElla. The contemplative mood of this novel coupled with the atmospheric quality really resonates if read at a time when one is centered and calm. I read about Parmuk's life a bit and I think that much of Ka's emotional truth is also his on the page. I'm glad to have also found someone who loved and understood the inner workings of this novel. What a heartwarming comment - thank you!


back to top