Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Esil's Reviews > Winter

Winter by Ali Smith
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3643764
's review

really liked it

Winter is the second book I’ve read by Ali Smith (Public Library and Other Stories was the first one). Both times I had to recalibrate my brain according to the following rules in order to enjoy the reading experience:

-Slow down � the book is short but you can’t speed through it.
-Give in to the lack of linearity � allow yourself to float and flit in time.
-Open up to the impressionistic feel of the story and language � working too hard to understand what’s happening seems to defeat the point.

The book is told primarily through the voice and eyes of aging Sophia and her adult son Art. The hub of the narrative is a Christmas in England when Sophia, Art, Sophia’s sister, and Art’s pretend girlfriend come together in Sophia’s house. Sophia’s mind seems to be failing, so her thoughts skip to different time periods, all the while revealing her as challenging and prickly. Art is a tad odd too, somewhat awed and beleaguered by his mother, trying more or less to make sense and gain some control over his own life.

In the background, contemporary news flows in from time to time, referring to Trump as the US president, suggesting political chaos beyond the personal chaos of these characters.

I’m not really doing Winter and Smith justice. Winter is not a book for everyone, but I really enjoyed the writing, the characters and feel of it once my brain fell in sync with the book’s sensibility.

Thank you to Netgalley and the publisher for an opportunity to read an advance copy.
151 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Winter.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

October 30, 2017 – Shelved (Kindle Edition)
October 30, 2017 – Shelved as: to-read (Kindle Edition)
October 30, 2017 – Shelved as: netgalley (Kindle Edition)
December 4, 2017 – Shelved as: to-read (Other Hardcover Edition)
December 4, 2017 – Shelved (Other Hardcover Edition)
December 26, 2017 – Shelved as: to-read (Other Hardcover Edition)
December 26, 2017 – Shelved (Other Hardcover Edition)
January 8, 2018 – Started Reading
January 8, 2018 – Shelved
January 12, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Canadian Jen (new)

Canadian Jen Nice review, Esil. I do have this one and the others on my list. I hope I enjoy them as much as you have.


message 2: by Esil (new) - added it

Esil Jen wrote: "Nice review, Esil. I do have this one and the others on my list. I hope I enjoy them as much as you have."

Thanks Jen. I'll be really curious to see what you think. I have Autumn and will read at some point. I don't think the order matters.


message 3: by Mike (new)

Mike Those are some great rules to you outlined for this one, Esil. Nice review!


message 4: by Julie (new)

Julie I've had mixed success with Ali Smith. Those I've loved I've LOVED, others I couldn't get past page 5. I will give this one a go!


message 5: by Kelli (new)

Kelli Doesn’t sound like my cup of tea, thanks for a great review.


message 6: by Esil (new) - added it

Esil Mike wrote: "Those are some great rules to you outlined for this one, Esil. Nice review!"

Thanks Mike!


message 7: by Esil (new) - added it

Esil Julie Christine wrote: "I've had mixed success with Ali Smith. Those I've loved I've LOVED, others I couldn't get past page 5. I will give this one a go!"

I'll be interested in your thoughts Julie. For me, I suspect that I have to be in the right mood to enjoy her writing. I definitely plan to read Winter.


message 8: by Esil (new) - added it

Esil Kelli wrote: "Doesn’t sound like my cup of tea, thanks for a great review."

Thanks Kelli!


Bianca I'm glad you enjoyed it. You're spot on about the necessary mental adjustments, which I just love because it expands our minds. Like you, I've only read two of her books, but they were such a treat.


message 10: by Esil (new) - added it

Esil Bianca wrote: "I'm glad you enjoyed it. You're spot on about the necessary mental adjustments, which I just love because it expands our minds. Like you, I've only read two of her books, but they were such a treat."

Thanks Bianca. I definitely plan to read Autumn. Taking the time to read this one reminded me that I often read way too fast —it’s worth slowing down every now and down.


message 11: by Angela M (new) - added it

Angela M Terrific review, Esil . Haven’t read her but appreciate your tips if I do.


message 12: by Esil (new) - added it

Esil Angela M wrote: "Terrific review, Esil . Haven’t read her but appreciate your tips if I do."

Thanks Angela. I think you have to be in the right mood, but it’s definitely worth a try.


Cheri Wonderful review, Esil, I do agree with all your tips / suggestions, and probably more than anything you need to be in the right mood, and willing to adjust your thinking - but I really enjoyed this. I loved Autumn just a bit more!


message 14: by Esil (new) - added it

Esil Cheri wrote: "Wonderful review, Esil, I do agree with all your tips / suggestions, and probably more than anything you need to be in the right mood, and willing to adjust your thinking - but I really enjoyed thi..."

Thanks Cheri. I definitely have to read Autumn sometime soon � when I’m in the right mood.


message 15: by Jaidee (new)

Jaidee My partner adores Ali Smith and has read all the novels at least twice.

I read him your review and he yelled out "Bang on Girlfriend...you do get her !"

I must try her myself !!


message 16: by Esil (new) - added it

Esil Jaidee wrote: "My partner adores Ali Smith and has read all the novels at least twice.

I read him your review and he yelled out "Bang on Girlfriend...you do get her !"

I must try her myself !!"


Thanks Jaidee � and to your partner :) You should definitely give her a try.


message 17: by Kevin (new)

Kevin Ansbro Great review, Esil.
Hope things aren't too cold for you in snowy Toronto!


message 18: by Esil (new) - added it

Esil Kevin wrote: "Great review, Esil.
Hope things aren't too cold for you in snowy Toronto!"


Thanks Kevin. We’ve had a few brutal days over the last two weeks or so, but it’s getting a bit warmer � a balmy -9 Celsius this morning :)


message 19: by Kevin (new)

Kevin Ansbro Esil wrote: "Kevin wrote: "Great review, Esil.
Hope things aren't too cold for you in snowy Toronto!"

Thanks Kevin. We’ve had a few brutal days over the last two weeks or so, but it’s getting a bit warmer � a ..."


Crikey! Get the sun loungers out! : D


message 20: by Larry (new)

Larry H Great review, Esil! I've been intrigued by this book, but I don't know if the lack of linearity will bother me. Glad you enjoyed it!


message 21: by Esil (new) - added it

Esil Larry wrote: "Great review, Esil! I've been intrigued by this book, but I don't know if the lack of linearity will bother me. Glad you enjoyed it!"

Thanks Larry. You absolutely have to have the patience for non linear narratives to read this one.


message 22: by Carol (new)

Carol You did really do the book and author, Ali Smith justice, Esil. And, I love that word, "prickly"...so descriptive! :)


message 23: by Amy (new) - added it

Amy Yes! Recalibration always takes me some time when I start an Ali Smith - there is just no one else who writes like her!


message 24: by Esil (new) - added it

Esil Carol wrote: "You did really do the book and author, Ali Smith justice, Esil. And, I love that word, "prickly"...so descriptive! :)"

Thank you so much, Carol. I have to find some time to read Autumn sometime soon.


message 25: by Esil (new) - added it

Esil Amy wrote: "Yes! Recalibration always takes me some time when I start an Ali Smith - there is just no one else who writes like her!"

Thanks Amy. I definitely need to read some of her other books.


message 26: by Chris (new) - rated it 1 star

Chris I had no patience. I was utterly confused. Granted the author has won prizes and awards for her writings. This one was just not for me and if her others are written in the same style, I will have to pass on them. There are better books/authors out there for me.


back to top