Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Meike's Reviews > Frankenstein in Baghdad

Frankenstein in Baghdad by Ahmed Saadawi
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
59050228
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: 2018-read, iraq

I have never read anything like this, and I severely doubt that I will read a better book this year. Like one of the many (and I mean: many) detonations we are witnessing in this text, the story, the timeline and the point of view simply explode right in our faces, again and again, and just like the characters, we are forced to piece everything together - will we succeed in doing this? And what kind of monster are we creating by devoting ourselves to this Sisyphean task?

In case you're wondering whether this book really offers cutting-edge political commentary, just take in the exposition of the story: When Hadi, a middle-aged junk dealer, loses his best friend Nahem in an explosion caused by a suicide bomber, he wants to make sure Nahem gets a proper burial - but for this, he needs a complete corpse, so Hadi decides to substitute the missing parts with the body parts of other victims of violence that he finds in the streets of Baghdad. You guessed it: The completed corpse, called Whatsitsname by Hadi, is entered by a displaced soul and comes to life. And not only that, the Whatsitsname wants revenge for the deaths of the people whose body parts he is composed of, and goes on a killing spree through Baghdad.

But wait a minute, maybe this didn't even happen. Maybe Hadi is just an alcoholic liar and made it all up. Or maybe the Whatsitsname is an urban legend and a personification of people's fears. Or of people's longing for justice. Maybe the Whatsitsname works for the Iraqi government. Or the Americans. Or the terrorists. Or one of the militias. Maybe the whole story was distorted by the media. Who the hell knows?

Which brings us to the heart of this book: In war-torn Baghdad, a whole society is exploding. Absolutely nothing is certain anymore, it becomes impossible to trust anyone or to verify information. It becomes dubious who stands on what side, who is spying on whom, and when and how the innocent become criminals. Human solidarity collapses over a variety of conflicts, and people get trapped in a circle of violence and revenge.

How do you piece a human life or a whole society back together? Saadawi starts by telling this story. The topic of fragmentation is also represented in the narrative style, which jumps in time and between perspectives, and while the narrator is omniscient, he certainly does not share all of his knowledge with the reader. The connection between personal experiences and the destiny of society as a whole as well as the connection between the people inside and outside of the novel gets apparent when the author of "Frankenstein in Baghdad", Ahmed Saadawi, becomes a character in the book, where he meets a journalist named Mahmoud al-Sawadi (the names Mahmoud and Ahmed both go back to Muhammad and mean "praise"). Mahmoud is carrying a big secret about his family's origin - one of the many breathtaking ideas this book throws at its readers.

This novel gives you what the best news report can't offer. It's the magic of literature, and this is a true masterpiece. Sample quote:

"Because I'm made up of body parts of people from diverse backgrounds - ethnicities, tribes, races and social classes - I represent the impossible mix that never was achieved in the past. I'm the first true Iraqi citizen, he (the Whatsitsname) thinks."
105 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Frankenstein in Baghdad.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 9, 2018 – Shelved
January 9, 2018 – Shelved as: to-read
February 5, 2018 – Started Reading
February 5, 2018 –
38.0% "Winner of the IMBP 2018. You heard it here first. You're welcome. :-)"
February 7, 2018 –
64.0%
February 9, 2018 – Shelved as: 2018-read
February 9, 2018 – Shelved as: iraq
February 9, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-22 of 22 (22 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Neil Once again, a fantastic review!


Meike Thank you so much, Neil! I really loved this book, just as you did! :-)


Neil I like it even more now that I have read your review!


message 4: by Renata (new) - added it

Renata Truly a fabulous review! My mind reels with the many links you explored with the stitching together of themes and ideas. Oh do more time to read!


message 5: by Tim (new) - rated it 4 stars

Tim Great review!


Meike Thank you, Renata and Tim!!!


message 7: by Ina (new) - rated it 5 stars

Ina Cawl excellent and fascinating review


message 8: by John (new) - added it

John Farebrother Great review, looks like a must read


Meike Ina wrote: "excellent and fascinating review"
John wrote: "Great review, looks like a must read"

Thank you so much, Ina and John!


WndyJW Excellent review, as usual. I just finished and don't what I can add to your stellar review.


Meike WndyJW wrote: "Excellent review, as usual. I just finished and don't what I can add to your stellar review."

Thanks, Wendy! I am glad you enjoyed the book as well!


Gumble's Yard - Golden Reviewer Just added my review - yours is excellent.


message 13: by Wen (new) - rated it 5 stars

Wen Meike, they should replace the blurb with your review! Yes, I think this will be one of my 2018 favorite books too.


Meike Wen wrote: "Meike, they should replace the blurb with your review! Yes, I think this will be one of my 2018 favorite books too."

Thank you so much, Wen! I'm happy that you enjoyed it too!

Gumble's Yard wrote: "Just added my review - yours is excellent."

Thank you, Gumble! (Sorry for replying so late, I somehow missed your posting!)


message 15: by Sonja (new)

Sonja Das möchte ich auf jeden Fall auch lesen!


Meike Sonja wrote: "Das möchte ich auf jeden Fall auch lesen!"

Ich kann es nur empfehlen, es ist wirklich großartig!


message 17: by Michael (new)

Michael Tolle Review, Meike! Das Buch passt momentan eigentlich gar nicht in mein Beuteschema, aber Deine Review macht es eigentlich zu einem must-read! Ich kämpfe mit mir ;)


Meike Michael wrote: "Tolle Review, Meike! Das Buch passt momentan eigentlich gar nicht in mein Beuteschema, aber Deine Review macht es eigentlich zu einem must-read! Ich kämpfe mit mir ;)"

Dankeschön! :-) Das Buch ist der Wahnsinn, und die Art, in der erzählt wird, weicht völlig von dem, was europäische Schriftsteller in der Regel so machen, ab - ich könnte mir gut vorstellen, dass der Text Dir auch gefallen würde! Also: Zeit für die Erweiterung Deines literarischen Beuteschemas! :-)


message 19: by Anika (new)

Anika Hast du zufällig Infos zu einer (geplanten?) deutschen Übersetzung?


Meike Lennongirl wrote: "Hast du zufällig Infos zu einer (geplanten?) deutschen Übersetzung?"

Ich hab gerade mal geschaut, leider konnte ich nichts finden! Die englische Version wird über Penguin vertrieben, aber auf der deutschen Verlagsseite und bei Random House ist Saadawi noch nicht unter den Autoren aufgeführt, und in der Vorschau findet er sich auch nicht...vielleicht hat die deutschen Rechte auch ein anderer Verlag aufgekauft, aber Google konnte mir hier nicht weiter helfen! :-(


message 21: by Anika (new)

Anika Meike wrote: "Lennongirl wrote: "Hast du zufällig Infos zu einer (geplanten?) deutschen Übersetzung?"

Ich hab gerade mal geschaut, leider konnte ich nichts finden! Die englische Version wird über Penguin vertri..."


Ja, ich hatte auch schon mal per Google gesucht, und gehofft, dass du vielleicht noch ein paar Insiderinfos hast ;) Dann warte ich einfach mal ab, vielleicht treibt ja ein Preis eine Übersetzung etwas voran. Danke für deine Mühen!


Meike Lennongirl wrote: "Ja, ich hatte auch schon mal per Google gesucht, und gehofft, dass du vielleicht noch ein paar Insiderinfos hast ;) Dann warte ich einfach mal ab, vielleicht treibt ja ein Preis eine Übersetzung etwas voran. Danke für deine Mühen!"

Kein Problem! :-)


back to top