ŷ

Crumb's Reviews > The Chalk Man

The Chalk Man by C.J. Tudor
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
53025065
's review

it was ok

Scenario One:
When you meet the gorgeous, charismatic, husband type..

Sometimes when you go on a first date, there is an instant connection and you know that this is it. I've found the one. Maybe he took you to a play, or just a really nice dinner. But in all honesty, location doesn’t matter. He may have pulled out your chair, opened your car door, and took off your coat. By the end of the evening, you were trying to think of ways to prolong the date, you didn't want to go home. You were also hoping for a kiss. Finally, when he does kiss you, there were sparks, you had chills! I’m talking major fireworks, ladies.. you know what I mean. Then he left and for the next couple of days you were watching your phone, waiting for it to ring.. finally, it did.



Scenario Two:
When you meet the eh..not so much..let's just be friends..type

This is your first date with someone your friend set you up with and you are really excited. You think to yourself, "maybe this will be my last first date I ever have to go on." You meet him.. he is OK, not bad looking. You go out to dinner and there is nice conversation. The date wasn’t terrible, but there was no passion, no instant chemistry. You think to yourself, "maybe he just isn't good at the art of a first date." Perhaps, the second date will be better. You decide to go on a second date and it is good, not great. Then he pulls you in for your first kiss (you didn’t really want to kiss him on the first date).. it is 'eh'. But do you really want 'eh?'.. No, you don't. You don't want to settle. You want fireworks.



If you are still reading my review, first thank you. Second, this will hopefully start to make more sense. I'm going to get to the actual book now! The description in scenario two is exactly how I felt about this book. I felt like I was waiting for something to happen. . . the.. whole..entire� book. And finally stuff happened, but it was a case of: too little, too late.

Yes there was murder, mystery, gore, and even some intrigue! All good ingredients for a thriller, right? But I didn't find a uniqueness if you will, something that really set it apart from other thrillers that I've read, and loved. Maybe I'm asking for too much, but maybe I'm not. I don't want to settle.. and I don't think I should have to. I want to be wooed! I want to be swept off my feet.. and as an ardent lover of books, I know there are books capable of achieving this.. Unfortunately, this wasn’t one of them.

Note: I read this as a buddy read with Jen. We setup a thread to discuss the book. If you would like to see our comments, please refer to /topic/show/...

I was given this book from the publisher to read and review, however this did not influence my opinion in anyway. Thank you to the author and the publisher for giving me an opportunity to read this.
279 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Chalk Man.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

August 13, 2017 – Shelved as: to-read (Other Hardcover Edition)
August 13, 2017 – Shelved (Other Hardcover Edition)
January 12, 2018 – Started Reading
January 12, 2018 – Shelved
January 13, 2018 –
page 119
42.5%
January 14, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 197 (197 new)


message 1: by Dash fan (new) - added it

Dash fan I can't wait to hear what you think of this one. I must get round to reading it x


Canadian Jen Oh good grief! I just saw your rating :(


Rachel Oh no! I have it downloaded and ready to go.


Crumb Jen wrote: "Oh good grief! I just saw your rating :("

I know.. I think there was so much hype that I was expecting more.. sometimes that happens. However, I did enjoy the buddy read with you!


message 5: by Tasha (new)

Tasha oh no!


Crumb I think I was just expecting more.. because of all the hype..


message 7: by Melody (new) - added it

Melody McNamara Uh-oh! I just ordered this book based on all the rave reviews. Looking forward to hearing your full review :)


Dianne Oh, no!!


Susanne Oh no Crumb! Sorry this was such a disappointment! I hope your next book is like scenario one!! I hope all of us get that (in real life too!) LOL


message 10: by ☮K (new) - rated it 3 stars

☮K Yikes, I really want to read this and was expecting something wonderful. Not too much to ask! I'll probably still try to get to it. Thanks for your review, Crumb!


Crumb Melody wrote: "Uh-oh! I just ordered this book based on all the rave reviews. Looking forward to hearing your full review :)"

My review is up, Melody!


Crumb Susanne wrote: "Oh no Crumb! Sorry this was such a disappointment! I hope your next book is like scenario one!! I hope all of us get that (in real life too!) LOL"

Yes, Susanne! So do I!


Crumb ☮K wrote: "Yikes, I really want to read this and was expecting something wonderful. Not too much to ask! I'll probably still try to get to it. Thanks for your review, Crumb!"

Of course, Karen. I think you should definitely read it.. this was just my opinion. I know I am outnumbered. :-)


message 14: by Mary Beth (new) - added it

Mary Beth Oh no Crumb! Terrific review! This one is coming up for me very soon.


Crumb I hope you like it more! I think it just wasn't my cup of tea.


Stephanie Great review! Sorry it didn't work for you! I just bought this one, but I'm not in a hurry to read it now after reading some mixed reviews. I'll definitely read it, but I'll read some that I need to get to first!


Marialyce So sorry you didn't like this one, Crumb.


Jeanette I'm reading this right now, and am nearly done. This is "billed" as a mystery. Not a category I would categorize this novel within, especially in the way it begins. It's much closer to horror. Loved your review, Crumb. This didn't "sweep" you because the characters are well defined but they are not particularly likable at all. In fact, quite the opposite and the "eyes" of the teller don't have a great investment for the reader because of that. For me anyway. It reminds me of a Stephen King without having the pizzazz of his era/ locale genius.


Crumb Thanks, Stephanie!


Crumb I did this as a buddy read, Marialyce.. and that part was fun!


Crumb I couldn't agree more with your astute observations, Jeanette!


Chelsea Humphrey So sorry this one didn't work for you Crumb; here's to the next one being much better for you!


Crumb Chelsea wrote: "So sorry this one didn't work for you Crumb; here's to the next one being much better for you!"

Thank you, Chelsea!


Heather Great Review Crumb. Sorry it didn’t grab you. I hope the next book is better for you!


Canadian Jen I love this honest review! Ah, we all want scenario 2. I think I came closer to it than you did but enjoyed doing the read together. Hope your next one is phenomenal!!


message 26: by Jennifer (new) - added it

Jennifer Masterson I’m sorry, Crumb! Great review! I hope your next book is a 5 Star for you! ❤️


Crumb Heather wrote: "Great Review Crumb. Sorry it didn’t grab you. I hope the next book is better for you!"

Thank you, Heather!


message 28: by Crumb (last edited Jan 16, 2018 05:17AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Crumb Jen wrote: "I love this honest review! Ah, we all want scenario 2. I think I came closer to it than you did but enjoyed doing the read together. Hope your next one is phenomenal!!"

Thanks so much, Jen. I enjoyed our read, too! I always want to really like a book when I'm doing a buddy read.. but sometimes it just doesn't work out that way.. I did however enjoy the experience.


Crumb Jennifer wrote: "I’m sorry, Crumb! Great review! I hope your next book is a 5 Star for you! ❤️"

Thank you so much, Jennifer! I do too!


message 30: by JanB (new) - rated it 4 stars

JanB I loved this one but I enjoyed reading your review! I hope your next book is a fabulous 5 star one 😊


Crumb JanB wrote: "I loved this one but I enjoyed reading your review! I hope your next book is a fabulous 5 star one 😊"

Thank you so much, Jan!


message 32: by Nazanin (new)

Nazanin Great honest review, Crumb! Sorry it was a miss! Onto the next!


message 33: by Lori (new)

Lori Thank you, for your honest review.


Crumb Thanks, Nazanin!


message 35: by Skyler (new)

Skyler Autumn I like the date comparison with your book love. I've been on the fence about reading this, your review makes me want to not bother. Too little time, too many books. Thanks!!


Susan Sorry this didn't work for you. For me, it was scenario number one. I hope your next book will give you that scenario number one experience.


Crumb Skyler wrote: "I like the date comparison with your book love. I've been on the fence about reading this, your review makes me want to not bother. Too little time, too many books. Thanks!!"

Of course, Skyler! I feel like all I can do when I read a rate and review a book is be as honest as possible..and then the rest is up to the individual if they decide to heed my advice or not! After all, I'm just one person,.


Crumb Susan wrote: "Sorry this didn't work for you. For me, it was scenario number one. I hope your next book will give you that scenario number one experience."

Thanks, Susan!


message 39: by debra (new) - added it

debra Great review, Crumb. Loved your dating comparison. Well done!!


message 40: by Nat (new)

Nat K Ditto! I loved your dating analogy, very clever.


message 41: by Crumb (last edited Jan 17, 2018 05:05AM) (new) - rated it 2 stars

Crumb debra wrote: "Great review, Crumb. Loved your dating comparison. Well done!!"

Thanks, Debra! I was worried it wouldn't make sense.. I'm so glad it did!


Crumb Nat wrote: "Ditto! I loved your dating analogy, very clever."

Thank you so much, Nat!


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) I ofund myself in 2nd scenario many times with my books. I hate it when I stick arounf for the 2nd and 3rd date and I figure out late that i should have ended the relationship after the 1st one.


Crumb Adina wrote: "I ofund myself in 2nd scenario many times with my books. I hate it when I stick arounf for the 2nd and 3rd date and I figure out late that i should have ended the relationship after the 1st one."

Completely agree with you, Adina.. there are usually some red flags, but sometimes you either don't see them or don't want to..


Carol Oh dear...sorry it didn't work for you Crumb. I loved it. So interesting to read everyone's different feeling about a book. Great review.


Crumb Thank you, Carol!


message 47: by May (new)

May Clever review, Crumb!! Thank you!!


message 48: by Taryn (new) - added it

Taryn Fantastic review! We've all been there and your "date scenarios" are a perfect description that feeling! I've been seeing more mixed reviews of this one pop up recently.


Crumb May wrote: "Clever review, Crumb!! Thank you!!"

Thanks, May!


Crumb Taryn wrote: "Fantastic review! We've all been there and your "date scenarios" are a perfect description that feeling! I've been seeing more mixed reviews of this one pop up recently."

Thank you, Taryn! I thought that would be a perfect analogy to describe my feelings..I'm glad it made sense.


« previous 1 3 4
back to top