Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Candi's Reviews > Pachinko

Pachinko by Min Jin Lee
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
3639005
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: asia, historical-fiction

"� there could only be a few winners and a lot of losers. And yet we played on, because we had hope that we might be the lucky ones. How could you get angry at the ones who wanted to be in the game?... Pachinko was a foolish game, but life was not."

I hadn’t really understood exactly what pachinko was before reading this novel. This book and Wikipedia have educated me on the topic. The way I envision pachinko is as a cross between a pinball machine and a slot machine. It’s a gambling game, where the odds may be fixed and the results controlled by outside hands rather than by those actually operating the handle. But folks will return again and again and spend hours in front of this parlor game with the hope of winning the big one. Pachinko can also be likened to the lives of the numerous characters that populate this generational family saga and historical fiction novel. They make choices, they pull the lever if you will, sometimes controlling what happens to them, but very often affected by the outside influences of others, especially those with more power. Some of the characters in this book work for or run pachinko parlors, but the reader spends very little time in these gaming facilities –I would have been running in the other direction otherwise!

What this book does provide us with is a rich story about a family that finds its roots in Korea during the early 1900s and straight through to late 1980s Japan. I love learning about countries and cultures of which I know nothing or very little. This book did not disappoint in that aspect. Much of this is heartbreaking, frustrating, and even maddening � due to the multiple injustices suffered by this Korean family both in their home country under colonial rule by Japan, as well as in Japan where they emigrated in search of more opportunities, safety and security. What they often found there was hatred and racial prejudices. They faced identity crises that some were able to rise above and others were not fortunate enough to overcome. I didn’t realize that the Korean people that moved to Japan during those years suffered to such an outrageous and unbearable extent. They were often discriminated against in the workplace, receiving lower wages than their Japanese counterparts. They were called names, considered lazy, even referred to frequently as criminals. Their living conditions were run-down. Children were bullied in their schools. The only alternative to these conditions seemed to be to return to Korea � but this means of escape was even worse following World War II with the widespread starvation and the introduction of communism in the north. So, the family remained in Japan and made a life, despite the oppression and limitations they faced.

This book was rather hefty, but I never tired of it. I did learn so much about the culture, the politics (though not heavy-handed), and a bit of the history of both Korea and Japan. There were many characters as the novel covers a lengthy span of time, but I never grew confused. I did feel a bit of a distancing from the characters themselves, and they were not quite multilayered enough. I savor wonderfully complex characters. One character, a young man named Noa, may have fit the bill here, but a couple more multidimensional individuals may have enriched this aspect of the book a bit more for me personally. However, I did feel much sympathy towards many of the family; their struggles were real and quite believable. I most admired the women who fought so hard for their families, their children, and worked tirelessly to survive and make ends meet. They were resourceful and brave despite their very quiet and unobtrusive bearing. The last two-thirds to one-fourth of the novel felt a bit more rushed and I was slightly less invested in the storylines of these characters than I was in those initial players. However, I found this to be very well-written, educational and engaging so I can’t really give Pachinko less than 4 stars. Recommended if you are a fan of epic family stories, immigrant struggles, and/or historical fiction. I would be more than happy to read more of Min Jin Lee in the future.

"Living every day in the presence of those who refuse to acknowledge your humanity takes great courage."
196 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Pachinko.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January 19, 2018 – Shelved
January 19, 2018 – Shelved as: to-read
January 19, 2018 – Shelved as: asia
January 19, 2018 – Shelved as: historical-fiction
March 19, 2018 – Started Reading
March 28, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-49 of 49 (49 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Dana (new)

Dana Wonderful review, Candi! I didn’t know what pachinko was, so thanks for enlightening me!


Lisa Nice review Candi!


Sara Excellent review. I happen to own an old pachinko machine. I had no idea they were actually used in gambling facilities. I will have to add this to my TBR, since the culture is very interesting to me.


Glenn Sumi Great review, Candi! I've got this on hold at the library, so I'm going to revisit your review in detail after I finish.


Diane Barnes I want to read this, but it has a lot of differing reviews, so I've been putting it off. Nice to see that you really liked it, as I think our reading tastes tend to be similar.


Diane S ☔ Terrific review, Candi.


Candi Dana wrote: "Wonderful review, Candi! I didn’t know what pachinko was, so thanks for enlightening me!"

Thank you, Dana! I had heard the term before this, but never knew what it was!


Candi Lisa wrote: "Nice review Candi!"

Thank you, Lisa! :)


Candi Sara wrote: "Excellent review. I happen to own an old pachinko machine. I had no idea they were actually used in gambling facilities. I will have to add this to my TBR, since the culture is very interesting to me."

Thank you, Sara. I'm so curious now as to how you obtained the machine! I think you would like this one for the historical details. It's not a perfect novel, but well worth the read.


Candi Glenn wrote: "Great review, Candi! I've got this on hold at the library, so I'm going to revisit your review in detail after I finish."

Thanks, Glenn! I'm glad to hear you're planning to read this one - I would love to hear your thoughts on it when you get to it :)


Candi Diane wrote: "I want to read this, but it has a lot of differing reviews, so I've been putting it off. Nice to see that you really liked it, as I think our reading tastes tend to be similar."

I was on the fence about this one for the same reason, Diane. But then the opportunity to read more about the culture of both Korea and Japan enticed me enough to give it a try. I'm pleased I did, even if I didn't fall in love with any of the characters :)


Candi Marita wrote: "Thanks for your excellent review, Candi. I’m nudging this book up in the tottering pile of to-read books."

Marita, I hope your stack isn't about to crash as mine is! Thank you for your kind comment as always :)


Candi Diane S � wrote: "Terrific review, Candi."

Thanks so much, Diane! :)


Sharon Fantastic review Candi! I agree the last sections felt a bit rushed but I still adored the novel. One of my favorites this year!


Candi Sharon wrote: "Fantastic review Candi! I agree the last sections felt a bit rushed but I still adored the novel. One of my favorites this year!"

Thank you, Sharon! I'm very pleased that you were able to find a 5 star and a favorite for the year in this book - makes you feel all warm inside when that happens, doesn't it?!


message 16: by Tammy (new) - added it

Tammy Excellent review, Candi! This is another one that I keep eyeing


message 17: by Erin (new) - added it

Erin Excellent review! Thank you for sharing! I definitely have to read this book! :)


Candi Tammy wrote: "Excellent review, Candi! This is another one that I keep eyeing"

Thank you, Tammy! This one has been popping up a lot lately on GR. I finally gave in and had to read it :)


Candi Erin wrote: "Excellent review! Thank you for sharing! I definitely have to read this book! :)"

Thank you, Erin! I hope that you enjoy this as much as I did, if you do end up reading it :)


message 20: by Deyanne (new) - added it

Deyanne Excellent review. Sigh. This book dragged for me. I was reading several others about North Korea at the same time for a book group. I ended up not finishing it. Funny how books can appeal at different times in our lives.


message 21: by Julie (new) - added it

Julie Terrific review, Candi!! 😊


Adina (notifications back, log out, clear cache) Very nice review. I have to read this as well.


Candi Deyanne wrote: "Excellent review. Sigh. This book dragged for me. I was reading several others about North Korea at the same time for a book group. I ended up not finishing it. Funny how books can appeal at differ..."

Thank you, Deyanne! It's very true what you say about books appealing at different times - in particular, if you are reading something else that somehow manages to capture your attention better than another. I have a non-fiction book about North Korea that I am eager to read :)


Candi Julie wrote: "Terrific review, Candi!! 😊"

Thank you, Julie! :)


Candi Adina wrote: "Very nice review. I have to read this as well."

Thanks, Adina! I'm interested to hear what you think of this when you get to it :)


message 26: by Jessica (new) - added it

Jessica Wow! So this is on my shelf and I’ve been so excited to read it but now I’m even more excited. Great review, I kind of feel like I understand a bit more now. I was a little intimidated by the plot because of my lack in knowledge of this cultures history but this kind of made me feel a bit more comfortable with what to expect, and that it will be possible for me to get by with just the wiki page up hehe thanks Candi!


Cheri Wonderful review, Candi, I recognized a lot of those feelings / frustrations that I had when I was reading this, but I think overall that 4 stars is a perfect rating for this one.


message 28: by Svetlana (new)

Svetlana what a wonderful, well thought out review Candi. It’s always amazing to read about events that we previously had no knowledge of - I love your ending quote :)


Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader Wonderful review, Candi! This is one I have meant to make time for and I hope I will soon. Love all the things you mentioned- immigrant stories, family sagas, culture, learning, historical fiction.


message 30: by Bianca (new) - added it

Bianca Terrific review, Candi.


message 31: by Karen (new)

Karen Wonderful review Candi! I’ve added and removed this several times. I’m going to read it after your review!


withdrawn A wonderful review of a wonderful book Candi. You’ve now set a high standard for me when I get to writing my own review of Pachinko. Thanks.


Candi Jessica wrote: "Wow! So this is on my shelf and I’ve been so excited to read it but now I’m even more excited. Great review, I kind of feel like I understand a bit more now. I was a little intimidated by the plot ..."

Thanks so much, Jessica! It's definitely not intimidating plot-wise (maybe just length-wise, lol), as the author does a great job writing about the culture and history. As far as the pachinko goes, you don't really have to understand the game too much, except that it's a game of chance! :)


Candi Cheri wrote: "Wonderful review, Candi, I recognized a lot of those feelings / frustrations that I had when I was reading this, but I think overall that 4 stars is a perfect rating for this one."

Thank you, Cheri! And I'm glad that we agree on this one! Lee was pretty ambitious with this novel, and I think she pulled it off really well :)


Candi Svetlana wrote: "what a wonderful, well thought out review Candi. It’s always amazing to read about events that we previously had no knowledge of - I love your ending quote :)"

Thank you very much, Svetlana. So many things we didn't learn in the classroom settings! I'm glad you like the quote I chose - it really struck me as being so meaningful :)


Candi Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader wrote: "Wonderful review, Candi! This is one I have meant to make time for and I hope I will soon. Love all the things you mentioned- immigrant stories, family sagas, culture, learning, historical fiction."

Thank you, Jennifer! I hope you can carve out a little space of time for this one - I don't think you'll be disappointed :)


Candi Bianca wrote: "Terrific review, Candi."

Thank you, Bianca! :)


Candi Karen wrote: "Wonderful review Candi! I’ve added and removed this several times. I’m going to read it after your review!"

Thanks, Karen! I'm glad I helped you decide which way to go with this one! I'll watch for your thoughts when you get to it :)


Candi RK-ique wrote: "A wonderful review of a wonderful book Candi. You’ve now set a high standard for me when I get to writing my own review of Pachinko. Thanks."

Thanks so much, Rk-ique. It's very kind of you to say so! I look forward to reading your review :)


Angela M Candi, a terrific review. Love the ending quote you added .


Candi Angela M wrote: "Candi, a terrific review. Love the ending quote you added ."

Thank you, Angela! I'm pleased you love that quote too :)


Rosemary I am halfway through this book now and am totally involved in the story. I lived in Japan for sixteen and a half years and am well acquainted with the treatment of Koreans at the hands of the Japanese. It still continues, I regret to say, though not in such extreme forms. I think PACHINKO is brilliant and I will write a review to say so as soon as I have finished reading it.


Candi Rosemary wrote: "I am halfway through this book now and am totally involved in the story. I lived in Japan for sixteen and a half years and am well acquainted with the treatment of Koreans at the hands of the Japan..."

Rosemary, I'm so glad you stopped by and commented here. I had been curious as to whether Koreans in Japans were mistreated at some level even today. I would love to read your review after you finish the book, especially given your experience living there for such a length of time!


Candi Elyse wrote: "Beautiful review Candi!!!!"

Thanks very much, Elyse!! :)


message 45: by Lisa (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lisa Wolf Lovely review!


Candi Lisa wrote: "Lovely review!"

Thank you, Lisa! :)


Candi Greta wrote: "Wonderful review Candi! I‘m just reading this and reading your review along the way is an enlightening experience!"

Thank you, Greta! I hope you enjoy this one. I'll be watching out for your thoughts on it when you finish!


Vishakha Wonderful review, Candy. You're absolutely right about the characters, they were not very complex, apart from Noa.


Candi Vishakha wrote: "Wonderful review, Candy. You're absolutely right about the characters, they were not very complex, apart from Noa."

Thank you, Vishakha! I took away a lot, learning about Korean culture. I just wanted a little more depth to the characters and it would have been a 5 star book for me :)


back to top