s.penkevich's Reviews > Coraline
Coraline
by
by

�When you are scared, but you do it anyway, that's brave.�
There are few villains that still frighten me to this day quite like the button-eyed Other Mother of Neil Gaiman’s Coraline. While, sure, this is a book for younger readers, but Coraline is a terrifying little tale that even adults can take to heart and feel inspired by 9year old Coraline as she learns that being �being brave didn’t mean you weren’t scared,� as Gaiman explains in his forward, �being brave meant you were scared, really scared, badly scared, and you did the right thing anyway.� This twisted coming-of-age story examines finding oneself as well as a sense of home, made all the more sinister when evil seeks to seduce you into their grasps by playing off of your loneliness and frustrations during periods of upheaval. Gaiman has crafted a delightfully spooky modern fairy tale that is sure to charm readers of any age with his whimsical imagination, foreboding vibes and empowering moral messages, and, best of all, his sharp and witty heroine, Coraline Jones.
I don’t care who you are, Other Mother/Bedlam is terrifying.
I recently reread Shirley Jackson’s The Haunting of Hill House with my book club and spent a lot of time thinking about how the novel discusses fear as being something that isolates us from the not-afraid parts of us, and can isolate our minds from reality. In this way, the house isolates Eleanor and plays off her feelings of lacking a home and even a solid identity in order to take hold of her, writing �come home� in blood on the walls to tell her the haunted house was her real home. This made me think of Coraline and how the Other Mother baits her by being a warm and welcoming mother during a time when her family is in the chaos of a move and the usual family frictions children have as they seek more independence from their parents. I don’t know if Gaiman was inspired by Hill House at all, but the symmetry is there, and in both books to fall into the snare means to have your soul consumed. Fun stuff! This novel, however, is about how a young girl and a sassy cat are able to overcome the psychological traps, entering into the fairy tale are returning wiser and with a better idea of the self.
�Coraline wondered why so few of the adults she met made any sense,� Gaiman writes, and much of the troubles arise because Coraline feels the adults in her life are failing her. This is a common theme in children’s fiction, and Gaiman embodies the trope masterfully with goofy neighbors and hijinks that make the adult world seem pretty lame and off putting. There is a great message at play in this book that even when relationships are rocky or stressed, people still love each other and the memories of this love can sustain you in your darkest hours. It is a beautiful sentiment, though when a demon is chasing you to devour your soul perhaps its better to take strength from it than bask in the mushy-goodness of it.
Gaiman also interrogates the idea of ‘home� in Coraline, an apt discussion for a child who has just been uprooted from Michigan (in the amazing film version by Henry Selick, the Jones family owns a snowglobe of the Holland Lighthouse where I live, so that's cool). Through the novel we seem the concept of ‘home� less as a physical space, and more an emotional one made up of good relationships with those around you. This is a good lesson to impart, and it is amusing to see Coraline connect with the strange neighbors living around her, though we see her impression of home become less welcoming each time she argues with her mother, pushing her closer and closer to the clutches of evil.
�Fairy tales are more than true: not because they tell us that dragons exist, but because they tell us that dragons can be beaten.�
- G.K. Chesterton
I love the way Gaiman takes on fairy tale attributes here. Keys and mirrors are frequent in the book, and Coraline literally enters a mirror world at the risk of being trapped there forever. She also has three neighbors who she visits on both sides of the mirror, and cycles of 3 is a common motif in fairy tale narratives. He toys around with tropes in humorous ways to fit his themes of self-identity, such as in the mirror world where her neighbor can actually call her by the correct name but she is then told by the cat that names are meaningless. �Now you people have names,� he tells her, �that's because you don't know who you are. We know who we are, so we don't need names.� The idea of naming something in a fairy tale often means taking power over it, but here we see names as a placeholder until we can have power over ourselves. Clever riffing on fairy tale logic is part of what makes Coraline such a sheer delight.
This is a scary book though, Other Mother for real creeps me out, but Gaiman needed a creepy villain in order to bestow his biggest message: be brave. Life is scary, he tells us, and sometimes the only way to get through is to truly be brave. �It wasn’t brave because he wasn’t scared: it was the only thing he could do,� he writes as an example, �but going back again..when he was really scared. That was brave.� It is a lovely reminder that doing the right thing often means facing hardships and fears, but we should do it anyways. Coraline is a stunning little book and a perfect spooky season read.
4.5/5/
�Be wise. Be brave. Be tricky.�
There are few villains that still frighten me to this day quite like the button-eyed Other Mother of Neil Gaiman’s Coraline. While, sure, this is a book for younger readers, but Coraline is a terrifying little tale that even adults can take to heart and feel inspired by 9year old Coraline as she learns that being �being brave didn’t mean you weren’t scared,� as Gaiman explains in his forward, �being brave meant you were scared, really scared, badly scared, and you did the right thing anyway.� This twisted coming-of-age story examines finding oneself as well as a sense of home, made all the more sinister when evil seeks to seduce you into their grasps by playing off of your loneliness and frustrations during periods of upheaval. Gaiman has crafted a delightfully spooky modern fairy tale that is sure to charm readers of any age with his whimsical imagination, foreboding vibes and empowering moral messages, and, best of all, his sharp and witty heroine, Coraline Jones.
I don’t care who you are, Other Mother/Bedlam is terrifying.
I recently reread Shirley Jackson’s The Haunting of Hill House with my book club and spent a lot of time thinking about how the novel discusses fear as being something that isolates us from the not-afraid parts of us, and can isolate our minds from reality. In this way, the house isolates Eleanor and plays off her feelings of lacking a home and even a solid identity in order to take hold of her, writing �come home� in blood on the walls to tell her the haunted house was her real home. This made me think of Coraline and how the Other Mother baits her by being a warm and welcoming mother during a time when her family is in the chaos of a move and the usual family frictions children have as they seek more independence from their parents. I don’t know if Gaiman was inspired by Hill House at all, but the symmetry is there, and in both books to fall into the snare means to have your soul consumed. Fun stuff! This novel, however, is about how a young girl and a sassy cat are able to overcome the psychological traps, entering into the fairy tale are returning wiser and with a better idea of the self.
�Coraline wondered why so few of the adults she met made any sense,� Gaiman writes, and much of the troubles arise because Coraline feels the adults in her life are failing her. This is a common theme in children’s fiction, and Gaiman embodies the trope masterfully with goofy neighbors and hijinks that make the adult world seem pretty lame and off putting. There is a great message at play in this book that even when relationships are rocky or stressed, people still love each other and the memories of this love can sustain you in your darkest hours. It is a beautiful sentiment, though when a demon is chasing you to devour your soul perhaps its better to take strength from it than bask in the mushy-goodness of it.
Gaiman also interrogates the idea of ‘home� in Coraline, an apt discussion for a child who has just been uprooted from Michigan (in the amazing film version by Henry Selick, the Jones family owns a snowglobe of the Holland Lighthouse where I live, so that's cool). Through the novel we seem the concept of ‘home� less as a physical space, and more an emotional one made up of good relationships with those around you. This is a good lesson to impart, and it is amusing to see Coraline connect with the strange neighbors living around her, though we see her impression of home become less welcoming each time she argues with her mother, pushing her closer and closer to the clutches of evil.
�Fairy tales are more than true: not because they tell us that dragons exist, but because they tell us that dragons can be beaten.�
- G.K. Chesterton
I love the way Gaiman takes on fairy tale attributes here. Keys and mirrors are frequent in the book, and Coraline literally enters a mirror world at the risk of being trapped there forever. She also has three neighbors who she visits on both sides of the mirror, and cycles of 3 is a common motif in fairy tale narratives. He toys around with tropes in humorous ways to fit his themes of self-identity, such as in the mirror world where her neighbor can actually call her by the correct name but she is then told by the cat that names are meaningless. �Now you people have names,� he tells her, �that's because you don't know who you are. We know who we are, so we don't need names.� The idea of naming something in a fairy tale often means taking power over it, but here we see names as a placeholder until we can have power over ourselves. Clever riffing on fairy tale logic is part of what makes Coraline such a sheer delight.
This is a scary book though, Other Mother for real creeps me out, but Gaiman needed a creepy villain in order to bestow his biggest message: be brave. Life is scary, he tells us, and sometimes the only way to get through is to truly be brave. �It wasn’t brave because he wasn’t scared: it was the only thing he could do,� he writes as an example, �but going back again..when he was really scared. That was brave.� It is a lovely reminder that doing the right thing often means facing hardships and fears, but we should do it anyways. Coraline is a stunning little book and a perfect spooky season read.
4.5/5/
�Be wise. Be brave. Be tricky.�
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Coraline.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Finished Reading
October 23, 2011
– Shelved
October 28, 2022
– Shelved as:
spooky
October 28, 2022
– Shelved as:
horror
October 28, 2022
– Shelved as:
younger_readers
October 28, 2022
– Shelved as:
coming-of-age
Comments Showing 1-41 of 41 (41 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Heidi
(new)
Oct 28, 2022 09:39PM

reply
|
flag

Oh yay I hope you enjoy, it’s so charming! Thanks!

Wonderful review, Steven!"
It’s so good! Yea, agreed, I’d love him to write more like this. I did read a thing the other day that the guy who did the Coraline film is hoping to do Neverwhere in the same style and I really hope that happens.


Oh that is wonderful! Glad they are enjoying. YES the cat is the best haha. Him and Gigi from Kiki’s Delivery Service are some of my favorite fictional cats haha

Thank you so much! I love books like this aimed for younger readers because you can sort of…see the literary engine underneath? It’s always fun.

Thank you! He’s really fun, haven’t read him in awhile but this is a good quick read and American Gods ruled. Everyone tells me Good Omens is their favorite though, still need to try that. Honestly the best is finding him reading his own short stories (he did on NPR a few times), he has a great reading voice.

Wonderful review, Steven!"
It’s so good! Yea, agreed, I’d love him to write more like this. I did read a thing the other day that..."
Oh, that would be great! Better than Neverwhere mini-series which is quite cheesy.

Wonderful review, Steven!"
It’s so good! Yea, agreed, I’d love him to write more like this. I did read a thin..."
Oh wow I didn’t even know that existed and now I understand why haha


Oooooo i bet this is amazing in audiobook with him reading it, he has SUCH a good reading voice. Other Mother is SO scary I wish I would have thought of it sooner because she would make for a great Halloween costume haha. Hope you enjoy the book if you get to it, it’s such a nice quick treat!

Thank you! It’s so good! I’m actually watching the movie of it RIGHT NOW too haha oh and I love your review, that’s is the best story.


Ooooo yes i hope you enjoy the book and Can read it soon! It’s worth it! Haha that’s how I feel about the rest of his books, like I really want to read Good Omens but I’m like the last Alive who hasn’t or seen the show it seems haha

I really need to remember this for next year!

It could, but how would you do the button eyes?!?!

It could, but how would you do the button eyes?!?!"
In The Simpsons, they glued them on Lenny with hot wax.

It could, but how would you do the button eyes?!?!"
I was thinking about that. Maybe use the lenses from round sunglasses and put dots for the button holes?

It could, but how would you do the button eyes?!?!"
In The Simpsons, they glued them on Lenny with hot wax."
That will be plan B haha


Aw that is great! I like how it’s basically become a modern classic at this point, and totally holds up as an adult which is even better!


Thank you so much! Oooo yes I love the movie! Finally rewatched it the other day and am just about to start the new one he just put out. I’m curious what you’ll think going from movie to book as there are some variations and I actually kind of enjoyed things that were added for the movie (Wybie is not in the book at all, though some of the scenes in the book I found a bit scarier maybe). I hope you enjoy! Thanks again :)


Thank you so much! haha fair, yea, this one even as an adult is rather frightening. And same, I was having a discussion with someone on here the other day where she phrased Gaiman as an author she wishes she enjoyed more than she did and I think that sums him up for me as well. I like the idea of really getting into him but haven't quite managed though I suspect a lot of that is me and not a commentary on his quality. This one, on the other hand, I absolutely adore (if you haven't, the film adaptation of his fairy tale world Stardust is outstanding, honestly a favorite movie of mine to watch on repeat--and not horror either just whimsical and fun).
But thanks again!


Thank you so much! Ooo how are you liking that one, I was thinking of reading it next. haha we should just swap--I hope you enjoy!


Thank you so much! I love that film adaptation, its kind of the perfect halloween vibe ( I saw it when it first came out and in 3D having no idea what the movie was going to be and it blew my mind haha). Hope you enjoy the novel version, its like, sure, definitely for younger readers but honestly I found it just as engaging and probably even scarier than the movie. I cant wait to hear what you think! Also...skip the graphic novel adaptation if you've seen the film.


Yeaaaaaa that was a massive letdown, and multiple people coming forward too. It seems extra frustrating and sad when its a celebrity so much enmeshed in teen and children's media too when those are the people they look up to. I remember being young and thinking wow, Gaiman is someone I would like to be able to write like. Just a tragedy really. Wow, I didn't realize they cancelled all the projects too. I think I had heard Graveyard Book was getting an adaptation awhile back, Such a shame, and will certainly taint his body of work forever too. Had this movie on the other day (it's my oldest's favorite) and was thinking about how many times we reread this every October. Won't be doing that this year (though luckily my youngest is super obsessed with Wild Robot so that will keep us busy haha)