ŷ

C. (Comment, never msg).'s Reviews > Sense and Sensibility

Sense and Sensibility by Jane Austen
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
10501026
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: riedel-titles-2018

* I take my writing seriously and consider comments the reward. Please do not leave “like button� clicks, until you are accompanying them with remarks for me. *

I wish Jane Austen could see she became an admired literary standard. She conjures such scholarly connotations, I was wary of enjoying �Sense And Sensibility�. I hope my words attain quality that is discussed and absorbed for meaning but books are about the story, personages, message, setting, and sympathizing with them. I couldn't care less about structural intentions, like “symbolism�, thus my reviews are never going to be critical essay types. Just as a novel, I am thrilled to report I liked this! I feel relief and triumph, to have enjoyed this enough to give it four stars!

We have read and seen numerous stories portraying the 1800s, most often in England; at a distance already for North Americans, culturally. They must spotlight a rare class, with mercifully extinct codes of conduct. Except Edward Farrars' Mother, I was shocked, to find an authoress from 1811 itself, depicting no stuffiness! How enlightening, from someone who knew how society acted. We still observe morals and manners, as we should but there was scarcely any unreasonable mindset. I followed this Mother and daughters right along, who loved each other and had fun. Quite unforeseen relief is that �Sense And Sensibility� is supposed to be about two who are different but Elinor & Marianne are loving and loyal. There was no antagonism. They had respectfully different attitudes and coping mannerisms.

Another striking aspect is that this family quartet of women, including young Margaret, needed a financial lift only as much as some men. They were content on their own. Even though they were aware their step-brother promised to share his male-structured inheritance, they did not challenge him and his selfish wife. The largest surprise, is that I expected a social commentary and found a veritable novel: with a story that goes somewhere and plot twists I did not dream it would yield.

Even though I am a linguist, I had to pause and absorb pages properly because they are stuffed full of intelligent language, with eloquently impressive turns of phrase but I praise this. Part of the point of sampling Jane, is to broaden my vocabulary and literary palate. However any modern person wondering if they will relate to Marianne and Elinor and find an enjoyable story, must be encouraged. I am glad I have read the first of her books! It is a due I felt it right to grant this lady, for an unusually personal reason. All the way from Canada, I have visited her house!
72 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Sense and Sensibility.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

February 4, 2018 – Started Reading
February 4, 2018 – Shelved as: riedel-titles-2018
February 4, 2018 – Shelved
February 4, 2018 –
page 22
6.41% "If I have gone so far as to walk inside Jane Austen's house in Bath, England seven years ago; into the gift shop room and house's foyer, at the foot of her stairs: it is time I should read her oeuvres! I didn't purchase a ticket to tour it because that is appreciated by someone who had read her. It would be my pleasure, once familiar with her. As someone intent on being an authoress, it is high time to read her."
February 5, 2018 –
page 45
13.12% "I might be able to get into this. I am doing all right."
February 6, 2018 –
page 72
20.99%
February 7, 2018 –
page 82
23.91%
February 8, 2018 –
page 90
26.24%
February 9, 2018 –
page 145
42.27%
February 10, 2018 –
page 206
60.06% "I am past halfway finished my first Jane Austen novel! The language is dense but I like sampling how richly a competent writer can use words. Especially since this is no strutting fancy vocuabulary for ostentation but truly deriving from a woman of 1811 and how she must have spoken. Now the tale gets more interesting than I would have thought. I expected only a character study. Herein are two beaux who are cads!"
February 11, 2018 –
page 245
71.43% "I am really making my way to the finish line now. It takes quite an author, to noticeably effect a perception change, like it occurs in life. It is possible that personages whom we thought charming and similar to us in interests, are not for us. Personages who seemed not our cup of tea, can become dear and prove profoundly loyal and moral. Even Mrs. Jennings and Elinor herself, become heroines we did not foresee."
February 12, 2018 –
page 300
87.46% ""Sense And Sensibility", far from the genre, era, and type I usually read, is managing to take turns that surprise me and is indeed enjoyable. If it weren't "Oak Island" and "Star Trek Discovery" night, I wouldn't have fallen asleep nigh on the last chapters. I am nearly finished my first Jane Austen novel! As I have shared: it is the least I can do, since I have visited the entrance interior of the lady's house!"
February 13, 2018 –
page 330
96.21%
February 13, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-45 of 45 (45 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Luvtoread (Trying to catch up) Great review C.


C.  (Comment, never msg). Thanks for visiting my initial musing, Luv! I'll round it out by tomorrow.


message 3: by Jaline (new)

Jaline Great review, Carolyn - I'm so glad you enjoyed this classic!


C.  (Comment, never msg). I'll balance out my thoughts properly soon. I am glad to share, preliminarily, that I like Jane Austen after all!


Susan If you haven’t seen already, you might also enjoy the movie with Emma Thompson, Hugh Grant, Alan Rickman, etc. The script sticks fairly close to the book but adds the costumes, settings, etc of the day.


message 6: by C. (Comment, never msg). (last edited Feb 14, 2018 05:52AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

C.  (Comment, never msg). I like all these actors, including Kate Winslet. I wondered if films could help being what I worried the original book might be: clipped, stiff, almost angry British language and demeanour; stuffy circumstances. I was so pleased that the novel was none of these. I might be glad to leave my image of freer, happier people here, unless assured otherwise of the films. Maybe the playfulness of those three actors dominates the tone.


Susan Hmm. I didn’t think the film was clipped, stiff or almost angry, but they do all have British accents and somewhat old-fashioned demeanors. Sometimes when a book has been peopled by our own imaginations, any movie is just a letdown :)


C.  (Comment, never msg). Obviously the accents are fine; part of the setting. If the demeanour was not clipped or stiff, this is the information I needed. In so many films, people are rivals and I did not want a book or film about sisters who were antagonists. Indeed, they are loving and only different in personality. I see the four actors in particular bringing humour to this book. I only finished Jane Austen yesterday and have no image, like many the world over! I am a great instance of a clean slate.


Susan Yes, just like in the book, Marianne and Eleanor are loving sisters in the movie version. They may disagree at times, but they care about each other very much. The movie also fleshes out their younger sister, who is a lot of fun. The actors, screenplay and direction do bring out the humor of the book as well as the feeling. It’s one of my favorites fwiw.


message 10: by Mary (new)

Mary Delighted this was a 4*read for you! I really hope you read Pride &Prejudice. It's a wonderful story.


message 11: by C. (Comment, never msg). (last edited Feb 15, 2018 04:00AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

C.  (Comment, never msg). I don't know the meaning of "fwiw" but certainly learned what I needed, to know "Sense And Sensibility" will be a pleasant movie as well.

Mary, I can't see your profile but how wonderful a new person has visited! My final review will be ready soon. I round out properly, after leaving initial thoughts publically, sometimes. You bet I already own the rest of Jane's oeuvres and look forward to continuing them in order, as if I were there to see them come out. Carolyn.


Susan “FWIW� = for what it’s worth. Look forward to hearing about your future reading adventures


Teresa Lovely review.


C.  (Comment, never msg). Thank you very much, Teresa! I knew I probably need not fear Jane Austen and Manitoba's own classics, Gabrielle Roy and Margaret Laurence. However I was hesitant enough about getting going, that it feels triumphant that I have.


Teresa Glad you enjoyed it. It really is a great read. It's been adapted to dvd very successfully too.


Nahte Your review is splendid! I have just completed the book--I agree with it wholeheartedly.


message 17: by C. (Comment, never msg). (last edited Feb 12, 2019 06:56PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

C.  (Comment, never msg). I'm glad I'm not late alone at the Jane Austen party. Especially happy my review resonates with you, Nahte! It exceeded how well I hoped I would like it and I won't hesitate to read "Pride And Prejudice".

Teresa, I saw the film go by on the satellite dish. Now knowing the story is warm-hearted instead of downtrodden and with those actors, I am sure to love the film indeed.


message 18: by Tammy (new)

Tammy Terrific, Carolyn!


C.  (Comment, never msg). Oh, thank you, Tammy! Are you new to classics too or did you dip that toe long ago? I'm well into Canadian classics but wonder which of the Bronte books I might like.


Teresa I'm not a great lover of the Brontes but I loved Agnes Grey by Anne Bronte. It's a fast read and could be an ideal one to start with.


C.  (Comment, never msg). Thank you, Teresa! What an interesting suggestion, since Anne seems to be the least famous. I'll pop into my library room and see if I own it. Someone told me I might like "Ulysses" or "Homer's Odyssey". One of them is supposed to be about creatures in a maze and that it is more exciting than I have been aware of.


Teresa Oh they're way too high brow for me. I wouldn't even attempt them. But if you enjoy them then have a go.


message 23: by Tammy (new)

Tammy C. wrote: "Oh, thank you, Tammy! Are you new to classics too or did you dip that toe long ago? I'm well into Canadian classics but wonder which of the Bronte books I might like."

Ages ago. I’d recommend Wuthering Heights but that’s my teenaged self speaking.


message 24: by C. (Comment, never msg). (last edited Mar 25, 2018 02:22PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

C.  (Comment, never msg). Oh good, Tammy! I own that! Do you know which "high brow" has the mazes and creatures: "Ulysses" or "Homer's Odyssey"? I thought the same until I heard it was more eerie and fantasy-like than I was aware of.

Teresa, I wouldn't worry about your home catalogue. I'm the girl who finds it hard to grant five stars to something that doesn't have a hautned house, LOL!


Teresa Ulysses is written as a stream of consciousness novel. They're awfully hard to read. My daughter had to read it over a Summer when she was doing a literature degree and it did her head in! She said 'he might be Irish but he's a pain in the arse to read'!


C.  (Comment, never msg). I hope your daughter did all right! Kate Atkinson writes as stream of consciousness and some are so chatty, they are likewise. It might be "Homer's Odyssey" but I know from whom the suggestion came and will ask Charlotte to refresh me. Proving I don't need to be hesitant about certain books is a nice feeling!


Teresa Yes you're a braver woman than me.


message 28: by C. (Comment, never msg). (last edited Mar 25, 2018 03:20PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

C.  (Comment, never msg). No, no; it's my "haunted house" theme whetting my appetite. Charlotte made it sound practically paranormal and I thought "I can read that"! She's in England, so tomorrow, she'll remind me which book it is. Then my review will tell everyone if it passed muster. Hehehe!


message 29: by Tammy (new)

Tammy C. wrote: "Oh good, Tammy! I own that! Do you know which "high brow" has the mazes and creatures: "Ulysses" or "Homer's Odyssey"? I thought the same until I heard it was more eerie and fantasy-like than I was..."

If I recall correctly it’s The Iliad. Ulysses is the Latin form of Odysseus unless you’re asking about the James Joyce novel which is another kettle of fish


C.  (Comment, never msg). You are certainly well-informed. It is "Iliad" and "Odyssey" that I will buy on the cheap easily and read. I have heard of James Joyce "Ulysses" too and will see if I am keen on that. One likes to be well-refined, if they enjoy it simultaneously.


C.  (Comment, never msg). Hi Greta! Thank you for finding my review and saying something that is wonderful to hear! I was relieved to enjoy Jane Austen when I tried her and plan to tackle "Pride And Prejudice" next month, trusting I will feel the same about her most famous masterpiece. Sincerely, Carolyn.


message 32: by Sylvia (new)

Sylvia Walker What a thoughtful review! I hope you love Pride And Prejudice as much as I do. I consider it to be one of the best books I have ever had the joy of reading.


C.  (Comment, never msg). I am glad you love my review and I hope you saw my thrilled answer to your birthday wishes, dear Sylvia! Yes, if I appreciate Jane's most famous novel as much as billions of people, I shall be happy to join you as a fan. I plan to read it next month. Your friend, Carolyn.


message 34: by da (new)

da AL great review! some of these denser books, I find easier as audiobooks...


C.  (Comment, never msg). Reading with eyes and paper, the books I have spent a lifetime collecting is the pleasure and point for me. However, I hope I conveyed that my fear of these classics was for naught and I didn't find them dense. They were relatable and had me invested in them beyond expectations.


message 36: by Sandra (last edited Dec 29, 2020 09:28PM) (new)

Sandra Wonderful review Carolyn! I've never read a Jane Austen book but I've seen many movie adaptions made to her books. I really enjoyed "Sense and Sensibility" with Emma Thompson and Hugh Grant! :)


C.  (Comment, never msg). Thank you for the compliment to greet my day, Sandra! If that film included Alan Rickman as Brandon, a clip on TV made him seem awkwardly old for the part. We know the eventual husband is their Mom's age but Alan didn't fit. Maybe it would make sense from the beginning. I am glad I am not alone in needed to read the rest of Jane's oeuvres, already on-hand as paperbacks. I will continue in order with "Pride And Prejudice" in 2021.


Kim N Quite unforeseen relief is that “Sense And Sensibility� is supposed to be about two who are different but Elinor & Marianne are loving and loyal. There was no antagonism. They had respectfully different attitudes and coping mannerisms.

Yes, the differences between the sisters did not generate conflict as they likely would in a modern story, a definite plus.

I'm curious to know if you read Pride and Prejudice in 2021 and what you thought of it compared to this book. For awhile P&P was my favorite, but that changed over time and now I prefer Persuasion.


message 39: by C. (Comment, never msg). (last edited Sep 28, 2022 07:00PM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

C.  (Comment, never msg). Hi Kim! I love stories for adventure and discovery instead of conflict, so this was nice. I have not read the next of Jane's books yet but I intend to by next year. I sure wonder if I will love that giant favourite of the world's. I was pleasantly surprised here.


message 40: by [deleted user] (new)

Another beautiful review :) Jane Austen she’s a Queen in my heart, I have read pride and prejudice and persuasion and I will reread them soon, pure classic gems 💎


C.  (Comment, never msg). God bless you for the lovely compliment, my new friend. Oh, it is nice to know you read more than horror. I saw Jane Austen's house when I was in England, Hailey. :) I must read the rest soon. If you love them, so will I. I did love this one to my surprise! Gems are worth seeking. Your new friend, Carolyn.


Alexandra That's a lovely review, Carolyn! I'm always happy to see people enjoying Jane Austen. I find her books surprisingly easy to read, considering when they were written. (But I do love classics in general.) All of Jane's novels have layers and layers of meaning in them, if you care to look. I find something new every time I reread.


message 43: by C. (Comment, never msg). (last edited Jun 11, 2024 11:43AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

C.  (Comment, never msg). Oh, hi Alexandra! I was not shown you treated me to a comment of my review in March. I put off reading "Pride And Prejudice" even though people revere it and I had a good experience with Jane Austen. This will open a large pop culture community of references for me to become privvy to, as well as enjoy it more than I am bracing myself for, I am sure. Classics besides Canadian ones, are not first choice for me. I am always relieved when they are not dull, overly wordy, but are excellent instead.


message 44: by Joe (new)

Joe Krakovsky I agree with what you said about, "I couldn't care less about structural intentions, like “symbolism�." I read a book for entertainment or to learn something, but I am not going to go digging for hidden meanings like a psychiatrist. I could just imagine Jane Austen saying, "I never meant that at all!"


message 45: by C. (Comment, never msg). (last edited Mar 19, 2025 11:32AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

C.  (Comment, never msg). Joe, what a rewarding and helpful response! I am educated but perhaps like a child, I take the words of authors exactly as they are written. They are supposed to tell us a story. You gave me a fresh way to explain to fuddy duddies: "not digging for meanings like a psychiatrist": thank you! I love your musings on Jane thinking we made too much out of her storytelling! Thank you for this smile today. Sincerely, Carolyn.


back to top