ŷ

Madeline's Reviews > The Aeneid

The Aeneid by Virgil
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
111921
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: poetry

"I sing of warfare and a man at war.
From the sea-coast of Troy in early days
He came to Italy by destiny,
To our Lavinian western shore,
A fugitive, this captain, buffeted
Cruelly on land as on the sea
By blows from powers of the air - behind them
Baleful Juno in her sleepless rage.
And cruel losses were his lot in war,
Till he could found a city and bring home
His gods to Latium, land of the Latin race,
The Alban lords, and the high walls of Rome.
Tell me the cause now, O Muse, how galled
In her divine pride, and how sore at heart
From her old wound, the queen of gods compelled him-
A man apart, devoted to his mission-
To undergo so many perilous days
And enter on so many trials."

Years after finally reading The Illiad and The Odyssey (one of my high school classes went over the important bits of The Odyssey, but that was pretty much the beginning and end of my classical education), I got around to reading the Roman side of the story, at last.

Is it blasphemy to say that I like Virgil's version more? Granted, Odysseus is probably a more compelling character, since he's at least morally complex in comparison to Aeneas's bland nobility and piety, but I kind of preferred reading the adventures of a guy who manages to be a hero without also having to be a self-centered, cheating dickbag. Even though I prefer the Greeks to the Romans overall, I'm Team Aeneas on this one, because man, Odysseus sucks. (I have this whole theory that everything that happens in the Odyssey is actually one huge lie concocted by Odysseus to explain why he didn't come home for ten years after the Trojan War)

As in Homer's epics, some of the best parts of this book are the battle descriptions, which are exciting, detailed, and appropriately gory. There's also a lengthy description of the armor that the gods give one of the characters, and even though that sounds boring, it's actually beautiful. And I liked the supporting characters a lot more than I liked Homer's, especially Queen Dido and Camilla the warrior girl. Also Aeneas travels to the Underworld, which is always a fun time.
58 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Aeneid.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

January, 2017 – Started Reading
Finished Reading
February 7, 2018 – Shelved
February 7, 2018 – Shelved as: poetry

Comments Showing 1-28 of 28 (28 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Savanna M. Wells I love your books


message 2: by Øïïå (new)

Øïïå Is that u in your profile photo?


Madeline No, it’s from a movie.


message 4: by Ana (new)

Ana Ruiz your reviews are always my favourites <3


Madeline Dude, you're following me.


message 6: by sky (new)

sky sorry to.butt in but� if you don't like the review then just don't say anything.


message 7: by Øïïå (new)

Øïïå which movie is ur profile photo from?


message 8: by Øïïå (new)

Øïïå BTW BI THINK UR REVIEWS ARE FREAKING GOOD!


Madeline My profile picture is from Fight Club. Please do not watch it until you’re older.


message 10: by kate 9192 (new)

kate 9192 is it really : 0


message 11: by Lydia (new) - added it

Lydia Good


message 12: by 7even (new)

7even Whats your favorite book guys.


message 13: by Øïïå (new)

Øïïå um... Maddie Im probrably older than you or your mum�


Madeline My name’s not Maddie.

And my bad. Made a judgement call based on the way you write, but I don’t know your life.


message 15: by Øïïå (new)

Øïïå Oh sorry Madeline
how old did you think I was?
I would geuss your in your early twenties???


message 16: by 7even (new)

7even Olivia you downwrong sneaky. I am so upset by that. I am 11 but do not be so rude.


Madeline Take it outside, guys. Or at least, off this thread.


message 18: by 7even (new)

7even sorry madeline its Olivia who caused the fight.


Madeline No actually you’re the one who was being antagonistic. If you’re going to start crap like that, don’t hijack another reviewer’s comment thread to do it.


message 20: by Ana (new)

Ana Ruiz :( Perfectly great reviews such as this should have only praise or discussion on the comment section, trolls are just boring. Please don't let them annoy you too much, ŷ needs youuu (at least I'm always happy when I check a book and see that you've reviewed it.)


Madeline They're not even trolls - just people who don't really understand how to use the site.

And I agree - I'd rather have dozens of comments telling me that my opinion on a book is bad and stupid than people using the comment thread as their own personal group chat.


message 22: by 7even (new)

7even Hey I'm not a girl you are.


message 23: by Øïïå (new)

Øïïå oh are you a boy????


message 24: by 7even (new)

7even Maddie you are getting on my nerves.


message 25: by sky (new)

sky get of her review your just spamming her now.


☘Mǰ徱☘ ⚡ϟ⚡⛈⚡☁ ❇️❤❣ Great review! The trolls probably envy you your style. Or will, when/if they grow up.


message 27: by Harshi (new)

Harshi i just love your books Madeline .


B. P. Rinehart I'm glad I am not the only one to prefer this poem to The Odyssey. I especially liked Camilla in this--can't imagine such a figure in Homer.


back to top