Elle (ellexamines on TT & Substack)'s Reviews > Witchmark
Witchmark (The Kingston Cycle, #1)
by
by

Elle (ellexamines on TT & Substack)'s review
bookshelves: 5-star, z-read2018, via-arc, z-favs2018, favorite-characters, favorite-relationships, fantasy, speculative-fic-fabulism, lgbtq, elle-recs-list, authors-of-color
Jun 04, 2018
bookshelves: 5-star, z-read2018, via-arc, z-favs2018, favorite-characters, favorite-relationships, fantasy, speculative-fic-fabulism, lgbtq, elle-recs-list, authors-of-color
You know when you read a really good romance, or your nostalgic favorite childhood series, and yes, you know that there might be a few tropes, but you are just so invested in everything within the story, and you want to praise it forever and send it to all your friends? That’s how I feel about this book. This has all the good qualities of really good romance [well-used tropes, story beats we can sense but still aren’t bored by, interesting and likable characters] and then all the good qualities of a good fantasy novel [great worldbuilding, compelling thematic journey] and then all the good qualities of a murder mystery [murder! intrigue! maybe family being evil? we'll just have to see!] and it is so so lovely.
Witchmark is sort of steampunk-fantasy murder-mystery with paranormal romance vibes set in a world inspired by WWI Britain, following a witch disguising himself as a doctor to avoid being essentially enslaved by his sister, Grace.
→w´Ç°ù±ô»å²ú³Ü¾±±ô»å¾±²Ô²µâ†�
So first of all, the worldbuilding of this book is completely excellent. The inspiration for this book is super palpable and clear and it works very well. I don't tend to get that into worldbuilding, but this world is just imaginative enough and just obscure enough to feel enthralling.
→plot & pacing�
I mean, see what I said above about tropes used well; the plot isn't necessarily the most original thing ever, but it has some good moments. This murder mystery, especially, is super interesting. This book is full of twists and cool reveals and interesting points. And also� I kind of devoured this? Aside from the first hundred pages, I binged the entire thing in a night, and I was so addicted.
→c³ó²¹°ù²¹³¦³Ù±ð°ù²õâ†�
I really liked both Tristan & Miles as characters. Miles especially has a lot of inner depth, and his conflict over his family is really well-done and lovely, and also I talked about him more below, and he means a lot to me. And then there’s the romance between Miles & Tristan. And� so listen, this romance does have a bit of instalove going on. But their dynamic is so lovely and full of care and I am so into it.
→t³ó±ð³¾±ð²õâ†�
So first of all, I would die for the way agency is tackled in this book. Miles is absolutely driven by his need for agency, for independence, for release from being under the boot of his family. And even when he’s offered freedom within that role, he doesn’t want it because he knows that freedom would be conditional. He knows it could be taken away at any moment. It's also a very good exploration of class privilege. I really love discussions of agency and I think this book really did a great job playing with it. I also love everything my blogger friend mentioned here.
I was confused at first about why another book is coming [I want more but this wrapped up so well!!] and it turns out it’s focusing on Grace, a character I liked but was not obsessed with. But I'm still super super excited.
But basically, I would die for this book. I would die for the Super Important Agency Focus and I would die for the plot twists and I would definitely die for Tristan and Miles. This is one of my favorite books I’ve read this year and I would totally add it to your list of 2018 releases, because it is not to be missed.
| Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ | |
Witchmark is sort of steampunk-fantasy murder-mystery with paranormal romance vibes set in a world inspired by WWI Britain, following a witch disguising himself as a doctor to avoid being essentially enslaved by his sister, Grace.
→w´Ç°ù±ô»å²ú³Ü¾±±ô»å¾±²Ô²µâ†�
So first of all, the worldbuilding of this book is completely excellent. The inspiration for this book is super palpable and clear and it works very well. I don't tend to get that into worldbuilding, but this world is just imaginative enough and just obscure enough to feel enthralling.
→plot & pacing�
I mean, see what I said above about tropes used well; the plot isn't necessarily the most original thing ever, but it has some good moments. This murder mystery, especially, is super interesting. This book is full of twists and cool reveals and interesting points. And also� I kind of devoured this? Aside from the first hundred pages, I binged the entire thing in a night, and I was so addicted.
→c³ó²¹°ù²¹³¦³Ù±ð°ù²õâ†�
I really liked both Tristan & Miles as characters. Miles especially has a lot of inner depth, and his conflict over his family is really well-done and lovely, and also I talked about him more below, and he means a lot to me. And then there’s the romance between Miles & Tristan. And� so listen, this romance does have a bit of instalove going on. But their dynamic is so lovely and full of care and I am so into it.
→t³ó±ð³¾±ð²õâ†�
So first of all, I would die for the way agency is tackled in this book. Miles is absolutely driven by his need for agency, for independence, for release from being under the boot of his family. And even when he’s offered freedom within that role, he doesn’t want it because he knows that freedom would be conditional. He knows it could be taken away at any moment. It's also a very good exploration of class privilege. I really love discussions of agency and I think this book really did a great job playing with it. I also love everything my blogger friend mentioned here.
I was confused at first about why another book is coming [I want more but this wrapped up so well!!] and it turns out it’s focusing on Grace, a character I liked but was not obsessed with. But I'm still super super excited.
But basically, I would die for this book. I would die for the Super Important Agency Focus and I would die for the plot twists and I would definitely die for Tristan and Miles. This is one of my favorite books I’ve read this year and I would totally add it to your list of 2018 releases, because it is not to be missed.
| Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ | |
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Witchmark.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
February 19, 2018
– Shelved
February 19, 2018
– Shelved as:
releases-2018
February 27, 2018
– Shelved as:
must-reads-arcs
March 1, 2018
– Shelved as:
must-reads-2018-april
April 15, 2018
– Shelved as:
to-read
June 4, 2018
–
Started Reading
June 4, 2018
–
16.35%
"ooooh I really like this!! a lot of discussion of ptsd and society’s lack of care for it, very strong focus on agency, and instantly likable characters 💕💕"
page
52
June 6, 2018
– Shelved as:
5-star
June 6, 2018
– Shelved as:
z-read2018
June 6, 2018
– Shelved as:
via-arc
June 6, 2018
– Shelved as:
z-favs2018
June 6, 2018
– Shelved as:
favorite-characters
June 6, 2018
– Shelved as:
favorite-relationships
June 6, 2018
– Shelved as:
fantasy
June 6, 2018
– Shelved as:
speculative-fic-fabulism
June 6, 2018
– Shelved as:
lgbtq
June 6, 2018
–
Finished Reading
July 10, 2018
– Shelved as:
elle-recs-list
May 8, 2021
– Shelved as:
authors-of-color
Comments Showing 1-40 of 40 (40 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Tucker
(new)
Jun 05, 2018 05:16AM

reply
|
flag

oh my god yes!! it's really great.

Always wary about books that have less than 300 pages, but this is close enough and well... if it doesn't need more.


It reminded me of (well-written) fanfiction too, which I didn't expect at all - since it was about PTSD and persecuted witches, I thought it was going to be way darker than it actually was? I'm glad it wasn't, though.
I didn't love Grace either and for a moment I was disappointed when I heard the second book was about her, but now I think she has potential exactly because she is very flawed (women with flaws and interesting arcs. Better if queer. That's all I ask).
The other PoV character will be Avia Jessup, which we saw very little of in this one, but she seems really interesting...

I’m hoping for queer Grace too! she didn’t really grab me here, but she definitely has potential. and oooh, I think I remember liking Avia from what we saw of her.


No, this refers mostly to style - the tropes and some of the writing reminded me of a lot of the good fanfiction I've read. I don't know exactly how to explain it - if you're curious, it might be worth looking up good fanfiction of something you enjoy? but maybe it's just my personal experience!

haha, I think my first fanfiction experiences were all television, but i remember them VIVIDLY. it was such an experience for young me :)


keep your spirit solidly in your own lane

I haven't even read it yet and her hyperbolic praise has set me off of it completely. I mean... I hope she doesn't actually have to DIE (insert eyes rolling here).

I haven't even read it yet and her hyp..."
you know what i would die for? a world in which rude people don't come on my book reviews to make fun of them. acknowledge that you're only being rude right now because you're upset about something else in your life, realize that you're talking to a real live person, consider whether your moral compass tends to incite you to straight-up comment (insert eye rolling here) on the post of someone you don't know, stop being petty over the internet, write your own damn review, and move on

<3 <3 <3 sometimes people are yikes!!

<3 <3 sometimes i have good clapbacks


tfw you just don't know how to own that Super Dumb Girl back


