Julie G's Reviews > Moving On
Moving On
by
by

Julie G's review
bookshelves: you-ll-need-a-cigarette, your-cheatin-heart, larry-i-love-you, don-t-mess-with-texas, 70s-forever-more-1970s-titles, love-and-marriage, what-a-character
Mar 23, 2018
bookshelves: you-ll-need-a-cigarette, your-cheatin-heart, larry-i-love-you, don-t-mess-with-texas, 70s-forever-more-1970s-titles, love-and-marriage, what-a-character
Trying to have an affair in this town would be nerve-wracking as hell, no matter who you are or who it's with. Monogamy must have been invented for dumps like Amarillo.
When Larry McMurtry published Moving On in 1970, his writing was greeted by an angry mob of women, all seemingly armed with rotten tomatoes. He was then properly pelted with figurative produce and literal hate mail and was forced to pull off his ten-gallon hat to ponder his position.
Larry was so confused! Why didn't the world realize how much he loved his protagonist, Patsy Carpenter? Why didn't women the world over love her as he did? Yes, she cried at the drop of a hat, but all women did that, didn't they?
But, after several years of this novel's terrible reception, Mr. McMurtry was forced to concede, “I had inadvertently left a copiously tearful young woman exposed on a lonely beach, just as the tsunami of feminism was about to crash ashore.�
And, instead of being nominated for the National Book Award (as it should have been), Moving On slipped into an obscurity that is every writer's nightmare. Even now, the book is challenging to casually locate on a Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ search, unless you include McMurtry's name with the title, and my local library had to sweat a little to find an available copy.
This book's near obscurity makes me want to cry as much as Mr. McMurtry's leading lady does.
And, no, Larry, I don't want to cry because of your belief that “virtually all women cry virtually all the time,� but because I hate for this level of fantastic writing to be relegated to the dark shadows of obscure libraries, or worse, to be rendered out of print.
And, Larry, you were wrong. All women do not cry all of the time, or as often as Patsy does, though I have known two women in my lifetime who have been as prone to tears, proving that a Patsy Carpenter can absolutely be true.
But, let me tell you who did cry, you fabulous son of a bitch: me. I cried throughout this whole goddamned, brilliant masterpiece. And, I cried so hard, I felt gutted. Cried so hard over lines like these:
At night, when some embrace on the late show reminded her that in the real world, as on the TV screen, humans did actually kiss and hold each other and make love she felt humiliated and small, for she was a woman, she had had a baby, she was ready to give such plenty as she had, and yet no man was there to touch her.
I cried again, just typing it, you bastard. Larry, why do you do this to me?
People, don't stumble over Texans and rodeos and crying protagonists here. This is a book about men and women, and how their differences in communication and physical preferences can isolate them so profoundly from the ones they love. It's a brilliant and almost incomparable examination of monogamy and it juxtaposes so many combinations of coupling (and living alone), it makes you realize that any happiness you're ever lucky enough to grasp with your two hands should be popped into your mouth immediately and consumed.
This isn't a novel for people who require action or intrigue (or zombies). This is a book about people and relationships and it's ideal for readers who love writers like Ian McEwan, Ernest Hemingway, John Updike and Graham Greene.
Oh. And for people who can handle a good, gut wrenching cry.
When Larry McMurtry published Moving On in 1970, his writing was greeted by an angry mob of women, all seemingly armed with rotten tomatoes. He was then properly pelted with figurative produce and literal hate mail and was forced to pull off his ten-gallon hat to ponder his position.
Larry was so confused! Why didn't the world realize how much he loved his protagonist, Patsy Carpenter? Why didn't women the world over love her as he did? Yes, she cried at the drop of a hat, but all women did that, didn't they?
But, after several years of this novel's terrible reception, Mr. McMurtry was forced to concede, “I had inadvertently left a copiously tearful young woman exposed on a lonely beach, just as the tsunami of feminism was about to crash ashore.�
And, instead of being nominated for the National Book Award (as it should have been), Moving On slipped into an obscurity that is every writer's nightmare. Even now, the book is challenging to casually locate on a Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ search, unless you include McMurtry's name with the title, and my local library had to sweat a little to find an available copy.
This book's near obscurity makes me want to cry as much as Mr. McMurtry's leading lady does.
And, no, Larry, I don't want to cry because of your belief that “virtually all women cry virtually all the time,� but because I hate for this level of fantastic writing to be relegated to the dark shadows of obscure libraries, or worse, to be rendered out of print.
And, Larry, you were wrong. All women do not cry all of the time, or as often as Patsy does, though I have known two women in my lifetime who have been as prone to tears, proving that a Patsy Carpenter can absolutely be true.
But, let me tell you who did cry, you fabulous son of a bitch: me. I cried throughout this whole goddamned, brilliant masterpiece. And, I cried so hard, I felt gutted. Cried so hard over lines like these:
At night, when some embrace on the late show reminded her that in the real world, as on the TV screen, humans did actually kiss and hold each other and make love she felt humiliated and small, for she was a woman, she had had a baby, she was ready to give such plenty as she had, and yet no man was there to touch her.
I cried again, just typing it, you bastard. Larry, why do you do this to me?
People, don't stumble over Texans and rodeos and crying protagonists here. This is a book about men and women, and how their differences in communication and physical preferences can isolate them so profoundly from the ones they love. It's a brilliant and almost incomparable examination of monogamy and it juxtaposes so many combinations of coupling (and living alone), it makes you realize that any happiness you're ever lucky enough to grasp with your two hands should be popped into your mouth immediately and consumed.
This isn't a novel for people who require action or intrigue (or zombies). This is a book about people and relationships and it's ideal for readers who love writers like Ian McEwan, Ernest Hemingway, John Updike and Graham Greene.
Oh. And for people who can handle a good, gut wrenching cry.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Moving On.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
March 17, 2018
–
Started Reading
March 18, 2018
– Shelved
March 18, 2018
–
6.75%
"Jim was in the waiting room alone, sitting on a couch with his eyes shut. "No one's here," he said, but no sooner had he said it than a fat implacably jolly nurse walked in and stood with her hands on her hips looking at Jim. . . . "I see the bloodshed's begun," she said. "Doctor'll be out in a minute. He's pumpin' out a kid who had himself some rat poison for dinner. It's a wonder that any of us survive.""
page
68
March 19, 2018
–
24.5%
""The one advantage of kids is that they take your mind off husbands," Emma said, fanning herself ineffectively. It was only ten in the morning but the park was already hot.
"Do they take husband's minds off you? If they do, I'll have to take a lover or something, just to have someone to talk to.""
page
247
"Do they take husband's minds off you? If they do, I'll have to take a lover or something, just to have someone to talk to.""
March 22, 2018
–
52.08%
"Patsy was hoping he would say something nice, something gentler, before he hung up, so she could go to sleep feeling in rapport with him. Jim was hoping she would do the same. Both of them concentrated on not saying anything wrong; neither said anything. . ."
page
525
March 23, 2018
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-50 of 90 (90 new)
message 1:
by
Betsy
(new)
Mar 23, 2018 11:14AM

reply
|
flag

I read it in 6 days, if that tells you anything. . .


It's sad but true. Plus, buy yourself a pack of cigarettes before you start. I've never been closer to smoking cigarettes or getting in my car to drive to a cowboy bar in Cheyenne.

I'd don a ten-gallon hat, if I thought that badass Texan would even so much as glance in my direction!

It's sad but true. Plus, buy yourself a pack of cigarettes before you start. I've never been closer to smoking cigarettes or getting in my car to drive to a cowboy bar in Cheyenne."
Julie, I'll meet you in Cheyenne with a pack of cigarettes. I'm way overdue for some time away! ;0

I'm so overdue for time away. . . that a Best Western in Cheyenne sounds almost as enticing as any hotel in Paris!

I'm so overdue for time away. . . that a Best Western in Cheyenne sounds almost as enticing as any hotel in Paris!"
Lol, I hear ya', Julie!


It's so character and dialogue-driven, I can't see you turning your face away from this one. Plus, it's *almost* as sexy as Updike!


Lonesome Dove definitely has a broader, more epic scope than this one (and more overall "plot"), but both novels are strong with characters and dialogue. I feel like everyone should read Lonesome Dove at least once, more so than Moving On, but if you happen to love The Sun Also Rises, this feels like the Texas version to me!
(P.S. Thank you!)


I think you'll like it, even if it is a massive read. Just grab your cigarettes and ask your husband to be very nice, in the background, while you read it!



I thought of you for several reasons. First, you love Mr. McMurtry like I do, second, you love an epic, and third, it is the ranch and the exposure to animals that starts to shift the flighty Patsy Carpenter's heart, and I know how you love animals!
Disclaimer: I can not be blamed if it causes you, or anyone else, to seek out an extramarital affair!

That's the great thing about Vegas. It's like Epcot: we can get the best margaritas from one hotel, Greek food from another, and cigarettes from strippers.




You are so right; Texas is HUGE! You'd need to spend a lot of time there just to get an accurate feel of the diversity of the state. McMurtry's characters were very unkind toward Amarillo, and they weren't too generous with Houston, either. In this novel, Dallas is *the* place to be!


I don't cry all the time, but that's also why I love reading books that move me to tears: the endorphins are awesome! :)


Lonesome Dove definitely has a broader, more epic scope than this one (and more overall "plot"), but both novels are strong with characters and dialogue. I feel like everyone should read ..."
Lol, a Texas version of The Sun... a book I've been reading since my teen years.
I went through a phase reading this author after Lonesome Dove came out, read all kinds of his books, but never saw this one.
I'll keep my eyes open for it.

You are a refreshing human being! Like, one in ten million??
Larry McMurtry is most famous for his magnum opus, Lonesome Dove, and I can't recommend it enough, but I think that I'm feeling intuitively that I'd like to recommend Terms of Endearment to you. Several readers have had a problem with that book, because they watched the movie first and they had the actors stuck in their head and so on, but I don't think you're going to have that problem. I think you'd have fun with it.

I had a grandmother who cried so often, she was known for staying out in the car while friends and family went in to the restaurant to eat without her. It almost completely went away after menopause, so I often suspected she was either allergic to her marriage or had a hormonal imbalance that went untreated.
You don't seem like much of a crier to me (unless you're on a pilgrimage with Harold Fry), and I'm not either, but I did cry through much of this book.


Larry McMurtry was born in 1936, and he claims that he watched/experienced women cry excessively, seems like until about the mid-1960s. That's obviously just his perspective, but it is interesting, especially if we consider that it was almost impossible to leave a bad marriage at that time, not to mention the lack of educational and professional opportunities for women. I'd probably have been crying every day.
(Thank you, by the way, both for reading this and for your thought-provoking comment).

I had a grandmother who cried so often, she was known for staying out in the car while friends and family went in to the restaurant to eat without her. It almost completely went away after menopause, so I often suspected she was either allergic to her marriage or had a hormonal imbalance that went untreated.
You don't seem like much of a crier to me (unless you're on a pilgrimage with Harold Fry), and I'm not either, but I did cry through much of this book."
I'm glad you said I don't seem like much of a crier - mostly I cry when I read something that is deeply touching for me . . . or when I watch certain things on YouTube like figure skating (am I crying because I totally can't skate or just because it's so beautiful?) I also cry when watching clips from Talent Shows on YouTube - again, it's the beauty of the songs sometimes - or an especially endearing audition. So, I guess the things that make me cry are poignant, endearing, beautiful, or just plain touching. :)
Re: your grandmother's tears being either an allergy to her marriage or hormone shifts - ahahaha - but you may be on to something there. "Back then" there was very little knowledge about or treatment for rapid hormone changes.
I was lucky because I was still in pre-menopause when I came upon a supplement in the Health Food Store that was developed by a nurse and a naturopath in Saskatchewan. I took it as a daily supplement for about two years and breezed through everything.

I have cried harder watching Michelle Kwan ice skate than I have at almost any other single event of my life. Do what you will with that information!
Also, my family seems super interested to know the name of this product that eases perimenopausal symptoms, like shouting and crying.
Does it still exist? If so, will you send me a message with the name of it?


I have read a lot by Mr. McMurtry, and even though I especially love Moving On, The Last Picture Show, AND Terms of Endearment, you must read Lonesome Dove. Once you read it, I can pretty much guarantee that you will wonder what took you so long.


If you think this cover is bad, you should see it on my copy! Ain't nobody gave the cover art or the title any love. It's too bad, because the narrative, the character development and the dialogue here are all first rate.