Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Jeb Dubus's Reviews > The Old Man and the Sea

The Old Man and the Sea by Ernest Hemingway
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
6890042
's review

it was amazing

Well it isn't about men and fish at all. Writers can only write what they know about to reveal a deeper understanding. It could have easily been a story of a woman carrying her children up a mountain to safety durring a winter's war, and having to talk herself out of giving up no matter what cost to herself, holding on to a hope for a better life. But Hemingway picked an old man and an ocean. An old man instead of a young one so there is a deeper connection to mortality and weariness. But it is the end of the story that reveals a deeper understanding about our sufferring in solitude. The first people to comment on the old man's boat are tourists who say "I didn't know sharks had such beautiful fins" they don't even know it's a tuna! We all have people like this in our lives: those that don't have the slightest idea what we persevere. The second to comment on what the old man endured are the keepers at the cabana. They accually know by looking at the mutilated tuna and the man being gone for so long what he must have gone through, but they just say: "why doesn't he just quit?"
We all have this kind around is too.They see what we go through but distance themselves.
But the third who comes is the boy who as soon as sees the fish he weeps and runs to the man's shack, and goes to get food for him, and tends to him, and tells the old man when you feel better I'll go out with you. This kind of person, this kind of love we don't get often if ever. So yes the story of the old man and the sea uses this plot of fishing alone to explore our struggle in solitude and how we talk ourselves through it alone and also that we have people around us who can't see us or do but don't care and then there are the treasures who really feel for us and will do whatever it takes to reduce our sufferring no matter what cost to themselves because they really love us.
5 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Old Man and the Sea.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

Finished Reading
November 8, 2011 – Shelved

Comments Showing 1-4 of 4 (4 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Sandy (new)

Sandy What a beautiful, insightful review. Thank you. Finally! Someone who isn't caught up in the literal nor distracted by the entertainment value (or lack thereof some would say). I felt the pain with this one too. Nice to know we're not alone, eh?


message 2: by Jeb (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jeb Dubus Hi and thank you Sandy. Its consistently puzzling to me when people seem to only be able to experience the plot in art and not it's themes. I wonder if this means the themes in their lives also cannot be perceived, contemplated, that may reveal some deeper truth about their struggle or beauty or connection to humanity, a lineal consciousness, first this happened then that , then that...maybe it's a blessing. Have you ever scene Sister Wendy Becket talk about paintings? She has an exist ordinary ability to see past the plot and sense themes.
Thank you again Sandy


message 3: by Sandy (new)

Sandy That's a great point and sadly, I suspect that you're exactly right - because they are concerned with events and "steps" to be taken, their perspective is limited and maybe that actually is a blessing. I think I'm envious of that ability (inability?) on some level. On the other hand, maybe Nietzsche was right and those who don't feel as much pain as possible are not capable of experiencing true joy either. And maybe that kind of true joy - the really pure kind - comes in the moments when the struggle can be appreciated and maybe even be seen as the thing of beauty itself. And that can't happen if you live life near the surface. Until today, I had not had a chance to see Sister Wendy Becket so, after I read this I looked up some video of her and the very first piece I saw was of her speaking on Van Gogh's "Artist's Bedroom". It was brilliant (and very moving). I sought out some of the other videos and will find more. What a treasure she is. Thank you so much for mentioning her - I feel like I've been given a great gift.


message 4: by Jeb (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jeb Dubus Oh Sandy Im happy you liked sister Wendy. She had a PBS series and a collection of all the episodes is on video. Perfect!
Yeah and socrates quote: "an unexamined life is not worth living"
Well unless your a bird or something. A cat.


back to top