ŷ

Cecily's Reviews > Black Swan Green

Black Swan Green by David Mitchell
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1199525
There is little narrative drive, but Mitchell is pretty much my age and this is heavily autobiographical, so I enjoyed being transported to a fairly accurate version of a world I remember. I could imagine knowing someone like Jason, maybe even being him some of the time.

The narration by a stuttering 13 year old boy is slightly reminiscent of Mark Haddon's Curious Incident, but not as convincing or interesting.

It mentions specific 70s brands and products too deliberately - as if he's trying to make it understandable far in the future, not at all how such a boy would have described things at the time. Also, it makes it read rather like Nigel Slater's Toast and Andrew Collins' opposite of misery-lit, Where Did it All go Right? autobiogs, which at least had a more valid reason for so doing - and he does credit the latter.

Overall, disappointing - even if not comparing it with his brilliant "Ghostwritten" and "Cloud Atlas".

Uses his trick of inserting characters from other books:

* Madame Crommelynck is the composer's daughter from Cloud Atlas

* Neal Brose is a an entrepreneurial bully who becomes a major character in Ghostwritten

* Number 9 Dream is a Beatles song that plays at a disco as well as being the title of another Mitchell book Number 9 Dream

* The dodgy older cousin, Hugo Lamb, is a major character in The Bone Clocks
31 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Black Swan Green.
Sign In »

Quotes Cecily Liked

David Mitchell
“Trees're always a relief, after people.”
David Mitchell, Black Swan Green


Reading Progress

Finished Reading
May 30, 2008 – Shelved
June 9, 2008 – Shelved as: miscellaneous-fiction
October 31, 2015 – Shelved as: mitchell-uber-book
September 22, 2024 – Shelved as: autism-maybe
September 22, 2024 – Shelved as: biog-and-autobiog
September 22, 2024 – Shelved as: uk
September 22, 2024 – Shelved as: solitary-protagonist

Comments Showing 1-4 of 4 (4 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by É (new) - rated it 5 stars

É Aguilar Did you notice the frequent appearances of the “moon-gray cat�? It appears on Bone Clocks and Jacob de Zoet as well


Cecily I didn't (though I included a quote about it in my JdZ review). Thank you.


Will Ansbacher How funny that you thought a 13-year-old wouldn't mention 70's brands and products the way Jason did! I clearly remember at that age, boring the pants off my parents with New Zealand Railways arcana. With others, it was the merits of Hornby versus Triang model trains. Perhaps it's a male adolescent thing?


Cecily Will wrote: "How funny that you thought a 13-year-old wouldn't mention 70's brands and products the way Jason did! I clearly remember at that age... Perhaps it's a male adolescent thing?"

As far as I can remember all these years later, it was the WAY he mentioned them that struck a wrong note for me, and the fact they were not necessarily the sort of brands that geeks and collectors cared about. However, as you say, there may also be a male adolescent angle.


back to top