Cecily's Reviews > Black Swan Green
Black Swan Green
by
by

Cecily's review
bookshelves: miscellaneous-fiction, mitchell-uber-book, autism-maybe, biog-and-autobiog, uk, solitary-protagonist
May 30, 2008
bookshelves: miscellaneous-fiction, mitchell-uber-book, autism-maybe, biog-and-autobiog, uk, solitary-protagonist
There is little narrative drive, but Mitchell is pretty much my age and this is heavily autobiographical, so I enjoyed being transported to a fairly accurate version of a world I remember. I could imagine knowing someone like Jason, maybe even being him some of the time.
The narration by a stuttering 13 year old boy is slightly reminiscent of Mark Haddon's Curious Incident, but not as convincing or interesting.
It mentions specific 70s brands and products too deliberately - as if he's trying to make it understandable far in the future, not at all how such a boy would have described things at the time. Also, it makes it read rather like Nigel Slater's Toast and Andrew Collins' opposite of misery-lit, Where Did it All go Right? autobiogs, which at least had a more valid reason for so doing - and he does credit the latter.
Overall, disappointing - even if not comparing it with his brilliant "Ghostwritten" and "Cloud Atlas".
Uses his trick of inserting characters from other books:
* Madame Crommelynck is the composer's daughter from Cloud Atlas
* Neal Brose is a an entrepreneurial bully who becomes a major character in Ghostwritten
* Number 9 Dream is a Beatles song that plays at a disco as well as being the title of another Mitchell book Number 9 Dream
* The dodgy older cousin, Hugo Lamb, is a major character in The Bone Clocks
The narration by a stuttering 13 year old boy is slightly reminiscent of Mark Haddon's Curious Incident, but not as convincing or interesting.
It mentions specific 70s brands and products too deliberately - as if he's trying to make it understandable far in the future, not at all how such a boy would have described things at the time. Also, it makes it read rather like Nigel Slater's Toast and Andrew Collins' opposite of misery-lit, Where Did it All go Right? autobiogs, which at least had a more valid reason for so doing - and he does credit the latter.
Overall, disappointing - even if not comparing it with his brilliant "Ghostwritten" and "Cloud Atlas".
Uses his trick of inserting characters from other books:
* Madame Crommelynck is the composer's daughter from Cloud Atlas
* Neal Brose is a an entrepreneurial bully who becomes a major character in Ghostwritten
* Number 9 Dream is a Beatles song that plays at a disco as well as being the title of another Mitchell book Number 9 Dream
* The dodgy older cousin, Hugo Lamb, is a major character in The Bone Clocks
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
Black Swan Green.
Sign In »
Quotes Cecily Liked
Reading Progress
Finished Reading
May 30, 2008
– Shelved
June 9, 2008
– Shelved as:
miscellaneous-fiction
October 31, 2015
– Shelved as:
mitchell-uber-book
September 22, 2024
– Shelved as:
autism-maybe
September 22, 2024
– Shelved as:
biog-and-autobiog
September 22, 2024
– Shelved as:
uk
September 22, 2024
– Shelved as:
solitary-protagonist
Comments Showing 1-4 of 4 (4 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
É
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Dec 29, 2015 12:30AM

reply
|
flag


As far as I can remember all these years later, it was the WAY he mentioned them that struck a wrong note for me, and the fact they were not necessarily the sort of brands that geeks and collectors cared about. However, as you say, there may also be a male adolescent angle.