ŷ

Miranda Reads's Reviews > Bear

Bear by Marian Engel
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
71848701
's review

did not like it
bookshelves: dumpster-fire, literally-painful-to-read

** spoiler alert ** She f*cked a bear.

She literally f*cked a bear.

No. This isn't some euphemism for a beefy gay man.

She motherf*cking literally f*cked a literal bear.

What. The. Hell.

Okay. So. I'm not a cultured reader. I read mostly YA and...well...that's about it. BUT, I am a reader. A layman reader. So, here is the review from a casual just-for-fun reader:

She f*cked a bear.

For the record: did I pick up this book knowing there will be bear-f*ckery? No.

I picked it because I wanted (for once) to read a novel. I wanted one of those fancy English-students-read-this sort of novels.

I found this 120ish page book on the "suggested reads" table of my local library. Here's the blurb from the back:
Marian Engel, one of Canada's most celebrated and provocative novelest, died...The short and controversal novel "Bear," her last and best-known work...
It sounded good - it had all the hallmarks for cultured reading, right? It won prizes, it's by a treasured national author, it was controversial. I was pumped - watch out world, I'm gonna get cultured.

The book started off okay. It's a bit pretentious but it was manageable. There's an isolated, island house donated to a historical society and it's filled with old books.
For once, instead of Sunday school attendance certificates, old emigration documents, envelopes of unidentified farmer's Sunday photographs and withered love letters, something of read value had been left to them.
A librarian (Lou) is sent there for the summer to categorize and catalog the collection. There's an old bear chained up that was the family pet that our Lou needs to care for.

At this point, the book wasn't too bad. It wasn't particularly gripping but hey. Not bad. Then we get to the "First Look":
As she sat down, she realized the bear was standing in his doorway staring at her.

Bear. There. Staring.

She stared back.
Again, not bad. She starts to befriend the bear, bringing him food, petting his fur, giving him anthropomorphic characteristics....essentially all the things that even a five year old knows NOT to do with a wild animal.

At one point Lou walks the bear on his chain to the island's edge and as the bear swims, she jumps in naked.

Yes, it was a bit odd - it was odd that she thinks of the bear with so many human emotions, that she goes skinny-dipping with him, that she notices his very "male-ness" when she first meets him....but I maintain that at this point, there wasn't any indication that things were going to go so far south.

I remember thinking, "Oh jeez. That's those fancy-novels. Free spirits. Wouldn't it be funny if..."

Turns out, that was not funny.

To summarize the rest of the book: (And note, I'm summarizing this in the blandest way possible but I'm still putting it as a spoiler - so you have been warned):

(view spoiler)

To use one of the side character's words:
"People get funny when they're too much alone."
Did the side character know? Did anyone find out? What was the plot?

Honestly, from pg 80 on I skipped every page that involved genitalia and stimulation thus reading maybe 20 of the 40 remaining pages. It was just too much.

I didn't get the plot but I am not going back for it.

| | | | | Snapchat @miranda_reads
567 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Bear.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 25, 2018 – Started Reading
March 25, 2018 – Shelved
March 25, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 216 (216 new)


message 1: by Clare (new)

Clare Snow Spoiler alert 😉


message 2: by [deleted user] (new)

Wow... I'll stay away from this one Miranda ;o)


Miranda Reads Clare wrote: "Spoiler alert 😉"

Sorry :P I did throw in a spoiler section to keep the major moments hidden :P


Miranda Reads J.K. wrote: "Wow... I'll stay away from this one Miranda ;o)"

Yeahhhh....not a fan of this one. I wish I could scrub my brain.


message 5: by Tom (new)

Tom Lewis Bahahaha! And just when you thought you'd heard it all...


Miranda Reads Tom wrote: "Bahahaha! And just when you thought you'd heard it all..."

You should've heard me when I was reading it. Ohhh, I was RANTING and RAVING.


message 7: by Lori (new)

Lori I like your bookshelves for this one.


Miranda Reads Lori wrote: "I like your bookshelves for this one."

Haha, thank you :P


message 9: by Tom (new)

Tom Lewis Miranda wrote: "Tom wrote: "Bahahaha! And just when you thought you'd heard it all..."

You should've heard me when I was reading it. Ohhh, I was RANTING and RAVING."


El Oh El!! I can imagine!!


Miranda Reads Tom wrote: "El Oh El!! I can imagine!!"

I don't think I can ever look a bear in the eyes again.


message 11: by Tom (new)

Tom Lewis Miranda wrote: "Tom wrote: "El Oh El!! I can imagine!!"

I don't think I can ever look a bear in the eyes again."


Bahaha! I suddenly no longer feel dirty for loving "All the Ugly and Wonderful Things". Thank you "Bear" for redefining "disturbing." =)


message 12: by Michelle (new)

Michelle Yikes!


Miranda Reads Tom wrote: "Bahaha! I suddenly no longer feel dirty for loving "All the Ugly and Wonderful Thi..."

Haven't read that....but making the mental note not to :P


Miranda Reads Michelle wrote: "Yikes!"

Exaaaaactly. Yuck.


message 15: by Debra (new)

Debra Johnson Omg! Are you kidding me?! Wth!!
Ewww #@#@#@ Yuck#@#@#@ Gross@#@@#@#
I love a good Adult Book, Not Animal Sexual Harassment.
I don't know what to say.....I am flabbergasted. And thoroughly disgusted!!!!!!
Eww I just did a physical heebie jeebie


message 16: by Lo9man88 (new)

Lo9man88 Holy-f... thank you very much for your review : it made my day ...


Miranda Reads Debra wrote: "Omg! Are you kidding me?! Wth!!
Ewww #@#@#@ Yuck#@#@#@ Gross@#@@#@#
I love a good Adult Book, Not Animal Sexual Harassment.
I don't know what to say.....I am flabbergasted. And thoroughly disguste..."


I don't understand how this was written? What editor went, "mm, great idea. Really like the bestiality in this one. Publish it as is."


Miranda Reads Lo9man88 wrote: "Holy-f... thank you very much for your review : it made my day ..."

Glad someone's day was made :P


message 19: by A. (new)

A. Welcome to the modern world :



message 20: by Debra (new)

Debra Johnson Honestly, I am often amazed by some of the absolute trash that gets published. Not only by Indie and Self-published, but also by actual publishing companies.
It's not only the content of the story, but the shabby editing of a book and the grammatical errors that can be rampant in them, that blows my mind.


Miranda Reads A. wrote: "Welcome to the modern world :
"


What the hell Canada??


Miranda Reads Debra wrote: "Honestly, I am often amazed by some of the absolute trash that gets published. Not only by Indie and Self-published, but also by actual publishing companies.
It's not only the content of the story..."


I'm pretty bad at noticing grammatical errors :P Once I get caught up in stories, I hardly notice the text :P


The Girl with the Sagittarius Tattoo I am honestly laughing at this review! On the other hand, I just read a terrifically stupid romance novel involving a human woman and a shapeshifting dragon, so... who am I to judge.


message 24: by Debra (new)

Debra Johnson A. wrote: "Welcome to the modern world :
"


I clicked on that link. And EWWWWWW


message 25: by Debra (new)

Debra Johnson Elaine wrote: "I am honestly laughing at this review! On the other hand, I just read a terrifically stupid romance novel involving a human woman and a shapeshifting dragon, so... who am I to judge."
But Elaine, thats a SHAPESHIFTING dragon. Which means he/she is part human. Or even mostly human, but magical. HUGE difference.


Miranda Reads Debra wrote: "A. wrote: "Welcome to the modern world :
"

I clicked on that link. And EWWWWWW"


hahaha....yeah, that should've been put on here with a warning.


Miranda Reads Elaine wrote: "I am honestly laughing at this review! On the other hand, I just read a terrifically stupid romance novel involving a human woman and a shapeshifting dragon, so... who am I to judge."

Glad you liked the review.

Someone else messaged me about a similar situation in response to my review. The difference in that case is that the dragon shifter had the intelligence of a human and (I'm assuming) romanced her as a human.

This was an old pet bear with the thoughts and instincts of a bear. No intelligence or emotions, just bear...


message 28: by Kristen (new)

Kristen Peppercorn ROFL!!


message 29: by Kim (new)

Kim M WHAAAAT.


message 30: by Kim (new)

Kim M "The Shape of Water" suddenly got less weird.


Miranda Reads Kristen wrote: "ROFL!!"

haha, glad you liked it.


Miranda Reads Kim wrote: ""The Shape of Water" suddenly got less weird."

LOL. Yes.


message 33: by Sarah (new)

Sarah 'The Shape of Bear'

I'm so sorry you had to go through that.


message 34: by Lyn (new)

Lyn LOL! nice review, think I'll pass on this one. Maybe she was making a further and oblique reference to Shakespeare's classic stage direction in A Winter's Tale: “Exit, pursued by a bear.�


message 35: by Rachel (new)

Rachel Bea I'm impressed that you never knew it was about that lol


Miranda Reads Sarah wrote: "'The Shape of Bear'

I'm so sorry you had to go through that."


Ha. and thank you.


Miranda Reads Lyn wrote: "LOL! nice review, think I'll pass on this one. Maybe she was making a further and oblique reference to Shakespeare's classic stage direction in A Winter's Tale: “Exit, pursued by a bear.�"

She could....but honestly, I have no idea :P


Miranda Reads Rachel wrote: "I'm impressed that you never knew it was about that lol"

I swear that back cover did not adequately describe the book contents.

It wasn't until ~pg 80 that things went south, and by then I only had 40 pgs to go...so I skimmed the rest.


message 39: by Heather (new)

Heather Zabrowski WOW!! That is something I would definitely regret reading!
Sorry you had to endure that!


Miranda Reads Heather wrote: "WOW!! That is something I would definitely regret reading!
Sorry you had to endure that!"


Thank you for you support (:P). Thank goodness I'm didn't buy this one.


message 41: by Troy (new)

Troy Hooker I am SO glad you reviewed this before I subjected myself to it! I hope you returned it to the library with a few "edits" with a black marker:)


Miranda Reads Troy wrote: "I am SO glad you reviewed this before I subjected myself to it! I hope you returned it to the library with a few "edits" with a black marker:)"

My pain, your gain.


message 43: by Lukas (new)

Lukas Not... A hairy man.. A BEAR!!


message 44: by Belle (new)

Belle Thanks for the heads up! Sorry it had to be you.


message 45: by Taisha (new)

Taisha Casimir lol what?


message 46: by Avalon (new)

Avalon Wow.... I am dying laughing!! I'm sorry you were unwittingly exposed to bestiality, but also secretly pleased that as a consequence I was able to enjoy your review about it :) I wonder what the author was thinking.... or maybe I don't.


Miranda Reads L wrote: "Not... A hairy man.. A BEAR!!"

LOL.

And yes. Unfortunately.


Miranda Reads Belle wrote: "Thanks for the heads up! Sorry it had to be you."

Haha. Well, now you know :P


Miranda Reads Taisha wrote: "lol what?"

Exactly. It was horrible.


message 50: by J.S. (new)

J.S. om.F.g! That's insane, LOL!


« previous 1 3 4 5
back to top