ŷ

Minni Mouse's Reviews > Redeeming Love

Redeeming Love by Francine  Rivers
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
49776720
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: 2018, book-favorites, fiction-christian, romance-swoon, here-take-my-heart, fiction-historical, roughed-up, pleasantly-surprised, romance-historical, romance-slow-burn, stars-5, fiction-western, romance-christian
Read 2 times. Last read September 3, 2019 to May 6, 2022.

Medieval romances, regency romances, and whatever else kind of trashy romance novels have been ruined for me because Redeeming Love was such a pure and gentle depiction of romantic love that I'll never be able to read about a bodice-ripping, eight-pack-ab Scottish warlord the same ever again.

Because here are common themes in those historical romances that I'm so addicted to:
� domination, aggression, possession, control, caveman jealousy
� alpha male asshats, brutes, rakes, womanizers/playboys
� physical lust leading to dubious consent or nonconsent for sex

And here are nuggets from the romance depicted in Redeeming Love:
� forgiveness, faith, humbleness, gentleness, sacrifice
� provider, protector
� seeking emotional intimacy parallel to physical intimacy

“I saw the way you started looking at me, Amanda. I felt the way you responded that last night. I felt it all the way through me.�

“And it gave you a sense of power, didn’t it? Didn’t it?�

“Yes!� he admitted roughly and caught her arm when she would have retreated to the back door. “But it’s not a power I’m going to use against you.�


Content warning: physical abuse, rape, incest, human sex trafficking. Gotta say, though...it's been a while since I read something that didn't play any of those themes off gratuitously.

THE GOOD
1) Let's talk about how much I stayed awake until 4AM weeping from parallels to Christian themes.

Then Peter came and said to him, “Lord, how often shall my brother sin against me and I forgive him? Up to seven times?�

Jesus said to him, “I do not say to you up to seven times, but up to seventy times seven.

MATTHEW 18 : 21-22


2) Michael and Angel are #relationshipgoals to the max. Seriously. Ladies, find you a man who humbles himself before God like Michael. Find a man tender enough to get on his knees and wash your feet after you've been tromping around all day in the dirt. Washing of the feet was one of the most humble and powerful ways Christ demonstrated his love and service to his disciples, so the meaning behind that scene in the book was so tender I had to put the book down and weep.

“I’m afraid, too, Mara. Not of the dark, not of the past—but of you and what you make me feel when I touch you. You use my desire for you as a weapon. What I feel is a gift. I know what I want, but when you press yourself against me, all I can feel is your body and my need."

--------

All the way back, she had imagined him gloating and taunting, rubbing her face in her own broken pride. Instead, he knelt before her and washed her dirty, blistered feet. Throat burning, she looked down at his dark head and struggled with the feelings rising in her. She waited for them to die away, but they wouldn’t. They stayed and grew and made her hurt even more.

His hands were so gentle. He took such care. When her feet were clean, he kneaded her aching calves. He cast the dirty water outside and poured more, setting the pan in her lap. He took her hands and washed them as well. He kissed her stained, scratched palms and worked salve in. Then he wrapped them with warm bandages.

And I hit him. I drew his blood�

Angel shrank back ashamed. When he raised his head, she looked into his eyes. They were blue, like a clear spring sky. She had never really noticed before. “Why do you do this for me?� she said thickly. “Why?�

“Because, for some of us, one mile can be farther to walk than thirty.�

--------

It was small satisfaction when the natural needs of his body were driving him harder the longer they were together. His mind would create pictures of them making love as it was written in Song of Solomon. He would almost feel her arms around him and taste her honeyed kisses. Then he would come out of the daydream and feel more frustrated and bereft than ever.

Oh, he could have her now if he wanted. She would be accommodating. She would be expert. And he would know, all the while he poured his hope into her, that she was counting the beams in the ceiling or the chores for the next day or anything else that kept her from him. She wouldn’t look into his eyes or care that he was dying inside for love of her.

--------

She looked at him bleakly. “Your kind of love can’t feel good.�

“Does your kind feel any better?� She looked away. He unlooped the reins. “Right now love doesn’t have an awful lot to do with feelings,� he said grimly “Don’t misunderstand. I’m as human as the next man. I feel all right. I feel plenty right now, a lot I wish I didn’t.� He shook his head, his face strained with hurt and anger. “I felt like killing you when I walked in that room, but I didn’t. I feel like beating sense into you right now, but I won’t.� He looked at her with dark eyes. “And no matter how much it hurts, and no matter how much I feel like hurting you back for what you’ve done, I’m not going to.� He snapped the reins and set off again.


3) Paints a fairly realistic picture of human sex trafficking/prostitution as well as what faith and trust and forgiveness and the Holy Spirit actually look like in action.

4) Faith.

He closed his eyes wearily. He hadn’t prayed in days. “I’d be a fool to go back,� he said aloud. “A fool.� He looked out at the dark, weeping sky again. “But that’s what you want, isn’t it, Lord? And you’re not going to give me any peace until I do.�

He sighed heavily and rubbed the back of his neck. “I don’t see what good will come of it, but I’ll go back, Lord. I don’t like it much, but I’ll do what you want.� When he finally went back to bed, he slept deeply and without dreaming for the first time in days.


THE BAD
1) I know this is a Christian book...but do all the characters really need Biblical names? Sarah, Angel, Michael Hosea, Joseph, Jacob, Andrew, Luke, Leah, Miriam, John, Rebecca, Elizabeth, Ruth -- am I forgetting anyone from role call?

2) After the 65% mark or so things got a bit boring. Angel's character motivations began repeating themselves when they weren't back up by enough emotional decisions behind them = snooze.

3) Could've used a wee bit more details in that epilogue.

4) PAUL. That turkey. (view spoiler)

FINAL THOUGHTS
After my first foray into Christian romance/fantasy via The Merchant's Daughter , I was extremely wary and ready to criticize. Christian fiction to me can come across a wee bit corny and preachy, and even though Redeeming Love tiptoed that line from time to time it was absolutely a beautiful, inspired, and convicting story to read.

Can't recommend it enough! It'll make you rethink the views you have on romance, love and serving, and drawing power from God to put faith in action.

She looked at the stars, tiny jewels against black velvet. She had never seen it like this before, so close she felt she could reach up and touch each bright speck of light. The night sky was beautiful. It had never looked like this from a window. And the smell—thick, moist, earthy. Even the sounds around her became a kind of music, like the birds and insects, like the rain plinking into the tin cans in a dingy wharf shack. Then the darkness lightened.

It began slowly, hardly noticeable. The stars grew smaller and smaller, and the black softened. She stood up, hugging the quilt around her, watching. At her back was darkness still, but before her was light: pale yellow growing brilliant, gold-streaked with red and orange. She had watched sunrises before from within walls and behind glass, but never like this, with the cool breeze in her face and wilderness in every direction. She had never seen anything so beautiful.

Morning light spilled slowly over the mountains, across the valley to the cabin and the woods behind, and up the hillside. She felt Hosea’s strong hands on her shoulders.

“Mara, that’s the life I want to give you.�

The morning sunlight was so bright it hurt her eyes, blinding her more than the darkness ever had. She felt his lips against her hair. “That’s what I’m offering you.� His breath was warm against her skin. “I want to fill your life with color and warmth. I want to fill it with light.� He put his arms around her and held her back against him. “Give me a chance.�

Angel felt a heaviness building inside her. He had pretty words for her, but words weren’t life. Life wasn’t that simple, that straightforward. It was tangled and twisted, writhing from birth. She couldn’t erase the last ten years, or even the eight before Rab had led her through the streets to the brothel and left her there for Duke to ruin forever.

It had started long before that.

She was guilty of being born.

Her own father had wanted her cut out of her mother’s womb and thrown away like garbage. Her own father. And Mama would have done it had she known she would lose him over her small defiance. All those years of endless weeping had told Angel that.
12 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read Redeeming Love.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

March 28, 2018 – Shelved
April 12, 2018 – Started Reading
April 12, 2018 –
page 1
0.21% "This book has almost 170,000 reviews and a 4.49 star rating. If this doesn't change my life, it's time to go home."
April 13, 2018 –
33.0% "He closed his eyes and slept peacefully, forgetting the enemy who was loose in the world. The battle was not yet won. Paul was coming home.

NO. Who is this Paul fellow?? Get outta here, Paul!! Scram!"
April 13, 2018 –
37.0% "YEP. PAUL NEEDS TO DIE."
April 13, 2018 –
43.0% "WHY ARE YOU STILL HERE, PAUL."
April 13, 2018 –
58.0% "ArrgHhH. Stop it, stop it, staaahhp. 💔"
April 13, 2018 – Finished Reading
September 3, 2019 – Started Reading
September 3, 2019 –
page 12
2.51% "Bought the original version instead of the censored, edited version and already there's a significant difference."
September 19, 2019 –
page 142
29.65%
May 6, 2022 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-7 of 7 (7 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Stephanie This is a powerful book. Glad to see you liked it. You do know it's a retelling of the biblical book of Hosea, right?


message 2: by Minni Mouse (last edited Apr 16, 2018 12:54PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Minni Mouse Stephanie wrote: "This is a powerful book. Glad to see you liked it. You do know it's a retelling of the biblical book of Hosea, right?"

Yes! It was a hits-home experience to see that story detailed out, however...gaaaah. Kinda like when you read "Jesus was flogged" but then you watch The Passion of the Christ and see in brutal detail how that one sentence might actually have been like.


Stephanie That is a very apt description.

I was thinking about how you said the book got kind of repetitive and boring after awhile, but Gomer kept running away from Hosea, so...

It's honestly been years since I read it, and I seem to remember it dragging a bit in the back half too. I do wonder how much of that is due to the source material (which I've read/learned about in sermons, but have never done an in depth study on, unless you count reading Redeeming Love 😏).


message 4: by Michelle (new) - added it

Michelle Added! :)


Minni Mouse Michelle, I can't wait to talk about this with you 🙂


L A i N E Y (will be back) Yeah I found Christian romance (the few that I’ve samples) preachy too but you made this one sounds really sweet and interesting :)


Minni Mouse l a i n e y wrote: "Yeah I found Christian romance (the few that I’ve samples) preachy too but you made this one sounds really sweet and interesting :)"

I know exactly what you mean, Lainey. This one works, though, for the most part. I hope you find it as moving and humbling as it's meant to be! 😊


back to top