Robin's Reviews > Ice
Ice (Penguin Modern Classics)
by
by

I was going to start off by describing this as dream-like, but it's actually a nightmare.
The Earth is rapidly covering with ice, a death sentence for its inhabitants. Meanwhile, our unnamed male narrator in an unnamed country has an obsession with a woman from his past. He feels compelled to save her, not only from the ice, but also from her rather jerky husband, then later from the more sinister "warden".
What I assumed would be a relatively simple plot in relatively few pages, is actually disorienting. Just when you think you know what's going on, you don't. The narrator says something about himself, and then a few paragraphs later you realise you're reading about something surreal happening to the woman that the narrator couldn't possibly know. She might be encased in ice, she might be alone, trapped in a room. Then you jump to another scene, maybe another place or time, maybe a dream. The narrator admittedly has a loose grip on reality. This has the effect of keeping the reader off balance, on slippery ground.
We never understand why the narrator is so hell-bent on following the woman around. It's certainly not for her personality (she has none that I could discern). All we learn of her is that she is the eternal victim. She is child-like, passive, with a history of being bullied and abused. And she's very white and very thin with sparkling hair.
About 20 pages in, I was scratching my head. While the descriptions of ice were kaleidoscopic in their refracting beauty, I felt like I was playing a bad version of pin the tail on the donkey. Someone had blindfolded me, spun me around till I was good and dizzy, and sent me walking with the ass-tail in hand, towards the edge of a jagged cliff.
I started to think about Anna Kavan. A lifelong heroin addict, her tennis coach introduced her to the drug to improve her game (??) in her mid twenties. She lived until the age of 67. That's 40 years using heroin, which goes against everything I think I know about heroin use (obviously I don't know much!). Kavan, who lived through many tragedies, was in and out of mental institutions for the last 30+ years of her life - for depression, for addiction, and attempted suicide.
The book started to make a lot more sense to me once I began reading it through more of a biographical lens. The detachment, the alienation, the encroaching ice. The sense of confusion and paranoia, of the weak woman running from oppressive abusers. The padded, soundproof rooms.
And then it occurred to me, what if Kavan's pale lady is splintered and fragmented into pieces of herself. What if the narrator is actually the part of her trying to act as protector, and the warden is the part that punishes and controls. If this is the case, the poor lady spends all her time in a nightmare world, chasing herself, saving herself, hating herself, escaping herself, and occasionally, through the haze, trying to keep it together long enough to feel at peace.
While her life experience had a huge impact on this work, I'm not suggesting that Kavan simply wrote this about herself. There's so much going on here. It's a complex and experimental post-modern novel. It has been described as apocalyptic, Kafka-esque, science fiction, and feminist. It's all those things, as well as a bewildering, frosty look, deep into the unblinking eye of death.
And I haven't even mentioned the lemurs. What a book!
The Earth is rapidly covering with ice, a death sentence for its inhabitants. Meanwhile, our unnamed male narrator in an unnamed country has an obsession with a woman from his past. He feels compelled to save her, not only from the ice, but also from her rather jerky husband, then later from the more sinister "warden".
What I assumed would be a relatively simple plot in relatively few pages, is actually disorienting. Just when you think you know what's going on, you don't. The narrator says something about himself, and then a few paragraphs later you realise you're reading about something surreal happening to the woman that the narrator couldn't possibly know. She might be encased in ice, she might be alone, trapped in a room. Then you jump to another scene, maybe another place or time, maybe a dream. The narrator admittedly has a loose grip on reality. This has the effect of keeping the reader off balance, on slippery ground.
We never understand why the narrator is so hell-bent on following the woman around. It's certainly not for her personality (she has none that I could discern). All we learn of her is that she is the eternal victim. She is child-like, passive, with a history of being bullied and abused. And she's very white and very thin with sparkling hair.
About 20 pages in, I was scratching my head. While the descriptions of ice were kaleidoscopic in their refracting beauty, I felt like I was playing a bad version of pin the tail on the donkey. Someone had blindfolded me, spun me around till I was good and dizzy, and sent me walking with the ass-tail in hand, towards the edge of a jagged cliff.
I started to think about Anna Kavan. A lifelong heroin addict, her tennis coach introduced her to the drug to improve her game (??) in her mid twenties. She lived until the age of 67. That's 40 years using heroin, which goes against everything I think I know about heroin use (obviously I don't know much!). Kavan, who lived through many tragedies, was in and out of mental institutions for the last 30+ years of her life - for depression, for addiction, and attempted suicide.
The book started to make a lot more sense to me once I began reading it through more of a biographical lens. The detachment, the alienation, the encroaching ice. The sense of confusion and paranoia, of the weak woman running from oppressive abusers. The padded, soundproof rooms.
And then it occurred to me, what if Kavan's pale lady is splintered and fragmented into pieces of herself. What if the narrator is actually the part of her trying to act as protector, and the warden is the part that punishes and controls. If this is the case, the poor lady spends all her time in a nightmare world, chasing herself, saving herself, hating herself, escaping herself, and occasionally, through the haze, trying to keep it together long enough to feel at peace.
While her life experience had a huge impact on this work, I'm not suggesting that Kavan simply wrote this about herself. There's so much going on here. It's a complex and experimental post-modern novel. It has been described as apocalyptic, Kafka-esque, science fiction, and feminist. It's all those things, as well as a bewildering, frosty look, deep into the unblinking eye of death.
And I haven't even mentioned the lemurs. What a book!
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Ice.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Comments Showing 1-46 of 46 (46 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Julie
(new)
May 05, 2018 06:21PM

reply
|
flag


Seems I can't get enough!
Actually, the only way I could stomach more ice is because Spring has finally arrived... otherwise it would have been too, too much!

Many thanks, Fede, for telling me about this strange, original, baffling book, that will undoubtedly remain with me a long time. Kavan is something else, hard to encapsulate in a review. My heart breaks to think of her life, especially if it was anything close to what she described in Ice.




Great insight, Robin, it helps to explain this simultaneously bright and dense book. I remember thinking that all the male characters, the narrator included, were the same person, playing a long and cruel game with the frozen heroine, but your version is even better.


What if the narrator is actually the part of her trying to act as protector, and the warden is the part that punishes and controls. If this is the case, the poor lady spends all her time in a nightmare world, chasing herself, saving herself, hating herself, escaping herself, and occasionally, through the haze, trying to keep it together long enough to feel at peace.
This makes perfect sense to me, -- of a novel I've never read!-- but now very much want to.
I have known people like this in my life and it resonates with the clarity of thought; and to use the ice as a metaphor on this train of thought is perfection itself, for nothing else could describe such a frigid prison in which these people live. Friends stand on "the edge of an icefield" trying to decipher what is happening, but impossible to melt away the layers to get to the core of that person. Brilliant review!

Thank you, Julie! It's such a fascinating little book that became so much richer as I thought about the author as a person. I can see it could be less fascinating for others, though :)

Thank you kindly, dear Jaline! It was my only way through my initial puzzlement, and turned out to be the way I saw the brilliance, too. Quite an original reading experience for me.

Hi Bianca. Thanks for reading my review, and your lovely comment, even though the book isn't one you think you'd pick up. I really appreciate it!
I didn't really know how challenging this would be, going in (which is probably a good thing!). It was recommended to me after I finished reading The Road, another dystopic book in which characters are unnamed. The Road is a much more traditional "story" than this, but both are very powerful in their own way.

Thank you so much, Fionnuala. It started to click for me, when I noticed the narrator repeating that the woman was "a part of me" and that he could not live without her. I also noticed that everywhere he went, no matter how random, she was there, not too far away. Often, he was in the room and nobody saw him, as if he were invisible - another proof to me that he was actually part of HER. And same with the warden. Sometimes the narrator and the warden almost seemed one and the same.
I'm going to go have a look at your review now, which is sure to illuminate more for me!

Thanks, Katie. She's off-the-wall, out-of-the-box, one-of-a-kind and hanging-on-by-a-thread. This won't hit the mark for some readers, but I am appreciating it more and more as I think back on it.

It definitely did that for me, Laysee. Thanks so much for your kind comment!

I love how you put this, Julie. It's so true. There are many stunning passages describing her imprisonment in and her defeat by, the ice. I think you would appreciate this book, given your understanding. Thanks so much for your great comment.

I know, right?! I'm just spit-balling here, but maybe her coach thought while on H, she'd become a better sport? i.e., not caring whether she wins or loses, or... anything at all?

Old style performance-enhancing drugs!

You're really kind, thanks Ian. It was a journey - and my synapses were firing the whole time, trying to make my way through it. A fabulous and meaningful reading experience. I think this book is sort of a "lost classic". A great discovery for me!

David Hemmings threw the ball almost like a shotput. Gaddis is fixing a hole where the rain gets in, and can't be bothered writing any more reviews on GR. How will we know what to think?


Thank you, Cheri. She's a hypnotic writer, and though I was initially bewildered, I was soon under her spell. I understand why the obscurity might be unappealing to some, though.


Hi Andrew. Thanks for your comment and for reading my review! This book provides quite the reading experience. How fascinating that it brought to mind the Fitzgerald novel. It's been so long since I read it, I don't recall enough of it except that I know it features mental illness and alcoholism - so I can see the parallels there.


Hi Michael, and thank you! I agree that an author's biography doesn't necessarily need to be brought in, in order to understand their work - and maybe the links I made have nothing to do with this book... I think it stands on its own, as a gorgeous work of art. I think at the time of my writing this review, I was trying to orient myself a bit in something tangible. Maybe though, that's not necessary. To sink into the disorientation might be the best way, instead of trying so hard to understand it. At any rate, it was a really fantastic read for me last year, and I still think about it. Definitely worth re-visiting at some point. Thanks for your great comment!

It really is, and I cannot wait to see what you think of it. I felt lost in the ice at times trying to make sense of it. Though maybe that was the wrong approach and one isn't meant to "make sense" of this novel.


I have doubts that heroin helps with any sport performance, but what do I know? :D
Thanks for the comment, Dustin! This is a memorable, trippy book. Definitely worth reading and contemplating.