Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Miranda Reads's Reviews > The Giver

The Giver by Lois Lowry
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
71848701
's review

really liked it
bookshelves: audiobook

description
Stuck at home? Got some time on your hands? Want to start a long series? But you don't want a dud?

Then I have some suggestions for you!

Check out this all about which series are worth your time (and which ones aren't)!

Thanks for watching and happy reading!

Check Out the Written Review!

Man oh man, for a children's book...Lowry certainly didn't pull any punches.

Jonas lives in a perfectly perfect world.

Every family has one mother, one father, one girl and one boy.

Families always get along, the parents never disagree, no one has any secrets.

Everyone contributes to society equally.

No one is ever outraged, angry, sad.
The life where nothing was ever unexpected. Or inconvenient. Or unusual. The life without colour, pain or past.
However what appears perfect on the surface hides a far darker truth. There isn't any negativity in their world but also, there isn't any true happiness or love.

All emotions are suppressed, children are taken from "birth mothers," and defected individuals are "released." His society is alive but not living.

Jonas is ready to undergo the ceremony of twelves (during which are children born in the same year 'age' to the next level).

He will be assigned his role in society but when he is supposed to accept his new job, he's given the title of Receiver.

Something he's never even heard of. No one really knows what the Receiver does other than the Giver.

Soon Jonas learns that the Giver holds the collected memories of the societies long since past and passes it along to the next generation.

Jonas is faced with startling realities that he would've never considered - how beautiful color is, how heartbreaking loss is, and how incredibly wonderful love can make a person feel.
The worst part of holding the memories is not the pain. It's the loneliness of it. Memories need to be shared.
And soon, he comes to a decision. One that would irrevocably shift his small world.
Of course they needed to care. It was the meaning of everything.
I first read this one in fifth grade and whew. It was a doozie.

Reread it this year and I'm starting to wonder if kids would like English class a lot more if any of the books were a bit more cheerful....

That being said, reading this one as an adult completely changed my perspective.

I remember liking it, in a slightly apathetic way, in fifth grade.

Now, I'm wholly invested in the plot, the characters and the world. What an incredible dystopia!

Audiobook Comments
Very well-read by Ron Rifkin. He wasn't a stunning narrator but definitely an enjoyable one. Though, it was a bit disconcerting to hear a grown man's voice for 12-year-old Jonas.

| | | | | Snapchat @miranda_reads
550 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read The Giver.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 12, 2018 – Started Reading
April 12, 2018 – Shelved
April 12, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 52 (52 new)


Marialyce My all out definitely fabulous YA novel. Read it for many years with my middle school lit classes.


message 2: by Katherine (new)

Katherine This was my fourth grade teacher's favorite book! I remember it was always sitting on his desk because he was always re-reading it!


message 3: by [deleted user] (new)

I read this in 6th grade for English class and I loved it then and I still love it now. It’s a great book.


Sarah Such a masterful book, simple in its style but fathoms deep in meaning. Excellent review, Miranda!


Cheryl What is your take on the ending?


Miranda Reads Marialyce wrote: "My all out definitely fabulous YA novel. Read it for many years with my middle school lit classes."

Ha! Yes! What was around when i first read it :)


Miranda Reads Katherine wrote: "This was my fourth grade teacher's favorite book! I remember it was always sitting on his desk because he was always re-reading it!"

Wow, i can't imagine rereading a book constantly. There's so many new ones out there!


Miranda Reads Jacinda wrote: "I read this in 6th grade for English class and I loved it then and I still love it now. It’s a great book."

So totally agree!


Miranda Reads Sarah wrote: "Such a masterful book, simple in its style but fathoms deep in meaning. Excellent review, Miranda!"

there were so many meanings that i didn't pick up on the first time through. It's very cool to see how my interpretation changed


Miranda Reads Cheryl wrote: "What is your take on the ending?"

I'm torn between what i want to believe and what the book hints at. I read book 2 but it literally didn't help at all. Ugh. I guess ill try book 3 to see if there is any conclusion.....

What about you?


Jamie Dacyczyn In my opinion, the sequels don't really add much. I kind of wish this was just a stand alone book with a purely ambiguous ending.


Miranda Reads Jamie (ReadsInTrees) wrote: "In my opinion, the sequels don't really add much. I kind of wish this was just a stand alone book with a purely ambiguous ending."

Oh no. Now I'm getting nervous. Just rented the third book but I don't see anything about Jonas & Co. in the description.


Jamie Dacyczyn The 4th one briefly gets back in touch with the original book (starts out back in the community where Jonas was from). So, that part was interesting.


Miranda Reads Ughhhhh.... now I just feel betrayed by the author :p


message 15: by Stacy (new)

Stacy I love your thought at the end of this review because my English teacher had the same philosophy, except dealing with Shakespeare. She decided that since most of the plays we would be reading of his were tragedies, we would read Much Ado About Nothing to show us the fun side and maybe make the transition a little easier.

Man, did it work! Decades later, that is still my favorite from Shakespeare and I do believe students would be more receptive if they were able to read something more cheerful every once and a while.


message 16: by Miranda (last edited Apr 24, 2018 10:16AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Miranda Reads Stacy wrote: "I love your thought at the end of this review because my English teacher had the same philosophy, except dealing with Shakespeare. She decided that since most of the plays we would be reading of hi..."

I've never had the pleasure of a non depressing Shakespeare.... now i want to check it out! Your English teacher sounds amazing


message 17: by Stacy (new)

Stacy You should, it’s wonderful! It revolves around rumors, friends trying to set two people up together and one character causing drama for the lols. Over 400 years old and still perfectly sums up high school!


Miranda Reads Stacy wrote: "You should, it’s wonderful! It revolves around rumors, friends trying to set two people up together and one character causing drama for the lols. Over 400 years old and still perfectly sums up high..."

you sold me on it :) Sounds awesome!!


Miranda Reads Jamie (ReadsInTrees) wrote: "The 4th one briefly gets back in touch with the original book (starts out back in the community where Jonas was from). So, that part was interesting."

Oh my gosh. Just finished book 3. That. Ending. ARE YOU KIDDING ME???


message 20: by Kyle (new) - added it

Kyle Wells I remember reading this in middle school and being absolutely transported.


Miranda Reads Kyle wrote: "I remember reading this in middle school and being absolutely transported."

Definitely. Rereading it as an adult really brought things to a whole new perspective.


Miranda Reads Nicole wrote: "I agree, thanks for your insight and review!"

Awww, thank you :)


Roxanne What a wonderful review! You captured a lot of my thoughts on this book


Miranda Reads Roxanne wrote: "What a wonderful review! You captured a lot of my thoughts on this book"

Did you like it too? Have you read the rest of the series?


message 25: by Art3mis (new)

Art3mis Miranda your reviews are amazing!


Miranda Reads Art3mis wrote: "Miranda your reviews are amazing!"

Thank you!


Mel (Epic Reading) One of my fave books as a pre-teen and as an adult! Lovely review!


M.M. Strawberry Library & Reviews I loved this book when I was a kid and loved it again as an adult.


AFENI MAKEBEA NELSON HI THANK YOU for this Blessed book I would love and like to read!


message 30: by Felicia (new)

Felicia Incredible book. FANTASTIC review as always 💖


message 31: by Katherine (new)

Katherine This was my fourth-grade teacher's favorite book of all time! I remember that it had a permanent place on his desk and he was constantly rereading it. <3


message 32: by Leila (new) - added it

Leila A wonderful review for a wonderful book Miranda! Thank you so much for sharing.


Miranda Reads Mel (Epic Reading) wrote: "One of my fave books as a pre-teen and as an adult! Lovely review!"

That's awesome!


Miranda Reads M.M. Strawberry wrote: "I loved this book when I was a kid and loved it again as an adult."

That's awesome :)


Miranda Reads Felicia wrote: "Incredible book. FANTASTIC review as always 💖"

Thank you so much!


Miranda Reads Katherine wrote: "This was my fourth-grade teacher's favorite book of all time! I remember that it had a permanent place on his desk and he was constantly rereading it. <3"

Oh wow! I would love to love a book like that. I guess my closest would be Harry Potter. What's your ultimate fave?


Miranda Reads Leila wrote: "A wonderful review for a wonderful book Miranda! Thank you so much for sharing."

Awww! Thank you :)


China 'The Giver' used to be my favorite dystopian novel until I had to re-read and analyze it for class. The things about the Community I didn't even pick up on my first time (fifth grade) are now glaringly obvious.


Miranda Reads Bunny wrote: "'The Giver' used to be my favorite dystopian novel until I had to re-read and analyze it for class. The things about the Community I didn't even pick up on my first time (fifth grade) are now glari..."

OMG yes. And that's part of the reason the reread was good (to me at least :P) - it's a whole new way of interpreting the book (though, a bit darker of an interpretation!).


China Miranda wrote: "Bunny wrote: "'The Giver' used to be my favorite dystopian novel until I had to re-read and analyze it for class. The things about the Community I didn't even pick up on my first time (fifth grade)..."

My mind went way deep in the gutter when I thought about the Birthmothers role in the Community. I was like, This is supposed to be a children's novel!


Miranda Reads Bunny wrote: "Miranda wrote: "Bunny wrote: "'The Giver' used to be my favorite dystopian novel until I had to re-read and analyze it for class. The things about the Community I didn't even pick up on my first ti..."

Mmmmmm.... and it still works cause kids don't see it the way you did :p i went on a childhood reread kick for a while and wo... some of the books they had us read were SUPER dark


China Miranda wrote: "Bunny wrote: "Miranda wrote: "Bunny wrote: "'The Giver' used to be my favorite dystopian novel until I had to re-read and analyze it for class. The things about the Community I didn't even pick up ..."

Even though she isn't my favorite, Lois Lowry is an absolute genius.


Miranda Reads Bunny wrote: "Miranda wrote: "Bunny wrote: "Miranda wrote: "Bunny wrote: "'The Giver' used to be my favorite dystopian novel until I had to re-read"

Did you read the other ones in the series?


message 44: by China (last edited May 15, 2019 02:38PM) (new) - rated it 3 stars

China Miranda wrote: "Bunny wrote: "Miranda wrote: "Bunny wrote: "Miranda wrote: "Bunny wrote: "'The Giver' used to be my favorite dystopian novel until I had to re-read"

Did you read the other ones in the series?"


I'm still debating if the others are worth the read. I've found out that Gathering Blue and Messenger have nothing to do with The Giver, so I'm kinda nervous here.


shanah Mathew wonderful book. my teacher is reading me this book


Ariana THIS IS MY FAVORITE BOOK OF ALL TIME!!!


message 47: by Laura (new)

Laura There are 3 books in this series. I never realized it until someone asked me at the library I work at.


Jamie Dacyczyn Laura, there's a 4th as well.


message 49: by advika (new) - added it

advika The first line of the review rlyyy captured my attention :D


message 50: by Caroline (new)

Caroline " Without opposition, there is nothing to overcome."
Ah, yes, this! (nice review, btw).


« previous 1
back to top