Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Yun's Reviews > Station Eleven

Station Eleven by Emily St. John Mandel
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
30181442
's review

did not like it

For me, Station Eleven falls squarely into the category of extremely dull books that seem to be highly-rated by everyone else.

The premise totally intrigued me. You put words like pandemic and apocalyptic times together with the promise of a civilization having fallen into chaos and ruin, and I sign up every time. I honestly can't resist. But it turns out that was the only interesting thing about this book, I'm sorry to report.

First, the whole story is told in nonlinear format, jumping around time-wise from years before the pandemic to 20 years after. Is there a particular reason for this jumping around? I honestly couldn't tell, unless it's to make it hard to follow the characters and what happened to them.

Speaking of characters, the ones in here are among the most uninteresting I've ever encountered. There was nothing about them that grabbed my attention and made me care about them. And they don't have distinguishing personalities from each other. In fact, they all seem to be approximately the same person, talking and thinking in the same tedious manner. It doesn't help that we are introduced to so many people in the Symphony and they are called by their instruments instead of their actual names, as if the author couldn't be bothered to give these people proper names, let alone personalities.

Probably the worst of all is the boring plot. It seems the whole point is that there are some people who seem loosely connected at the beginning of the book, but then we follow them and realize by the end that there are a few more connections between them than was first realized. Ok...

In the first two-thirds of book, hardly anything happens, which is amazing considering this is a book about the apocalypse! It mostly switches between following a self-important actor as he goes through his acting and his successive wives, and the main character Kristen as she walks through barren desolate landscapes. There are so many descriptions of rusted out cars, dusty houses, grass and weeds, no electricity, being vigilant, etc.

I have to mention that there is also a comic book in here and we are treated to prose description of various parts of it. In case you're wondering, there's a reason why prose renditions of comic books has not taken off as a genre.

To me, the most interesting part of a premise like this is reading about what happens to civilization in the aftermath of a cataclysmic event and finding out how the people who managed to survive did so. But that isn't covered until way later in the book and its treatment was disappointing. In what is meant to add suspense to the plot, there is also a weird prophet who goes around taking wives and killing people in his way. What?

I just don't understand this book at all. So many people loved it, but to me, it's one of the most dull and disjointed books I've ever read.

~~~~~~~~~~~~
� Connect with me � �
1420 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Station Eleven.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 13, 2018 – Shelved
April 14, 2018 – Started Reading
April 16, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-50 of 272 (272 new)


message 1: by Kelli (new)

Kelli Wilson I recently tagged a TBR 'The Lost One'. I came across Station Eleven mentioned in it's reviews as comparisons. What I noticed is readers that liked Station Eleven, didn't love The Lost One. Perhaps you'd enjoy the latter as such:) I'll be holding off on Station Eleven. Your review sounds spot on for my tastes


message 2: by Kelli (new)

Kelli Wilson Correction: "The Last One"


message 3: by Yun (last edited Apr 10, 2019 11:46AM) (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Kelli wrote: "I recently tagged a TBR 'The Lost One'. I came across Station Eleven mentioned in it's reviews as comparisons. What I noticed is readers that liked Station Eleven, didn't love The Lost One. Perhaps..."
Haha I'm afraid to read another philosophical apocalyptic book after Station Eleven, which completely ruined the genre for me. I know so many others who loved it, which meant my reaction took me completely by surprise. I think if what I mentioned is inline with your tastes, definitely avoid this one. If you end up reading "The Last One", I'll be interested to see what you think. :)


Christy I totally agree! This is what I said about it: "Meh... I thought it was okay. It wasn't as nearly as good as I expected and found myself rather bored during a lot of it." I'm not quite sure why I even gave it 3 stars? I enjoyed all the interconnected stories... but like I said in my review... none of them stood out to me.


casey (ink drinker) I also gave this 1 star. A boring bunch of story-lines that never connect. Great review.


message 6: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Christy wrote: "I totally agree! This is what I said about it: "Meh... I thought it was okay. It wasn't as nearly as good as I expected and found myself rather bored during a lot of it." I'm not quite sure why I e..."
Ah sorry you didn't like this one either, Christy! Like you, nothing in this book really stood out in a good way for me. It's always a letdown when a story others love didn't do much for you. Bah!


message 7: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Casey wrote: "I also gave this 1 star. A boring bunch of story-lines that never connect. Great review."
Thank you, Casey! Sorry you didn't like this one either. But I'm glad we both got through it, and now we've moved on to better books! :)


message 8: by Kisa (new) - rated it 1 star

Kisa Libby I felt totally catfished by the reviews this book got. I haven’t been so disappointed in my fellow readers since 50 Shades of Gray


message 9: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Kisa wrote: "I felt totally catfished by the reviews this book got. I haven’t been so disappointed in my fellow readers since 50 Shades of Gray"
Oh no, Kisa, sorry this one didn't live up to your expectations either! It's always extra disappointing when it's a book that others love so much and you find to be rather pointless. Sigh. I'm glad we have both finished this book and can now move onto something much better! :)


Daniel Montague Thank you for this review. I saw all of these laudatory reviews and could not reconciled how I felt about this work. My biggest issue was something you touched upon with the Prophet and that was motivation. Why would the Prophet take so many wives? Why would he risk so much, being vastly outnumbered just for that one young girl? I understand, people/characters are not always rational but there were too may gaps that affected my coherence and understanding.


message 11: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Daniel wrote: "Thank you for this review. I saw all of these laudatory reviews and could not reconciled how I felt about this work. My biggest issue was something you touched upon with the Prophet and that was mo..."
Thanks, Daniel! It's been years since I've read this, but I remember being super confused that others loved this while I barely connected with the story. Sorry it fell a bit short for you too!


Laura I completely agree with your review! This book was so disjointed and confusing. Very dull. I didn't understand the jumping around and wasn't interested in characters. I was disappointed with this book.


message 13: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Laura wrote: "I completely agree with your review! This book was so disjointed and confusing. Very dull. I didn't understand the jumping around and wasn't interested in characters. I was disappointed with this b..."
Thanks, Laura! Yes... so dull and disjointed! What a bummer you were disappointed with this book too!


haytham ♡⋆౨ৎ˚⟡˖ ࣪ Oh no, I'm so sad you didn't like this, it's one of my favourites! :(
But I understand why you disliked this. I hope your next read is much better!


message 15: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Haytham wrote: "Oh no, I'm so sad you didn't like this, it's one of my favourites! :(
But I understand why you disliked this. I hope your next read is much better!"

Thanks for the comment, Haytham! There's such a disconnect between me and this book. I just can't make heads or tails of it! Obviously, I'm in the minority and so many readers loved this... I'm glad you did too! Just wish I saw what you did! :)


Jenna I love this review! I obviously liked the book better than you did (although I must admit I have little memory of it, which isn’t a great sign either!). I can completely see all your points though, and you are not wrong!


message 17: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Jenna wrote: "I love this review! I obviously liked the book better than you did (although I must admit I have little memory of it, which isn’t a great sign either!). I can completely see all your points though,..."
Thanks, Jenna! Appreciate your support! There was just this total disconnect between me and the book. Whatever everyone else saw, I just couldn't see it. Maybe I read a different book... lol. I'm so glad you enjoyed it, even if you don't remember much now! :)


Nataliya Great review, Yun! ApparentlyI loved this book, but since I never reviewed it I can’t remember what about it made it stand out for me.

Nonlinear timeliness seems to be an increasingly common approach now. And of course post-pandemic stories are probably weird to read in the current during-pandemic world,


message 19: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Nataliya wrote: "Great review, Yun! ApparentlyI loved this book, but since I never reviewed it I can’t remember what about it made it stand out for me.

Nonlinear timeliness seems to be an increasingly common appr..."

Thanks, Nataliya! I don't know what it is about this book, but I couldn't make heads or tails of it. It was just such a strange story (nonstory?) that I kept waiting for something more, which never materialized. It's definitely me though... so many others loved it, and I'm glad you did too, even if you can't remember much now. :)


message 20: by Lucy (new)

Lucy Hadn't heard of this story, but that's probably a good thing. Enjoy your next read! 💛


message 21: by Baba (new) - rated it 4 stars

Baba I feel so bad... but this book looks really appealing to me, as I have a soft-spot for non-linear stories with ensemble casts! Thanks for the thought provoking non-conformist view Jun :)


message 22: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Lucy wrote: "Hadn't heard of this story, but that's probably a good thing. Enjoy your next read! 💛"
Thanks, Lucy! Ha, wish I hadn't heard of this one either! 😅


message 23: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Baba wrote: "I feel so bad... but this book looks really appealing to me, as I have a soft-spot for non-linear stories with ensemble casts! Thanks for the thought provoking non-conformist view Jun :)"
Thanks, Baba! I feel like there was such a disconnect between me and this book. I couldn't make heads or tails of it. It just felt like words on a page. Obviously, I'm in the minority and so many others loved it. Just wish I had the same experience. :)


message 24: by Joan (new) - rated it 2 stars

Joan I completely agree I don’t get the hype for it at all


message 25: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Joan wrote: "I completely agree I don’t get the hype for it at all"
Thanks, Joan! Glad I'm not the only one who didn't get it lol. :)


message 26: by Maureen (new)

Maureen Hope your next is a winner Yun!


message 27: by John (new) - rated it 5 stars

John Interesting review! I read this a few years ago, and don’t remember that much about it, but I liked it a lot. In fact it introduced me to one of my favorite authors. But intriguingly, I’ve noticed her writing appeals to me more for some reason that it does to most. This is easily her most highly rated work, but I actually love all of her books and can’t wait for the upcoming Sea of Tranquility. Sorry you didn’t like it but I’m not surprised; seems like a lot of people have that reaction. Makes me wonder if I’m weird!!


message 28: by Julie (new)

Julie Yikes! Sorry this one didn't work for you. Hope your next book is a better fit! 💖


message 29: by Kay (new) - rated it 3 stars

Kay I dont get it either Yun!!


message 30: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Maureen wrote: "Hope your next is a winner Yun!"
Thanks, Maureen! :)


message 31: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun John wrote: "Interesting review! I read this a few years ago, and don’t remember that much about it, but I liked it a lot. In fact it introduced me to one of my favorite authors. But intriguingly, I’ve noticed ..."
Thanks, John! I don't know what it is about this book, but I couldn't connect with it at all. The story doesn't make sense to me, the characters are so flat. It's like I'm just reading random words on a page. Obviously, this is a really highly rated book, and I'm in the minority. So I don't think you're weird so much as I am lol. I'm glad you love this author! I want to give her another try and her Sea of Tranquility did catch my eye. :)


message 32: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Julie wrote: "Yikes! Sorry this one didn't work for you. Hope your next book is a better fit! 💖"
Thanks, Julie! It certainly can't be any worse, at least! 💖


message 33: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Kay wrote: "I dont get it either Yun!!"
Thanks, Kay! Glad I'm not alone in the befuddlement!


message 34: by Icey (new) - added it

Icey Oh no! So bad that this book didn’t work for you, Yun! I have this book on my TBR pile and my expectation is not high now after reading your review…I hope your next read will be an engaging one!


message 35: by Ian M. Pyatt (new)

Ian M. Pyatt It was a DNF for me.


message 36: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Icey wrote: "Oh no! So bad that this book didn’t work for you, Yun! I have this book on my TBR pile and my expectation is not high now after reading your review…I hope your next read will be an engaging one!"
Thanks, Icey! So many others loved this book, so I definitely hope you will too when you get to it. But I totally don't get it. I couldn't understand the story or what the point was. Maybe if you end up loving it, you can explain it to me! 😂


message 37: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Ian wrote: "It was a DNF for me."
Ha! Obviously, I should've done the same lol.


message 38: by Stacey (new) - added it

Stacey Camp DNF for me as well. Boring and I hate the word boring.


Anthony Ruta I agree with you here


message 40: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Stacey wrote: "DNF for me as well. Boring and I hate the word boring."
Thanks, Stacey! Sorry this didn't work for you either, but I appreciate you letting me know I'm not alone! :)


message 41: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Anthony wrote: "I agree with you here"
Yes!! Another reader who agrees with me! Thank you! :)


message 42: by Paul (new) - rated it 4 stars

Paul Weiss Don’t hold back! Why don’t you just come out and say you didn’t like it, 🤪?


message 43: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Paul wrote: "Don’t hold back! Why don’t you just come out and say you didn’t like it, 🤪?"
And here I thought I was holding back!! Haha! 😅


Nancy (playing catch-up) I always love your thoroughly thought out reviews, Yun. I hope your next book is a 5 star read. 💖


message 45: by Tina (new)

Tina Oh no! Sorry this one was such a miss. I hope you love your next one!!!


message 46: by Kerrin (new)

Kerrin Bummer! Thanks for your fair review.


message 47: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Nancy wrote: "I always love your thoroughly thought out reviews, Yun. I hope your next book is a 5 star read. 💖"
Thanks, Nancy! That's really kind of you to say! 💖


message 48: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Tina wrote: "Oh no! Sorry this one was such a miss. I hope you love your next one!!!"
Thanks, Tina! My current read can't possibly be worse, so it's all good! :)


message 49: by Yun (new) - rated it 1 star

Yun Kerrin wrote: "Bummer! Thanks for your fair review."
Thanks, Kerrin! Ah, can't win them all. :)


Joanna Chu (The ChuseyReader) Great review Yun and very fair! Haha uneventful apocalypse, how is that possible?! I haven't read a book where I enjoyed a non linear timeline, its just disjointed and confusing! I'll be giving this one a hard miss!


« previous 1 3 4 5 6
back to top