ŷ

Marialyce 's Reviews > The Dream Daughter

The Dream Daughter by Diane Chamberlain
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
1277371
's review

liked it
bookshelves: net-galley

2.5 rather for me disappointing stars
My review can be seen here:

Sometimes no matter how hard you try you really can't like something you thought you would. It's disappointing as you try to figure out just what it was that went wrong. Such is my feeling with the book The Dream Daughter

What I liked about this book.....There is nothing like the love of a mother for a child. We read so often of the ultimate sacrifices that mothers make for their children and in this book, Caroline Sears has been dealt two awful heart breaking occurrences. Her beloved husband has been killed in Vietnam, and the daughter she is pregnant with is diagnosed with a heart defect that will ultimately kill her. It is the 1970s where technology and medicine, in today's world, seems old and so out of date. It is a horrible diagnosis and now Caroline is faced with two tragedies. Her brother in law Hunter, has a solution he believes. Hunter is and has been a mysterious man. He seems to know things, like future song lyrics and is a brilliant physicist. What he suggests to Caroline requires a suppression of all Caroline knows but it may ultimately be a way to save her child. Hunter offers hope, he offers a solution, but it is so bizarre that Caroline wonders if it could be true

What I didn't like.....I have always had trouble with the idea of time travel in novels. From the book The Time Traveler's Wife as well as the Outlander series, I can't seem to be able to wrap my arms around this concept. So part of the problem I had with this book is definitely my aversion to the theme of time travel. In particular in this book, I had difficulty accepting the role some of the characters played. They just didn't reach out and touch me the way I thought they should. I also found quite a few inconsistencies in the story. How a brilliant physicist who ascribed to the theory that one traveling in time should never disturb events and then went ahead and did just that was one thing that stuck in my caw. There were other things that bothered me but then again they might have done so because I was readily looking for flaws.

So, I am going to leave it at that and try to remember that the theme of this book was ultimately what dimmed this book's shine for me. I am sure many will and do love this book. I also know that all books are not for all people.

Thank you to Diane Chamberlain, St Martin's Press, and NetGalley for a copy of this novel.

47 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read The Dream Daughter.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

April 23, 2018 – Shelved
April 23, 2018 – Shelved as: to-read
October 5, 2018 – Started Reading
October 8, 2018 –
25.0%
October 9, 2018 –
99.0%
October 10, 2018 – Shelved as: net-galley
October 10, 2018 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-26 of 26 (26 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

JanB Marialyce, a very thoughtful, honest, and fair review. Not every book is for every reader and you were very clear on your issues. The logic, or lack of, is always the conundrum with time travel books. Sometimes I can accept and just go with it and other times, not. I hope your next book is a better read!


message 2: by Brandice (new)

Brandice Nice review, Marialyce! Sorry it was a letdown. I did enjoy The Time Traveler’s Wife but tend not to gravitate toward time travel themed reads as they’re often hard for me to suspend belief while reading.


message 3: by Kaceey (new)

Kaceey Great review Marialyce! Sorry this one didn’t work for you! Hope you are enjoying your current read!


message 4: by Dana (new)

Dana Nice, honest review, Marialyce! Thanks for sharing your thoughts.


message 5: by Suzy (new) - added it

Suzy So sorry you didn’t care for this one Marialyce! I just started it and I’m trying to keep an open mind about the time travel thing. Wish me luck! 🤞🏻😊 Hope your next book is better!


Debra Great honest review, Marialyce! Sorry this didn't work for you.


Angela M Sorry it didn’t work for you, Marialyce!


Lindsay L So sorry this didn’t work out better Marialyce. I have a hard time with time travel as well so I wonder if this will be the same for me. Hope your next book is fantastic!!! 💜


message 9: by Katie (new)

Katie Fingers crossed for your next one, Marialyce!


Marialyce JanB wrote: "Marialyce, a very thoughtful, honest, and fair review. Not every book is for every reader and you were very clear on your issues. The logic, or lack of, is always the conundrum with time travel boo..."

Thanks Jan! I always feel a tinge of guilt when I don't like a book others have loved.


Marialyce Brandice wrote: "Nice review, Marialyce! Sorry it was a letdown. I did enjoy The Time Traveler’s Wife but tend not to gravitate toward time travel themed reads as they’re often hard for me to suspend belief while r..."

I should have realized that this book probably wasn't for me given my history with time travel books. Thanks. Brandice!


Marialyce Kaceey - Traveling Sister wrote: "Great review Marialyce! Sorry this one didn’t work for you! Hope you are enjoying your current read!"

Thanks Kaceey, and yes I am enjoying my current reads.


Marialyce Dana wrote: "Nice, honest review, Marialyce! Thanks for sharing your thoughts."

Thank you, Dana!


Marialyce Babydimps (Suzy) wrote: "So sorry you didn’t care for this one Marialyce! I just started it and I’m trying to keep an open mind about the time travel thing. Wish me luck! 🤞🏻😊 Hope your next book is better!"

Hoping you do like it Suzy!


Marialyce Debra wrote: "Great honest review, Marialyce! Sorry this didn't work for you."

Thank you, Debra!


Marialyce Angela M wrote: "Sorry it didn’t work for you, Marialyce!"

Thanks, Angela!


Marialyce Lindsay - Traveling Sister wrote: "So sorry this didn’t work out better Marialyce. I have a hard time with time travel as well so I wonder if this will be the same for me. Hope your next book is fantastic!!! 💜"

Thanks so much, Lindsay. I hope you love it.


Marialyce Katie wrote: "Fingers crossed for your next one, Marialyce!"

Thank you, Katie! There are always five star books waiting for us.


message 19: by Maureen (new)

Maureen Sorry you didn’t enjoy it Marialyce but great review anyway 😘


Marialyce Maureen wrote: "Sorry you didn’t enjoy it Marialyce but great review anyway 😘"

Thanks so much, Maureen!


message 21: by Melissa (new)

Melissa Love this review, Marialyce! And thank you! I've seen so many stellar reviews for this one and was planning on picking it up, but like you, I cannot handle time travel. No matter the character, time period or anything else . . . it just doesn't work for me. Hope your next read is amazing.


Marialyce Melissa wrote: "Love this review, Marialyce! And thank you! I've seen so many stellar reviews for this one and was planning on picking it up, but like you, I cannot handle time travel. No matter the character, tim..."

Thank you, Melissa! I do appreciate your comment as we seem to be kindred spirits about this theme.


Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader Thoughtful review, Marialyce! I hope your next read is one you love!


Cheri Wonderful review, Marialyce, I loved this, but I sometimes can accept the "time travel" concept in stories, and sometimes not. In this, it's so central to the story that I can't imagine enjoying it without being able to accept that! Onward to better ones for you!


Marialyce Jennifer ~ TarHeelReader wrote: "Thoughtful review, Marialyce! I hope your next read is one you love!"

Thanks Jennifer! I am loving the one I am reading now.


Marialyce Cheri wrote: "Wonderful review, Marialyce, I loved this, but I sometimes can accept the "time travel" concept in stories, and sometimes not. In this, it's so central to the story that I can't imagine enjoying it..."

Thanks Cheri! I am glad you loved this story.


back to top