Nate D's Reviews > The Third Bear
The Third Bear
by
by

I don't always have a lot of patience with contemporary sci-fi and fantasy, but Vandermeer here tempers forays into pulp with a better-than-working-familiarity with the more postmodern and surreal threads running through 20th-century fantastic fiction, as well as that formative dread of the turn of the century weird. Which I suppose encapsulates all of what the New Weird sub-movement he's a part of promises in general, though I don't often find it so elegant in execution as in the three or four especially standout stories here, which push into genuinely strange, memorable, and original territory.
It's bits like the mostly unexplained conceptual tendrils, for instance, permeating "Three Days in a Border Town", which could be set in an ordinary post-apocalyptic world were it not for its yearning towards a de-localized, ghostly, there-but-not-there city promising something better than dusty present life. Or the reconfiguring of Pale Fire, reinvented autobiography, and rewritten bits of other stories, in "Errata". Possibly best of all, the otherworldly office politics of "The Situation", which remains unpredictable throughout by never totally resolving its terms, even as many scenes familiarly recapitulate drab contemporary day job existence. Not so incidentally, that story also offers prototype and sub-variant of Vandermeer's stellar most recent novel, Borne. Or the multiverse-spanning political nightmare in "The Goat Variations".
Other stories do fall more neatly into their categories, and suffer for it -- there's a steampunk piece, a myth retelling, a few bits of surrealism creeping into normal life basically in line with the original weird templates of the past. These will fade down in my memory before long, I'm sure. But then you have a story of a bear plaguing a small town with the techniques of a serial killer, that soon expands from horror yarn into a bleak commentary on how society treats its outsiders. Something familiar here is turned unfamiliar, then smarter and more knowing -- even as it basks in the pulpiest pulp it can offer. Which I can get behind. Sometimes I like to be entertained, it's just that so much ostensibly purely entertaining storytelling, and especially unfortunately horror writing, for me, feels limited and uncreative or else tips over into mawkishness, and I can't really enjoy it. This, more often than not, avoids these pitfalls.
It's bits like the mostly unexplained conceptual tendrils, for instance, permeating "Three Days in a Border Town", which could be set in an ordinary post-apocalyptic world were it not for its yearning towards a de-localized, ghostly, there-but-not-there city promising something better than dusty present life. Or the reconfiguring of Pale Fire, reinvented autobiography, and rewritten bits of other stories, in "Errata". Possibly best of all, the otherworldly office politics of "The Situation", which remains unpredictable throughout by never totally resolving its terms, even as many scenes familiarly recapitulate drab contemporary day job existence. Not so incidentally, that story also offers prototype and sub-variant of Vandermeer's stellar most recent novel, Borne. Or the multiverse-spanning political nightmare in "The Goat Variations".
Other stories do fall more neatly into their categories, and suffer for it -- there's a steampunk piece, a myth retelling, a few bits of surrealism creeping into normal life basically in line with the original weird templates of the past. These will fade down in my memory before long, I'm sure. But then you have a story of a bear plaguing a small town with the techniques of a serial killer, that soon expands from horror yarn into a bleak commentary on how society treats its outsiders. Something familiar here is turned unfamiliar, then smarter and more knowing -- even as it basks in the pulpiest pulp it can offer. Which I can get behind. Sometimes I like to be entertained, it's just that so much ostensibly purely entertaining storytelling, and especially unfortunately horror writing, for me, feels limited and uncreative or else tips over into mawkishness, and I can't really enjoy it. This, more often than not, avoids these pitfalls.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
The Third Bear.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
May 27, 2018
–
Started Reading
May 30, 2018
– Shelved
June 25, 2018
– Shelved as:
stories
June 25, 2018
– Shelved as:
weird
June 25, 2018
– Shelved as:
fantasy
June 25, 2018
– Shelved as:
read-in-2018
June 25, 2018
– Shelved as:
horror
June 25, 2018
–
Finished Reading
Comments Showing 1-10 of 10 (10 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
mark
(new)
Jul 03, 2018 11:09PM

reply
|
flag

Granted, the problem of tipping over into the ridiculous, is an issue I have with all too much horror writing in general (ie, it may be my problem not anything to do with the works themselves). This marred my enjoyment of Vandermeer's own Southern Reach trilogy as well. It's just that here it seems like he's often more intentionally playful, so it works.

the only Cisco I've read is his collection of stories, Secret Hours. I thought it was amazing.

tl;dr I should probably get over it and read some Ramsey Campbell already regardless, which I'm sure will be ridiculous, but probably also a lot of fun.
(Oh, and that's the other thing -- horror for some reason seems to have an even more cult following than sci-fi, so it can be difficult to find and really force me to work in order to have my ambivalent reactions. I've never even seen a novel by Ramsy Campbell, or Michael Cisco for that matter, on a bookstore shelf.)

I wonder what you will think of Ramsey Campbell. he's one of my favorites. although Aickman is too...

most of my experience with him was in my 20s. he's an often quirky and mannered writer who loves to play with unreliable narrators; I recall liking the ones where his prose and story were especially off-kilter (The Doll Who Ate Its Mother, Incarnate, The Nameless, The Face That Must Die) and not particularly enjoying ones that felt more mainstream (The Hungry Moon, The Influence, Ancient Images).
the most recent Campbells I've read were the very hit-or-miss Cold Print and the surprisingly delightful The Last Revelation Of Gla'aki
here's another author I think you should look into: T.M. Wright. I've read three by him recently, and two of them were superb: The Eyes of the Carp and Strange Seed