Caroline's Reviews > The Happiness Project
The Happiness Project
by
by

Caroline's review
bookshelves: 5-star-books, miscellaneous, psychology
Jun 14, 2018
bookshelves: 5-star-books, miscellaneous, psychology
Read 2 times. Last read May 17, 2018 to June 2018.
I enjoyed reading this book, it was fun and stimulating, and it made me HAPPY.
It involved following Gretchen Rubin in her year-long pursuit to increase the amount of happiness in her life. I learnt a lot along the way, and often they were things I was not expecting to learn. I didn't agree with everything she tried - but then neither did she - some of her projects just didn't work out. But a lot of them did, and she has given us all a lot to think about.
The book has been a great success, spawning a blog that loads of people seem to read and take part in, but the hype isn't just hype - I think she deserves the positive feedback.
She takes a different topic each month of the year..
Vitality
Marriage
Work
Parenthood
Leisure
Friendship
Money
Eternity
Books.
The main messages I got from this book about happiness?
Be you. Blow doing anything you don't enjoy. If your real pleasure is collecting Cindy dolls - then just go for it, regardless of more highbrow pleasures that might turn other people on.... we must do the things that make us joyful.
Try and work out what makes you happy, and then keep a resolution chart that will ensure that you actually DO the things that make you happy. Rubin says that keeping a resolution chart was the very nub of what made this project successful for her. It ensured that she kept practising her new habits, or in Rubin's words "Accessibility to good ideas and practises makes it easier for the subconscious brain to access them." So, a resolution chart is good!
Finally, the book ends with an excellent list of books for further reading.
I shall end with my usual stack of notes (view spoiler)
It involved following Gretchen Rubin in her year-long pursuit to increase the amount of happiness in her life. I learnt a lot along the way, and often they were things I was not expecting to learn. I didn't agree with everything she tried - but then neither did she - some of her projects just didn't work out. But a lot of them did, and she has given us all a lot to think about.
The book has been a great success, spawning a blog that loads of people seem to read and take part in, but the hype isn't just hype - I think she deserves the positive feedback.
She takes a different topic each month of the year..
Vitality
Marriage
Work
Parenthood
Leisure
Friendship
Money
Eternity
Books.
The main messages I got from this book about happiness?
Be you. Blow doing anything you don't enjoy. If your real pleasure is collecting Cindy dolls - then just go for it, regardless of more highbrow pleasures that might turn other people on.... we must do the things that make us joyful.
Try and work out what makes you happy, and then keep a resolution chart that will ensure that you actually DO the things that make you happy. Rubin says that keeping a resolution chart was the very nub of what made this project successful for her. It ensured that she kept practising her new habits, or in Rubin's words "Accessibility to good ideas and practises makes it easier for the subconscious brain to access them." So, a resolution chart is good!
Finally, the book ends with an excellent list of books for further reading.
I shall end with my usual stack of notes (view spoiler)
Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read
The Happiness Project.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Finished Reading
May 17, 2018
–
Started Reading
June, 2018
–
Finished Reading
June 14, 2018
– Shelved
Comments Showing 1-27 of 27 (27 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Jan-Maat
(new)
Jun 15, 2018 01:06AM

reply
|
flag

Yes, absolutely.
I have for a while been using a calendar with ticks and letters of the alphabet to show I have done certain things on certain days. It's been a real boon with doing exercises like my old-lady's-balance-exercises, or remembering to take pills. I'm moving into a state of unravelling though where I shall have to start putting ticks for putting on my shoes and brushing my teeth as well..... :O)

Yes, absolutely.
I have for ..."
come on! Lets all have fun putting on our shoes! One, two, Buckle my shoe!



I also thought that was excellent advice!

That's a good question! I think the thing that impressed me most was her description of good and bad habits in conversation. I think I have quite a few of the bad habits she described, and since I read that, I have been trying to be a better conversationalist. I really have been trying...
Re. her children, I think the thing that most impressed me was the way she tried to relish them. In her happiness research she realised that time with children passes quickly, and she resolved to pause and really enjoy them. She also adopted the idea that the process, the 'growth', is almost more exciting than the goal, and she tried to give her children access to experiences which elaborated on this. For instance she let one of her daughters go back to the cake shop to 're-choose' her birthday cake, realising that the choosing was probably the best bit of the enterprise.
She also created such wonderful memories for her children, not only in their special celebrations, but she made things like lovely photo albums - not only containing photos, but all sorts of other mementos, and bits of writing. It must have been such fun for her and the children. There were other things too, but I forget them - rather I am left with a warm fuzzy feeling that it must be very nice to be one of her children.

I appreciate the details. It seems that with many good things, and by this I mean also the more steady times in life, we do not appreciate them until we come to the unsteady hard bits!


Very true!
I think it is powerful to sometimes practise a combination of gratitude and mindfulness - a bit like a meditation. Even if it just means sitting in your favourite armchair and appreciating the cosy comfort you get from it.
And now you have made me remember a poem that I haven't thought about for about 30 years!
What is this life if, full of care,
We have no time to stand and stare.
No time to stand beneath the boughs
And stare as long as sheep or cows.
No time to see, when woods we pass,
Where squirrels hide their nuts in grass.
No time to see, in broad daylight,
Streams full of stars, like skies at night.
No time to turn at Beauty's glance,
And watch her feet, how they can dance.
No time to wait till her mouth can
Enrich that smile her eyes began.
A poor life this if, full of care,
We have no time to stand and stare.
William Henry Davies.

I look forward very much to hearing what you think of it Caroline!

And thank you for the reminder Sue. I think this is a good idea too, but I always forget to practise it. I am going to write myself a post-it note right now....

Personally, I believe in serendipity and cause and efect. That's my mantra. This became apparent the other day. I love watching the French news in the evening and there was a clip for "Cinderella". Oh no, was my immediate thought. A Hollywood overkill. Well I watched the clip, was enchanted and ordered the BluRay.
The film was amazing. Lily James, the English actress, as Cinderella, had this quality of goodness about her. Now I'm not digressing here but her philosophy in life, following that of her mother was "to have courage and be kind". Indeed if you have the two, happiness is always there. Well I believe so... And I'm no know-all!
And finally, keep going with your notes. Love them!

In the book Gretchen Rubin says that it is easy to denigrate a Pollyanna-ish approach to life - but in reality it does much to make life better for yourself and for other people. Personally I fully approve of a philosophy of having courage and being kind. I don't feel that happiness is ever guaranteed, but it is certainly an outlook I like....

Ben Franklin also liked them!

[plus, I dislike order and structure - it seems to diminish everything. I'd rather fail to do something ten times, and then suddenly accomplish it when the mood takes me, rather than tick it off dutifully on the first day and move on to my next obligation. (maybe it's just that I don't like authority figures, including myself... if I try to force myself to do something, I immediately rebel...)]
I also don't agree with her guide to good conversation. Well, in some ways I do - everything you list there is generally considered key to 'good' conversation , in the sense of making most people like you. The problem is... it's so ghastly. Good conversation is so appallingly dull that whenever I attempt it I soon find myself boring my own ear off - and what's worse, if you are good at conversation, you attract to yourself other people who like, and engage in, good conversation. Which is a dull and unproductive situation to find yourself in - what could be worse than being surrounded by unchallenging supportiveness and positivity? It may be nice for a little while, but you soon realise that their "good conversation" is just lying, and lying in an uninteresting way. If someone always responds to your enthusiasm with "wow, yes, it was great, wasn't it?", then you very soon stop talking to them, because if they're just echoing your own tastes back to you, what are they really bringing to the conversation? Besides, a lot of people would be happier, I think, if they learned to deal better with disagreement and difference (myself included, of course...). Bad conversation is like going around giving people cowpox: perhaps not very pleasant in the moment, but actually good for everybody in the long run...
[at the extreme end of that idea: some researchers have called into question the idea that happiness is a good thing, at least in part because happiness is strongly correlated with suicide - countries and regions where people report greater happiness also have higher rates of suicide. It's thought part of this might be the innoculation effect: people who are used to great happiness struggle to cope with sudden unhappiness; those who have been innoculated with lesser irritations are more able to bear greater burdens when they do arise.]
So, I'm constantly argumentative*, I almost always deflate other people's optimism (though I try to do so in an amusing way where possible), and I'm a know-it-all - treat others the way you'd like to be treated, after all! And as the old proverb says: if you can't say anything bad, you shouldn't say anything at all... I'm not a 'topper', though, as I hate being boastful (I'm far too well brought up to ever boast about anything, except ironically)...
Well, 'so' is obviously inaccurate there. I'm that way because... I'm that way. Hence nobody likes me. But the fact I enjoy being that way, and more greatly enjoy an interesting, respectful but honest conversation with someone who tolerates me than I would a "good" but barren conversation with someone who liked me, is a big part of why I've never even tried to change that about myself.
The rest of the advice seems a little obvious, but true nonetheless. [I hadn't heard the idea about transference... i wonder if that's true? Seems too neat...]. And frankly most of us could do with being told some obviously true but easily forgotten things periodically, because most of us have short memories when it comes to building better habits...
*I'm actually a little passionate about this one. Disagreement is the most valuable thing you can do in speech, in most circumstances (not all, of course). Whatever anyone thinks, they're wrong - they always are, because reality is more complicated than any theory. And even if they're completely right, they're probably over-confident. Whatever they believe, they have clearly provided that side of the argument themselves - the only way they can improve their situation and their prospects is if somebody offers the other side. Disagreement is how we - individually and as a society, and as a species - progress. I view this modern taste for agreement - intellectual flattery - with great suspicion.

[plus, I dislike order and structu..."
Clearly you are not similar in personality to Franklin, which I expect comes as no surprise. However, I ought to clarify that he was attempting to practice virtue and good work habits rather than being happier or more popular (although I gather he was both). He decided to focus on one virtue or good habit at a time and then give up on the one's he was worst at. I believe they were tidiness and chastity, but don't quote me on that, I read his autobiography in high school.

[plus, I dislike order and structu..."
I was extremely interested to read what you had to say Wastrel, and thank you for responding! I came to the conclusion that we are just very different people - really the proverbial Jack Sprat and his wife, but hopefully we can communicate across that divide.
I find resolution charts invaluable. More than anything I use mine to make sure I do my daily old-lady-balance-exercises and pelvic floor exercises. Until I kept a chart I was always forgetting to do them (in fact I use a calendar.) But you have reminded me that I could use them for something more esoteric, and I would have no compunction about using them for that either. I am a fantastically a creature of habit, and creating new habits for me is a major task. The likelihood of me simply doing things differently because "the mood takes me" is miniscule. I am like a blinkered dinosaur on rails! Ye gods I'm not proud of this - it would be lovely to be more spontaneous and quick-witted....but I am neither of these things.
I agree with what you say about disagreement in conversation - to an extent. Again I see our different reactions to Rubin's suggestions about 'good conversation' as being largely a personality thing. For instance I personally sometimes feel grumpy and belligerent, and I can hear myself playing that out in conversations, and I don't like myself for it. On the other hand, whatever my mood, if someone argues against something I strongly believe in, I am not going to sit there and nod encouragingly, I am of course going to argue back. But I choose my battles carefully - and Rubin's book has encouraged me to do this even more. For instance my brother has no small talk. He only wants to talk about politics and world events (& robots, & artificial intelligence, two great pet loves of his.) All of this suits me fine. But..... we have very different views about nearly everything. Practically every time he opens his mouth I feel an urge to disagree. I don't though, I say something diplomatic instead, usually something neutral like "I appreciate you feel that way." Every now and then he hits a raw nerve, and then I argue - but most of the time I just nod. He usually comes over for a whole day at a time. I am very fond of him. He is a kind, honest and intellectually searching person. But if I were to argue with every single point he raises that I disagree with we would be at it hammer and tongs for hours on end. I think our relationship would fall apart....and I think that would be a real loss for both of us. I DO argue with him....but I let a lot of minor things just ride.
Re. agreeing with someone who was very enthusiastic about a book or film I disliked? No, I wouldn't do that. If they were really besotted with it though I would probably be quite gentle in putting forward my perspective, unless I thought they were supporting something toxic.
Re what Rubin's said about transference - in my experience this is realistic, but in a fairly mild fashion. It also depends on the person and the context.
Once again - I am very pleased that you stopped by to voice your opinion - I found it most interesting, and thought you raised some valid points.

Thank you Jessaka. I can't remember if she said turn off the news, but that would have been a darn good suggestion!

Thank you for the compliment.... but I'm sorry I can't help, I tried to copy the notes to my flickr stream, but Amazon won't let me link to another site.

Are you on a computer or using the phone app? On a computer you should be able to copy and paste to a word doc.