ŷ

Peter's Reviews > In Cold Blood

In Cold Blood by Truman Capote
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
63168028
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: crime, non-fiction, buddy-read

Chilling
An outstanding and powerful work of literature, even more impressive because it conveyed true crimes, a profound investigative insight, the vivid sense of time and place, and the atmosphere that cloaked the evil events carried out on November 15 in 1959, in Holcomb, Kansas. Truman Capote is an artist that painted every detail of the story with such a detailed flow that causes us to stop and appreciate the surroundings rather than wishing the story was being pushed at a faster pace.

Looking at America in the 50s from the perspective of a foreigner we often think more of a Holywood version of an innocent age, affluent, white picket fences, apple pie, and rock and roll pervading the airwaves. If anyone asked me when and where I'd liked to have lived it would have been the US in the 1950s. In Cold Blood smashes that image with the reality that cruelty can take away life, a community’s character and the idyllic vision I'd imagined above.

The murders of four of the Clutter family by Dick Hickock and Perry Smith for $40, stunned not only the population of Holcomb but ultimately a world-wide audience. My vision, I so wanted to believe of the US, couldn't have been better envisioned than by Holcomb in the 1950s, where families rarely locked their doors and the safety of the neighbourhood was never doubted. Hickock and Smith not only brutally destroyed the lives of four innocent people but destroyed the fundamental promise of safety in our own homes.

The story explores the background of the murderers, what drove them, how they considered what they had done, the investigation into the crimes, and the community that became fearful and suspicious that for a long time they did not know who was responsible. To achieve this nonfiction novel with such beautiful prose is a seminal point in literature where it is arguable that Capote created a new genre.

I have for a long time been fascinated by the relationship between Truman Capote and Harper Lee and how they helped each other research and draft their renowned classics. It is interesting that Harper Lee had been inspired during the ‘In Cold Blood� collaboration with Capote to research and use the case of Robert Burns who shot dead the serial killer, Reverend Willie Maxwell, to write her own true-crime novel - which never materialised. Another relationship Capote shattered during his years of self-destruction.

I do believe this is a must-read novel and is surely a classic and a powerful combination of true-crime with such beautiful writing talent. I have my wonderful friend Julie Grippo who encouraged me to read this book and read along with me when I had the opportunity to do so. Thank you so much, Julie, and please see her brilliant review at /review/show...
130 likes · flag

Sign into ŷ to see if any of your friends have read In Cold Blood.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

June 15, 2018 – Shelved
June 15, 2018 – Shelved as: to-read
June 15, 2018 – Shelved as: crime
June 15, 2018 – Shelved as: non-fiction
September 24, 2020 – Started Reading
September 24, 2020 – Shelved as: buddy-read
December 17, 2020 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-39 of 39 (39 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

message 1: by Diane (new)

Diane Wallace Terrific review, Peter ;)


Julie G Peter,
My father was born in the Midwest, in 1943, and he always said if he could live forever in any time period, it would be in America in the 1950s. Granted, he was a white man from a small town, so he definitely experienced an idealized version of what might have been very different for a different person.
We do think of many good things that came out of the '50s, though, and this story WAS NOT ONE OF THEM! Ack!
We just drove through hours and hours of Western Kansas, heading back from my son's after Thanksgiving, and for the first time ever, I looked at the farmhouses and the large parcels of farmed land, and thought, "How awful, that such a world could have met with such an end."


Peter Diane wrote: "Terrific review, Peter ;)"

Thank you very much, Diane, really appreciated.


Peter Julie wrote: "Peter,
My father was born in the Midwest, in 1943, and he always said if he could live forever in any time period, it would be in America in the 1950s. Granted, he was a white man from a small town..."


It is much easier for me to imagine America during the 1950s not living there and only getting insight from what we gleaned from the movies. It is interesting that you used the phrase "that such a world could have met with such an end." That's one of the main takeaways I felt after reading this book.

Great that you managed to get through Thanksgiving all healthy and safe. Thanks for joining me on this book and sorry work became such a pain in the butt.


Julie G New buddy read in 2021?


Jayme Ooh! I remember this one! Terrific review!!


message 7: by Michael (new)

Michael David (on hiatus) Phenomenal review, Peter! I read this book so long ago that I don't even have a review for it. I'm thrilled you got so much out of it!


Barbara K Great review, Peter. I read this many years ago and it left an indelible impression on me for the quality of the writing. Have you read The Furious Hours, the book Casey Cep wrote about Harper Lee’s failed effort to write the Willie Maxwell story? It’s quite well done.

Re the US in the 1950’s, I was only a child then, but I think I can say with a fairly high degree of confidence that it was a great time to be a white heterosexual male. For the rest of us, not so much. I know a number of men now in their 80’s who would very much like to turn back the clock to that time.


message 9: by Yun (new)

Yun Terrific review, Peter! This sounds like a fascinating read, especially for true crime fans. So glad you enjoyed it immensely! :)


message 10: by Paromjit (new)

Paromjit Marvellous review, Peter. :):)


Peter Julie wrote: "New buddy read in 2021?"

Absolutely something to look forward to early in 2021. 🤗👊


Peter Jayme wrote: "Ooh! I remember this one! Terrific review!!"

Thank you very much, Jayme, it is a fantastic book.


Peter Michael wrote: "Phenomenal review, Peter! I read this book so long ago that I don't even have a review for it. I'm thrilled you got so much out of it!"

Thank you very much, Michael, there are so many books I've often wondered should I go back and try to write reviews for. :) It was certainly an amazing book.


message 14: by [deleted user] (new)

Merry Christmas, Peter!


Peter Barbara wrote: "Great review, Peter. I read this many years ago and it left an indelible impression on me for the quality of the writing. Have you read The Furious Hours, the book Casey Cep wrote about Harper Lee�..."

Thank you for your kind comment, Barbara. Yes, I did read The Furious Hours - very well researched and I enjoyed the insight.

I totally get the issue you raised and humanity has an unforgivable sin in that it has always treated sections of our communities with injustice and inequality. I hope and pray that someday we can see a better world but we have a long way to go. I think I know who you talk about in their 80s. 😂


Peter Yun wrote: "Terrific review, Peter! This sounds like a fascinating read, especially for true crime fans. So glad you enjoyed it immensely! :)"

Thank you so much, Yun and it was fascinating but also so heartbreaking and horrific.


Peter Paromjit wrote: "Marvellous review, Peter. :):)"

I appreciate your lovely comment, Paromjit, thanks. :):)


Peter Dita wrote: "Merry Christmas, Peter!"

Merry Christmas to you my dear friend. I hope you and your family have a happy and healthy holiday, and Santa is good to you. 😂🎁🎄


Maureen Fantastic review Peter 👏🏻


Peter Maureen wrote: "Fantastic review Peter 👏🏻"

Thanks, Maureen I appreciate the kind comment.


Regina Although I didn't love this book (I tried!), I loved your review, Peter!


message 22: by Kat (new)

Kat I watched the movie based on the book years ago and it was quite compelling. I'm sure the book is an even fuller representation of all the events. Fantastic review, Peter!


Peter Regina wrote: "Although I didn't love this book (I tried!), I loved your review, Peter!"

That is extremely kind of you Regina and you've made an old man very happy. 😂


Peter Kat wrote: "I watched the movie based on the book years ago and it was quite compelling. I'm sure the book is an even fuller representation of all the events. Fantastic review, Peter!"

The book is a classic but I can't compare as I've never seen the film. Great that you found it compelling as well. Thanks, Kat, really appreciated.


message 25: by Penny (new) - added it

Penny -Thecatladybooknook I almost bought this today!! I might go back and get it sometime.


message 26: by Barbara (new)

Barbara Did you read Furious Hours by Casey Cep? The relationship between Capote and Lee is addressed. It is a great book. Wonderful review, Peter.


Peter Penny wrote: "I almost bought this today!! I might go back and get it sometime."

I think it is well worth reading and certainly a classic to keep in your library. I hope you enjoy Penny.


Peter Barbara wrote: "Did you read Furious Hours by Casey Cep? The relationship between Capote and Lee is addressed. It is a great book. Wonderful review, Peter."

Yes, I read Furious Hours and found it very interesting. Casey Cep did a great job with the research. I also read Swan Song which dealt with the almost social suicide of Capote as he ratted out all his friends and their secrets in his last book project. Thank you very much, Barbara.


message 29: by Kathleen (new)

Kathleen Wonderful review of this classic. It still gives me chills.


message 30: by Barbara (new)

Barbara Peter wrote: "Barbara wrote: "Did you read Furious Hours by Casey Cep? The relationship between Capote and Lee is addressed. It is a great book. Wonderful review, Peter."

Yes, I read Furious Hours and found it ..."

I'll put Swan Song on TBR list. Thanks for the recommendation. Happy holidays, Peter!


Peter Barbara wrote: "Peter wrote: "Barbara wrote: "Did you read Furious Hours by Casey Cep? The relationship between Capote and Lee is addressed. It is a great book. Wonderful review, Peter."

Yes, I read Furious Hours..."


You're welcome Barbara and I hope you enjoy it. I hope you and your family have a wonderful Christmas and best wishes for a healthy and peaceful New Year.


message 32: by Barbara (new)

Barbara Peter wrote: "Barbara wrote: "Peter wrote: "Barbara wrote: "Did you read Furious Hours by Casey Cep? The relationship between Capote and Lee is addressed. It is a great book. Wonderful review, Peter."

Yes, I re..."

Thanks so much,Peter.


Marialyce Wonderfully detailed review, Peter.


Peter Kathleen wrote: "Wonderful review of this classic. It still gives me chills."

It's scary monsters alright and all the more so because it was true. Thank you for your kind comment, Kathleen.


Peter Marialyce wrote: "Wonderfully detailed review, Peter."

Thank you so much, Marialyce, truly appreciated.


message 36: by Ann (new) - added it

Ann Fabulous review, Peter. Scary that this was a true story.


Peter Ann wrote: "Fabulous review, Peter. Scary that this was a true story."

I know Ann it was so upsetting to realise this was a true story. Thanks for your kind comment.


Lesle Great review


Peter Lesle wrote: "Great review"

Thank you very much, Lesle, really appreciated.


back to top