Cecily's Reviews > Cider With Rosie
Cider With Rosie
by
by

A quintessential coming of age story. It tells of Laurie Lee’s childhood in Gloucestershire, just after WW1. But it is not only Lee’s coming of age, it is also that of the village, as the rural backwater changes rapidly, losing many of its traditional village ways and gaining things such as motor vehicles.
The first time I read it, I was quite young and slightly confused as it was the first book I read that was not really chronological, but instead told the story grouped by overlapping themes, such as seasons, school, grannies (not blood ones) and festivals. It also takes a very relaxed approach to consenting incest, underage sex and drink and attempted gang rape � not something I expected as a teenager reading a book of such antiquity! Rereading it as an adult, is rather different.
The most memorable scenes for me are not the famous cider in the haystack but two big disappointments: when Laurie is deemed too old to sleep in his mother’s bed and then when he starts school and is told to sit in a particular place “for the present�, and is bitterly disappointed not to be given said present at the end of the day.
It's interesting to compare this with DH Lawrence's early short story, nearly half a century earlier:
Love Among the Haystacks.
The first time I read it, I was quite young and slightly confused as it was the first book I read that was not really chronological, but instead told the story grouped by overlapping themes, such as seasons, school, grannies (not blood ones) and festivals. It also takes a very relaxed approach to consenting incest, underage sex and drink and attempted gang rape � not something I expected as a teenager reading a book of such antiquity! Rereading it as an adult, is rather different.
The most memorable scenes for me are not the famous cider in the haystack but two big disappointments: when Laurie is deemed too old to sleep in his mother’s bed and then when he starts school and is told to sit in a particular place “for the present�, and is bitterly disappointed not to be given said present at the end of the day.
It's interesting to compare this with DH Lawrence's early short story, nearly half a century earlier:
Love Among the Haystacks.
Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read
Cider With Rosie.
Sign In »
Reading Progress
Finished Reading
June 14, 2008
– Shelved
May 23, 2009
– Shelved as:
classics
May 23, 2009
– Shelved as:
biog-and-autobiog
Comments Showing 1-11 of 11 (11 new)
date
newest »

message 1:
by
Kevin
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Mar 31, 2016 09:10AM

reply
|
flag

Thanks for commenting on this ancient review, that I think was written a few years after I'd most recently read it. I'm not sure what I'd make of it now; I certainly hope I wouldn't be confused by it.
I'm glad you've enjoyed it recently.

Review posted in 2008, so according to my calculation you first read it when you were two years old.
Anyway, it's a given that I love the review, but I didn't want to say anything until I have ;)

;)
But
Apatt wrote: ""Anyway, it's a given that I love the review, but I didn't want to say anything until I have posted my own ;)"
Is not flattery and will not get you anywhere good!
Anyway, I said "first read". When I wrote the review, eight years ago, it was probably only a couple of years since my most recent reading of it. So I'd have been at least 20.
:p

;)
But
Apatt wrote: ""Anyway, it's a given that I love the review, but I didn't want to say anything until I have p..."
You did click on that link in my comment didn't you?

Yes, which is why you deserve to end up somewhere bad!
(But only briefly.)

Yes, which is why you deserve to end up somewhere bad!
(But only briefly.)"
Happy April's Fool to you too! ;)
Amazing that meme is still going after all these years!


I'm sure you had more enjoyable teenage experiences you were saving those memory slots for.
;)

Apatt: "Review posted in 2008, so according to my calculation you first read it when you were two years old."
Cecily: "Flattery will get you somewhere only when it's within the bounds of credibility."
Happened upon this amusing piece of interplay again. You two are quite the double act when the mood strikes. : )