Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ

Gabi's Reviews > Passage

Passage by Connie Willis
Rate this book
Clear rating

by
84001290
's review

it was amazing
bookshelves: hugo_nominees, locus_winners, nebula_nominees

I was trying to not give so many 5 star ratings this year, but after having thought a bit about „Passage� I fear I have to go for another one of the highest ratings.

The novel bears the same typical Connie Willis trademarks of characters missing one another through bad timing, trying to hide from other characters, non functioning equipment or a misleading environment (in this case it is a labyrinthian design of a hospital with corridors ever so often blocked because of repair and/or being painted). The running gag here is a cafeteria that seemingly never is open. We also have the usual bunch of crazy, slightly tropey side characters that feel like belonging into a sitcom. As always the story takes its time, the plot is slowly unfolding taking a lot of detours.

All these points I see frequently mentioned in reviews of her books as a negative, and I can see how those quirks could be offputting for some readers. For me they are what makes Connie Willis� writing special, recognizable and extremely loveable. After the first chapter I was again fully immersed in her nutcase world. The audio, which has a length of roughly 30 hours, was meant as my companion for the next week or so, but I raced through it in 3 days.

In the case of this novel the erratic flow wasn’t only a signature but an outside metaphor for the inside struggle that is at the heart of the story. Once I realised that I appreciated the typical style even more and this appreciation was what lead in the end to another 5 stars.

At the center of „Passage� are near death experiences (NDE). Psychologist Joanna Lander studies NDEs and tries to get to the how and why of it through factual approach while always finding herself a step behind her ‚colleague� Dr. Mandrake, a religious charlatan and author of best-selling After-Death-Experience books, who influences NDE patients with his leading questions and ruins their experience for Lander in the go.
Together with neurologist Richard Wright who runs a study where he is chemically evoking NDEs in a healthy subject group she hopes to get to the bottom of this phenomenon without interfering from Mandrake. Yet as more and more of the test group prove themselves unreliable for various reasons Lander decides to go under herself with a very weird result.

Willis attends to the subject with an unemotional eye. She stays off pathos or religious colouring on the one hand, but also doesn’t steer into the too dry field of mere scientific terms � even though she shows a well researched medical knowledge. The metaphysical experiences she describes feel ‚real� (as far as such a word is possible with this topic), she tries to find an answer and not to veil anything with obscure mysticism.

Not surprisingly one of the most prominent topics of her novel is the importance of being honest, even in the face of devastating truth. She condemms the notion of being lied to. This issue is masterfully brought to page with the character of nine year old Maisie suffering from cardiomyopathy and little hope of surviving. The girl is sick and tired of being lied to by adults who want her to stay positive and buries herself in the studies of human disasters like the sinking of the Titanic, the burning of the Hindenburg and others. Her obsession with those topics lets her become Joanna Lander’s secret study assistant who is the only one to tread her like an adult.
The paragraphs concerning Maisie and her view on life and the world in general are some of the very best moments in the book. Her fierceness and vulnerability are skillfully portrayed. I was rooting for her in a way that it even didn’t matter if she lived or died in the end. Every outcome would have felt right. Willis managed to overrule my everylasting fear of death with her writing and somehow let me make my peace with our mortality � not a small feat.

About two thirds into the book the author decided to go into a direction I have seldomly seen in novels (and which I can’t say much about for spoilery reasons) and which awed me even more, because it really worked.

Connie Willis is a literate, intelligent author and uses her knowledge well in her novels. So this time I learned a lot about disasters and literature and medical terms/procedures concerning cardiac arrest and how everything somehow connects to everything. But above all I learned about the importance of honesty and the healing effect of being useful.
Her holistic approach to life and death was a pleasure to behold and one more entry in my so-far-I-love-everything-she-wrote list.
23 likes ·  âˆ� flag

Sign into Å·±¦ÓéÀÖ to see if any of your friends have read Passage.
Sign In »

Reading Progress

July 13, 2018 – Shelved as: to-read
July 13, 2018 – Shelved
December 10, 2019 – Shelved as: hugo_nominees
December 10, 2019 – Shelved as: locus_winners
December 10, 2019 – Shelved as: nebula_nominees
April 8, 2020 – Started Reading
April 8, 2020 –
3.0% "Back with the master and it feels sooooo good!"
April 8, 2020 –
8.0% "LOL! It starts in the typical Connie Willis way with a lot of screwball moments and people not meeting each other or missing their way."
April 8, 2020 –
16.0% "This nurse won't pass the Bechdel test 🤪."
April 8, 2020 –
25.0% "I fear this turns out to be another one of those 30 hours audiobooks that don't work the way I intended them to work (namely to keep me occupied for a week or more to not spend too much money on audiobooks). Connie Willis is just such a masterful dialogue writer that I find myself glued to her works and listenting to them whatever else I do.
She is such a comfort writer for me."
April 8, 2020 –
42.0% "Have to stop now because homeschooling starts, but I do it reluctantly XD.

Hell, Connie Willis' stories go slow like treacle but I treasure every second of them. Love!"
April 9, 2020 –
48.0% "It's so strange to read about a time where people weren't glued to their cellphones all the time. Sounds so relaxed :D.


The Alzheimer patient is a bit hard to read about cause of personal situation."
April 9, 2020 –
65.0% "Always loving it when I learn something new (and hopefully remember later on). Here it is the psychological principle of confabulation. I have never heard of this one before."
April 9, 2020 –
74.0% "Whew! The end of part II was intense. Great!"
April 10, 2020 –
83.0% "It's lovely that "The Ancient Mariner" features so prominently. It was the favourite poem of my sister's in her teens and I have such fond memories of that time."
April 10, 2020 –
85.0% "Maisie's character is perfect. I'm so in love with her chapters and her bravery in the face of death."
April 10, 2020 – Finished Reading

Comments Showing 1-14 of 14 (14 new)

dateDown arrow    newest »

Anthony Yay! I read this many years ago, so I don’t remember a lot of details, but I remember devouring it and being quite moved and impressed by it. Glad it worked so well do you. I agree that she’s a really special writer.


Gabi Yes, she is very special. She always gives me the feeling that she not only has a sure hand with prose and language, but also a profound understanding of the human condition. I'm so happy that you got me acquainted with her, Anthony.


Anna I couldn't quite bring myself to rate it 5 stars, but it's hovering between 4 and 4.5 stars for me! I had to sit in bed alternately sobbing and staring at the darkness at 5AM this morning when I finished it. I have very tiny quibbles about some minor things, but for the most part I loved it and agree with your review! I wish I had more Connie Willis books lined up, which is how I always feel after finishing something by her.


message 4: by Gabi (last edited Apr 11, 2020 04:35AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gabi Anna wrote: "I couldn't quite bring myself to rate it 5 stars, but it's hovering between 4 and 4.5 stars for me! I had to sit in bed alternately sobbing and staring at the darkness at 5AM this morning when I fi..."

I was initially going for 4 stars as well, but that twist (view spoiler) and the realisation that her writing structure in this case mirrors the way of the brain work in NDEs was just too fascinating for me to not go for full stars.

What were your quibbles? (I guess my major one was the constant attempts to get Joanna into a relationship)


Anna Oh I forgot to comment on that! I've seen that in a YA book once (wouldn't recommend), and I feel like somewhere else, too, but it's not something you would usually expect. It was very emotional!


message 6: by Anna (last edited Apr 11, 2020 04:48AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anna I actually loved that there was no romance :) It didn't bother me that they talked about (view spoiler)

My very tiny quibbles: (view spoiler)


Gabi Oh, I didn't get that with the age. Good one!

The references to skin colour/origin are something that would vex me in actual books, but in a 20 year old work I overlook them as long as they are not deprecatingly meant.

As for Jesus, (view spoiler)

As for the twist: (view spoiler)


Anna Like I said, very, very minor quibbles! I've enjoyed more religious works (or works with more religion sounds more accurate) from Willis, like some of her short stories which feature her church choir experience, but sometimes I just wish I wouldn't have to see religion everywhere.

The twist: (view spoiler)


Gabi (view spoiler)


message 10: by Anna (last edited Apr 11, 2020 07:04AM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Anna I meant (view spoiler)


message 11: by Gabi (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gabi Anna wrote: "I meant [spoilers removed]"

Ah, okay, got it!


message 12: by Beth (new)

Beth Letting the reader make peace with mortality is among the very tallest of "tall asks." Interesting! Thanks for the thoughtful review.


message 13: by Gabi (new) - rated it 5 stars

Gabi @Beth: it resonated extremely with me on this level due to personal experience.


message 14: by Jakub (new)

Jakub Skonieczny Thanks to your review I bought the book. I was looking for an ACTUALL review and not this "bla bla too long bla bla I'm bored bla bla could be shorter bla bla".... I don't care how boring someone think the book is, I want to know about the contents of the book itself. If it has intelectual value and this one seems like it does. Thank you very much for this awesome review.


back to top